10 Most Underrated Drummers In Rock

Backbeats in the Background.

Hall of Fame Inductee, Nirvana, Dave Grohl performs at the 2014 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Induction Ceremony on Thursday, April, 10, 2014 in New York. (Photo by Charles Sykes/Invision/AP)
Charles Sykes/AP

Why do drummers always end up getting the short end of the stick in rock bands? Despite being the main backbeat behind every song, every other drummer ends up getting the sour reputation as 'the dumb one' who just sits in the back and bangs on things for a living. Though there have been many significant drummers in rock's pantheon, millions more monsters behind the kit have been sorely neglected.

Then again, it's pretty easy to see why the member with the least star power is the one who is literally stuck behind a kit for the majority of their performance. Whereas many people like to focus on the guitar players or singers in these bands, none of them would have been where they are today if it wasn't for these rhythmic monsters providing the foundation for them.

While some drummers are content with just hanging back and being badass in the background of rock and roll, other rhythmic monsters are relegated to the bottom slot of their respective acts by being either overshadowed by the more interesting members or for the more ill-advised moments in their career. The world has had their fair share of guitar heroes...now it's time to take a look at the experts behind the kit who deserve much more love than they probably get.

10. Paul Cook - Sex Pistols

Rock fans really need to drop the idea that the Sex Pistols had no talent. Even though their look and sound were a hell of a lot different than their counterparts at the time, there was a lot more at work than just a bunch of punks wanting to bang away on their instruments. With Johnny Rotten already belting out some of the foulest lyrics imaginable, Paul Cook was the one who really sent the band into overdrive.

From a pure musical perspective, Cook is pretty much the same kind of drummer you would come to expect, with a style that almost seems reminiscent of someone like Charlie Watts of the Rolling Stones. On the other hand, the real innovative part was how he approached the actual drumkit. Rather than using the actual stick part of the drum stick, "Cooky" used the thicker edge of the stick, which resulted in a much fatter sound when they tore through songs like Holidays in the Sun or Anarchy in the UK.

Once that kind of forcefulness locked in with the guitar playing of Steve Jones, what was originally just your average rock song got its spine ripped out. Even with the notorious flameout of the Sex Pistols, Paul Cook is the one survivor of the punk scene who seemed the most in tune with the musical side of the drums.


9. Larry Mullen Jr. - U2

Most rock fans tend to fall in either the love or hate category when it comes to U2. Even though there have been plenty of highlights over their career with albums like the Joshua Tree, the more holier than thou attitude that they have towards their causes have also turned off a fair amount of fans over the years. Instead of worrying about Bono's politics and life choices, take a look at the back of the stage to see the real brilliance on display.

Being one of the most solid drummers in the world of rock, Larry Mullen Jr.'s timing always feels eerily precise on some of U2's finest records, long before drum machines were starting to become a thing. In addition to the perfect timing he has on albums like War, there is also an ingenious setup that he has going on in some of the band's classic material.

Take something like Pride (in the Name of Love), for instance. Instead of using the traditional snare sound, Mullen positioned every tom tom in just the right place to move his hand around the entire kit, making that fat sound that is known to fill stadiums. Even when the band reinvented themselves on Achtung Baby, Mullen's touch when it comes to electronic music wasn't too shabby either, embracing drum machines and becoming the human metronome opposite Adam Clayton. So next time someone brings up the amazing effects that comes out of the Edge, you might want to take a second look at the living, breathing entity Larry Mullen Jr. birthed behind the kit.


8. Dominic Howard - Muse

At the start of the '00s, it was no longer cool to be bombastic anymore. With acts like the Strokes and the White Stripes rising to prominence, a lot of the rhythmic structure present in modern rock songs was nothing more than the traditional garage rock sounds that we had heard a thousand times before. Just when people started to tune out, Dominic Howard released a sonic boom from behind his drum throne.

Whenever people bring up Muse, it's normally at the expense of the operatic vocals of Matt Bellamy, so much so that they forget what Howard is even doing. Compared to his contemporaries, Howard was one of the more eclectic drummers to rise to prominence, taking on everything from electronic samples to the regular kit depending on whatever the song called for.

Regardless of the musical taste he spanned, there was always a ton of muscle behind his delivery as well on some of the band's more forceful moments. Just one listen to a song like Assassin or Stockholm Syndrome just tells you that this is a guy who might be used to drumming in more heavy metal acts before finding his home with Muse. At a time when the drummer was falling back into just playing a supportive role, Dominic Howard threw caution to the wind and made his drumming hit like a cannon blast.


7. Josh Freese - Various

Some of the brightest stars in the drum world tend to go unnoticed. Despite having the attention of being in a big rock band, the idea of hanging back and settling into whatever groove an artist throws at you is also one of the biggest strengths in any drummer's arsenal. In the modern world of session drummers though, Josh Freese might have one of the most eclectic rap sheets in the business.

Even though his name might not appear in every single album he performs on, chances are you've heard this man's drumming on songs by your favorite artists more than a few times. While he is primarily known now as the drummer for A Perfect Circle, Freese has had his hand in other heavy acts like Nine Inch Nails and My Chemical Romance over the years. On the opposite side of things, Freese has also been a go-to session drummer for bands like Weezer and Slash on their respective projects, as well as lending his skills to acts like Bruce Springsteen and Social Distortion over the years.

There's probably a handful of people who don't even know this man's name, and yet have praised his drumming countless times over the years. While there's a certain lane for drummers who decide to remain faceless, you might want to take a second look at the liner notes of your favorite records to see if Josh Freese turns up at all.


6. Dave Grohl - Nirvana, Queens Of The Stone Age, Etc.

There's probably a young subset of rock fans who probably don't even realize that Dave Grohl was originally a drummer. Aside from his stint as the frontman of the Foo Fighters, Grohl's legacy was secure way before then when he was the primary drummer for Seattle legends Nirvana. Though Grohl feels much more at home at the front of the stage nowadays, people need to understand just how much power he had behind the kit.

Very much a descendant of drummers like John Bonham, Grohl's soft-spoken nature when in Nirvana was needed to not deter too much from the star power of Kurt Cobain. On the other hand, most of Nirvana's songs wouldn't be what they are without Grohl at the helm, from the opening wash of Scentless Apprentice to the gradual crescendos of Come As You Are. Still having the itch after all these years, Grohl's contributions on albums by other artists are also beyond reproach, with his performance to Songs for the Deaf by Queens of the Stone Age being some of his most forceful playing in ages.

Never one to really sit around and do nothing, it seems like Grohl has some insatiable energy to create, with drums being his primary outfit for bringing his musical personality to the world. While it's one thing to entertain a crowd as the ringleader of the band, you might want to take a few steps back if you ever come across Dave Grohl behind the kit.


5. Eric Carr - KISS

So much attention has surrounded the core lineup of KISS that it's practically a part of rock and roll folklore. Even though Paul Stanley and Gene Simmons have gone through several different iterations of the make-up clad badasses from the '70s, some people still can't come to terms with these guys without Ace Frehley and Peter Criss. Aside from the core lineup though, the real muscle behind the band came when Eric Carr got behind the drum throne.

Granted, Carr didn't have the smoothest transition into his role, with his first appearance being the misguided concept album Music from the Elder. On the other hand, Carr made his mark on every single one of the group's records in the '80s starting with Creatures of the Night. As opposed to the jazz drumming you would normally get with Criss, Carr's drums felt like the sound of thunder providing the beat, almost like he was trying to steer the band back into their original heavy direction.

Far from just being a drummer, Carr also had the perfect husky vocal timbre in his voice to match Criss' intensity, which paid off in spades when they performed songs like Black Diamond live on stage. While KISS has always been about Stanley and Simmons, Eric Carr might be the one reason why these glam rock superheroes actually survived the '80s.


4. Phil Selway - Radiohead

When talking about acts that are heralded as the greatest of their generation, Radiohead are certainly one of the weirder concoctions of the '90s. Never before had anyone seen a band taking on genres like ambient, rock, jazz, and electronica and combining them to making something wholly unique. Then again, if you're covering that much different material on an album, it's probably best that you have a kickass rhythmic structure beforehand.

Starting off in their grunge days, Phil Selway already worked well in the Radiohead mold, with drum parts that seemed as much indebted to the Pixies as they were to Nirvana. On the other hand, Selway has proven himself to be somewhat of a jack of all trades when it comes to percussion, as he practically created a human drum loop on Airbag and made some of the most intriguing glitchy rhythms across albums like Kid A and Amnesiac.

Unlike the more "eclectic" drummers who tend to throw whatever they can at the wall for the hell of it, Phil is also one of the few drummers who understands when the drum machines are needed and when you have to strip everything back down to the old kick and snare. Even though Thom Yorke gets a lot of credit for the songwriting of Radiohead, Phil Selway is another glowing example of why this band is about the collective rather than any one member.


3. Bernard Purdie - Steely Dan

Steely Dan are one of the most wacky case studies ever to be seen in the world of rock and roll. Whereas most acts of their day relied on the foundation of blues and R&B to get their rocks off, the music of Donald Fagen and Walter Becker pulled from pretty much everything except rock and roll and made some of the most experimental pieces the rock world had ever seen. Even though these musical twins were known as the beating heart of the group, there was no real groove until Bernard Purdie stepped behind the kit.

Coming from more of a funk background, Bernard's timing is just off enough to make it feel human. Even though there's a ton of drummers who frown upon being behind the beat, Purdie really understood the art of laying back in the mix and letting the entire song breathe on its own, whether it's the off-kilter swagger of Kid Charlemagne or the equally bizarre accentuations on Deacon Blues.

Also, it doesn't hurt when you have a characteristic groove to your name, with the "Purdie shuffle" being incorporated on later hits for groups like Toto. Whereas most artists might be concerned about the timing of the drummer, it's almost as if you don't have to worry about the drums once you get Bernard in the back.


2. Phil Collins - Genesis

There's probably a certain group of people who blame Phil Collins for the neutering of rock and roll. Even though he has some semblance of credibility being the drummer for Genesis, that doesn't stop the inherent cheesiness of some of his ballads from "ruining" the integrity of the group. However, the deep well of drum knowledge that Collins possesses goes far beyond that drum fill in In the Air Tonight.

Back when Peter Gabriel was still at the helm, Collins' work in the back with Genesis was a spectacle unto itself. Given their habit for writing in some of the weirdest time signatures imaginable, Collins became the glue that anchored these guys together, whether it was on the epic songs like Supper's Ready or the impending doom that comes on Dancing with the Moonlit Knight. This intense knowledge of percussion even informed his eventual singing routine, as he placed every note in just the right spot to compliment the overall composition.

Hell, you know you have to be doing something right when even the Professor himself Neil Peart has singled you out as being something special, with the Rush drummer talking at length about taking influence from albums like Selling England by the Pound. So next time you hear one of the sappier ballads from Collins on the radio, just remember that he can still open up a firm bludgeoning behind the kit if he wants to.


1. Jim Keltner - Various

It's never really easy picking a drummer who is really underrated. I mean, unless you have someone like John Bonham and Keith Moon who fly off the hinges at every turn, most drummers tend to never see the spotlight all that often. However, when talking about the percussionists who are underappreciated, it doesn't really come to virtuosity...it's the feel.

As opposed to the more gifted modern drummers coming out today, Jim Keltner's work behind the scenes has become a staple of the classic rock world for years now. Instead of being tied to one singular band, Keltner's reputation as a session drummer has been about staying in the pocket and serving the song he's playing. This has led to him building up quite the rap sheet as a fixture on George Harrison's records, along with working for everyone from Don Henley to B.B. King to Elton John.

Equally competent with either a thunderous rave up tune or a slow ballad, Keltner is one of the true descendants of someone like Ringo Starr, who never focuses on technique and instead listens to the song and delivers what the track needs. Even as he's still working today, Jim Keltner's reputation as one of the more quiet drummers in rock and roll has given him the opportunity to thrive in the music business for nearly half a century.


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97