10 Pop Stars Who Should Have Been One-Hit Wonders

How did any of these people make it to a second hit single?

Singer Avril Lavigne gestures during a photo session in New York's Central Park.
JIM COOPER/AP

You only get one chance to make a first impression, and nobody knows that better than the dreaded one-hit wonder. Just ask Chumbawamba if they'd like to go back in time and maybe shelve "Tubthumping" (a.k.a. the "I get knocked down" song) for a few more years in favor of something a little less kitschy. They're actually a very solid punk group with a penchant for political skewering, but you'd never know that from the song about "pissing the night away" from whiskey drinks, lager drinks, and cider drinks.

Part of the trick to avoid having one ultra-popular song overshadow the rest of a musician's discography is staying away from any song that might be considered a novelty. No one's taking your work seriously after "Who Let the Dogs Out?" It's just not happening.

Although, how did human garbage bin Kesha (spelled without the dollar sign symbol, because that's stupid and she's not Prince) get to be so popular? Who knows. That's the luck factor playing a major role, as fate apparently lets a few stinkers slip through the cracks for more than just their fifteen minutes on occasion.

The following musicians all caught a lucky break somewhere down the line, because based solely on their breakout single, they all should have failed to make it past the "Where Are They Know?" files. They're not all bad, per se, just...fortunate.

10. Avril Lavigne

Singer Avril Lavigne gestures during a photo session in New York's Central Park.
JIM COOPER/AP

Though it might be a stretch to still be calling Avril Lavigne a "pop star" by today's standards, she's managed to scrape together a couple of hits over the last few years. Her relationship with fellow Canadian musician (and equally unlikely pop star) Chad Kroeger probably helped keep her in the spotlight. (Together, they form the power couple that no one wants to get stuck talking to at the awards show after parties.)

Lavigne's debut single, "Complicated," was a polite, inoffensive little slice of pop music played to a pre-teen market that had just missed out on the Britney/Christina years. It was fine. It did it's job. But then "Sk8er Boi" happened. It was incredibly painful to type the name of that song just now, but it was even harder to constantly sit through a three and a half minute insult to punk music that would make Good Charlotte cringe. Yet, it was a big time hit. 

And she wasn't done yet. A few years later the world let her have another big seller with "Girlfriend," a watered down rip-off of Toni Basil's "Hey Mickey." This is why people find it so easy to mock Canada at times.


9. Linkin Park

Chester Bennington, from left, and Mike Shinoda of the band Linkin Park perform in concert during their Carnivores Tour 2014 at the Susquehanna Bank Center on Friday, Aug. 15, 2014, in Camden, N.J. (Photo by Owen Sweeney/Invision/AP)
Owen Sweeney/AP

Beginning a list of pop stars with the one-two punch of Avril Lavigne and Linkin Park may seem a bit far-fetched, but the latter has had plenty of mainstream exposure with their recent crossover hits. Linkin Park is no longer the nu-metal imitators they appeared to be back in 2000. Now they're the hard rock version of toast: simple, consistent, and easily digestible. 

Despite frequent, drastic changes in their sound, occasional side projects, and the fact that most people can't name a Linkin Park song from the last decade, the band has managed to be a radio staple for fifteen years.

Wait...FIFTEEN YEARS? From the guys who gave us these bits of lyrical genius in their first hit single?

Shut up. Shut up. Shut up. Shut up when I'm talking to you. Shut up. Shut up. Shut uuuuuuuuuup. 'Cause I'm about to break.

While it's wonderful that they surpassed the likes of Limp Bizkit, breaking away from their nu-metal shackles to forge a slightly more timeless sound, it's also hard to believe these guys ever rose to bigger prominence than Powerman 5000 and Alien Ant Farm. 


8. Kylie Minogue

Australian pop singer Kylie Minogue performs on stage during the Closing Ceremony for the Commonwealth Games Glasgow 2014, at Hampden Park stadium, in Glasgow, Scotland, Sunday Aug. 3, 2014(AP Photo/Frank Augstein)
Frank Augstein/AP

When your first mega-hit is a cover song, that doesn't bode well for any sort of longevity. When your first hit is a cover of "The Locomotion," you might as well just phone your parents and forewarn them that a lifetime of disappointment is on the way. ("My daughter? She, uh...she's a fishmonger. Yes. And a...train enthusiast?")

Twenty years later, there's no reason Minogue should have been able to come back and have another hit. But lo and behold, she told logic to "suck it" and orchestrated a nearly flawless career from then on.

To be fair, in her native Australia and in the UK, Kylie never went away. She was pumping out hit after hit every few months, evidently as a self-imposed punishment for revitalizing the Locomotion line dance. In the States, however, her 2001 smash "Can't Get You Out of My Head" was treated as a major comeback. It may have taken her longer to shake the one-hit wonder label stateside, but she got it done.


7. Train

Pat Monahan, of the band Train, performs at the Global Citizen 2015 Earth Day on the National Mall, Saturday, April 18, 2015, in Washington. (Photo by Nick Wass/Invision/AP)
Nick Wass/AP

Oh, how lucky we'd be if "Meet Virginia" was the only thing Train was known for. There'd be no "Drops of Jupiter," there'd be no "Marry Me," and there'd be no "Hey, Soul Sister." It's exactly what John Lennon was singing about in "Imagine." And it really is beautiful if you think of it.

Instead, the vanilla wafer wearing a blazer that is Train went balls-out in the 21st century, throwing themselves onto any and all genres, absorbing the worst parts of said genres, and then evacuating those remnants onto pop radio. To call their career trajectory the result of "genre-hopping" is an insult to artists who genuinely explore different musical avenues.

At first, Train was just another in a long line of post-grunge, light alt-rock-ish supplements, easily confused with the likes of Tonic and Vertical Horizon and...you're already Googling Tonic and Vertical Horizon, aren't you? Exactly. And Train could have faded away just as easily.

But no, Train has stayed popular because of a sadistic, chameleon streak wherein they assume the identity of whichever band just made a splash on the charts with a unique sound. Then they copy-and-paste it over lyrics that were most likely written in an airplane bathroom.


6. Lady Gaga

Lady Gaga
Joel Ryan/AP

This one-woman carnival act got lucky because her weirdness filled a gaping hole in mainstream music, which had been in need of another pop oddity ever since Marilyn Manson faded from the limelight.

The Office's Michael Scott was absolutely correct when he misattributed Lady Gaga's breakout hit, "Just Dance," to Britney Spears. There's nary a hint of the signature offbeat textures that occupy the rest of her discography. That sort of mainstream attention-grab is often hard to overcome, with the artist and the label fighting over what identity to present to the audience. Often the artist will push too far in the other direction, spending the remainder of their career trying to distance themselves form their big hit.

Luckily, she simply glided past it, proceeding to push out a slew of eccentric pop songs with just the right amount of sheen to get them onto pop radio. "Bad Romance" was a defining moment that found Mother Monster pushing the weird pedal hard enough to speed past all the generic pop stars on the crowded highway toward notoriety.


5. Justin Timberlake

Justin Timberlake
Yui Mok/PA Archive

Branching off from a boy band isn't a recipe for success. Ask literally any other person besides Justin Timberlake how well their solo careers have gone. You can't, because no one knows their addresses or phone numbers or Twitter handles, because Chris Kirkpatrick is not at the top of anyone's mind. (Except for right now. Because I just put his name there... Aaaand he's already gone.)

Timberlake was supposed to break away from his buddies, prove that he was a "serious" artist in his twenties, and then fade away like all good Boy Band alum eventually do. His first single as a solo performer even features prominent use of an acoustic guitar rhythm. It was all set to go down as a footnote in pop music history.

Instead, he managed to become a damn national treasure. For a guy coming out of one of the most manufactured, assembly line oriented scenes in music, Timberlake has some serious soul. And an incredible falsetto. And charisma coming out of his pooper. And dance moves that make audiences week in the knees. 

And Jessica Biel. That's how you know he's had a good career.


4. Jon Bon Jovi

FILE - In this Nov. 5, 2013, file photo, Jon Bon Jovi performs in concert with his band Bon Jovi in Philadelphia. While Bon Jovi is interested in becoming an NFL owner one day, he's not currently pursuing the Buffalo Bills, the New Jersey rocker's
Owen Sweeney/AP

Yes, he was a major success in the 80s, largely due to his copious hair and safe-but-sexy appeal. Yes, "Livin' on a Prayer" is a classic. And "Wanted Dead or Alive" is still an absolutely killer track. 

But his first hit single, "Runaway," was the epitome of the cheesy, toned-down hair metal that would have embarrassed even the likes of Poison. Following that unfathomable hit, Bon Jovi released a series of similarly generic, synth-laden tracks that they surely submitted as possible theme songs to Miami Vice. These are the types of songs that are relentlessly mocked in modern parodies of 80s movie montages.

Five terrible radio singles passed before it looked like the Jov-ster would be spending the rest of his career playing high school dances. And then "You Give Love a Bad Name" happened. Where did that come from? Seriously, where had those guitar licks been hiding? Did someone lose a bet? THERE ARE TOO MANY QUESTIONS!

Had they not escaped that deep pit of mediocre synth pop, there's no way Bon Jovi could have had a late career resurgence in the 90s, and again in the early 2000s. 


3. Justin Bieber

Justin Bieber
Francois Mori/AP

"YouTube sensation" doesn't usually equate to "long-term megastardom." Somehow that managed to be the case for Justin Bieber, despite producing a debut single that didn't even try to hide the fact that a pasty, smiley thirteen-year-old was trying to sound hard while rocking an Old Navy hoodie and a haircut that looks like a Lhasa Apso caught in a windstorm.

And this was before YouTube became an actual launching pad for musicians. (Carly Rae Jepsen would follow in the Biebs' footsteps a few years later, and she seems on her way to having a legitimate career now.) How did he do it? More importantly, how did he swindle Usher into funding his adorable campaign of terror?

Whatever the reason, Bieber went on to have an excessive number of hit songs (one of which features the word "baby" no fewer than 1,900 times) and a public downward spiral that resulted in him becoming a punchline for another two decades, at least.


2. Will Smith

U.S. actor Will Smith poses in front of a Japanese poster of his latest movie
KATSUMI KASAHARA/AP

Call him the Fresh Prince forever. Because that's exactly where his music career should have stopped.

There was no reason to usher in a new "Willenium." How did we all let a grown man demand us to get jiggy, then simply shrug our shoulders, disregard that there's no such thing as getting jiggy, and then just kind of go with it until Wild Wild West came out?

His music has always been inextricably linked to his acting career. People were ready to write off the Fresh Prince and his dopey rap-lite song "Parents Just Don't Understand" until they saw him on their television screens performing weekly hijinks on The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air. And his music only came back into the mainstream in the late 90s because he'd written the theme song for his sci-fi blockbuster Men In Black. But then it just kind of...stayed there. For a few more years.

Thankfully, it seems Smith has mostly given up making his own music in favor of coaching his children's fledgling careers. Then again, no one ever expects a Will Smith album. It just happens. So beware that the upcoming Suicide Squad film could feature another Smith hit called "The Joke(r)'s On You!" rolling over the credits.


1. Katy Perry

Katy Perry
John Shearer/AP

"I Kissed a Girl" is the kind of novelty song that conjures up images of Tatu or the Pussycat Dolls. It's supposed to be taboo, it's supposed to get everyone all riled up for no good reason, but it lacks a lasting punch. 

Female singers marketing their sexuality is certainly not a trend inspired by Katy Perry (though she harnesses it like a superpower), and "I Kissed a Girl" wasn't necessarily a new concept either, just shocking enough to receive some free publicity from easily-offended parent groups. It was a song very much "of the moment," featuring faux-heavy guitars and the kind of bite that Pink was known for at the time. 

But even if your first hit is a disposable bit of mild raunch, if your follow-up is something as bombastic and butt-shakingly catchy as "Hot n Cold," you're not going anywhere any time soon. And Perry has proved that time and time again, as she's constantly putting out respectable chart-toppers with infectious choruses. She doesn't deserve to be a one-hit wonder, it's just kind of shocking that she wasn't.

Fun fact: There was actually another song called "I Kissed a Girl" by Jill Sobule that came out in 1995. "Who is Jill Sobule?" you're no doubt asking yourself. Exactly. What a difference a decade makes. 


Watch Next


In this post: 
Avril Lavigne
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.