10 Musicians That Got Fired From Huge Bands
Shown the door.
The rock and roll lifestyle isn’t supposed to have any rules. For most of the cycle of touring, it’s the Wild West, and you can find yourself getting into a lot of trouble when you’re having a little too much fun. You just have to remain on good terms with the rest of the band, and these guys rubbed their bandmates the wrong way one too many times.
As much as these artists may have been great behind their instruments, there was just as much drama behind the scenes that their musical brethren just couldn’t put up with anymore, sending them packing without even asking their input most of the time. It might seem heartbreaking at the moment, but half the time some of these firings are just about being realistic, with the bandmates not being on the same creative page as their fellow musicians or wanting to go in a different direction and not exactly gelling with them once they got everything going.
At the worst of times though, some of these firings end up playing out like a bad divorce, with musicians shouting expletives at each other, getting fed up with what the rest of the band was doing, or going on a public tirade about how the band was already down the tubes by the time they were leaving anyway. For all of the great music that they may have created together, the end of these friendships definitely got more than a little bit ugly.
10. John Kiffmeyer - Green Day
Being in a power trio is always a much different beast in the world of rock and roll. Since there's only three of you onstage, you all have to pull equal weight throughout the song so that everything doesn't collapse and turn to mush. Green Day already had a sturdy rhythm section with Billie Joe Armstrong and Mike Dirnt's guitars, but there was always a little bit of tension every time you listened to the actual drums.
Going through the first few years of their career, John Kiffmeyer tended to be the Achilles heel of the group every time they played live, sounding way too frantic behind the drum kit and never settling into the kind of groove that Billie Joe was working with at the time. Since pop punk didn't really have a name yet, John seemed to approach songs on their debut 39 Smooth from a more hardcore punk standpoint, which tends to get really sloppy on the pop friendly tracks like At the Library and I Was There.
Although John actually worked as the band's de facto manager at the time, his decision to step out of the band to go to college may have been a blessing in disguise, with the band grabbing Tre Cool from fellow punk rock band the Lookouts, who was much more about serving the song than just getting all of his pent up aggression throughout the course of a song. There might not have been anything inherently wrong with John, but we would have had a much bigger problem if he decided to stay for Kerplunk.
9. Dennis DeYoung - Styx
For a good portion of critics, Dennis DeYoung is the reason why Styx never actually reached their potential. Even though he had his fair share of hits under his belt like Come Sail Away, DeYoung's theatrical vision for the band and grating voice tended to hit the exact wrong note with the reviewer crowd, turning them into one of the worst reviewed bands to come out of the '70s. Dennis was the boss though, and the Styx reunion that the fans wanted ended with the rest of the band revolting against their creator.
When the guys were preparing to go on a new tour at the start of the '00s, Dennis was suffering from fatigue from being out on the road for so long, becoming light sensitive and not really wanting to commit to a full tour of constant shows day in and day out. The rest of the band needed to play their music though, and Dennis saw his band get taken away from him, never thinking that the rest of the guys would perform without him.
This wasn't the first time that Dennis got fired though, with tension rising during the Kilroy Was Here tour and Tommy Shaw leaving in a huff to form Damn Yankees and leaving the rest of the band high and dry. No band can really be called a true democracy all of the time, but there comes a point when you have to put the dictator in their place, and if they don't give up the reigns, you'll have to cut them loose.
8. Michael Anthony - Van Halen
It's impossible to be in a band like Van Halen and actually keep a low profile. This was the band that single-handedly shifted the rock scene to the Sunset Strip with a guitarist that could blow your mind the minute you heard him, so it's not like the cameras were exactly shy during the recording of records like 1984. Throughout every iteration of the band though, Michael Anthony was always the secret weapon of the group... until the early '00s.
Coming off of the abysmal reception to Van Halen III, the band initially went out on a tour with both David Lee Roth and Sammy Hagar, which got sidetracked after Eddie started to not take care of himself on the road. After one too many spats with Hagar though, the band announced a tour with the classic David Lee Roth era of the band, with Alex, Eddie, and.... Eddie's son Wolfgang filling out the bass parts. It might make sense to get yet another Van Halen into the band, but Michael Anthony's trademark harmonies were suddenly gone, being a staple of the band's sound through both the Dave and Sammy years.
From the looks of it though, Michael seemed to be cut out of the group because of his friendship with Sammy, with the band not even telling him they were moving on with Wolfie, and Dave even saying that this new version of the group that was going out on tour was a completely new band from what they had done back in the '80s. Even for a man that's as over the top as Dave, that's a below the belt move.
7. Tony McCarroll - Oasis
No member of Oasis was meant to be the greatest musician in the world by any stretch. While Noel Gallagher likes to talk about how he might be a god amongst musicians some of the time, he also admits that he doesn't know much on guitar, but knows enough to make some of the greatest songs in the world. A song is only as good as the performance though, and Tony McCarroll's days were numbered before Definitely Maybe even came out.
During the first few recording sessions for the album, Tony would be constantly out of step with the rest of the band, never quite playing in time and getting chewed out by the lads both on tour and during rehearsals. While songs like Bring It On Down sound monumental on the record, it's only out of pure frustration, with Tony getting to that point after being riled up by the rest of the band and becoming so furious that he found that sort of energy. When Noel was ready to take the leap on the next album though, he knew that tracks like Champagne Supernova and Don't Look Back In Anger would never have worked at the rate they were going.
Going into the studio for Some Might Say, the first single off of Morning Glory would be the last with Tony, ditching him for Alan White, who had much more precision behind the drumkit that suited songs like Wonderwall a lot better. It must have been awful for Tony being treated like dirt most of the time, but his style of drumming gives Definitely Maybe a punk rock vibe that they never really captured again.
6. Syd Barrett - Pink Floyd
Not everyone who comes into the world of rock is necessarily ready for the baggage. Even if you just want to play your songs for anyone to hear, the world of big business is always bound to get in the way of things sooner or later, leading to bands having to either compromise their sound or get frustrated to no end trying to make music the way they want to make it. It happened to Kurt Cobain, it happened to John Frusciante, and nowhere did it happen more drastically than with Syd Barrett.
While the origins of Pink Floyd may have been much more psychedelic than they became, Syd started to become less and less reliable both on stage and in the studio, numbing himself with drugs and slowly losing his mind over the next few years. This wasn't just some usual rock star meltdown either, with Syd struggling to even hold his guitar pick and some shows where he would go up onstage and not be able to get a single word out. Before the rock star life claimed a victim though, the rest of the band brought in David Gilmour to help out on guitar, deciding to kick Syd out of the band so he could take care of himself.
Even if Syd wasn't in the band, the rest of Floyd's existence would be defined by his absence, being the inspiration behind the element of madness on Dark Side of the Moon and the character of Pink in The Wall practically being a stand in for what Syd represented in Floyd's mind. Syd might not have been there in the physical sense, but his spirit is alive and well every time you put on something like Brian Damage.
5. Pete Willis - Def Leppard
When you're out on the road touring with your band, alcohol could practically be a cure to everything. Even if you're not up to playing a show, many bands have had stories about drinking their troubles away, fumbling onstage hammered and trying to make it through as much of the set as they can before passing out. You can have as much fun as you like onstage, but Def Leppard were in for a rude awakening when they got into the studio to record Pyromania.
Working with producer Mutt Lange, the band were forced to play in lock step with each other to get the tracks right, which didn't suit Pete Willis' style of playing. Although High N Dry may have gone well with Pete playing, his drunken behavior was not sitting well with Mutt or the rest of the band, including one instance where Mutt laughed at Pete's meagre attempt to record a guitar solo for the song Stagefright.
While the initial plan was to give Pete a few weeks to go back home and get his act together, the group were never going to waste time like that, bringing in Phil Collen from the band Girl to record guitar parts and nailing the solos to songs like Photograph in only a few takes. Though Pete would not step on a stage with Leppard again for decades, the band were at least sympathetic to his situation, giving him credit on Pyromania's back sleeve for his contribution to the group.
4. Stan Lynch - Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers
There aren't too many people in the rock world that would be so bitter as to pick a fight with Tom Petty. For all of his heartland rock aesthetics, Tom had been the leader of all things rock and roll up until his death, standing up for what's right in the music world and always looking out for the underdogs of the genre. The name of the band was always Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers though, and that never really sat well with Stan Lynch.
While tensions had been high with Stan ever since the days of Damn the Torpedoes, things weren't much better once Petty decided to spread his wings as a solo artist, with Stan wanting no part of the album Full Moon Fever because there were a few songs on there that he didn't really fit in with. Since Full Moon Fever was the model for Petty's career going forward, Stan didn't really feel like contributing to the album process, saying that he didn't like any of the songs on Wildflowers and feeling like he was playing in a cover band every time he got up on stage.
The whole ordeal reached a head when the band was going to play at The Viper Room in California, with Stan coming in an hour before the show started and mentioning to someone outside the band that the Heartbreakers weren't his main gig anymore. By the time Tom's manager had to make that fateful call, the writing was already on the wall, with Stan asking if he was fired just as some sort of relief. Though one chapter of the Heartbreakers' story was closed that day, the addition of Steve Ferrone gave the band a sense of peace they hadn't had for a long time.
3. Brian Jones - The Rolling Stones
Most of the Rolling Stones' story seems to begin and end with the partnership of Mick Jagger and Keith Richards. Since they started writing songs together in the early '60s, the band went from some of the hottest blues players that the British Invasion had ever seen to a songwriting powerhouse, trying out everything from psychedelia on She's A Rainbow to raw menace on a song like Gimme Shelter. The Rolling Stones may have been born from their songs, but the actual group began in the mind of Brian Jones.
For all of the great songs that he played on, Jones was really the mastermind behind the group in the early days, giving the band their name from a blues song and acting as the outfit's manager before Andrew Loog Oldham took over later down the line. Despite being able to play a myriad of different instruments, Brian never had an outlet for his creativity, always having to play second fiddle to Mick and Keith and never really getting a chance to let loose. With all of that energy stifled, Brian started to spiral fairly quickly, drinking heavily and becoming less reliable during Stones' sessions, bringing in Mick Taylor halfway through Beggars Banquet and kicking Brian out of the band.
Brian didn't last long after the Stones cut ties with him, getting more blitzed out of his mind at home before dying in his swimming pool under very mysterious circumstances. Given the fact that he built the band from the ground up and now seeing them go into the big leagues without him, the drugs may have just been trying to soothe Brian's broken heart.
2. Pete Best - The Beatles
The rise of the Beatles in the early '60s is the kind of magical luck that will probably never be seen again in pop music. Even though they may have just been the hottest skiffle group on Merseyside at the time, their manager Brian Epstein saw the potential hidden behind everything and finally found them time in Abbey Road Studios working alongside George Martin. The band seemed to have everything lined up for superstardom, until they actually had to hit PLAY for the recording.
After a few sessions, Martin called the band in saying that he wasn't happy with Pete Best's capabilities as a drummer, thinking that he wasn't really cut out for the songs. Although the initial plan was to hire a session drummer, the rest of the guys didn't want to lose the camaraderie, drafting in Ringo Starr from fellow Liverpool act Rory Storm and the Hurricanes, and ditching Pete. While the band had worked with Ringo before, they were not prepared for the backlash back home, with George Harrison even getting into a fist fight and sporting a black eye when they went into record with Ringo.
None of the Beatles can actually say they did the deed though, with Brian Epstein doing the dirty work and even getting a call midway through firing Pete from Paul McCartney to make sure that he had fired him. Pete may have missed out on some of the biggest accolades known to man, but even being a footnote in the story of the Beatles is more than most musicians do in their lifetime.
1. Dave Mustaine - Metallica
Not many people who get kicked out of bands manage to take it all that well. When you have that band of brothers mentality, it's not easy going back to your day job when the rest of the guys think that you're not cut out for the big time. There tends to be a lot of anger tangled up in those relationships, but Dave Mustaine used that anger to pull off one of the biggest comebacks in metal history.
After Metallica began their long trek across America to sign with MegaForce records in New York, Dave was getting more and more erratic, destroying people's houses and getting way too out of hand with his drinking, which usually escalated to violence fairly quickly. By the time the band got to New York, they had a bus ticket in hand for Dave, giving him a one way ticket back to California and keeping some of the riffs he wrote for themselves like Jump In the Fire and The Call of Ktulu.
On the bus ride back though, Dave was already planning something bigger down the line, hooking up with bassist David Ellefson not long after he got back and forming the crux of what became Megadeth, operating as a more technical version of what Metallica were doing half a world away. Dave already had his songwriting intact before he was sacked, but he wasn't going to let a band like Metallica keep him from becoming one of the greatest metal guitarists in the world.