10 Musicians We Had To Hate Before We Could Love

A metal band with keyboards? Run to the hills.

There are some bands that we instantly take to our hearts, bands so beloved that we€™ll happily overlook a dodgy concept album or ill-advised live EP. Think Bowie, The Clash and the Foo Fighters. Then there other bands who, no matter how hard they strain their vocals chords and tear at their instruments, fail to convince a single music-loving soul to treat them with anything but contempt. Think Limp Bizkit. Think Creed. There are, however, a handful of bands who are either mocked, derided or totally ignored by the press and public alike, yet be it through talent, intelligence or honest perseverance alone, go on to turn around their reputation and win the respect of the very people who previously wrote them off. Indeed, some of these bands go on to be pioneers, without whom the modern music landscape would look entirely different. It€™s time, then, to pay tribute to those irrepressible bands who refused to give up on the rock €˜n€™ roll dream, those talismanic artists who faced volleys of abuse from all quarters yet kept believing that one day they€™d get the last laugh. Ladies and gentlemen, take your hats off to these ten stalwarts.

10. Marilyn Manson

In 1996, Marilyn Manson were the most hated band in America, fronted by a totem of indecency who prowled the stage wrapped in bandages in front of imagery that channeled Satanism, numerology and fascism to terrify polite American society back into its gun closet. At their peak, songs were blacklisted from radio stations, shows were picketed by religious groups and, for a while, it seemed as though the self-styled antichrist superstars might actually take over the world. Yet along with this notoriety came the assumption that Manson was a degenerate idiot who only shouted because he had nothing useful to say. Then two teenagers, Dylan Klebold and Eric Harris, gunned down twelve students at Columbine High School and, despite police insisting that no Marilyn Manson records were found at the boys€™ homes, the media blamed the band none the less. The platform on which Manson chose to defend himself was the Michael Moore documentary Bowling For Columbine, in which the vilified frontman revealed himself to be eloquent, intelligent and tenderhearted. While this didn€™t come as a surprise to Manson€™s fans, it did make millions of others reconsider the man whose antagonistic lyrics €“ €œI am the faggot anti-pope€, anyone? €“ had previously turned him into public enemy number one.

9. Blur

At the height of the 90s, Blur were locked in a battle of the bands with Oasis that would last a whole decade without coming to a fruitful conclusion. Yet while the Essex quartet snagged four gold records during this era, their chirpy indie pop was always considered lightweight, songs like Girls And Boys and Parklife having an unfortunate novelty quality that few thought would stand the test of time. As Cool Britannia rolled to a close, arch enemies Oasis plunged headlong into mediocrity while Blur went off the radar for two years. When they returned they were clutching fifth album Blur, a record that forced everyone to reconsider a band who should have burned up with the Britpop dream. Gone were the Mockney knees-up anthems, in their place a savvy new sound that took the alternative rock of Pavement and The Pixies and threw in a dash of Elvis Costello for measure. Overnight Blur were wrenched free from their reputation as nice but dim pretenders. They quickly became the darlings of the music press who recast them an as intelligent, experimental band of monolithic importance, a position of respect they continue to occupy to this day.

8. Motorhead

You might be rubbing your eyes at this point or wondering if you€™ve clicked on the wrong article, for surely Motorhead are one of the most beloved bands the world has ever seen? As evidenced by the huge public display of mourning when founder Ian €˜Lemmy€™ Kilmister passed away in December, they were indeed a band who united everybody, be it rock, pop or opera fans,with their raucous energy and uncompromising attitude. Yet when Motorhead first emerged from the ashes of prog rock legends Hawkwind, the music world wasn't quite so welcoming. For unlike in the modern day, when so many bands combine the dual influence of punk and metal that they€™ve almost become inseparable genres, the late 70s saw two distinct factions €“ the punks and the metalheads €“ both of whom hated each other intensely. Motorhead€™s problem was that they sounded like a punk band €“ breakneck pace, chunky power chords, lyrics full of hedonism €“ yet with their long hair, leather trousers and bullet belts, looked like a metal band. This saw them shunned by both punks and metalheads alike, though over time the trio relentlessly tore down the barriers and are now recognised as one of first meeting points between two genres that would go on to be best friends.

7. Fallout Boy

When Fall Out Boy first sprang from the Illinois suburbs boasting a spirited though unexceptional debut album, they quickly sunk into the soup of the emo scene that dominated the turn of the century. Their songs were brisk but lacked muscle, their lyrics snarky where they needed to be smart. Even follow up From Under The Cork Tree, which plunged into pop punk oblivion with choruses catchier than an sexually transmitted disease, failed to bother anyone for whom Hot Topic and the Warped Tour weren€™t the central pillars of existence. Then something strange happened: they started experimenting. In the blink of an eye, gone were the fresh-faced emo kids with fringes so long they interfered with their fretboards; in were a bunch of tour-hardened twenty-somethings intent on taking things to the next level. Third effort Infinity On High used strings and brass to blend soul and R&B into their trademark melodic rock. Critics lauded this newfound innovation while rock fans began to take them seriously. What came next? Three more gold albums, all experimental yet rooted in ten ton hooks and bolstered by choruses the size of oil tankers, along with acknowledgement that Fallout Boy are one of the most creative and influential bands of their generation.

6. Blink 182

Back in the mid '90s when Blink 182 were an insignificant pop punk band singing about apple shampoo at sophomore basement parties, they enjoyed the kind of respect that accompanies a total lack of success. Skip to 1999: Enema Of The State has just shot into the Billboard top ten and the trio are now enduring the vicious hostility that accompanies success. Yet it wasn€™t the soaring album sales and main stage festival slots that bothered their detractors the most. Instead, Blink€™s combination of whiny teenage angst and outright stupidity was considered an insult to punk€™s long-standing love affair with politics and social issues. Eventually, after shipping more than ten million albums and touring the world countless times, the frazzled band did something no one saw coming: made a dark, intense, serious record for adults then promptly split up. The upside was that, having expanded their pop punk template to include atmospheric keyboards and a guest slot for The Cure€™s Robert Smith, their farewell effort suggested there was more to the band than mere mother issues and masturbation jokes. Ok, so we still weren€™t going to their shows in the hope of an intellectual debate, but at least the flappy penis video for What's My Age Again? no longer defined them either.

5. Bring Me The Horizon

The vitriol poured upon Sheffield metallers Bring Me The Horizon upon the release of their debut EP was breathtaking to behold. Critics and metal fans alike jeered at the teenagers€™ full sleeve tattoos, floppy haircuts and pouty Myspace pics while questioning their knowledge of metal folklore. What, you can€™t name 50 obscure Norwegian metal bands from the 1980s? Ludicrous! Yet while their carefully manicured image came under fire (the band were frequently bottled off-stage while touring with Killswitch Engage), even the harshest hater found it hard to deny that their music, while still somewhat raw and confused, had a spark that might lead to something in the future. It would take a few more years, however, for the band to put the haters to bed. Wisely abandoning the unconvincing deathcore they'd pursued so far, the boys conjured a dark, gothic take on metalcore inspired by singer Oli's experience of sleep paralysis. It paid off big time, and suddenly they were taken seriously. Now respected for their ability to blend different musical influences into a brutal, brilliant whole, the Steel City kids took the long route to the top of their game.

4. Slipknot

It's hard to believe, but when Slipknot first crawled out of the badlands of Iowa they were torn apart by journalists and fans alike, their masks earning them a novelty act tag that wouldn€™t be shaken off until second album Iowa obliterated all opponents. Equally, their use of samples, synths, keyboards and turntables irritated the purists for whom metal was about one singular entity: the riff. Seventeen years and five platinum albums later, the band are considered not only one of the best of their generation but true pioneers, a ragtag mob of freaks who took on the notoriously hard to please metal genre and won. Weaving hip hop, psychedelia and even a little pop into their molten metal broth, the nine-piece plugged away until even the most hardened cynic had to admit that their talent, drive and innovation, not to mention sheer brutality, might actually make them one of the most important bands ever. Bolstered by a phenomenal live show, the band reversed their novelty reputation with ease.

3. Motley Crue

Punk is dead and there€™s no sign of a pulse. The world is begging for something vaguely new involving guitars. The stirrings of a movement can be seen in the skintight glam rock of Bon Jovi and the pouty posturing of Quiet Riot. Yes, it€™s 1983 and the hair metal scene is starting to take flight. While pretensions of hedonism exist, they€™re mild and made for daytime TV. Enter a backcombed mob of freaks called Motley Crue. Disgusted by how safe and sanitised this new form of rock €˜n€™ roll is becoming, they€™re out to ensure that sex, drugs and overdoses are shunted to the top of the agenda once more. Combining the spirit of the Sex Pistols with the aesthetics of the New York Dolls, they were quickly considered €“ much to their delight €“ as symbolic of everything that was wrong with America€™s lost generation. Music critics, meanwhile, shunned their music as crass and vacuous while continuing to champion Def Leppard. Go figure. Fast forward thirty five years of heroin addiction, nervous breakdowns, failed marriages and belting tunes and you have one of the most enduring rock €˜n€™ roll bands of all time. It helps that their best songs €“ Kickstart My Heart, Shout At The Devil, Girls Girls Girls €“ still sound as fresh and vital as they did three decades ago, but it€™s mostly the band€™s singularly unstoppable character that demands they be remembered as legends.

2. Eminem

When Eminem first burst onto MTV in the guise of Slim Shady, such was the outcry against his lyrics that there was practically a government inquiry into how such a monster could come to be. Accused by politicians and parents of promoting homophobia and sexism as well as condoning violence, many radio stations blacklisted his music while live shows were picketed by outraged religious groups. In short, he€™d stolen Marilyn Manson€™s mantle of being the most feared man in America. Of course kids loved him, yet with songs like My Name Is (€œwanna see me stick nine inch nails through each one of my eyelids? Wanna copy me and do exactly like I did?€) and Role Model (€œI€™m about to drown myself, you can try this at home and be just like me€), he was hip hop€™s answer to the Pied Piper of Hamelin, here to lead the world€™s children into a life of sex, drugs and self-destruction. Then The Marshall Mathers LP came along. Sure, the depravity was still there (driving your pregnant girlfriend off a bridge probably constitutes a felony) though the class clown vibe was replaced by a dark intensity that exposed the human heart of Mathers. His detractors hid embarrassed blushes as it dawned on them that Slim Shady was a character, a careful construction meant to represent the worst of humanity distilled into one being, and that Mathers was actually a talented artist and not a raging psychopath. From this point on, Eminem became one of the most respected rappers of his generation, his work, however controversial, revered for its artistic integrity rather than feared for its lyrical content.

1. 30 Seconds To Mars

Keanu Reeves is in a band. No, really. They opened for Bon Jovi once and they€™re absolutely awful. Other famous actors have bands, too: Kevin Bacon, Russell Crowe, even Corey Feldman. Yet without exception (only Juliette Lewis gets a lunch pass), they hawk out some of the most horrible attempts at music ever to be inflicted upon the human ear. We can be forgiven, then, for receiving the news that 30 Seconds To Mars, a trio so hotly tipped in Hollywood that at one point they had more cover shoots than recorded songs, contained Jared Leto. You know, the blonde guy who gets his head smashed in by Brad Pitt in Fight Club. The Cali lads were up against it from the start. Leto talked of playing to entire audiences who stood with their arms crossed chatting to their friends, paying no attention to the stage except to listlessly applaud roughly every three minutes or so. Yet the debut album arrived and it wasn€™t bad. Leto had a decent set of lungs and exuded such passion that it was difficult not to get carried along by his intensity. Then better albums came. Jethro Tull and Tool met modern melodic rock in a bare knuckle basement brawl. Leto€™s lyrics were abstract but heartfelt, the band earnest to the point of being cute. Cue a healthy cult following, then a large following, then a reluctant acceptance by the world at large that, try as we might to diminish the man who once filmed a sex scene with Kimberley Kates, the movie star turned rock star truly has had the last laugh. Apt, of course, given that this summer he€™ll be grinning at us from cinema screens once more as the terrifying new incarnation of the Joker.

In this post: 
Eminem
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Feature and fiction writer based in the north of England.