10 Musical Collaborations That Didn't Really Work
The Glorious Fumbles.
When you hear about two giants collaborating with each other, the hype normally goes through the roof. Since we would usually go nuts over your average new music, seeing two giants going toe to toe with each other is enough to get people buzzing like crazy. And then they hear the finished product and realize that they may not have thought everything through that well.
Before we even get into this, it's not like these people were aiming to make something bad. If anything, it's noble of each of these artists to actually try something like this out, going for a new sound and trying to push themselves creatively. The only problem is that they worked themselves into creative ditches most of the time, turning in singles that were either dead on arrival or just making stuff that's too weird to put into words.
Most of the time you're less disappointed and more dumbfounded at the fact that these were actual projects that existed and people actually forked over money to make it. It's always nice to experiment, but you guys are much better working with your main gigs then trying your hand at something different. The names on here should tell you to get your hopes up, but you're probably going to end up facepalming a lot more than you thought with songs like this.
10. Fade In Out - Oasis and Johnny Depp
Not every song on this list has to necessarily be an all time trainwreck. When you have two great players come together on a project, sometimes the energy just doesn't work and you're left with something that's more disappointing than anything else. And if we're talking star power, a song like Fade In Out should have been a much bigger deal than it ultimately became.
Since this was the moment where Oasis were on top of the world, Noel Gallagher wanted to bring in a handful of guests to contribute something to the record. Just like Paul Weller had played the iconic guitar solo on Champagne Supernova, the slide guitar on this song was performed by Johnny Depp, and you wouldn't know it if you weren't told just now. While Depp is definitely a competent guitar player for the likes of The Hollywood Vampires, hearing him on this song is nothing more than musical window dressing, just adding another track to the layers upon layers of guitars on Be Here Now.
And it's not like the song is all that bad either. If you listen to what happened when Oasis took to the road, the live version of this song sounds absolutely amazing, almost evoking the same kind of vibe that you would get from a song like Headshrinker. All we're left with in the studio is just a wash of guitars, with Noel trying to make it sound as large as possible. Then again, making a song sound as big as possible isn't going to mean a thing if you don't make it sound good as well.
9. Can't Stop Partying - Weezer and Lil Wayne
During the mid '00s, Weezer fans were about to enter an extremely dark time. Although Rivers Cuomo's return to rock on albums like Maladroit was solid all around, the draw towards more mainstream material on songs like Beverly Hills veered on the wrong side of cringy a lot of the time. It may have just seemed like a blip on the radar, but nothing could have prepared for what went down in the middle of Raditude.
While most of this record is not looked back on that fondly by Weezer fans, Can't Stop Partying is where the entire project hits a brick wall, with Rivers talking about how much fun it is to be partying all night long. For most Weezer fans, you don't even need to be told why this is bad, as the same guy who wrote Say It Ain't So is now talking about loving his addiction and wanting to become one of the cool kids.
And to put the cherry on top of this whole thing, here's Lil Wayne on hand to drop a guest verse, which feels like it was only made for him to sneak in a line at the beginning saying "It's Weezer and It's Weezy." What makes it worse is that this song sounds 1000% better on Rivers' original demo, sounding like a man so distraught at not being able to stop partying. But no...we had to settle on the dance club banger written by the kings of nerd rock.
8. Nine Lives - Def Leppard and Tim McGraw
It's not the worst idea for some rock stars to turn to country as they grow older. You can get a lot more perspective in the music industry over time, and some of the best writers in the world tend to turn to Nashville to get some more experience under their belt. When you try to do country on rock's terms though, it doesn't really come together in the same way.
As Def Leppard were coming off of their covers record Yeah!, hearing them work with country superstar Tim McGraw feels more like they were trying to get him for name recognition than actual songwriting expertise. While Tim does a pretty respectable job behind the mic, most of this just feels like your standard Def Leppard song that just tacked on a guest verse from someone else to just make it sound finished. And for all the acts to go country, it makes zero sense to see Leppard going that route.
Here was a band that are damn proud of their rock roots, down to the fact that they have the word in a lot of their songs, and now they're suddenly trying to put themselves in the good graces of Nashville. Even though the rest of Songs from the Sparkle Lounge was a return to form, this is the kind of music that feels like it's supposed to soundtrack a middle aged biker rally than actually push the genre forward.
7. Nightlife - Green Day and Lady Cobra
When Green Day first announced that they were making a trilogy of albums, it didn't feel like the worst thing in the world. These guys had already written two untouchable rock operas, so they had enough experience under their belt to tackle something like this. And while Uno may have been a return to roots, Dos was the garage rock record where everything went wrong.
Then again, it's not hard to see why most Green Day fans like to clown on this song so much, being way too slow for a band that identifies as punk and Billie Joe Armstrong sounding like he's half asleep behind the mic during the chorus. Billie doesn't have to do much on this song though, with most of the lyrics being a rap from Lady Cobra, who hails from an underground band in the Bay Area that Billie was a fan of. This isn't Kendrick Lamar or anything though, since most of these lyrics sound like something that you would hear in some skeezy adult film than a Green Day album.
Considering Green Day don't do features all that often, having one of the only ones go to this track is mind boggling, like they're trying to tap into the dark atmosphere of Arctic Monkeys and winding up closer to the dozier side of a band like The Black Keys. While the punk side of things was already lacking on 21st Century Breakdown, this song made all of us wonder if we had lost the band that gave us Basket Case for good.
6. Illusion of Power - Black Sabbath and Ice T
Towards the end of the '80s, the idea of rock and hip hop working together was actually starting to gain some traction. In the wake of collaborations between Anthrax and Public Enemy, there was definitely a middle ground between the heaviness of metal guitar and the in your face production that you got from the golden age of hip hop. So when the real OGs of both genres come together, how did Illusion of Power fumble like it did?
While it could be easy to dismiss the haters not welcoming change, they do have a point when it comes to the first song on Black Sabbath's Forbidden. Though Ice T has never been shy about his love for metal music, hearing him alongside Tony Iommi's guitar feels a lot more disorienting, almost like he's trying to make the song sound heavy and coming off like he's trying to compete with Sabbath. And when you put yourself up against Sabbath in terms of heaviness, you lose EVERY SINGLE TIME!
Then again, it's not really that much of a competition on here, just having both of these two different styles inching close together but never quite gelling. Whereas something like Bring the Noise made too much sense back in the day, Illusion of Power is just having both of these legends standing next to each other and just hoping that everything comes together in the mix.
5. Drawbar - Linkin Park and Tom Morello
Tom Morello doesn't really have to prove a point to anyone anymore. Ever since the breakup of Rage Against the Machine, Tom could have still been considered a legend of the genre if he decided to never pick up a guitar again, still having some of the weirdest sounds of the six string under his belt. If you're in the game long enough though, you need to make sure that you don't get rusty along the line.
Because when Linkin Park made The Hunting Party, Morello was one of the first names on the list to collaborate with, seeing the entire record as being a love letter to the kind of hard edged rock and roll that they loved as kids. And while people like Daron Malakian and Page Hamilton have some great moments on the record, you probably wouldn't have been able to spot Morello on Drawbar if you hadn't been told.
While the idea of a Linkin Park interlude should be fantastic news given their track record with Session and Cure For the Itch, this sort of ambient sound that Tom is going for here just doesn't work, especially when he plays licks that sound like he was recording someone's first few weeks playing guitar. Every collaborator should try to enhance the track that they're a part of, but you could take this entire track off of The Hunting Party altogether and probably not notice the difference.
4. All in the Family - Korn and Limp Bizkit
If you go back and look at the golden era of nu metal, you're going to see a whole lot of cringe. Although there were some standouts like Linkin Park and System of a Down leading the charge, the whiny set like Staind just wasn't all that fun to listen to. But if All in the Family is what nu metal sounds like when it's having fun, they might want to go back to the whiny stuff.
Coming towards the tail end of Follow the Leader, this was Korn goofing off in the studio with a rap battle between Jonathan Davis and Fred Durst. While Fred's track record was already a little spotty in Limp Bizkit's catalog, this is probably the one nu metal song that has aged the worst, as most of their rhymes are just him making gay jokes Davis for 3 minutes. Jonathan's rhymes aren't that much better either, with most of this sounding like all of the training rap scenes in 8 Mile if they were just played for laughs.
And it doesn't stop there, with Fred trying to spit "vicious" bars and coming up with "korn on the cob" as one his best disses. If nu metal already had a bad reputation, this is where the entire genre started its real downslide. I mean, when you go for something fun and all you can come up with is subpar dad jokes, you know you've crossed the line somewhere.
3. Accidental Racist - Brad Paisley and LL Cool J
One of the biggest draws for musicians to get together is the "message single." Even if the entire project ends up sounding terrible from the start, it will always get the celebrity seal of approval for actually stepping up and attempting to have an impact on the world. Then again, when you're making something with a message, some of them can be a little more on the nose than others and it hits a real ugly note.
That's not to say that Brad Paisley and LL Cool J didn't have their hearts in the right place when making Accidental Racist, looking to have some sort of dialogue about racial tension in the South. In execution though, this feels like some of the most uncomfortable conversations imaginable sung by a guy who's more equipped to be singing about the wonders of his truck. While we're already on unsteady ground with Brad Paisley taking on this song, hearing him trying to defend the Confederate flag on his Lynyrd Skynyrd T-shirt just makes for something incredibly cringy once you hear it in context.
And while LL does his best to act as the other side of the conversation, most of these rhymes feel more like they were written by Paisley and Cool James over here was just the rapper that they got to sing it. There's a lot of ugliness when it comes to racial tension, but it's made that much worse when you're not being careful about it. This is the kind of song that comes in trying to answer a lot of tough questions and then leaves you with more questions than you had going in.
2. River - Eminem And Ed Sheeran
Eminem could have set himself up to be one of the greatest rappers alive if he had decided to take a break after the Slim Shady era. Albums like the Eminem Show and The Marshall Mathers LP have become standards of the genre, and while not every line has necessarily held up that well, they're still some of the most raw anger ever heard on a hip hop release. That was the '00s though...and now we have the Eminem that's hitting his dad phase on River.
While the more mature version of Eminem has never been shy about using pop singers like Rihanna on his tracks, seeing Ed Sheeran on here is definitely not the right fit. Although Ed always came from a slightly hip hop background with the way that he writes, his signature emotional style of singing doesn't match with Em's angry flow at all, almost sounding like they're trying to sing two separate songs at the exact same time.
Ed Sheeran is by far the best part of this song though, as Em tries to top himself with just how many cringy lyrics he can fit into every single line. Though most of the lines on here could be his worst, what takes the cake has to be him talking about his former relationship by saying "just sh*t on my last chick cause she has what my ex lacks." The minute that that line was committed to tape, we all knew we were never going to get a Kim or Cleanin Out My Closet or even a Real Slim Shady ever again.
1. Lulu - Metallica and Lou Reed
Throughout their history, Metallica have never been strangers to controversy. Even as far back as the '80s, you had fans getting angry at them because they had the gall to use a tiny bit of acoustic guitar on Fade to Black, which is now regarded as one of their greatest songs. Even with the change on the Black Album and the sacrilege sound of St. Anger, we still weren't ready for what we eventually got on Lulu.
Bringing together a metal band like Metallica alongside art rocker Lou Reed would have made for great news at the time, until we actually saw what they had in store. While the riffs on most of these songs are solid, the momentum gets sucked out of them the minute that Lou opens his mouth, as he starts reciting poetry where James Hetfield's traditional vocals would be. And when James does contribute a few lines here and there, it ends up on the wrong side of hilarious, like him emotionally singing "SMALL TOWN GIRL" on Brandenburg Gate or reminding us that he is indeed the table on "The View."
Then again, this isn't the kind of hilarity that actually makes for something fun. No, the only reason why we're laughing is to keep ourselves from weeping at just how far the mighty have fallen. Metallica have since gone back to their metal roots though, and we all still have the Hetfield table memes to enjoy until the end of time.