10 Most Overhated Bands In Rock

They're really not as bad as you think...

Green Day perform live on stage.
Yui Mok/PA Archive

In the grand scheme of rock music, fans usually have the final say in an artists' worth. Whether it be through buying their records or calling out inauthentic behavior, fans have all the power when it comes to calling something good or not. Though many bands have gotten a fair amount of criticism for their music, there are many acts who don't deserve the slogging they normally receive.

As time has gone on, these bands that were initially panned by fans and critics alike have stood out as something much better than we remembered. Even some of the greatest acts in the world were able to conjure up a bit of hate because of certain questionable artistic directions. However, that doesn't mean we should count a band out entirely if they made something that we didn't like.

Being an artist is all about taking chances, but you are liable to any type of criticism once you put your musical vision out on a public stage. For as much scorn as these artists have weathered over the years, there will always be a core fanbase who will be there to help nurse their wounds. Here's just a little helping of those acts that people had a little too much fun hating on.

10. Stone Temple Pilots

In the early 90's, every other band was trying to infuse a little bit of alternative rock into their sound. Whether it was old dogs trying to compete with the young competition or wannabes trying to find a footing, everyone was looking towards the grunge capital of Seattle to make their millions. Though Stone Temple Pilots established themselves as major players in the scene, they always seemed to get bypassed by the pure grunge fans.

Coming from California rather than Seattle, these guys were instantly looked at as just another wannabe trying to feed off the coattails of Eddie Vedder, with the single "Plush" being pegged as a cheap Pearl Jam knockoff. However, the band proved they had a genuine amount of talent underneath the alternative exterior. Across albums like Purple and Tiny Music, the band did a fantastic job of distancing themselves from their grunge roots with some of the greatest rock tunes of the era like "Interstate Love Song."

Though the band are adrift a bit nowadays after the loss of vocalist Scott Weiland, they deserve a lot more than just being called an "also-ran" of the alternative scene. Sure, they may have aspired to be like their grunge big brothers, but once they found their identity, there was no else in the rock scene who could touch them.


9. Red Hot Chili Peppers

There are a lot of bands who get called out for being too homogeneous with their sound. While you may have a handful of great tunes, it's doesn't make that much of a difference if every song ends up sounding the same. Even though people single out the Red Hot Chili Peppers as prime candidates for this spot, their exquisite blend of influences have made them true originals.

Granted, there are many times in the band's 90's output where they sounded pretty much the same, down to the singsongy flow of Anthony Kiedis and the raw bass whirlwind of Flea. On the other hand, the band actually tried their hand at several different genres if you know where to look for them. For as many songs like "Give It Away," songs like "I Could Have Lied" bring a raw introspective side to the band's music.

As they emerged at the end of the 90's with John Frusciante back in the band, they even started to incorporate more melodic sensibilities into their sound, making them feel like the raw-nerved funky counterpart to rock's greatest songwriters. The Peppers certainly have a specific sound in mind when writing a tune, but while some Peppers songs sound the same, no one can create the real magic they possess.


8. Linkin Park

While it's one thing to write off a certain band from your youth, some music fans have gone too far the other way and purged entire genres from their existence. Out of all the more cringey genres through the years, nu metal has typically gotten the most vitriol because of the melodramatic lyrics and cartoonish approach to what was initially a heavy genre. Linkin Park tend to get brought up as one of those whiney acts, but there's tons of great material that these guys have put out.

Across albums like Hybrid Theory and Meteora, the band tapped into an inner melancholy that was far removed from the off-hand complaining of other acts. Rather than turning their anger outward on their parents, these songs tapped into an internal frustration with one's self, which is much more captivating than the Limp Bizkits of the world could ever hope to be.

Even after the nu metal tag faded, Linkin Park showed they could stick around with more alternative leaning records like on A Thousand Suns and Minutes to Midnight. It's easy to see Linkin Park as a nostalgia band, but they have been able to grow beyond the nu metal wave and become a major player in the greater conversation of rock bands.


7. Aerosmith

Ever since they started in the early 70's, Aerosmith has always had a firm grip on hard rock music. Throughout their classic run, they created some staples of the genre from the proto power ballad "Dream On" to the swagger of songs like "Sweet Emotion." On the other hand, Aerosmith have gotten a fair bit of hate at both the earliest and latest points of their career.

Back when they were finding their sound, the rapport between Steven Tyler and Joe Perry was too similar to the Rolling Stones for many people to bare. There may have been some Stonesy moments in the band's history, but their mix of a funky groove in between the riffs gave the band a different edge. Instead of the typical blues outfits the Stones would take on, these guys were becoming the heaviest swing band you've ever heard, with horn sections being replaced with guitar riffs.

Once the band reached the late 90's though, they got an equal amount of flak for going too commercial on records like Just Push Play. Though there are certainly arguments to be made about Aerosmith's catalog as a whole, there's no denying the power that the band's classic material has.


6. Green Day

Green Day are known now as one of the biggest rock bands in the world. With classics like "American Idiot" and "Basket Case" under their belt, it seems that their legacy as one of the greatest bands in the world should be all but secure. At the same time, Green Day have gotten hate relentlessly persecuted for being one of punk music's biggest sellouts.

Originally coming from the punk squats of California, the band's initial fanbase was absolutely furious when they signed to a major label for their 3rd effort Dookie. While the rest of the world was chanting along to the band's tuneful punk rock, the rest of their hometown were criticizing them for using their beginnings as just a stepping stone.

Though the band did end up getting more poppy after coming to a major label, this was also when they were writing some of their greatest songs. The band singlehandedly jumpstarted the pop punk movement, with bands like Paramore, Blink 182, and Sum 41 quickly following suit. The band even managed to transcend the punk label altogether with American Idiot, where they officially became mainstream rock giants. Even if they still get hate as sell-outs, Green Day have established themselves as a band that does whatever the hell they want to do, which is as rock and roll as it gets.


5. Rush

In the grand scheme of prog rock bands, Rush deserves a spot amongst the greatest to ever play in an odd time signature. With their grandiose musical epics and casual redefinitions of the prog genre, the band launched a slew of different bands who were into something as heavy as Led Zeppelin and as complicated as Genesis. Though the band are called legends now, many rock fans had very harsh things to say about this Canadian power trio.

Given the band's penchant for more complex song structures, many potential fans were turned off and wanted to get back to the normal hard rock of bands like Bad Company and Foreigner. A few relative cheap shots at the band usually had to do with Geddy Lee's voice, whose high-end scream was compared to the shrill sounds of a dying animal. Another big one is the band getting called out for being a "nerd rock" band based on their weighty song topics.

However, time has been a lot kinder to Rush....and to nerds in general. Whereas some of the other hard rock bands sound dated by today's standards, Rush has carved out one of the most loyal fanbases in the music business, whose addiction to the band knows no bounds. Call them what you want, but Rush is always going to be considered a legendary band regardless of what any nerd basher has to say about it.


4. Muse

Muse have made a name for themselves as one of the greatest hard rock bands still going today. The band's amazing sense of melody combined with the stratospheric screams of Matt Bellamy has put them in the top tiers of musicians for decades now. Even though the band has developed their own identity, they still seem to get people negating them for wearing their influences on their sleeves a little too much.

In the band's inception, their mix of spacey sounds with ethereal vocals seemed very reminiscent of something like Radiohead, but the band have been able to craft their persona by adding jawdropping musicianship to their arsenal. Across albums like The Resistance and Absolution, the band have created some of the most eclectic rock albums of the modern age, comprising everything from classical passages to operatic rock sections to heavy metal ragers.

Many music connoisseurs may call the band's music mediocre, but you can't deny how much emotion the band are able to pack into these tunes. There are always going to be rock fans who hate Muse for not being Radiohead, but given Thom Yorke and co.'s move away from the mainstream rock realm, these guys are still a more-than-worthy band who can carry the torch for hard rock going forward.


3. Slipknot

Ever since its first stumbles into existence, many rock fans were quick to point out the silliness behind the nu metal scene. Given the serious topics coming from the grunge scene a few years earlier, the last thing we needed was metal music as told by the sophomoric teenagers of the world. Though Slipknot often get singled out as having the worst trappings of the scene, their music was always something much darker.

While there is certainly an argument to be made about the band's insistence to wear masks onstage, the music behind these 9 metalheads was some of the strongest that the late 90's had to offer. Sure, the band's debut record may sound a little basic when compared to a band like Tool, but once they hit Iowa, they had become one of the hardest acts in the world of metal.

Though the band have tinkered with more melodic passages in their sound, their ability to write coherent songs has only strengthened, with recent albums like We Are Not Your Kind being some of the highest quality ragers in the past few years. Slipknot may still get hate for being 9 maniacs onstage, but all of that fades away once you are bludgeoned by their music.


2. U2

U2 is a band known more nowadays for their non musical pursuits rather than their actual songs. For as firm a grasp as they had on the music industry in the 80's, the band has gotten a reputation as a bloated relic of the 80's, with Bono being one of the more preachy frontmen in the rock pantheon. Though the band does have their moments of infamy, are we just going to ignore all the great stuff they gave us?

Throughout the 80's, the band created some of the most awe-inspiring tracks of the rock era, combining new wave and post punk sounds with a rock ethos that was impossible to resist. Across albums like The Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby, the band hit upon some of the most massive sounds of the era, with songs that could touch your heart like "One" and "With or Without You."

Does Bono's political insistence wear on people's nerves? Absolutely. However, listening to a song like "Where the Streets Have No Name" is such a transcendent experience that any other non-musical cringiness just fades from view. There's plenty of reasons to despise U2, but the masterpieces they have given us are able to win over even the most jaded music fans.


1. Metallica

Metallica deserve all the credit in the world for bringing heavy metal to the upper echelons of rock music. Across their discography, the band have created some of the greatest tracks the genre has ever seen, from the punk thrashiness of "Master of Puppets" to the forceful stomp of "Sad But True." The band may have firmly cemented their legacy, but the hate garnered from metalheads cannot be ignored.

Even Metallica fans have lobbed a fair bit of hate at the band over the years, which can be traced back to certain points in the band's timeline. Whether it was when they went mainstream with the Black Album or when they put out the messiness of St. Anger, fans have always spoken up when something was below the high standard the band had set for themselves. There are even diehard metal fans who mock songs like "Fade to Black" for being too mellow compared to the band's thrashy works.

While people don't tend to mince words about their least favorites, the beauty of Metallica's music comes from the amount of diversity that they have rather than their deliberate attempts to cheat their fans. No matter what kind of musical endeavor they decide to step into, Metallica have always done what has suited them and created one of the biggest metal congregations the world has ever known.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97