10 Most Underrated Paul McCartney Songs
Before He Dazzles Us Again With McCartney III, Here's Some of Macca's Greatest Low-Lights.
Paul McCartney is really no stranger to the mainstream. For most rock fans, this man has been making music longer than your favorite rock stars have been alive. Even with the impressive body of work he has with the Beatles and solo, there are some that have fallen through the cracks.
Even with a bit of a shaky start to his solo career, McCartney has been able to work musical magic even when out of the mainstream spotlight. Whether it be with Wings or truly by himself, the man's gift for melody never really left him, allowing him to follow his muse wherever he saw fit. Granted, there is some embarrassing stuff every now and again, but there is also some pieces that sound like they're on the cutting edge of something brilliant at every corner. One second you'll see him dipping his toes into electronic soundscapes, and the next he will be reinventing himself as a rustic country rock storyteller.
Either way, you can normally expect something to get stuck in your head by the time the song is over. From uptempo rockers to some of the most beautiful ballads known to man, here's just a taste of what to expect from the man who blazed the trail for pop as we know it.
10. Sing the Changes - Electric Arguments
Paul McCartney has always gone under a variety of aliases in his time. Whether it was being known as the frontman for Wings, the Cute Beatle, or even Percy "Thrills" Thrillington, Macca always used different psuedonyms to divorce himself from the high bar he had set for himself. On the other hand, don't take that to mean that every side project was necessarily bad.
Right after coming off of his work in the classical world with the Liverpool Oratorio, McCartney started to make different forms of electronic music under the name the Fireman, which proved to be a welcome change of pace for most fans. Though this kind of stuff never really saw chart success, Sing the Changes off Electric Arguments was a return to the Paul McCartney that many of us had taken for granted.
Compared to the slower pop he was coming out with, this song was a throwback to the psychedelic pop of the Beatles' years, with a singalong chorus and just the subtlest of electronic enhancements to make the whole track feel like it's floating in the sky. While this was never a big hit, McCartney did think enough of the tune to include it on his live album Good Evening New York City. Despite the '60s hippie culture becoming a stereotype at this point, Sing the Changes is a glimpse into what made that mindset so special in the first place.
9. Junk - McCartney
At the start of 1970, there was no real road map for where Paul could go next. After being the bassist and key songwriter for one of the biggest bands of the previous decade, what happens when you find yourself without the rest of your mates? Though he may have been known as a perfectionist in the Beatles, Junk showed us the warts-and-all Paul McCartney no one knew we needed.
For the most part, McCartney's self-titled is way too rough around the edges, with some of the most fragmented compositions he has ever released to the public. While Maybe I'm Amazed has gotten its due throughout the years, there's a certain spare beauty that comes in the form of Junk. Written while the Beatles were still together, you can still hear Paul's incredible gift for melody, as he uses almost jazzy chords that would have fit right in on something like Mother Nature's Son from the same era.
Then again, it makes sense why this was never issued as a full-on single, considering that most of it sounds like a demo, as Paul gets a feel for the instruments he has at his disposal. This would have made for an unstoppable ballad later down the line, but as far as demos go, you could certainly do much worse than this.
8. Despite Repeated Warnings - Egypt Station
You can't really count on music legends to come up with aces every time they go into the studio. Even if a new album is on the horizon, there's no reason to expect that Paul McCartney is going to grace us with another version of Abbey Road all over again. Then again, songs like Despite Repeated Warnings show that you should never count out these legends either.
On the whole, Egypt Station is a great addition to McCartney's later period, showing that he's able to adapt with the times and incorporate his trademark optimism into the modern pop scene. Though there are a lot of traditional peace-and-love themed tunes laced throughout the album, this penultimate track is where we get to see Macca's political tongue out in full force. Always a great storyteller, we see McCartney telling a story of a ship on a crash course, as the captain refuses to heed any of the warnings from his crew.
Though it was never overtly said, it's hard not to look at this as an homage to Donald Trump, right down to Paul talking about this captain having his own agenda and not going along with the program. For a man who has been known for his more easygoing behavior throughout his career, it's nice to see that even in his old age, Macca isn't afraid to speak his mind on the state of the world.
7. Jenny Wren - Chaos and Creation in the Backyard
As the '00s turned a corner, Paul didn't really need to rely on a hit single anymore. After fully recovering from the death of his wife Linda, he was now making music for himself regardless of what the cynics may have thought of it. On the other hand, what happens when you pair one of the greatest rock songwriters of all time with the producer behind Radiohead's greatest records?
Across Chaos and Creation in the Backyard, you can tell that Paul is getting back in tune with what would become his signature modern style, with pop tunes that toed the line between extremely catchy and lyrically complex. Though there are plenty of great tunes to go around on this record, Jenny Wren is the one take that has a few faint wisps of the early days laced throughout.
Set to a simple acoustic guitar line, you can almost hear echoes of Blackbird in the song construction, especially as we hear McCartney talk about the struggles of our protagonist who has weathered most of life's hardships, from heartache to poverty. Even though there aren't too many lyrics on this one, every single line tends to have some significance behind it, from seeing the world's foolishness to spending days casting love aside. Paul had certainly come a long way since his Beatle years, but Jenny Wren is a perfect example of a song that is both reminiscent of his old style while also pointing a path towards the future.
6. Tomorrow - Wild Life
Wild Life by Wings is not exactly a high point when talking about the best of McCartney's solo career. Across every song on this debut, you can tell that Paul and Linda were just starting to get the ball rolling with this new lineup, given that most of these songs result in nothing more than just decent jam sessions. However, the album does pick up a bit of steam towards the back half.
Though a lot has been said about McCartney's apology to John Lennon on the album closer Dear Friend, the first great Wings song rears its head on Tomorrow, which sounds like it could have been a hit single in Paul's solo catalog. Set to a slow piano melody, this song feels like the counterpart to something like Another Day, complete with some of the most beautiful singing Paul had ever laid down up until this point. Even though these lyrics are certainly nothing new for the Cute Beatle, this is one example of where those "silly love songs" work in his favor.
Then again, it's hard to really separate this song from the album, what with its lyrical masterpieces like Bip Bop and Mumbo. While most of Wild Life tends to feel more like a decent demo than a proper album, Tomorrow is one of those McCartney gems that you need to dig up yesterday.
5. Waterfalls - McCartney II
There was some question as to where Paul was going to go next after disassembling Wings. For most of the '70s, this new band had been his main vehicle away from the Beatles, even giving him some of his biggest hits like Live and Let Die and Jet. Those days were gone now...it was time to strip everything back to canvas.
Going back to the model of his first solo album, McCartney II shows Paul embracing the electronic sounds coming from the new wave sphere, which made for some of the more eccentric (and annoying) songs of his career. Though there are some people who can't get behind something like Temporary Secretary, Waterfalls is where we see Paul's genius shining through all the synthesizers. With only a subtle synth line to anchor everything, the song is carried by Paul's vocal, as he talks about being heartbroken and in need of repair.
While most of the song stays in line with what you'd expect from Paul, the production on this song is right where it needs to be. Being somewhat of a DIY construct, there are even some spots on here that sound like what Damon Albarn would be doing decades down the road with Gorillaz's debut record. It may be a little frayed around the ends, but you'd be hardpressed to find anything else on the radio this gorgeous.
4. Morse Moose and the Grey Goose - London Town
The journey of Wings gets a little bit spotty once you reach London Town. With half of the band quitting again after a falling out over business, Macca, Linda, and Denny Laine came up with some of the more radio-friendly songs of their career like Girlfriend and the title track. Though this album can get a bit too yacht rock for some people, they knew how to bring everything home on Morse Moose and the Grey Goose.
Compared to all of the other Wings tracks up until this point, this was one of the most experimental things they had ever come out with. While most of the song is structured like Band on the Run closer 1985, the amount of love and care put into this story is amazing, as McCartney plays the role of a man stranded out at sea searching for help. That kind of synopsis would be enough, but these guys end up incorporating different sonar sounds and ambient noise to make borderline musical theater.
When taken with McCartney's entire body of work, this sounds like the offspring of something like Tomorrow Never Knows, more of an audio experience than an actual song. Given that Paul was always known as the radio-friendly side of the Beatles, the sheer weirdness of this song would have surely made John Lennon proud.
3. Only Mama Knows - Memory Almost Full
As McCartney reached his elderstatesmen phase, there was no real reason to keep making rock tunes like he did in the early days. Whereas a song like Hi Hi Hi or Junior's Farm may have done well in the '70s, the late period albums like Driving Rain and Flaming Pie were going for a more mellow mood than many rock fans may have wanted. Just when you thought his days of heaviness were over, Macca gave us quite the surprise on Memory Almost Full.
For the most part, this album has some decent McCartney tunes like Dance Tonight and Ever Present Past, but Only Mama Knows sticks out like a sore thumb on this album in the best way possible. Opening up like your traditional McCartney tune, the chorus is what really throws you for a loop, where the loud guitars come in and Paul comes through with a vocal that is both angry and playful all at the same time.
This isn't the '50s style rock and roll either, as guitars cascade across your eardrums that almost seem reminiscent of the more caustic rockers on albums like Revolver or even Band on the Run. Even though Paul doesn't kick out the jams that much anymore, when he does decide to throw down, he's playing to win.
2. Monkberry Moon Delight - RAM
There's been a bit of a divided opinion on McCartney's rustic album RAM ever since it was released in the early '70s. Being the first proper artistic statement since his Beatle years, the country tinged sounds of this album did end up turning some fans off who preferred the classic Paul sound. Say what you want to about RAM as a whole, it certainly is unique for what it is, with Monkberry Moon Delight being the weirdest song Paul ever wrote.
From the moment the track starts, it almost feels like you've been transported into some warped circus, with a rolling guitar line that never really resolves quite like it should. If you think that's not weird enough, just wait until you get to Paul's vocal, whose gruffness has never really been equaled anywhere else in his solo career.
Granted, the lyrics don't really mean much outside of nonsense, but this track is more about the sound that it's able to create rather than the actual wisdom it's supposed to impart. And even with all of the backlash that she gets over the years, the addition of Linda McCartney actually really works here, with her background vocals gelling just right next to Macca's howls. While this might not be as earth-shattering as something like Let it Be or Yesterday, leave it to Paul McCartney to take what would have been considered trash and make it pretty compelling.
1. Soily - Wings Over America
When it comes to rock and roll, there's no better showcase than the live album. Whereas a lot of live releases are considered throwaways now, it's golden age in the '70s often included some of the best material any band had to offer, be it Cheap Trick, Peter Frampton, or even KISS. However, Wings Over America gave us one of the greatest rockers McCartney ever made in Soily.
Coming right at the tail end of the record, this song is one of the most raucous compositions that Paul had ever attempted in his Wings years, as he pulls out his Little Richard-esque screams and a growling bass performance. From the tempo to the rapid fire delivery, Macca hadn't sounded this raw and aggressive since his work on Helter Skelter back in his Beatles years. Compared to the more metallic acts arriving on the scene like Black Sabbath and Led Zeppelin, this song is almost punk in its delivery, almost as if Paul is trying to prove that he can write more than silly love songs.
It's also a testament to this performance that Soily never got a proper studio recording, instead remaining a relic on their live album and a staple of the Wings tour. Even with a plethora of different albums to choose from, this one little track stands as the greatest McCartney rocker that most fairweather fans have never heard of.