10 Rock Bands That Were Successful After Major Lineup Changes

Bands that were able to replace an integral member with someone new and keep the train rolling.

Bon Scott Along with creativity, passion and drive, one of the most important elements of any successful band is chemistry. Placing a group of extremely talented musicians together doesn't always produce the desired results. Conversely, there's that moment when the first chord is struck that it becomes apparent that there's magic about to be made. Sometimes the personality behind the instrument can be as important as the sound coming out of it. For lead vocalists and guitarists especially, who're usually at the forefront of a band, success can often be attributed as much, if not more so to charisma and style than talent and ability. When a popular band undergoes a significant lineup change it can be the kiss of death. The disruption of the band's chemistry, losing a vital member of the songwriting process and changing the public image can all be a severe detriment. It's a testament to a band's talent and appeal when they're able to replace an integral member with someone new and keep the train rolling, sometimes even growing in popularity and garnering increased acclaim. Let's take a look at 10 of the most successful rock bands who've faced this challenge and came out of it on the positive side.

10. Iron Maiden

Iron Maiden was formed in 1975 by bassist and songwriter Steve Harris, the only remaining founding member. They're famous for being pioneers of the UK heavy metal scene, with a discography 37 albums deep. The original lead vocalist for Maiden was Paul Day, who was very quickly replaced with Dennis Wilcock. Wilcock was a KISS fan who incorporated similar theatrics into his performance. Eventually he left to start his own band and Paul Di'Anno stepped into the role. Di'Anno fronted Iron Maiden on their first two releases, "Iron Maiden" (1980) and "Killers" (1991), the latter of which led to their first world tour. Unfortunately for Di'Anno, cocaine sunk its teeth into him and his erratic and self-destructive behavior led to his firing at the conclusion of the Killers tour. Bruce Dickinson, formerly of Samson, was immediately brought on to replace Di'Anno. Dickinson brought with him an incredible voice and signature sound, debuting on 1982's "The Number of the Beast", their first #1 record. That album has gone on to sell over 14 million copies worldwide and kicked off what would be a hugely successful run for the band. Iron Maiden would see plenty more lineup changes throughout their career, with Dickinson himself departing and eventually returning at one point. But with the band still active nearly 40 years after its inception, its safe to say that the revolving door of musicians didn't hinder their success at all. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=geHLdg_VNww

9. KISS

Just as much a licensing and merchandising machine as a band, 2014 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame inductees KISS have been going strong since 1973. Known for their face-painted characters and theatric stage shows, the band has sold more than 100 million albums worldwide. The one constant with them throughout their storied career has been frontman/rhythm guitarist Paul Stanley and vocalist/bassist Gene Simmons. The band's other two founding members, guitarist Ace Frehley and drummer Peter Criss, were members band from inception up until the early 80s, when drugs, alcohol, business disagreements and personality conflicts led to their replacement. Criss was replaced with Eric Carr, who would remain with the band for 11 years until his death in 1991. Notable auditions to replace Space Ace were Richie Sambora and Yngwie Malmsteen, as well as Eddie Van Halen who was looking to leave his band due to tension between he and David Lee Roth. Frehley's spot briefly went to Vinnie Vincent, and then Mark St. John before Bruce Kulick settled into the role. During this time the band would go through their "unmasked" phase, where they ditched the makeup that defined them. While a re-masking, several reunions, breakups, lineup changes and re-reunions would follow in the years to come, it's obvious that Stanley and Simmons have always been the driving creative force behind the success of KISS. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Hgz-q76KtQ

8. Black Sabbath

The godfathers of heavy metal, Black Sabbath was birthed from the minds of Ozzy Osbourne, Tony Iommi, Geezer Butler and Bill Ward. The band formerly known as Earth took a turn toward the occult and began incorporating horror-themed lyrics to accompany their trademark downtuning. Sabbath released two albums in 1970, their self-titled debut and the classic "Paranoid", which is one of the most influential metal albums ever recorded. The band paved the way for generations of metal acts that would follow in their footsteps, although it wasn't until 1973's "Sabbath Bloody Sabbath" that critical acclaim began to accompany the fanfare. Ozzy Osbourne, one of the most unique characters in music history was ousted from the group in 1979 for drugs and alcohol. The entire band was abusing, but according to Ward, Ozzy's using was on a different level entirely. In a nice bit of irony, the future Sharon Osbourne, daughter of Black Sabbath's manager suggested Ozzy's replacement. Rainbow vocalist Ronnie James Dio was brought into the fold in June of 1979, and the band took on an entirely new sound and style. The classic "Heaven And Hell" was Sabbath's first release with Dio and the album was a success both critically and commercially. Eventually egos came into play (as they so often do for the wealthy and famous) and Dio was soon out the door as well. Tony Martin, Ian Gillen (formerly of Deep Purple), Ray Gillen, Glenn Hughes and David Donato would all take turns at the microphone for the band over the years. Today the original members, with the exception of Ward, are back together and touring once again. It just goes to show that time and the potential for lucrative earnings can heal all wounds. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-og87crqsCE

7. Guns N' Roses

Perhaps no other band, with the exception of possibly Nirvana, has ever made such a big impact in so little time as Guns N' Roses. 1987's "Appetite For Destruction" is one of the greatest rock debuts ever. Consisting of gigantic hits "Welcome To The Jungle", "Sweet Child O' Mine" and "Paradise City", the album rocketed GNR into the stratosphere. Unfortunately substance abuse and rampaging egos brought them crashing back down to Earth. During the 1980s glam rock scene, the standout bands had a colorful lineup of characters behind the music as image became increasingly important. Their most successful peers of this era, bands like Motley Crue, Poison and Bon Jovi, were heavy on style and presentation. Initially a glam band themselves, Guns toned down their feminine appearance and just focused on churning out grimy yet melodious hard rock tunes. When the band entered the studio in 1990 to record the follow up albums, "Use Your Illusion 1 & 2", drummer Steven Adler was let go due to his severe drug usage (an unfortunate recurring theme in this article). Matt Sorum, formerly of The Cult, came in to replace him and added a new dynamic to the band. Adler, who was such a key part of GNR's sound, was no longer irreplaceable. Sorum proved to be a great fit, both musically and personally. During the Use Your Illusion tour, amidst riots, infighting, chaos and controversy, rhythm guitarist Izzy Stradlin quit the band. In a twist on the usual drug abuse tale, Stradlin was newly sober and cited his inability to be around the hard-partying Guns. Although Axl originally wanted Dave Navarro, Gilby Clarke took over. The band would embark on several more hugely successful tours before settling into a lengthy hiatus. Axl would reform the band with replacements for all the original members (including virtuoso guitarist Buckethead) several times with little success. The rumor-riddled and long-awaited album "Chinese Democracy" was finally released with a whimper in late 2008. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pA0GIS7hinc

6. Rush

Rush is famous for their incredibly complex musicianship and diversified catalog of sounds and styles. Inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 2013, the band has a very dedicated fan base. Their style is polarizing to be sure, but it's impossible to overlook the talent that vocalist/bassist Geddy Lee, guitarist Alex Lifeson and drummer Neil Peart possess. Original drummer John Rutsey was forced to withdraw from the band immediately following the release of their debut album due to complications from diabetes. With no disrespect to Rutsey, this is probably diabetes' only positive contribution to humanity, because it gave music fans the opportunity to witness the greatness of Neil Peart. Chosen as the greatest drummer of all-time by his peers, critics and fans, Peart is to drumming what Hendrix was to guitar. His live solos have to be seen to be believed and anyone who has ever picked up a pair of drumsticks has studied Peart. He also composes the majority of Rush's lyrics, inspired by themes such as fantasy and philosophy as well as the more traditional topics. While it's impossible to know whether Rush would have achieved the same level of success had Rutsey remained in the band, it's undeniable that their influence on music would have been much less significant. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fADeOpIhHIk

5. Genesis

The genesis of Genesis took place in 1967 when vocalist Peter Gabriel and keyboardist Tony Banks combined their school bands. They initially had more of a pop sound before moving into the progressive rock category. Their debut album "From Genesis To Revelation" was released in 1969 to little interest. The band has basically disowned the record entirely, and with good reason. Peter Gabriel would remain with the band for their first 6 albums, up until the concept record "The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway". Phil Collins, who joined the band on drums in 1970 eventually took over lead vocal duties. Gabriel would go on to have a fairly accomplished solo career while Genesis, with Collins at the helm would enjoy their biggest success, including a free concert in Rome in front of a staggering 500,000 fans. They're one of the biggest bands of all-time, selling over 130 million album across the globe. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pW68T84RLHw

4. Metallica

metallica When Metallica came on the scene like a locomotive full of heavy metal rage in the early 80s, they carved out a spot for themselves amidst the extremely popular glam bands of the era. Along with other thrash acts like Anthrax and Slayer, Metallica was largely responsible for bringing metal back to commercial viability. Over the years the band has seen a handful of significant lineup changes. The first was the replacement of guitarist Dave Mustaine by Exodus' Kirk Hammett. Mustaine was booted due to the ever present drug and alcohol issues in addition to a violent temper. Mustaine went on to form Megadeth, and while successful in their own right, would never come close to reaching the heights Metallica did. The second change came when popular bassist Cliff Burton was killed in a 1986 tour bus accident. The guys had drawn cards to determine who would sleep where, and in a cruel twist of fate Burton won and chose Hammett's bunk. Hammett, James Hetfield and Lars Ulrich came out of the accident virtually unscathed. Jason Newsted was chosen to replace him and would be with Metallica during their glory years. He was welcomed by the fans, but they always held a sentimental spot for Cliff Burton. Newsted left the band in 2001 and Metallica's search for his replacement is documented in the fascinating and unflattering documentary "Some Kind Of Monster". Their choice was Robert Trujillo, who had been playing in Ozzy Osbourne's band. Ironically, Jason Newsted would then be his replacement in Ozzy's band for the remainder of the 2003 Ozzfest tour. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=boanuwUMNNQ

3. Van Halen

While the impetus of Van Halen has always been namesake genius guitarist Eddie Van Halen, the band's career can be clearly divided into two separate periods where different lead singers drove the sound in distinctive directions. Eddie and his drummer brother Alex teamed up with bassist Michael Anthony and vocalist David Lee Roth to create one of the most successful rock acts of the late 70s and early 80s. The band would release 6 albums with Roth as frontman, the most successful being "1984". That album spawned the wildly popular single "Jump", one of the most iconic rock songs ever recorded, as well as "Panama" and "Hot For Teacher". The album climbed all the way to #2 on Billboard, with Michael Jackson's "Thriller" preventing it's ascent to the top spot. Artistic and personal disputes led to the breakup of Roth and the rest of the band. After Patty Smyth declined the role of lead vocalist, Sammy Hagar got the spot thanks to a connection from a mutual friend. Hagar was fresh off a good year as a solo artist and joined the band as a singer and on-stage rhythm guitarist. Van Halen's first album with Hagar, "5150", was a smash hit as well. All four Hagar-fronted albums went to #1 on the charts with 17 top-12 singles and a Grammy. The brothers Van Halen are notoriously difficult to deal with (as most geniuses tend to be) and Hagar left the band in 1996. A brief run with Extreme's Gary Cherrone failed to gain any traction and multiple reunions with both Roth and Hagar followed. Currently the band consists of the Van Halen brothers, Roth and Eddie's son Wolfgang on bass. The loss of Michael Anthony is definitely felt as his vocal harmonies were a big part of the band's sound. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JK5zubdgf4Y

2. The Rolling Stones

There isn't much that can be said about The Rolling Stones that hasn't already been said infinite times before. They're arguably the biggest band of all-time. Sales exceeding 250 million copies, 29 studio and 18 live albums and too many hit singles to name. Their resume speaks for itself. It's remarkable to think that the band has remained so beloved with fans despite some significant changes in membership over the years. Founding member Brian Jones drowned in a swimming pool shortly after leaving the band in 1969. His death at age 27 made him one of the first members or music's morbid 27 Club. Other members include Jimi Hendrix, Janis Joplin, Jim Morrison and Kurt Cobain. Jones was replaced by Mick Taylor up until 1975 when Ron Wood joined the band and has remained to this day. While Wood's contributions to the band are numerous, Taylor is often regarded as the best guitarist to ever play with the Stones http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZRXGsPBUV5g

1. AC/DC

AC/DC is one of the biggest bands to ever strum a musical note. Formed in 1973 in Australia by brothers Malcolm and Angus Young, the group has left an indelible legacy on the world of hard rock. The unique sound of lead vocalist Bon Scott was at the forefront of the band's first 5 international releases. The Scott-led AC/DC albums have sold over 44 million copies. His trademark voice can be heard on such iconic singles as T.N.T., Dirty Deeds Done Dirt Cheap and Highway To Hell. His untimely death in 1980 during the early stages of work on the album that would ultimately become Back In Black could have led to the death of the band as well. But at the urging of Scott's parents, the band chose Brian Johnson as their new singer and resumed working on Back In Black. The album became AC/DC's biggest seller, producing the hits You Shook Me All Night Long, Hell's Bells and the titular anthem. The band continued on an incredible string of successful albums and touring. They did experience a decline in popularity during the late 80s, but 1990's The Razor's Edge saw a regain to commercial and critical form. They've barely stopped to take a breath in the years since, remaining one of the most successful touring bands in the world and continuing to release hit records, most recently Black Ice and Live At River Plate. AC/DC show no signs of slowing down and keep rocking harder than ever. Bon Scott would be proud. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gEPmA3USJdI

Contributor
Contributor

Brad Hamilton is a writer, musician and marketer/social media manager from Atlanta, Georgia. He's an undefeated freestyle rap battle champion, spends too little time being productive and defines himself as the literary version of Brock Lesnar.