10 Perfect Songs From Terrible Bands

Getting It Right Once.

Fred Durst Limp Bizkit WrestleMania XIX
WWE.com

Not every band is meant to be one of the most legendary bands in the world. For every critical darling, there are just as many acts that get torn to shreds by critics who think they are a disgrace to the music industry, only to become stars anyway. Every artist has at least one great song in them though, and each of these artists really shine on these tracks.

For all of the venom that gets thrown their way, every single one of these songs has something unique to offer, whether it’s a weird experiment that the band hadn’t tried before or actually making a version of their older sound that’s a lot more digestible than what we had heard before. Are these necessarily on the same level as some of the most beloved bands of all time? Hell no.

By the standards that are normally set for each of these acts though, these songs blow every other track they made out of the water, leaving many to wonder whether it’s a fluke that they got these tracks to sound so good or thinking that they wasted all of their potential going into just one track. Every one of these acts has had more than their fair share of bile thrown their way, but for these few songs, there was no one else who could touch them.

10. In My Place - Coldplay

In the grand scheme of things, the only crime that Coldplay have really committed is just becoming stale. They might like to claim they're holding up the flag for rock music for the past few years, but the sounds of albums like Music of the Spheres have much more in common with pop music than anything that you're going to hear out of rock stations. Before the post Viva La Vida mess though, Coldplay could be a damn good pop rock band when they wanted to.

Coming off of their overnight success after Yellow, In My Place was originally written by Chris Martin to make sure he could still write a hit song, bringing it into the band almost fully finished. Though it might not have the same overarching sound of something like Clocks, the main guitar hook works beautifully over Chris' vocal melody, almost reaching the same heights that U2 were aiming for in their prime. Rather than Bono's overt politics though, we instead get Chris writing some of the most heartfelt lyrics of his career, feeling lost in his own mind and asking himself how long he has to deal with his own internal issues.

Compared to the eternal optimism that happens throughout the majority of their back catalog, it's surprising to see them get a lot more introspective here, sounding like they are actually concerned whether this whole thing is a fluke or if it's something they can make a career out of. That's what real emotion sounds like, and not something that's the musical equivalent of a Hallmark movie.


9. For the Movies - Buckcherry

There's a good chance that Buckcherry started their career about a decade too late. While they may have killed it on the same LA rock streets that Motley Crue came from, hearing this kind of sleazy rock and roll just seemed like a bad joke in the late '90s, as if Steel Panther were taking every single one of their songs seriously. Before Crazy Bi*ch became one of the biggest drunken singalongs in strip clubs across the world though, the band actually had...some heart?

For all of the macho posturing and screaming that Josh Todd likes to do, For the Movies is one of the more introspective songs that the band would ever write, talking about being down on your luck in the City of Angels and wondering if any of this hard work is ever going to pay off. While we're seeing most of this through the eyes of this couple in the song trying to make it work, it's not hard to make the connection between them and every kid who comes to Los Angeles with a twinkle in their eye, looking to find something a lot better than what they were getting back home.

Granted, the past few years have made many people regret giving bands like Buckcherry a shot, using their chance at fame to make some of the more tacky music that the rock scene has ever spat out. When you put these guitar chords and just a little bit of charisma together on a song like this though, making it big in the music industry actually seems like it could be possible.


8. Bat Country - Avenged Sevenfold

There is such a thing as too much exposure when it comes to metal music, and Avenged Sevenfold has never heard the end of it. For all of the amazing players that they have in their band, fans have been dogging on them ever since they hit it big on Waking the Fallen, calling them the more watered down version of what metal is supposed to be. You can try to tear them down all you want, but there's some genuine talent behind every one of these records, and Bat Country is a modern metal masterpiece.

Taking inspiration from the work of Hunter S Thompson, half of this song is an ode to the most sleazy sides of West Hollywood, talking about how the life of sex, drugs, and rock and roll actually seems pretty fun when you read into it. Although there are a few moments where M Shadows talks about how much self destruction you can get into, those roaring guitars almost seem like the devil luring you back in for more, giving you that adrenaline rush that most people hadn't heard since the days of Metallica and Guns N Roses.

The performances are also fantastic, being at the peak of the Rev era and him absolutely demolishing the kit, all while Zacky and Synyster trade different guitar licks and pepper in some incredibly tasty harmonies towards the end of the song. The world of this song isn't really for the faint of heart, but it only takes one hit of something like this to get you addicted for the rest of your life.


7. Push - Matchbox Twenty

In hindsight, there probably isn't one genre that was more derivative than post grunge. Even though the glory days of Nirvana and Pearl Jam made it seem like the revolution might be succeeding, the backwash sounds of bands like Staind and Creed left us with some of the most underwhelming rock music ever created, either talking about their scar collection or (in Creed's case) their rocking love for Jesus. If rockers didn't have much to love from that, Matchbox Twenty was practically Dawson's Creek grunge.

When you actually look past some of the lightweight riffs that were coming out of songs like Real World, Push is one of the few amazing songs that the band would ever put out, going past their mammoth single 3 AM and actually sounding like something that could have come off of a record by Live. Keeping it to a fairly standard rock setup, Rob Thomas' tale about a guy feeling left out to dry by society fits right into the normal loner anthems of the grunge movement, practically telling the same story of Glycerine by Bush or Creep by Radiohead.

While this is not necessarily the heaviest thing that grunge ever spat out by any means, you can definitely tell these guys were cut from the same cloth as bands like Nirvana and Alice in Chains, only with a more R.E.M. level of intensity. The world of grunge had grown a little bit calmer in the post-Cobain world, and there was nothing wrong with the rock star that girls could introduce to their parents.


6. Let Me Down - Limp Bizkit

It's about time that most of us realize that Limp Bizkit were a mistake to the history of rock. Even for a genre that could get as ridiculous as nu metal, it looked like most of us were starting to see the error of our ways in the early '00s, with Fred Durst getting more insufferable in interviews and pretty much starting a riot during their disastrous set at Woodstock 99. So right when everyone started to fall out of love with them, why did they pick right then to come out with something actually pretty good?

Right after Chocolate Starfish and the Hot Dog Flavored Water, Results May Vary is easily bottom of the barrel Limp Bizkit, with songs that have Fred trying to minimize the effects of Columbine and wanting to sniff a girl's underwear that he barely even knows. In between all of that disgusting behavior though comes Let Me Down, which has a pretty decent guitar hook and the rest of the band killing it behind the scenes, with John Otto's drums moving the groove forward and DJ Lethal putting together a beat that's about as good as the House of Pain days.

While it's easy to just say that it's good because Fred isn't visible, he actually shows up to work here, taking a back seat to the music and actually putting some genuine grit into his voice when he talks about feeling like he's ostracized from society. They might not have had guitar genius Wes Borland behind them, but sometimes bands show you what they're really made of when they have their backs against the wall like this.


5. Far Away - Nickelback

Ever since Nickelback's reign of terror in the '00s, there seems to have been a little change of heart when it comes to their back catalog. Much like the Star Wars prequels, the band's career trajectory has gone from being one of the biggest things in the world to the worst bands in history, and then looping back around to fans actually digging them again. While they might not be ready for full redemption just yet, Far Away might be one of the biggest indicators of why they should be remembered.

As much as Chad Kroeger talked about writing songs based on what sounds popular at the time, Far Away's attempt at a country rock hybrid actually suits them a lot better, giving Chad's vocals a break from screaming and actually tapping into something a little more vulnerable. While lyrics of a long distance relationship might not be the most thought provoking thing for a travelling rock musician to think of, Chad is selling it 100%, talking about how he can't wait to get back to his girl back home and almost combining the grit of James Hetfield with his usual grungy sound.

There's more to Nickelback than just Chad though, and the rest of the band are no slouches either, from the bass lifting the chorus up at exactly the right time to just the slightest hints of slide guitar brought into the mix. Nickelback might not make many people's all time favorite bands list, but when you hear songs like this, it's hard to argue with the few fans that are still ride or die for them.


4. Control - Puddle of Mudd

In the wake of Kurt Cobain's death, the stench of post grunge lasted a lot longer than most people wanted to. The old guard of the genre may have had great bands like Pearl Jam tapping into something real, but the next generation had to settle for acts like Candlebox who just couldn't seem to capture the magic in the same way. Once you get enough sales though, the label will want anyone who can yarl on their roster, and the world was given the horrors of Wes Scantlin.

Granted, Come Clean seemed designed to piss off a portion of the rock fanbase, with Wes pulling heavily from the post grunge scene and actually getting the seal of approval from Fred Durst before he even got signed. Before we witnessed songs like She Hates Me climb the charts and the most wretched cover of Nirvana's About A Girl ever put to tape, Control is the best foot forward that the band could have hoped for, having a meaty detuned guitar riff to tie everything together and Wes actually sounding angry over everything else, sounding like he's seething behind the microphone.

As much as a song like Blurry may have had better writing than a song like this, this feels more indicative of what Puddle of Mudd sounded like before they got signed, standing somewhere between the dirty sounds of grunge and adding a little bit of a metal edge into things. For all of the auditory mud that we've had to sit through, it's nice to take a look at the original clean slate when the band actually sounded like they were trying.


3. Interstate Love Song - Stone Temple Pilots

Right when Seattle was becoming the music capital of the world, many locals were getting a lot more protective of their music. Anyone would get uncomfortable when someone tries to invade their home territory, and some of the OG fans were lining up to pass judgement on anyone coming along who sounded even remotely like a poser. So when you had a band like STP coming along who actually sounded like they wanted to be rock stars, fans were ready to pounce at a moment's notice.

On the band's second album though, you can hear them starting to grow beyond just the grunge label, putting together a collection of decent rock songs with Interstate Love Song being damn near close to perfection. While there were already some grunge heavyweights by this point, what makes this song work was how much of a breath of fresh air it felt next to acts like Pearl Jam, bringing a bit of rock sunshine into the mix, almost like if the Eagles had been brought up listening to a lot of the Melvins.

Along with the amazing vocal harmonies on the chorus, the rest of the band are more than just set dressing here, with the bass line actually being pretty busy for the most part and the guitar lick actually having a fair bit of polish once you pee back all the layers of distortion. Stone Temple Pilots may have felt like everything wrong with grunge back in the day, but when we start looking through the history of '90s rock, Interstate Love Song might deserve a place alongside Smells Like Teen Spirit as one of the most best written rock songs of the time.


2. Bullets - Creed

It would be easy to just blame every single thing wrong with Creed squarely on Scott Stapp. Though you can get over the preachy lyrics in a song like Higher if you wanted to, the foundation of what would become Alter Bridge tended to get neutered whenever Scott opened his mouth, sounding like a poor man's Eddie Vedder and trying to sell it in tight leather pants. Creed always had a heavier side than songs like With Arms Wide Open, and their third album Weathered actually sounded like it was going to kick ass from the very first track.

With Mark Tremonti taking the reins with the main riff, the opening is about as metal as Creed would ever get, harkening back to the days of My Own Prison with how vicious some of the guitar licks sound. Just when you think that everything's going to start going downhill when Scott opens his mouth, the snarling sound of his voice combined with some clever audio effects actually makes the song a lot more intriguing, almost serving as an entrance to the rest of the record while the drums beat the snot out of you coming out of the chorus.

There are even a few moments where you get a sort of glimpse of what Alter Bridge was going to be a few years later, with Tremonti pulling out some of his flashiest guitar licks up to this point and Scott even trying out his higher register every now and again. Creed have always been known for going a little over the top in places, but a song like this sounds like it should be playing over the credits of an early '00s action movie in the best way possible.


1. Slow Dancing in a Burning Room - John Mayer

John Mayer is probably one of the main reasons why good guitar music doesn't chart that much anymore. Fans may have been able to stand the post grunge and even tolerated some of the nu metal schlock, but there was a limit, and that was crossed when the college frat bro brand of rock and roll started to get time on the charts with songs like Daughters and Your Body is a Wonderland. If you look past all of those douchey qualities though, we had one of the greatest guitarists of our generation buried just underneath it all.

For all of the snark that he might cram into his lyrics, Continuum by John Mayer is one of the best pop albums to come out of the '00s, with Slow Dancing in a Burning Room being damn close to his masterpiece. Having already studied the guitar licks of people like Jimi Hendrix and Stevie Ray Vaughan, you can hear John's subtle attention to detail even with the slightest string bend, making the guitar almost sound like it's crying during the solo sections of this song.

And while Wonderland might haunt people's dreams to this day, John actually has a more mature outlook on what love is about, depicting a relationship that's slowly falling apart, putting in slight jabs at his lover while also knowing that it's going to hurt like hell when he's left alone. You can call him a pretty boy if you want, and you can easily blame him for radio falling out of love with the guitar, but no musician can write a song like this unless they've put some real miles on their soul beforehand.


 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97