10 Most Hated Classic Rock Songs (From Great Bands)

When titans drop the ball.

U2 Get On Your Boots
Interscope

There's a damn good reason why the bands from the 60's to the 80's have been labelled "classic rock" bands. The songs in their repertoire have become standards of pop music that have gone to influence millions of rock fans around the world. While most of these bands' records are well worth your time, every now and again there's something that should have been left on the cutting room floor.

As much as we like to idolize these artists, it's important to know that no band is able to put out perfect material all the time. Every now and again, bands will come out with songs that are mediocre, lazy, or outright reprehensible in some cases.

Does that mean that these bands lose their credibility as legit songwriters? Not at all. In fact, sometimes it takes one average song from a band for the fanbase to realize just how much great material the band has already put out. For one reason or another, these are the songs that drive fans (as well as some band members) up the wall every time they hear them. Some of these might not be outright awful, but these acts can certainly do better than this.

10. Mother - The Police

The Police were monsters of the pop and rock world throughout the 80's. From their feeble beginnings with "Roxanne" to the monster hit "Every Breath You Take," the band never struck out when it came to creating absolute ear-candy for the mainstream public. While Synchronicity is looked at as the band's last creative moment before their breakup, there's one song that appears in the middle of the record and ruins everybody's fun.

Penned by guitarist Andy Summers, "Mother" is an absolutely egregious tune that is much more avant garde than the experimental stuff the band was writing at the time. To its credit, the song definitely isn't uninteresting, as most of the tune revolves around a chaotic backing track and Summers droning on frightfully about what sounds like a domestic abuse scenario between him and his own mother.

The Police were always looked at as a somewhat off-the-wall band, but was anybody expecting something like this from the guys who gave us hits like "Message in a Bottle" and "King of Pain?" This song may be a bit of a faceplant, but the record quickly picks up steam with songs like "Wrapped Around Your Finger" and "Synchronicity II" shortly afterward. Though Synchronicity has garnered a reputation as one of the most essential albums of the 80's, you can bet that this song is something people skip time after time.


9. Back Chat - Queen

Any self-respecting rock fan has Queen placed in the upper echelons of rock gods. Even though some bands have been bigger, you simply cannot deny the raw talent that radiates from these guys, from their operatic tunes like "Bohemian Rhapsody" to the pure bombast of "Somebody to Love."

By the time the band reached the 80's, they started to make engaging pop music for a whole new generation with songs like "Another One Bites the Dust." The song's disco beat and infectious bassline was irresistible for the pop landscape, but the band started falling into bad habits when they tried to build on that momentum.

Though the band's record Hot Space featured the smash hit "Under Pressure" with David Bowie, "Back Chat" is one of the songs that shows everything wrong about this era of the band. From the more stylized production to the lack of real hooks, this song sounds like something that should be playing at a middle school dance rather than the sleek nightclubs of New York City. Out of all the albums in their catalog, even drummer Roger Taylor has counted this tune as among the few Queen songs he despises. Though the band went on to greater feats down the road, this stands as one of the more flagrant misfires in the band's catalog.


8. Door To Door - Creedence Clearwater Revival

By the time Creedence Clearwater Revival got to the early 70's, they had reached the end of the line. With rhythm guitarist Tom Fogerty already AWOL after spats with his brother John, the band was widdled down to a trio for their final release Mardi Gras. To add insult to injury, the band thought that this would be a good time for John to let go of songwriting duties and let the other members take a crack at writing tunes of their own.

While not everything on Mardi Gras is bad, "Door to Door" is a song that should have never made it past the first draft. Written and sung by bassist Stu Cook, the song is a mindless foray into the life of a traveling salesman who sells different accessories that you'll buy and eventually forget about. This song could have been remedied by a decent vocal performance, but Cook does what sounds like an unflattering impression of John Fogerty's gravelly voice, which makes for one of the most annoying moments on the record.

This song can be enjoyed if only for its shock value, but the sad reality behind it is the greatest swamp rock band in the world barely able to cobble together a coherent tune.


7. Get On Your Boots - U2

U2 has had a reputation for being the most loved and hated band in all of rock music. While there are many fans who think Bono deserves a spot amongst the rock and roll gods, there are others who feel that his pretentious moments are some of the worst moments in rock history.

Though the band has had its staunch defenders over the years, it was still hard to find any merit in "Get On Your Boots" from No Line on the Horizon. With its danceable rhythm and squeaky clean production style, this song feels like the guys are absolutely aching to be played on the radio with the rest of the cool kids. The idea of switching up styles has worked with U2 before, but the song's lack of a good hook results in a dance song with absolutely nothing to latch onto.

The band may have been proud of it at the time, but this song hasn't aged well over the years, with the band rarely bringing it out during their stadium shows. As opposed to being the great rock gods who paved the way for new bands, this song just sounds like U2 chasing trends rather than creating them.


6. Tai Shan - Rush

Rush has always been a band that does whatever the hell they want to do. Throughout their long career, the band dipped their toes into many genres of music regardless of whether it was considered cool or not. Though many fans followed along for the ride, things started to get a bit too overblown during their 80's period.

Once synths became a part of the band's sound, many of their prog rock fans were really turned off and patiently waited until they returned to the hard rock world. While the synth period has some great moments, even the band considers Hold Your Fire being the album that blew everything out of proportion, with "Tai Shan" being the shining example.

Originally composed as an experiment, the song takes different elements of Chinese music and turns them into one of the most mindless compositions that they've ever released. The song also features samples from other tracks on the album, which just makes you think of better songs you could be listening to rather than this. In retrospect, even the band members have considered the song a sore spot, with Geddy Lee claiming they should have known better than to release it. Rush were always one for experimentation, but this is just one of the moments where their broad musical vision came up a bit short.


5. I Was Made For Lovin You - KISS

KISS are one of the most awe-inspiring acts to ever come from rock's golden age. Donned in horrific stage makeup and ominous costumes, the band created one of the greatest live shows of the genre, from the bombs going off to the smoking guitar from Ace Frehley. The music was always as hard-hitting as the show, with gargantuan riffs and insane hooks that were the epitome of hard rock excess.

Though the band had a career victory lap from their second massive live album Alive II, they never seemed to get on the same page afterwards. With everyone taking a break to make solo albums, the band's next proper record Dynasty began the descent of the band.

While the album does have its bright spots, hard rock fans were having none of "I Was Made For Lovin You." Being the long-haired kings of the world, these guys had no business hopping on a song that sounded like it should have been a long-forgotten B-side from Donna Summer. Though the song is pretty decent by pop standards, the push-back from this one tune was so strong that many diehard fans outright refused to accept this new version of the band. KIwould eventually have a more hard rock flavored version of the tune on the live stage, but at the time, this showed that the hard rock demons were indeed fallible.


4. Mumbo - Paul McCartney

The Beatles' breakup at the end of the 60's was a truly dark day for the rock community at large. While the band would no longer be making music together, the members were still making some amazing stuff as solo artists, with George Harrison's "My Sweet Lord" and John Lennon's breathtaking "Imagine." While Paul McCartney started off equally strong with the song "Maybe I'm Amazed" and the eccentric Ram album, things started to take a turn for the weird once he formed a new group.

After a few years of making music by himself with his wife Linda, Paul was missing the camaraderie that came with having a group rather than being by yourself. Drafting Denny Laine from the Moody Blues among others, Paul went into the studio to cut Wings' first album Wild Life, which had a bit more sore spots than you remember.

Though the album has a beautiful message to John Lennon on "Dear Friend," much of the front half is loaded with jams that don't really go anywhere, with "Mumbo" being the worst. The song is basically just a good guitar riff combined with what can only be described as McCartney ad-libbing lyrics with no real rhyme or reason. While Paul would eventually find his groove again with Band on the Run, the first offering from this new group ended up being a meandering mess.


3. Jaded - Aerosmith

Aerosmith have more than earned their place among the all time greatest in rock and roll. Even when the band were floundering in the mid 80's, the charisma of Steven Tyler and Joe Perry proved it had the star power to outlast any trend, with songs like "Janie's Got a Gun" and "Rag Doll" being fantastic pop rock songs.

Somewhere around the late 90's though, the band started to dip their toes into waters that were a bit too poppy for their own good. This manifested itself in the 2001 album Just Push Play, which was the sign that the Bad Boys from Boston had gotten way too glossy for most rockers to stomach. While it's far from being a terrible song, "Jaded" was everything that was wrong with this era of Aerosmith, complete with a radio-ready sound and guitars that absolutely screamed millennial pop.

On any other day, the 70's version of Aerosmith would have laughed this song out of the room, but the song that we ended up getting was much more in line with the Top 40 than the blues-rock hits they were known for. As far as pop goes, it's fine, but for rock fans, this is so below the band's paygrade.


2. Harlem Shuffle - The Rolling Stones

The Rolling Stones are so integral in the development of rock and roll that they may as well be on the cover on the Great Story of Rock. The band built upon their foundations as a British Invasion to become one of the most enduring bands of all time, with great blues rock albums like Beggars Banquet and Let it Bleed. While the blues always suited them best, the quality was a bit more questionable once they ventured outward.

Sure, the band had great experimental stuff in the 60's with songs like "Paint It Black," but later disco songs on Some Girls started to give the band some bad habits. By the time they stumbled into the 80's, their attempts at following trends led to some of their most off-putting material on "Harlem Shuffle."

Taken from the maligned album Dirty Work, the song doesn't come close to matching the swagger of the other singles in the Stones' catalog. Whereas other songs felt dangerous and carnal, this song sounds like it should be played on your grandpa's new boombox to show that he's with the times. The Stones have definitely done wonders for the rock genre, but that doesn't mean this song automatically gets a pass.


1. Run For Your Life - The Beatles

The Beatles were one of the few bands that some could say had a perfect career. While not every song was meant to be an all-time classic, each of the band's records had great material up until their breakup in the late 60's. It's easy to look at the band's tenure with rose-colored glasses, but even the band had a fair share of songs they hated.

Rubber Soul was known as the album that saw the band expanding beyond their typical mop top sound, but John Lennon was particularly ashamed that a song like "Run For Your Life" made the final cut. Most of the album revolves around the band peeling back the layers of love to create something more complex, which makes this tale of violent romantic spite look so much worse by comparison.

Lennon himself was even hesitant to record the song due to its subpar writing, but the deadline for the album demanded that the band bring whatever material they had to the table. Recorded at the very beginning of the sessions, this song was quickly knocked out and promptly forgot about until the final mastering process, where the song was included in the final version. Though Rubber Soul is one of the greatest albums the band would ever make, this song feels much more uninspired than the classics it has to sit next to.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97