10 Pop-Punk Bands Whose Second Album Was Better Than Their First

Sophomore Slump or Comeback of the Year? Here are the pop-punk bands defying the second album myth!

Pop Punk albums
Victory/MCA/Island/Reprise/Fueled by Ramen

Sophomore Slump or Comeback of the Year? You spend a lifetime creating one hit album only for a record label to want another in the fraction of the time. Of course the quality is going to diminish... Right? Wrong! Or so right it's wrong?

Well, writing a second successful album isn't the Simple Plan many think it may be, and there is the risk of hitting an All Time Low instead of finding some New Found Glory as the search for success continues.

The curse of the stagnant second album seems to be a myth when it comes to the genre of pop punk, with many iconic bands proving that the second go round doesn't always have to be less exciting!

Of course, not every pop punk band can upgrade on their opening efforts, but we've found ten whose sequel managed to trump their debut - but they likely had to pursue Every Avenue in order to do so, so let's stagedive right in and grab a pizza the action!

10. New Found Glory

NFG's Nothing Gold Can Stay definitely set us up for the path the band would embark on and remains a classic to this day. Propelled by the success of hit single Hit Or Miss - which has become a mainstay of the band's live setlists 'til this very day, the album received very favourable reviews upon its release.

Much like many first outings in the pop punk realm, the one weakness of Nothing Gold is also its charm - low production values mean the sound isn't incredible, but it does provide a rawness that's almost impossible to replicate as a band becomes more successful.

Filled with all the hooks and harmonies we've come to expect from one of the planet's most distinctive sounding bands, their first effort was incredible - which says a lot for what followed as their self-titled was even better!

Now, how do you improve on the album with Hit Or Miss on it? Well, you re-record Hit Or Miss and put it on the next one. This time, Dressed To Kill and Better Off Dead accompanied the hit single and it received the maximum five K! score from Kerrang among other impressive reviews.

No matter which you prefer, New Found Glory's first two albums still remain classics to this day - and may have been responsible for creating one of the most successful bands in rock music, as Pete Wentz handed over both albums to Jared Logan as inspiration for Fall Out Boy's debut release.


9. The All-American Rejects

The All-American Rejects' first album may have introduced us to the unique vocal stylings of Tyson Ritter - and birthed the incredible Swing, Swing - but you'd be hard pressed to find anyone who doesn't think Move Along is a much better all-round album.

The self-titled debut got favourable reviews and was listed on Rock Sound's 51 Most Essential Pop-Punk Albums of All Time list but, as was reflected in most of the reviews, was more of a signal of potential for things to come rather than the finished article.

Three years after the 2002 release, though, came Move Along - and that's precisely what the band did, as the band switched up their pop-punk stylings for a more direct rock release.

Any album opening with Dirty Little Secret was likely going to be the band's best work, but add Move Along and It Ends Tonight to the singles released from this album and a quarter of the tracklist is already stacked.

Move Along has now been certified as Double Platinum, having sold over two million copies, with the band seeing its greatest mainstream success to date with the three singles on their sophomore LP.


8. Every Avenue

Much like The All-American Rejects, there's a strong argument that Every Avenue's second outing is their greatest work.

First full-length album Shh, Just Go With It saw Every Avenue tour with All Time Low and Mayday Parade among others, but the album didn't make many waves in any charts, nor really outside of the United States.

Less than 18 months later, new single Tell Me I'm A Wreck was uploaded to MySpace (Yes, it was really that long ago) to precede the release of the fittingly-named Picture Perfect album. The title track and For Always, Forever bolster the strong singles outing from PP, while Mindset and Clumsy Little Heart ensure minimal filler on this LP.

Starring collaborations with Ryan Key of Yellowcard and Tom Higgenson of Plain White T's among others, Picture Perfect is 40 minutes of pure, unadulterated pop-punk pleasure.


7. Blink-182

Blink-182 are probably the biggest misnomer of this list, as their third and fourth albums were undoubtedly much more successful than their first and second.

However, for the purposes of this list, we need to chuck our thoughts on Enema of the State and Take Off Your Pants and Jacket to one side and look solely at their first two releases.

Cheshire Cat, their first release, was, by all means, a strong seller for an independent band - even at a time when piracy was just starting to peak. The album was released back in 1995, initially on cassette before a later CD release. While it's now seen as an iconic album, it was very much a "first album" in the regard of it now sounding like blink-182, but like a dissected version of what we know them to be with sprinkles of their trademarks throughout.

Featuring Carousel and M&M's as its openers and containing 16 tracks, it's a great listen for blink fans, but Dude Ranch was much more cohesive and polished and kicked off the band's journey to the top.

Dude Ranch was certified gold in 1998, and had broken one million copies by 2001. Filled with tracks like Dammit, Pathetic, Voyeur and Josie, it's plain to see why the album eclipsed its predecessor.


6. Set It Off

With three EPs under their belts before even releasing their first album, Cinematics, Set It Off were a band with more experience than most by the time that dreaded second release came around.

While Cinematics had a very admirable philanthropic cause, helping the band raise money for VH1's Save the Music Foundation, they rocketed into the limelight for their second outing.

Touring with Black Veil Brides and being featured on the Punk Goes... compilations saw Set It Off opened up to a whole new world of fans, before breakout single Ancient History had a video featuring actress Chelsea Mee.

Also featuring hit songs NMW and Wolf In Sheep's Clothing, Duality remains one of Set It Off's strongest albums - although successor Upside Down doubled its first week sales before band signed with Fearless Records.


5. Paramore

While All We Know Is Falling was a belter in its own right, Riot! was undoubtedly Paramore's coming out party.

While All We Know birthed tracks like Pressure and Emergency, it got Paramore off to a very rocky start with their record label. Not only did they initially want Hayley Williams to be a solo act, they almost fired the band because they thought they were "terrible" - before the band wrote Hallelujah and Here We Go Again and essentially saved the deal.

Almost from the get-go, it was clear Paramore had something special, but All We Know didn't quite achieve its potential until the release of Riot! sparked sales to life. None of its singles charted until after Riot! was released, and it's now been certified gold.

Riot!, of course, was Paramore's true coming out party. The band returned with an edgier look, with Hayley Williams' auburn hair now bright orange and the band in colourful skinny jeans - and their sound represented the aesthetics.

While All We Know had an edge, Riot's was razor-sharp and its angst acted as the catapult that shot Paramore to super-stardom with hit singles Misery Business, Crushcrushcrush, Hallelujah and That's What You Get. The album has since been certified Triple Platinum and was number ten on Rock Sound's 101 Modern Classics list.


4. My Chemical Romance

I Brought You My Bullets, You Brought Me A Better Album.

Firstly, apologies to all those who are gasping in horror at My Chemical Romance being classified as a pop punk band here, but it's near impossible to NOT have them on this list.

While the band's trajectory has taken them down the road of stadium rock, their first outing is very much in the pop punk mould - and arguably the best thing they ever did was veer away from those roots.

Three Cheers For Sweet Revenge is often thought of as MCR's first outing - purely because it's when they stepped out to be noticed! However, the lesser-known I Brought You My Bullets, You Brought Me Your Love was released way back in 2002.

Tracks like Vampires Will Never Hurt You, Headfirst For Halos and Honey, This Mirror... are still iconic to this day, but nothing could have ever lived up to the genius of Three Cheers. I'm Not Okay and Helena put the rocket on the band and gave them the platform for mainstream success with third album The Black Parade.

While somewhat of a departure from their punk origins, Three Cheers was a small step in the direction they've strode in now, and has sold over three million copies to date in the United States alone, and is still heralded as one of the greatest "emo" albums of all time.


3. Good Charlotte

There's no story like Good Charlotte's when it comes to the transition from first album to second.

Having almost been dropped by their label due to poor sales of their eponymous first album, GC produced an unskippable masterpiece with The Young and the Hopeless - selling 117,000 copies in its first week, two million within a year and now certified Triple Platinum.

Their self-titled debut did produce tracks like Little Things and Festival Song, but it was nothing compared to what would follow just a couple of years later when the band proved they were young, though anything but hopeless.

Standout track Lifestyles of the Rich and the Famous has become one of the most iconic pop punk songs ever due to its commentary on celebrity culture resonating with teenagers in the early '00s while Anthem and Girls & Boys rocketed into the charts themselves.

Remove the singles and you still have an amazing album with zero filler - with tracks like Wondering and Riot Girl becoming fan favourites.

While their first album is looked back on fondly, their second was much more cohesive and explosive - and almost certainly the band's greatest work.


2. Fall Out Boy

Ironically, the band who sing about a sophomore slump most definitely didn't suffer from one as From Under The Cork Tree trumped Take This To Your Grave by a long way!

Fall Out Boy may fall under a similar category to My Chemical Romance in that they really aren't a "pop-punk" band now - and pigeon-holing such a diverse band as such would be disrespectful to them - but it's worth acknowledging those roots when you rewind to their first two releases.

FOB's Take This To Your Grave was their punkiest outing, featuring tracks like Saturday and Grand Theft Autumn, but it still signalled the more theatrical road the band would embark upon. The album has been certified Gold in its own right, but barely holds a candle - never mind sixteen - to its successor.

From Under The Cork Tree really put Fall Out Boy on the map as Sugar, We're Goin' Down and Dance, Dance dominated radio stations worldwide. Both songs hit the top ten of commercial charts in the UK and US, while Sugar... is Triple Platinum certified on its own.

From Under The Cork Tree remains Fall Out Boy's biggest selling album, and has re-entered the charts upon each of the band's new album releases since.


1. All Time Low

Arguably the band with the most obscure debut album on this list, All Time Low's The Party Scene was released in 2005 - but the album was so overlooked that five of the tracks ended up being re-recorded for an EP - Put Up Or Shut Up.

Music videos were released for Circles and The Girl's A Straight Up Hustler, but All Time Low's first album is now a very tricky find and sells for upwards of $100.

Meanwhile, their next full-length album couldn't have been further away from this. So Wrong, It's Right sold almost 15,000 copies in its first week of release, with hit single Dear Maria, Count Me In being certified gold in 2011 and platinum in 2015. The album has since been certified Gold too in May 2017.

Only Dear Maria and Poppin' Champagne were released as singles - and the latter was unable to replicate the commercial success of Dear Maria - but the album is so fondly viewed that tracks like Let It Roll, Six Feet Under The Stars and Vegas are among the fan favourites - and the band even decided to support themselves on tour in the UK and play the entire album through to mark its tenth anniversary in 2017.

While all ten of the albums on this list have had their own glow up between albums one and two, the difference between All Time Low's are almost literally night and day - one barely seen, one so bright, it shot the band into the limelight and gave them a platform for the 15 years-plus which have followed!


Pop Punk Quiz: Who Released These Early 2000s Albums?

WhatCulture

1. Wasting Time

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Gary is a freelance writer published via BBC, Inside The Ropes, Nutmeg Magazine, SPORF, Sportskeeda, and The Anfield Wrap, among others. The author of Wrestling's Most Memorable Promos, Gary has interviewed the likes of Triple H, Shawn Michaels, Edge, Chris Jericho, Jon Moxley and Tyson Fury. Gary has broken news regarding signings, contracts, album releases, and even the location of WrestleMania - with exclusives sourced by CNN, NBC, FOX, Forbes, TalkSPORT and many others.