10 Most Underrated Metallica Songs

Enter King Nothing.

Metallica King Nothing
Elektra

Not too many things associated with Metallica can be considered "underrated." Ever since the early '80s, these thrash metal giants seemed to have reinvented the entire metal genre in their own image, with almost every one of their albums being contested amongst metal fans. Then again, even the most classic of bands can find a few stragglers that never saw the light of day.

Whether it was down to a poor management decision or just a snafu with the record company, these songs have remained in the dark corners of Metallica's catalog, with only a few people bringing them up as something fantastic. Though these spots are normally reserved for the worst material a band has to offer, a lot of these cuts have some inspired musical choices that you might not expect from the world's biggest metal band.

Granted, there have been times where Metallica have changed it up and failed miserably (St. Anger, Lulu, et al), but these are the few songs that actually got that shakeup right. It's time for these undiscovered pieces to have their day in the sun and see if they hold up to the band's previous classics. They might not set the world on fire, but they may just sneak up on you as some of the band's most overlooked deep cuts.

10. Cyanide - Death Magnetic

At the end of 2008, Death Magnetic was one of the best things a Metallica fan could have hoped for. After years of fiddling around with different material, this was the return to form that the band needed to win the hearts of thrash fans all over again. Even though songs like "The Day That Never Comes" have become etched in the minds of fans everywhere, "Cyanide" is one of the unsung heroes that feels most like the band's glory years.

From one section to the next, this song is filled to the brim with great riffs, with notes clashing against one another in the best way possible. Even though the focus may be on the collective, the start of the verses gives bassist Robert Trujillo a proper chance to shine, with his rhythmic accents setting the stage for the main lick.

Complete with a subject matter dealing with the standard topics of death, James Hetfield sounds like he did back on the Black Album, with a voice that is as tuneful as it is ferocious. "Cyanide" might not be at the top of most fans' favorites lists, but if it weren't for songs like this, Metallica might not have been able to get back in touch with their heavy origins.


9. No Remorse - Kill Em All

When looking at Metallica's entire discography, their debut Kill Em All is one of the most straight head thrash albums they've ever made.

Sure, albums like Ride the Lightning and Master of Puppets may qualify as genre classics, but the punk edge of this record is the purest metal affair that the band ever indulged in. These may have been the songs that built the Metallica empire, but "No Remorse" is more than just another thrash tune.

As the opening lick starts off, you can practically hear every single influence the band has had, with a groove that fits somewhere in between the swing of Black Sabbath and the crunch of the New Wave of British Heavy Metal. Though a swing rhythm doesn't necessarily blend too well with heavy music, the way Hetfield annihilates this lick makes you feel like you're being physically pulled into the groove.

Though the chorus is just a standard thrash affair at this point, this is one of the more impressive riffs that Hetfield played in the early years, where he started to hone his downpicking to a machine gun speed. Metallica were just tapping their potential with Kill Em All, but if even these lesser songs still hold up, you know you're going places.


8. Of Wolf And Man - The Black Album

It's pretty hard to find anything about the Black Album that could be considered underrated.

For as many million copies that have been sold around the world, this one record has become the Dark Side of the Moon of metal, with every other track being a classic. "Enter Sandman" might still hold up after all these years, but "Of Wolf and Man" taps into something even creepier.

Metallica are certainly no strangers to heavy subject matter, but this tale of a man turning into a werewolf during the full moon is one of the most vivid sonic journeys they've ever made.

The actual composition might be rooted in the thrash of their early years, but the real emotion comes with the way the chorus is constructed. As the chords break apart and you hear Hetfield scream "SHAPESHIFT!," it sounds like he's slowly losing control of his humanity, almost in mid transformation.

Not only does this give you an adrenaline rush, but it also recontextaulizes the rest of the song, with the chugging rhythm almost painting a picture of this deranged beast stalking his prey through the countryside. Metallica may indulge in some goofy lyrics from time to time, but this attempt at a fantasy narrative is so impressive it deserves its own theatrical rock production.


7. Murder One - Hardwired...to Self Destruct

Throughout their 40 years together, Metallica have never forgotten where they came from. No matter how much money they make from their tours or the extravagant lifestyles they lead, the members at the heart of this band have always remained fans first and rock gods second. So when one of your musical heroes ends up departing from this Earth, it's only fitting to give him the best sendoff you know how.

After the passing of Motorhead bassist Lemmy Kilmister, the band set out to write a tribute song in the form of "Murder One." Falling towards the end of their album Hardwired...to Self Destruct, this song is a worthy tribute to the booze-swigging rock troubadour, as James Hetfield namechecks several Motorhead tracks like "Born to Lose" and "All the Aces."

While the song starts off slow like "Welcome Home (Sanitarium)," the tune switches to heavy groove immediately after, as if to say that Lemmy doesn't go for any sappy s**t.

Hardwired itself might be a bit of a long sit for even the diehard Metallica fans, but this song is still a fitting tribute to one of the progenitors of thrash metal. Whatever bar Lemmy finds himself in these days, let's hope he's raising his Jack and Coke to his metal offspring.


6. Low Man's Lyric - Reload

There is an entire generation of Metallica fans who wishes they could forget the Load/Reload era of this band.

While some songs may have been good like "Fuel" and "The Unforgiven II," the entire project seemed like Metallica watering their sound down further to win favor with the hard rock and grunge crowd. The band may have cut corners in places, but when they ended up experimenting, some of the results were absolutely stunning.

From the very beginning, "Low Man's Lyric" sounds almost nothing like a Metallica song, with a clean guitar leading the charge and a hurdy gurdy pumping out the main melody. Though this may have been a different breed of Metallica, the dark subject matter hasn't changed, with Hetfield telling the story of a homeless junkie seeking redemption from his family.

The entire thing is almost heartfelt in a way, but the dark turn in the bridge brings us back to Earth, as our protagonist seeks to get clean but knows that he will just return to his seedy roots all over again. Change was definitely in the air for thrash metal at the time, but leave it to Metallica to make their twisted version of a country song and actually make it sound heavy.


5. Mercyful Fate - Garage Inc.

When you're talking about some of the greatest material a band has put out, it gets a bit tricky when talking about cover songs. After all, since it's not really their song, how can it be judged as something artistically groundbreaking? There's a lot of debate amongst fans about the legitimacy of covers, but when Metallica stepped up to the plate for Garage Inc., they turned in one of their finest performances.

Always a fan of old school metal, the band were particularly enamored with the theatrical rock act Mercyful Fate led by madman King Diamond. The band couldn't quite pin down which song to do...so they ended up doing a bunch of them. Rather than do multiple covers of the same artist, this track is an 11 minute medley of Mercyful Fate cuts, from "Evil" to "Curse of the Pharoah" to "Satan's Fall."

You can definitely hear the old school metal influence, but the band play it so well that is just ends up sounding like a great Metallica cut that never saw the light of day. From the tasty Kirk Hammett leads to the smooth transitions into each section, this is Metallica at their most uninhibited, as they have a blast paying tribute to their heroes.

All of these pieces put together shouldn't really work, but somehow the metal overlords found a way to make one of the most questionable ideas look seemless.


4. Four Horsemen - Kill Em All

Whenever you talk about the best of Metallica, it normally comes down to their epics.

Ever since their '80s glory years, the band have been known to stretch their songs to colossal lengths, with some of the most infectious riffs that the metal world has ever heard. Though some might single out something like "Fade to Black" or even "Disposable Heroes" as some of their more epic moments, the first time it reared its head was on their debut.

Centered around a swinging metal groove, "The Four Horsemen" is the first time Metallica tried their hand at writing an epic song, with the lyrics dealing with the forecoming apocalypse. With parts written by former guitarist Dave Mustaine, this song has everything you're looking for in an early Metallica song, from the killer main riff to the melodic interlude to the amazing solo from Kirk Hammett.

Given the amount of twists and turns this song takes over 7 minutes, "The Four Horsemen" is practically a warm up for what the band would later master on "Master of Puppets" just a few years later.

Metallica were already a great metal band by the time they released their debut, but "The Four Horsemen" was the first sign that we were witnessing a musical giant being birthed.


3. King Nothing - Load

By the time the mid '90s rolled around, metal fans were chomping at the bit for more Metallica. After heading off the road for a well-earned break following the Black Album, the band ventured into the studio to cut Load, which would be the massive follow up to the biggest selling metal album of all time. However, as the riff of "King Nothing" was played for the first time, fans couldn't help but feel disappointed.

From top to bottom, this song is a blatant retread of the same type of music the band had made with the Black Album, down to the callbacks to "Enter Sandman" in the last few seconds.

Fans might have been pissed, but there's a lot more to unpack beyond the "same sound, new haircut" mentality. For starters, this is one of the bluesiest tunes the band had released up to that point, with Kirk Hammett being a heavy metal substitute for Stevie Ray Vaughan.

Along with the riff's swagger, Hetfield's lyrics are actually pretty pointed, as he talks about a person focused on material possessions only to have nothing emotional to latch onto.

Coming from a band that had more money than they could ask for, this song was pretty bold for asking the question of what fame and attention really mean. "King Nothing" is far from the greatest single the band ever made, but it did end up putting the band on familiar ground with their fans.


2. The Thing That Should Not Be - Master Of Puppets

From the very start of their career, Metallica never wanted to be a metal band that wrote solely about demons and dragons.

For as many bands as there were writing about the supernatural evils of the world, Metallica were more concerned with the everyday evils, from the war horrors of "Disposable Heroes" to the tragic figure at the heart of "The Unforgiven." On the other hand, things did take a turn for the epic when the band did end up discussing more beastly material.

Fitting snuggly between the heavy hitters on Master of Puppets, "The Thing That Should Not Be" was the band's first lyrical attempt to depict Cthulu, with one of the heaviest grooves in the band's canon. While the tune starts off ominous with a few clean guitar notes, the song builds with the start of the verses, as Hetfield depicts the horrific sight he sees emerging from the abyss.

As we reach the breakdown, the band ascends even further, almost like we're looking at Cthulu making his way across the Earth. Being one of the first songs the band tuned down for, this song is the subtle taste of menace creeping through Metallica's instruments. Master of Puppets isn't short of any classic material, but this song deserves to be right alongside the title track and "Orion" as one this album's masterpieces.


1. To Live Is To Die - And Justice For All

The loss of bassist Cliff Burton in 1986 was something that seemed impossible to recover from. More than just a four-stringer, his advanced musical knowledge helped the band go from typical thrash punks to some of the most complex musical thinkers in the world of metal. This kind of blow struck at the very heart of Metallica, but once they picked up the pieces, a tribute was in order.

Though the band's album And Justice For All is typically seen as Jason Newsted's first attempt on the bass, the presence of Burton looms large over the instrumental "To Live Is To Die." From day one, Burton was always encouraging the instrumental passages, but this one song is something that is integral to the rest of the band. The melodic passages may be based on Cliff's initial sketches, but the melancholy haze of his death is coated throughout this song.

While it starts as a typical thrash groove, the middle section feels like the band grieving through their instruments, as they try to artistically process the death of their musical brother.

Even when the thrash elements return, James Hetfield recites a poem written by Cliff prior to his death, centered around the concept of relief that comes with the afterlife. Cliff Burton may be the missing puzzle piece in Metallica, but this one track showed that the band were strong enough to continue on without him.


Finish The Lyric: Metallica

Metallica Hetfield Horns
AP Photo/Christian Parma

1. Come Crawling Faster

In this post: 
Metallica
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97