10 Perfect Rock Albums For Production

Blending The Clean and The Dirty.

Rumours Fleetwood Mac
Warner Bros.

Rock and roll has been known to be a dirty genre. Since most of the popular music that was coming out at the time was from the realm of jazz and big band, hearing something like Chuck Berry and Elvis Presley sounded like some of the nastiest music imaginable. That’s not to say that rock didn’t eventually learn how to clean up nicely.

Going through rock history, there are many different albums that have amazing productions behind them, whether that be using new recording techniques or the way they captured little moments in the studio as the tape was rolling. This isn’t a matter of dissecting the individual songs and finding out what they really mean. Even if some bands have the greatest songs of all time, it’s easy for them to sound dated in a few years if you don’t have the right producer in the chair. These weren’t just artists looking to just make another collection of songs.

This was a matter of making something long lasting, and half of these artists could practically be considered more like engineers than actual musicians. There’s still the same bite of rock and roll in here, but there’s just a little more sheen going on this time around.

10. In Utero - Nirvana

There are probably a bunch of audiophiles just shaking their heads at a pick like this, wondering how the hell anything with Steve Albini’s name on it could be on here. This is a guy known for some pretty gnarly hardcore punk records from back in the day, and hearing him teaming up with Nirvana made for one of the most abrasive sounding records of their career. All of that is true…and that’s why this thing sounds so amazing.

When work started on In Utero, Kurt Cobain envisioned it sounding really rough around the edges, and you can hear that from the first discordant sound of Serve the Servants. Throughout this entire record, Kurt was definitely at his wit’s end, and the production puts us right in the chaos with him, from the drums sounding loud as hell and the guitars sounding really in your face whenever they are brought up in the mix. This album was designed to be a lot more artsy, and listening to it makes you feel like you have raw nerves, as Kurt lashes out against his newfound fame and makes it sound like a living Hell.

When the nastiness is pushed back though, the softer moments shine that much brighter like the cello on All Apologies or the sleepy sound of Dumb. And to Albini’s credit, he did know when to push things a little bit more in the mix, like filling out the chorus of Heart Shaped Box with growling power chords from Krist Novoselic’s bass. This might not have been the Nirvana record most fans were asking for, but you start to appreciate the different left turns every time you put it on.


9. Rage Against the Machine - Rage Against the Machine

Around the same time that grunge was starting to make its first steps into the world, there was something a little different going on down South. In the same clubs that once housed bands like Winger and Motley Crue was a young band named Rage Against the Machine, with a sound that no one had ever thought of before. What was happening was nothing short of lightning in a bottle, and these four guys nailed their sound down in just a few days.

Recording out of the legendary Sound City studio, most of the first Rage record gets by on just sounding as fundamental as possible. While it didn’t have the same sounds as the grunge scene coming out at the time, fans could still appreciate the massive amount of punch behind this record, like Tom Morello stomping on his foot pedals to rip your face off at the beginning of Bombtrack or Timmy C’s bass flying off the hinges at the beginning of Take The Power Back.

Rage were always a rap rock outfit though, and the beat was the most important part of things, from Brad Wilk’s easy classic rock fills in the mix and Zack de la Rocha getting his point across with pure anger in his soul. It might be just a rock band and a microphone, but the songs behind it feel like so much power. This feels like the kind of music that you’re hearing on the street as the resistance starts preparing to go to war.


8. The Black Album - Metallica

After the ‘80s had faded, Metallica were in dire need of an upgrade in the production department. Although And Justice For All was met with a fairly positive reception by the fans, time has not been kind to the mix in the slightest, sounding super thin with no bass and James Hetfield sounding like he’s on his last legs from a vocal standpoint. And for all of the naysayers that it gets to this day, The Black Album is still one of the best sounding albums that metal has ever produced.

Though Bob Rock takes a brunt of the blame for making Metallica more mainstream after the ‘80s, his vision was always to write the best songs they could, which resulted in one of the most diverse sounding records in Metallica’s catalog. In between the traditional ballads like The Unforgiven, Sad But True might be the heaviest that their guitars ever got, along with weird outlandish ideas that went over well, like using gunshots on The God That Failed and bringing in a gong, sitar, and a 12 string bass for Wherever I May Roam.

Even the much maligned Nothing Else Matters still sounds like a true Metallica song, shifting the focus from the heavy guitars to an entire orchestra, making for something that feels almost bigger than rock in its construction. And for all the times that it’s beaten into the ground on the radio, there’s a reason why Enter Sandman is what gets everything going for new Metallica fans, having the riff lure you in before kicking you in the face. Metallica could have just done another record like they always do, but living in a world without the teeth behind Sad But True just feels wrong now.


7. Continuum - John Mayer

And this is probably where most people like to tune out or wonder what the hell John Mayer is doing on a list of great rock albums. It’s not like the holes aren’t clear as day in his delivery either, with his first few records being either too saccharine to take seriously or too douchey to really want to take seriously at all. John did have a vision though, and Continuum may be the greatest sounding rock record released in the ‘00s.

And that’s not even on the part of John all that much. Looking to make the perfect pop album that he always wanted to make, John is only as good as the people he’s working with, and having people like Steve Jordan and Pino Palladino in your wheelhouse makes for absolute magic on this record, always finding the right space to play a fill and also knowing when to support John when he takes center stage.

That’s not to put down John as a guitar player either, having just as many chops as the rest of the players behind him and turning in some phenomenal solos across this record like on Gravity and his cover of Hendrix’s Bold As Love. Before you even get to the solos, the tone on the guitar is near perfect on every track, whether that means the soft bends in Slow Dancing in a Burning Room or the fingerstyle stuff that happens in Stop This Train. As much as this might be a generic singer songwriter album on the surface, you never forget the humanity going on. These songs were made with human hands, and you can feel the heart beating through every song as well.


6. Pet Sounds - The Beach Boys

Each step that Brian Wilson took in the mid ‘60s felt like it was designed to reach Pet Sounds. In the wake of the Beatles getting more and more psychedelic with their records, Brian was convinced that he could take his band further, and set out to make songs that were about more than just fun in the sun with your girlfriend. Even with his back against the wall half the time, what came through turned into one of the most stunning albums in rock history.

Though Brian was already known for his unorthodox style of writing pop songs in the early days, he seems to go even more off the rails on every other track, using the Wrecking Crew session band like an instrument unto themselves, turning these magical moments into little symphonies like on God Only Knows and Don’t Talk Put Your Head on My Shoulder.

In between the traditional Beach Boys harmonies though, there are different pieces that shouldn’t really work in the context of the song yet somehow do, like when the band continues on while the bass is playing in a completely different key or the beginning of You Still Believe In Me as Brian “plays” the strings of the piano with different pins to get the raw sound that comes through the speakers. It may have sounded a little bit strange on mono mixes back in the day, but that’s because technology wasn’t even ready for Brian. Here was a guy that was working with a stereo mindset in a world that needed a few more years to catch up to him.


5. Aja - Steely Dan

When you really break down what they do, it’s hard to claim that Steely Dan really rocks any harder than any other rock and roll act out there. These guys have pretty much co-opted the dad rock aesthetic years before it became a thing, having the sounds that make you feel like you’re on some expensive yacht in the Virgin Islands in a tacky Hawaiian shirt. It’s easy to talk trash on their credibility, and another thing entirely to actually listen to the mix that we got on Aja.

Going through almost every single track, Walter Becker and Donald Fagen almost feel like studio lab rats than musicians, using the Steely Dan name more as an aesthetic than anything else. Though Fagen’s voice appears on every single one of these songs, the session musicians are almost looked at like sonic colors being used for their songs, like when they bring in Larry Carlton for some jazz guitar on Black Cow or Steve Gadd delivering a clinic on how to write an amazing drum solo on the title track.

This wasn’t just being in the right place at the right time either, as they worked with Gary Katz day in and day out to make the meticulous corrections when they needed, taking almost an entire day to lay down the solo on Peg. Even though this might still sound like dad rock today, this is the kind of wonderland that most audiophiles dream of whenever they put on their headphones. The ‘70s may have been a time of excess, but Steely Dan were already ahead of the game in terms of what you could do in the studio.


4. The Joshua Tree - U2

There’s an ongoing joke around everyone close to you U2 saying that the only time a record is finished is when it actually comes out. Even though we have the raw sounds of what these songs are like at the time, these are ever evolving ideas that take on a new life whenever they play them live. And for as many times as they got more and more artificial in the ‘90s with Zooropa and Pop, there’s something about the Joshua Tree that always feels human.

It’s not like they don’t flirt with new sounds here though, as the Edge brings in more delay effects to create different sounds around your head. That’s just one small part of the puzzle though, as Larry Mullen Jr. plays different world music style drum parts all the time, switching up the feel on songs like Bullet the Blue Sky and making a marching rhythm sound like the most important thing in the world on I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For.

And you don’t even need to get started on Bono during this era of the band, having the kind of vocal chops that could translate just as well live and they could on record. Most of the best albums of the ‘80s really show their age these days, but the Joshua Tree almost feels like a record out of time. With almost 40 years under its belt, it still feels like you’re stepping into the future when you hear it.


3. Rumours - Fleetwood Mac

It practically takes a small miracle for any album to get made properly. When you have a shoestring budget most of the time, you have to deal with creating some sort of magic whenever you step up to the microphone, and somehow have the right song with the right singer along the line. Even when you do have the budget for these blockbuster albums though, Rumours feels like it shouldn’t have been possible to be made this well.

Despite the production hazards, all of the band members were already at each others’ throats, both couples going through major separations while also being out of their minds on drugs in their downtime. Putting their differences aside though, every single song on this record is polished to an absolute sheen, balancing every single genre well and making each instrument pop out of the mix.

You can see a song like the Chain or Dreams as good songs by themselves, but you’re in for a treat actually peeling back the layers of sound, like the juicy keyboard parts from Christine McVie or hearing Lindsey Buckingham’s fingers moving across the strings of his guitar. The magic wasn’t lost on any of the audio nerds back in the day either, with most people playing this album as a way to demonstrate how well music could sound when played out of speakers. We were already exploring what genres could do in the late ‘70s, but Rumours feels the culmination of what can be done with a few good songs and some of the best producers in the business.


2. The Wall - Pink Floyd

For most of the albums that we’ve seen so far, there’s never a point where you don’t realize that you’re listening to an album. As much as they may seem like just another collection of songs, these are the kind of records that are meant to take you on a journey, even if it’s just a journey away from the real world for a little bit. Roger Waters was looking to make something more cinematic though, and the road to making the Wall almost feels like an undertaking unto itself.

In the process leading up to this album coming out, Roger took control of Pink Floyd and even had to fire Richard Wright after he couldn’t provide the parts that he was hearing in his head. Amid the turmoil though, progress was getting made on one of the most operatic concept albums of all time, telling the story of Pink closing himself off from society.

Though it’s easy just to come here for the classic songs like Another Brick in the Wall or Comfortably Numb, there’s a lot of emotion coming out of even the most subtle things here, like the loneliness behind the classical guitar on Is There Anybody Out There or the different cartoonish voices playing into the idea of this being meant for the stage as much as it is for the vinyl. Once you start paying attention to detail, hearing different melodic passages show up again make the whole thing come together, like Hey You interpolating the lick from Another Brick in the Wall over again. After years of coming to grips with their celebrity status, Floyd took their insecurities and turned it into high art.


1. Abbey Road - The Beatles

Towards the end of the ‘60s, there was nothing that the Beatles really needed to prove anymore. Going through their back catalog, they had revolutionized the rock scene two times over with the rise of the British Invasion and the Summer of Love, and they were starting to break free of their usual conventions on The White Album. The band definitely were growing apart creatively, but their final goodbye sounded unlike anything else that the rock world had to offer.

Looking to make albums the way they used to, Abbey Road was put together with George Martin at the helm, with each song taking on its own unique character. Returning with some new toys like the first Moog synthesizer, there’s almost a futuristic sound coming in on the back half of Here Comes the Sun or the barrage of white noise on I Want You (She’s So Heavy).

There are even some moments on this record that feel like they’re more suited to classical productions, like the baroque style harpsichord and overlapping harmonies in Because or finally building to a peak with the medley towards the end, weaving together bits and pieces of songs they had lying around and making it sound like one of the biggest finales that you’ve ever heard. Even though the next few years were bound to take their toll on the Fabs in their solo years, Abbey Road is still the peak of all that they're capable of: great songwriters coming together to turn their songs into something more than just notes on a page.


 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97