10 Musicians That Got Fired From Huge Bands

Just Shy Of Iconic Territory.

Foo Fighters Learning To Fly
wiki

Every musician is going to do everything they can to reach the top of the world. This is a cutthroat business, so you're going to need to go the extra mile so that you're a cut above the rest of the acts that have come both before and after you. If you want to reach that point though, you might have to lose a bit of dead weight from the band in the process.

In the beginning of each of these band's careers, there was always that one person that didn't seem to be pulling as much of the workload as the rest of the band. That's not to say that all of these people on this list are terrible musicians. In fact, these people help set up the building blocks for most of these bands in the very early stages.

When it was called into question though, it didn't take these bands long to see what they had to do, letting them go in lieu of someone more capable for the job. Then again, it probably stings just a bit seeing your former friends find someone new and end up being one of the biggest bands in the world while you're left to look on the sidelines. You may have that Three Musketeers mentality in the very beginning, but things change as you grow older, and you're going to need to pull your weight if you're thinking of being there for the long haul.

10. Steven Adler - Guns N Roses

In the early days of Guns N Roses, the whole appeal of the Appetite for Destruction era felt like more than just another LA band from the Sunset Strip. These guys carried themselves like a gang, with everyone contributing a piece to the puzzle, from Slash's fiery lead work to Duff McKagan's punk edge on his bass. The pulse of everything was always the swing of Steven Adler, which ended up coming to a dead halt once Use Your Illusion got underway.

Because with a lot of success comes a lot of drugs in rock and roll, and Steven went down a rabbit hole that he was never able to bring himself out of, always trying to get clean and continuing to struggle with his demons. While you couldn't necessarily call anyone in the rest of the band squeaky clean in terms of substance abuse, the rest of the guys started to notice Adler's drumming suffering for it, leading to multiple ultimatums where the band would go to his house and investigate for any drugs that he had.

By the time that they had to cut the tracks, Axl had put his foot down, choosing to leave him behind and drafting in Matt Sorum from the Cult to play on the record instead. Even though this was the first time that the core family of Guns N Roses would be pulled apart, this was only the beginning of the next few years of insanity that led to their breakup in the '90s.


9. Jason Everman - Nirvana AND Soundgarden

When the Seattle scene was starting to come into its own during the late '80s, no one was really a snob with who played in what band. If you go back and look at the lineups from what would soon be legendary acts, you can find band members coming and going day after day, as everyone tried to land on the kind of lineup that made the best music. It would be bad enough to be kicked out of a huge band, but Jason Everman had to deal with getting booted from two of the biggest names in grunge.

Looking to explore the Seattle scene, Everman first struck gold when he became the second guitarist for Nirvana, even appearing on the album cover for the record Bleach. Though Kurt Cobain wanted a two guitar band, he didn't let Jason perform on Bleach despite him paying for the studio time to record the album. After finding himself leaving Nirvana, he seemed to land back on his feet when he was asked to join Soundgarden once original bassist Hiro Yammamoto left.

Aside from one cover of the Beatles' classic Come Together though, Jason was deemed not the right fit with the rest of them either, being let go within the span of a few months once Ben Shepherd was brought in. Despite not having the same kind of royalty checks as his former bandmates, there are only a handful of musicians in the Seattle area who can claim to have a resume that this guy had.


8. Mark Stone - Van Halen

For a few years in the early '70s, there was a good chance that we were never going to see the classic Van Halen lineup come to fruition. As much as Eddie and Alex may have worked well bouncing off each other, they started off as enemies with David Lee Roth, who was in a rival band that they were splitting their PA with. When they actually got Diamond Dave behind the mic though, it was time to let go of some dead weight on the bottom end.

Being a longtime friend of the Van Halens at school, Mark Stone was originally a much more straight ahead bass player for the band, always holding down the low end and making sure to balance out the sound between Eddie and Alex. As time went on though, he kept forgetting different parts when it came to play live with them, not having the same kind of drive that the rest of the band did to become global superstars.

If you ask Mark, he had said that he left to focus on his time at school, but the Van Halens have also made mention that Mark was a stoner kid who was more interested in building LSD molecules in class than actually paying attention. After seeing a performance of a local band named Snake, they found Michael Anthony, with a driving bass and a high vocal that perfectly complimented Dave's singing. Mike has said that he was just trying to keep up with the rest of the band, but they were already hitting on something magical.


7. Syd Barrett - Pink Floyd

When we talk about bands that had to fire members, usually it comes down to a personality clash. Not every act is meant to be a band of brothers, and sometimes you have those certain personalities that can turn toxic in the wrong situations. Pink Floyd were a band of brothers in the beginnings, and one of those brothers ended up burning out way too fast.

Though we normally associate Floyd with David Gilmour and Roger Waters, the original incarnation of the band had Syd Barrett at the helm, bringing together weird psychedelic sounds that fit perfectly in the world of '60s London. As he started to take to the road, Syd started a downward spiral with his mental health, often struggling to pay attention and not even being able to hold his guitar pick correctly during some rehearsals. While Gilmour was brought in as a second guitar player during A Saucerful of Secrets, they had to make the decision to dismiss Syd, thinking that a life on the road would ultimately kill him.

That doesn't mean Syd's presence ever left the rest of the band, as their classic records would be defined by his absence, from the dissection of lunacy in Dark Side of the Moon to the full on tribute album to their ill bandmate on Wish You Were Here. It might be easy to ignore Syd Barrett as a band member on paper, but if he hadn't been a part of Floyd in the beginning, chance are the shape of rock history would look a lot different.


6. Pete Willis - Def Leppard

The rock and roll lifestyle has always come with its fair share of misbehavior. As much as you might come back to the music at the end of the day, this is a genre that comes with a lot of excess, and there have been countless stories that involve bands indulging themselves in whatever way they can. And that's all well and good...as long as it doesn't get in the way of the actual recordings.

While Pete Willis was one of the main originators of Def Leppard in the early days, he started to become increasingly out of step with the rest of the band, going on drinking benders that got more and more out of hand when he took to the stage. The performance aspect is one thing, but when Leppard got into the studio to record Pyromania with producer Mutt Lange, Willis didn't have a prayer of being able to keep up.

Since Mutt is always about perfection, Pete couldn't even record the rhythm tracks correctly, including one time where he came to the studio after drinking an entire bottle of brandy the day before and turning in one of the worst performances they had ever heard. After telling Pete to go back home to chill out for a few days, the guys were already drafting in Phil Collen from the band Girl, who brought a more technical expertise to their sound alongside Steve Clark. Though Pyromania does have Pete's original rhythm tracks intact, this is really Phil's shining moment.


5. Franz Stahl - Foo Fighters

For the past 20 years, Dave Grohl has pretty much carved out a niche for himself as one of the single nicest people in rock and roll. As the Foo Fighters have gone on for the past few years, it's almost difficult not to have a good time seeing him do his thing, being just as enthusiastic about his music as he was when he first started playing. And it's good that he has that impression now because the first incarnation of the band was not the most functional band at the best of times.

During the recording of the Colour and The Shape, the band had already lost drummer William Goldsmith when Dave rerecorded his drums without him knowing it. After that was water under the bridge, Pat Smear announced he was quitting because he didn't want to deal with the touring life anymore. Dave had just the guy to fill his shoes though, with Franz Stahl being more than happy to take over, being a lifelong friend of Dave from back in the day when they were both in the band Scream.

It seemed like everything was falling into place, until it came time to actually write music, with Franz never really fitting into the band's creative process and the chemistry not quite gelling when they went into the studio. After a few great years on the road, Dave had to ask his friend to leave the band, eventually making There is Nothing Left to Lose as a three piece. Chris Shiftlett would be brought in later down the line as the next Foos guitarist, but it looked like the band was on extremely shaky ground going into the new millennium.


4. John Kiffemeyer - Green Day

The punk community has never really worried about technical chops. Since some of the greatest punk bands of all time could get by on just playing the bare essentials, it ended up being more about the attitude that you put into your playing than actually playing all of the correct notes at the right time. Once Green Day started to grow though, John Kiffmeyer was not necessarily going the same distance as the rest of his bandmates.

Trying to juggle drumming as well as his job as the band's agent and de facto manager, Kiffmeyer's job behind the kit was not exactly setting the world on fire, with more than a few times where he would fumble over different drum fills on their first handful of releases. Before the band could even fire him though, he had already announced his departure, saying that he was planning on no longer working with the band after deciding to go to college.

Even when they brought Tre Cool into the mix though, you could still hear the rough edges that needed to be ironed out, with Tre's playing being much too frantic for the rest of the band to even keep up with half the time. When they finally learned to serve the song on albums like Dookie, the pop punk brats that we loved to listen to started to finally fall into place.


3. Tony McCarroll - Oasis

When Oasis were getting the ball rolling, they weren't really all that concerned with being the most flashy players in the history of rock and roll. Their style of music was supposed to bring rock and roll back to basics, and even producer Owen Morris ended up cutting up bits and pieces of solos like Live Forever because they sounded too much like Slash. You still had to be competent behind your instrument though, and Noel had a real bone to pick with Tony McCarroll.

In the early days of the band, McCarroll was just the right guy for the job, having a kind of ramshackle way of playing the drums that gave a punky edge to their sound whenever they played live. Once they tried to transfer that to the studio, the whole thing turned into a disaster, to the point where they stuck the hiss on the front of Cigarettes and Alcohol because the drums go out of time with the rest of the band until they lock back in.

Though there were a few bright spots like Tony's feature on Bring It On Down, the band was under the impression that he was never going to be able to make the second record. If you listen to the kind of drum fills that are going on in tracks like Don't Look Back In Anger and Champagne Supernova, Noel knew that there was no chance that Tony was going to be able to step up to that kind of challenge. By the time the seeds of What's the Story Morning Glory were being planted with singles like Some Might Say, Tony was out the door and quickly replaced by Alan White.


2. Dave Mustaine - Metallica

The whole idea for some rock stars to get a little bit out of hand while on the road is nothing new at this point. If you know anything about party animals like Keith Moon or Joe Walsh, you know that there's a fair bit of debauchery that goes on whenever some rock stars leave the stage for the night. There comes a moment where you have to draw the line though, and Dave Mustaine found himself on the wrong end of that argument when he made his way to New York City with Metallica.

Then again, it makes zero sense that Metallica let Mustaine go for drinking too much, since they were garnering the nickname Alcoholica around the same time for how much liquor they could go through. It's all about how you handle it though, and the dark side of Dave made for too much when they made their way to the East Coast from California, trashing people's houses and getting the band into some pretty hairy situations before signing a record deal.

By the time they got to meet with Johnny Z at Megaforce Records, Dave was given a bus ticket back home to the West Coast, where he started to plan his scheme to get back at them by forming the thrash band Megadeth. This might not have been the most wholesome story for Mustaine to deal with, but if it meant that we got two of the greatest thrash bands in history out of the deal, it might have been a fair trade.


1. Pete Best - The Beatles

When the Beatles were making their first steps into rock and roll stardom in Liverpool, no one was thinking that they would become the living legends they are today. These were just rough and tumble kids that were looking to play the kind of American rock and roll that they loved, until their producer Brian Epstein was able to snag them a recording contract with Parlophone Records. Once they reached the studio, producer George Martin saw a lot of potential in these kids...with one small exception.

Playing most of their initial recordings like they would live, Martin was getting more and more dissatisfied with Pete Best's drumming, always changing up the rhythm and being generally a little sloppy whenever they tried to lay down early tracks like Love Me Do. While the initial idea was to hire a session musician to play drums on the record, the Beatles sided with Martin and brought in Ringo Starr from fellow Liverpool band Rory Storm and the Hurricanes, which sent fans into a frenzy when they played their old clubs.

It wasn't just the drumming either, since Best never quite fit in with the rest of the band, never getting the trademark moptop haircut and being generally quiet and reserved without the charisma of the rest of the band. Before Pete could even plead his case with Epstein, Paul McCartney was calling Brian on the phone to make sure the deed had been done. Pete was officially out, and the Beatles were now about to step into rock and roll history.


In this post: 
Foo Fighters
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97