10 Rock Albums That Were Stuck In Development Hell
These albums all took a long time to come out - but were they worth the wait?
Wikipedia describes development hell as when "a project, concept, or idea that remains in a stage of early development for a long time."
We describe it as "one of the most annoying things to ever happen to anything ever."
Nothing is worse than hearing about an upcoming release, only for it to get delayed again, and again, and again. It's utterly soul-crushing as a fan, so imagine how much worse it must be when you're creatively involved?
Whilst the term is usually used in relation to film, music is no stranger to development hell either. Plenty of albums from bands big and small have started off with the best intentions, only to be ground to a halt by the oppresive mire of the production process.
For this list, we've focused solely on albums that did eventually get released. Albums that were cancelled or are still in production would make for an entirely separate topic, and we weren't going to deny ourselves those sweet sweet clicks.
So sit back, enjoy this list, and try not to get second-hand stress reading about some of the most frustrating scenarios in music history.
10. Hot Sauce Committee Part Two - Beastie Boys
Rap rock idols Beastie Boys may have had their heyday in the 80s and 90s, but they were still releasing albums well into the 21st century.
The trio have put out three new works post-2000 with the final one being Hot Sauce Committee Part Two. Now, you might be thinking that the album that proceeded this was called Hot Sauce Committee Part One.
You would be thinking wrong.
Material for the proposed two-part release was recorded between 2008 and 2009, but plans changed when member Adam "MCA" Yauch got diagnosed with cancer.
Part One was actually ready to go with artwork and everything. However, the news of Yauch's illness meant that its release date just kept getting pushed back.
In 2010, the band announced that Part One was going to be put on the shelf. Then, after almost three years of waiting, Part Two finally hit shelves in May 2011.
Unfortunately, Yauch passed away in 2012, meaning that this will likely be the final Beastie Boys album we'll ever hear.
Still, putting out an album titled "Part Two" without ever putting out Part One is a fitting legacy for one of rock's greatest groups of mischief makers.
9. Closure/Continuation - Porcupine Tree
Following the release of their tenth album The Incident, British prog rockers Porcupine Tree were going through a... prickly time.
Sorry, that was bad.
Frontman Steve Wilson felt constrained by the limitations of the band and decided that he wanted to spend more time working on his own stuff. He did this and then some, spending 2011 recording and releasing one solo album and another album for one of his side projects.
This guy has absolutely nailed procrastinating.
Feelers were put out for another Porcupine Tree album in 2012, but then Wilson went and recorded a third studio album instead. He fell out massively with his fellow members over this and it felt as if maybe the group was done for good.
After many years of back and forth, the band came out and said that they were not only releasing a new album, but it was already done! They'd finished it off in secrecy in Autumn 2021 and were just going to drop it out of nowhere!
From start to finish, Closure/Continuation took over ten years to complete. Was it worth the wait? 71% on Metacritic, so...
8. Let The Bad Times Roll - The Offspring
You see, the expression is usually "Let the Good Times Roll", but The Offspring changed it to "Let the Bad Times Roll."
Honestly, how do these musicians do it?
Those Pretty Fly (White Guys) put out this highly intelligently named album in 2021, almost a decade after their last release.
This wasn't because the band had taken time off to find themselves or anything; it was because the universe was seemingly doing everything in its power to stop this record from coming out.
The band first went into the studio to record material for this album in 2013, but a heavy tour schedule slowed down progress. Also, they were in the process of leaving Columbia Records, the label they had been with since 1996.
By late 2015, they only had two or three songs ready to go and it wouldn't be until 2019 that the group confirmed that everything was done.
Well, 98% done. It took them another two years to finish up that last two percent.
Throw in a pandemic and the final release date for Let the Bad Times Roll was the 16th of April 2021.
Still, it was all worth it to read that title.
Genius.
7. Hard-Off - Bloodhound Gang
In true Bloodhound Gang fashion, the band behind Bad Touch released an album called Hard-Off in 2015 which featured what appears to be a man in bad makeup with incredibly long breasts on the cover.
That is not something you can see on the Discovery Channel.
Bloodhound Gang fans had been treated to a greatest hits compilation called "Show Us Your Hits" in 2010, but this was the band's first collection of new songs since 2005.
Why did it take so long? Honestly, not a clue.
In 2008, guitarist Lupus Thunder (not his real name) left the band to replaced by A's Daniel P. Carter (his real name).
Speculation arose that a new album was coming in 2012, but that year came and went without incident.
Rumours flew around that the record would be called anything from Getting Laid on a School Bus to Fishin' for Hookers, but it wasn't until 2015 that a new Bloodhound Gang record finally saw the light of day.
It was getting to the point where they were even joking on stage about how long the album was taking.
Maybe not such a good idea there, guys.
6. Imaginos - Blue Oyster Cult
Trying to get your head around just what went on behind the scenes during the making of this album is a one way ticket to migraine-ville.
Imaginos began life as a solo album for Blue Oyster Cult drummer Albert Bouchard, who began writing music for it back in the early 1970s.
The name comes from a character created by producer Sandy Pearlman for a series of poems in the 1960s. In fact, the name Blue Oyster Cult comes from one of these early Imaginos scripts.
Unsure whether or not it had an umlaut to begin with though.
The music for the album was completed by 1977, but the following few years were a turbulent time for our pals in the Cult. Bouchard was actually fired from the group in 1981.
He worked with Pearlman to get the album finished by 1984, but the record label rejected it. The band then began working on Imaginos in 1986 before it finally got its release in July of 1988.
And what was the end result of these years of hard work and toil? Number 122 on the albums charts and mixed reviews from critics.
Great.
5. Chicago XXXII: Stone Of Sisyphus - Chicago
A musician's public catalogue of work is always just the tip of the iceberg of their overall output.
Artists always have more stashed away in the vault that rarely ever sees the light of day, but fans of the band Chicago were treated in 2008 to an album many assumed was lost for good.
In 1993, the band laid down a record called Stone of Sisyphus, a reference to the Greek myth about a man doomed to push a stone up a hill only to have it roll back down again every time.
Ironically, this is basically what happened with the album.
Just when it looked like Stone of Sisyphus was going to get released, the record company changed their minds and decided they didn't like it anymore. So the whole thing was scrapped and it lay dormant for the next decade plus.
It was only in 2008 that it finally got a release on Rhino Records, after acquiring cult status as one of the greatest albums never released.
Fans were overjoyed that this long journey had finally ended, as Sisyphus finally got that stone to the top of the hill.
4. I/O - Peter Gabriel
Remember when we said earlier that we weren't going to talk about albums that weren't out yet?
We lied.
Peter Gabriel dropped the name i/o into conversations around 2002 as the potential successor to his album Up. This didn't happen though, as the former Genesis man got distracted by tours, new projects, and trying to explain to people what "World Music" actually meant.
i/o was then discussed in 2005, but two more albums in 2010 and 2011 came and neither of them bore that title.
After another decade's worth of fannying around, Gabriel finally put out the first proper single for i/o in early 2023.
In an outstanding twist of fate, the guy now can't stop putting out songs from the record, having released three more singles at time of writing.
The singles have been coming out at every full moon, which is the most Peter Gabriel thing of all time.
Whilst the jury is still out on whether i/o is any good, Gabriel's fans are never going to forget the story of the album that spent two decades in the dark.
Hopefully the album finally comes out in 2023 and we don't look like massive tits for including it here.
3. Still Sucks - Limp Bizkit
Stampede of the Disco Elephants.
That's what this album was originally going to be called.
Oh boy.
L-I-M-P Bizkit were right at the end of the promotion cycle for their 2011 album Gold Cobra when they left Interscope Records. In 2014, the band signed with Lil Wayne's Cash Money label and put out the song Ready to Go in 2013.
"Great!" thought fans of the Biz. "New album soon, then?" And they waited. And waited. And waited some more.
Rumours began swirling that Fred Durst wasn't happy with most of the recordings, hence why the new album was being delayed.
Guitarist Wes Borland confirmed this in 2021, stating "we've been working on stuff, working on stuff, working on stuff. And Fred has been consistently kind of unsatisfied with where vision is."
Mercifully, the new release finally hit stores later that year. Mercifully as well, they'd decided to drop the Disco Elephants name in favour of the much funnier "Still Sucks" moniker.
The delay might have done Bizkit some good, as publications remarked that this new, older iteration of the band was much more self-aware and less obnoxious.
Well, as un-obnoxious as Fred Durst can ever be.
2. Fear Inoculum - Tool
In the 13 years between 1993 and 2006, the band Tool released four different studio albums.
In the 13 years between 2006 and 2019, the band Tool released... one studio album.
And everyone was really annoyed about it.
Lead singer Maynard James Keenan originally implied that 2006's 10,000 Days would be the band's final album, before going back on that in 2008 and stating that something new was coming "right away."
Clearly his interpretation of that phrase was very different from the rest of us.
Work on the new album continued at a glacial pace over the next few years, marred by injuries, lawsuits, and just about everything else that could have gone wrong.
It actually became a meme that the new Tool album was never going to come, until the veil was finally lifted in 2019 with the release of Fear Inoculum.
The album went down a treat, debuting at number one in the US and receiving widespread acclaim from fans and critics alike.
This might have had something to do with the fact that people had been waiting for this album for over a decade, but let's not take anything away from Tool and their hard work.
1. Chinese Democracy - Guns N’ Roses
The development hell album to end all development hell albums, Guns N' Roses' infamous Chinese Democracy was the band's first original release in 17 years.
Basically, in the 1990s, everyone but Axl Rose left the band. The members were infighting like crazy, which meant that absolutely nothing relating to music ever got done.
Rose wanted to record a more industrial-sounding album, an idea nobody else liked.
The band then cycled through several new members and collaborators - ranging from Brian May to Moby - before Rose finally announced the name of the record in 1999.
But it still wasn't over.
Manager Doug Goldstein said in 2000 that the album was 99% done. He was wrong.
The recording process dragged out for another eight years, before Chinese Democracy eventually made its way into the public on November 23rd 2008.
After nearly two decades of bust-ups, line-up changes, recordings, re-recordings, songs being teased and then unteased again, and Axl Rose essentially turning into the rock version of delusional dictator, it was finally done.
The estimated cost of this album was a whopping $13million. Was it worth all that money? Well, take a listen and decide for yourself.