10 Perfect Songs On Terrible Albums

Shining Through the Cracks.

Nickelback Far Away
wiki

For every great album that’s in a band’s catalog, there are also a few that seem to not quite measure up to the rest. Whether it was a bad idea on the surface or things getting testy in the studio, each of these albums seemed doomed well before they hit store shelves and were quickly forgotten about once fans actually gave them a listen. If you throw all of the record away, you’re also pitching some stuff that may have been great to begin with.

Because even if these albums have a lot of faults, that doesn’t mean they’re inherently bad from beginning to end. Some of the worst songs that these bands have ever made turn up on these records, but there are also some songs that show them getting back on the right track if only for a few minutes, giving you a glimpse of the band you used to know lying just underneath the surface.

Once you notice songs like these, they end up sticking out like a sore thumb when you actually listen to the album in full, with either awful or forgettable songs coming and going before having something fantastic actually peek through the cracks. If anything, these are the few times where we actually start to see what these bands were going for with these projects, only for them to fumble it by going in a different direction.

10. I Am The Bullgod - Kid Rock

For most nu metal fans, Kid Rock is supposed to be a distant memory that's best left in the late '90s. Throughout his years of continued releases and dipping his toes into different genres, Mr. Rock has turned himself into one of the best used car salesmen that the rock scene has ever known, talking about how real he is despite growing up in suburban Detroit. If you're in the right headspace though, he seemed to have some sort of potential on his most successful work.

Although Devil Without a Cause is known more nowadays for Bawitdaba's dumbass chorus, I Am the Bullgod seems to be going for something that's a lot more dirty and almost metal in some places...and it actually pulls it off surprisingly well. With not as many obvious samples blaring in the background to remind you of the better music you could be listening to, Kid Rock actually sounds hungry on this track, looking to wallow in all of the excess that go into playing the big rock star.

Granted, it's easy to see Kid Rock playing to his strengths on a song like this as well, since rhymes about sex, drugs, and more drugs are pretty much everything there is to this lyric sheet. For all of the questionable decisions he's made in his lifetime, I Am The Bullgod feels like the quintessential Kid Rock song, looking to call his shot as one of the meanest mammajammas from Detroit (his words, not mine). It's not nearly as badass as he thinks it is, but we're one notch up from Bawitdaba's baby gibberish, and we have to take the victories that we get.


9. Far Away - Nickelback

And from one regrettable act we come to one of the biggest punching bags in the history of rock and roll. There's a good chance that you don't need someone like me to tell you that Nickelback is hated...chances are you've seen countless articles already say that at length. Chad Kroeger might not be on the level of Freddie Mercury or anything, but he can actually write something a bit more compelling when he wants to.

Which is strange considering All the Right Reasons was the moment where Nickelback really started to live up to their wasted potential, with Photograph turning into one of the biggest memes of the mid '00s. In between that and satire songs like Rockstar, there was also Far Away, which is a much more downtempo ballad that goes down a lot smoother. Without his signature scream, Chad actually sounds a lot more tolerable here, penning a nice song about being in a long distance relationship and trying to keep that connection even when you're half a world away.

Granted, the rock style is turned way back for a song like this, but Chad's voice is what really keeps it in the category, trying to tap into something a little bit heartfelt than just the raw aggression that he gets into half the time. This might be a cheesy ballad for most people, but if you find yourself falling on the more country side of rock and roll, you may actually want to give this one a shot.


8. This is England - The Clash

The entire downfall of the Clash feels like the great Greek tragedy of punk rock. While it was clear to anyone with eyes that the Sex Pistols weren't going to last very long, the words of Mick Jones and Joe Strummer felt like more than just your average rock and roll rebellion song, looking to tear down those corrupt with power and lead rockers into the next revolution. They almost went the distance, but Cut the Crap feels like the sad aftermath of a few too many bad decisions.

Having brought back Bernie Rhodes as their manager, Joe Strummer got the idea to fire Mick Jones and continue on with a whole new lineup of the Clash with Paul Simonon, which turned into one of the most regrettable records that a mainstream band have ever released. Though it's hard to really think of anything to salvage off of this project based on its questionable production, Joe Strummer stood by the fact that This is England is the last good Clash song, painting a grim look at the poverty going on during the Thatcher era.

Out of all the other songs on Cut the Crap, this feels like the vintage Clash that most of us remember, with Joe sounding depressed about not having any hope for the future and clinging to his motorcycle jacket even though he has to walk everywhere these days. The days of London Calling may have been gone for good, but The Clash at least had one more great song up their sleeves before calling it a day.


7. Eminence Front - The Who

Out of all the bands to come out of the Flower Power era of rock and roll, the Who actually seemed to have a fairly good shelf life in the years that followed. Since Pete Townshend was known for his attention to detail and not dancing to anyone else's tune, these songs helped resonate with future generations of rock stars, from the punk crowds to Eddie Vedder of Pearl Jam being a longtime fan of the group. Once we reached the '80s, it was hard for Pete to sound like the same angry young man.

For most of the album It's Hard, The Who seem to be smothered in the sounds of the time, with different synthesizers creeping into the mix and overtaking most of the songs half the time. And it seems that Pete knows that he's not at his best this time around either, if you listen to any of the lyrics that he says in Eminence Front. Even though this song has the same feel of the rest of the album, Pete is talking about how much the rock scene has changed since he was a kid, noting how quickly people forget about your ability to change the world around you.

If anything, this entire song gives away its message in the title itself, calling the rock and roll lifestyle just a front that businessmen put on to get the fans into the seats and bribing them out of their money. Since this would be one of the last Who records that we would see for a long time, it would make sense that Pete would lay it all on the line to tell us how much we're being ripped off.


6. Bullets - Creed

Ever since they broke up in the early '00s, everyone and their mother has tried their hand at their own terrible Creed impression. Their unique brand of spiritual post grunge may have seemed unique at the time, but hearing Scott Stapp blatantly copy Eddie Vedder's signature vocal style falls more on the corny side the more times you listen to it. The rest of the band did have some fire in their playing though, and it actually looked like we were going to hear some of it on the opening song to Weathered.

Though this entire record is known as the moment where things went way off the rails for the band, Bullets actually starts things off on the right foot, with Mark Tremonti pulling double duty on both guitar and bass and making a song that's probably the closest to metal that the band ever got. Scott is actually in rare form behind the mic this time around as well, playing off of the riffs in just the right way and actually having some fire in his delivery, understanding how they need to start off this record big after the success of Human Clay.

Then again, this song almost is better to look at in retrospect than it did at the time. From the aggressive sounds in the guitars to the more high energy vocal performances, this feels like it doesn't belong in the same category as a Creed song. Scott may have still been one of the biggest rock stars at the time, but the structure of this track is practically a warm up for Alter Bridge.


5. X-Kid - Green Day

Billie Joe Armstrong hasn't made it a secret that he wasn't in the best place when making Green Day's infamous trilogy of albums. Although there are some bright moments on these records, Billie's dependence on pills around this time made for some of the spottiest Green Day projects ever made, to the point where he considers the entire thing to have been entirely pointless. In between the more forgettable stuff, there are a few moments where he can tug on your heartstrings.

Though X-Kid is just your traditional Green Day single on the surface, Billie actually took the lyrics of this song from an experience that happened with one of his friends that had passed away. After being the rough and tumble kid back in the '90s, this song frames the narrator as lost in his old age, being too old to be so dumb and feeling like the rest of the world has left him in the dust.

As much as he might try to relive his glory days, he knows that there's no way that he can return back to his old stomping grounds anymore, becoming a shell of a man instead of the freewheeling punk rocker that he had always wanted to be. Billie may be singing about himself, but this song is more for the entirety of Generation X: those lost souls that will be mentally stranded in the '90s for the rest of their days.


4. Dear Friend - Wings

In Paul McCartney's own words, he didn't really know how to be in a band after the Beatles. Being heartbroken by losing some of his best friends as part of the Fab Four, the first few years of Macca's solo career was him trying to move on by making solo outfits with his wife Linda. When he finally assembled a band together with Wings, they were still clearly working through the bugs on Wild Life.

Going through most of this album, it feels more like a jam session than a proper record, with two songs on the first side being nothing but the band just riffing for a few minutes. Despite having a full band at his disposal this time around, Paul did have his former bandmates on his mind, and Dear Friend was his first attempt to build bridges with his former writing partner. After slinging mud at John Lennon on Too Many People and Lennon hurling some back on How Do You Sleep, Dear Friend is Paul's acceptance that they've both just reached different points in their lives and won't be available for each other like they did back in the day.

It isn't all doom and gloom though, as Paul closes things out saying that they've found love elsewhere in their lives and that will help keep them afloat even when things seem rough. Paul never wanted to hurt any of his best friends, and hearing this song was probably the first time that both the Fabs and fans started to heal a little bit.


3. Frantic - Metallica

The entire mission that Metallica had behind St. Anger was to make something that was closer to raw aggression, and the fans have never forgiven them for it. Despite fans being more and more fed up with the guys making more pop centric songs on albums like Load and ReLoad, seeing them go in the exact opposite direction so quickly made for an unlistenable piece of trash, with Lars Ulrich's drums sounding like literal garbage on every track. For the first track though, things seemed to be going pretty well.

Granted, one of the main reasons why people defend something like Frantic is because it's just the introduction to the chaos that's about to unfold on the rest of the album. That really sells the song short though, with riffs that are a lot more gutteral than what we have heard on the past few Metallica releases and the quiet/loud dynamics actually working well for this kind of style.

While James Hetfield's lyrics on this record do seem to be hit or miss depending on what song you're listening to, hearing him come to grips with his addiction problems on a song like this is fairly compelling, searching for something more to keep you satisfied until you drive yourself crazy trying to fill the void. This is far from the best of Metallica's catalog, but if the rest of St. Anger were like this, fans probably wouldn't be nearly as upset.


2. Shackler's Revenge - Guns N Roses

One of the biggest crimes that you can make in the world of rock is having too many anticipation. Even though keeping fans in the dark on some parts of your creative process is good to keep them excited for what comes next, leaving them yearning for more and more can become toxic pretty quickly. Waiting means getting expectations, and when they stack up skyscraper high, there was no way Axl Rose was going to be able to match them.

After having every other member of Guns N Roses leave during the mid '90s, Axl finally stepped up to the plate with Chinese Democracy in 2008, with songs that sounded like a complete mess when you actually heard them. In between some of the more Frankenstein-d songs, Shackler's Revenge is actually the closest that the album comes to the gritty sound of Guns N Roses that most people were waiting for. With the addition of new guitarists Bumblefoot and Buckethead, hearing them play off each other alongside Axl's wail is exactly fairly compelling.

Though hearing a Guns N Roses album without Slash behind the six string is certainly disheartening, Axl actually seems to show up on this song, not as savage as he was in the Appetite days but no less pissed off. There's a good chance that nothing could have lived up to Chinese Democracy's expectations, but this at least felt like a step in the right direction.


1. Under Pressure - Queen

Of all the bands that were legends in the '70s, Queen's sound was almost too perfect for the MTV generation. Given Freddie Mercury's ability to hold every single crowd in the palm of his hand, seeing them go pop on their album The Game felt like the next logical step for them, with Another One Bites the Dust turning them into superstars all over again. That kind of sound worked for one song though, and having an entire album of that seemed to get old a little too quickly.

Out of all the mainline Queen albums, even some of the band members aren't all that kind to Hot Space, seeing it as them just cashing in on the kind of trends that were coming out in the wake of artists like Michael Jackson. Most of this record would have probably gone by completely unnoticed, if it weren't for the one diamond of a final track with Under Pressure.

Compared to the rest of the album, Queen's classic collaboration with David Bowie is one of the more perfect rock songs to come out of the '80s, with both icons playing off each other's strengths and making one of the greatest feel good rock songs of all time. Looking at the rest of the tracks that came before it, this song sticks out like a sore thumb in the greatest way possible. It's completely unnecessary and it has no business being on this album, but when you have something that's this good, you can't just pass it up.


In this post: 
Nickelback
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97