10 Rock Bands That Continued Without Major Members

A Band at Half Capacity.

Foo Fighters I'll Stick Around
wiki

Any rock and roll band tends to feel like family after a while. When you have to rely on every member of the group to make ends meet, you've got to at least have some sort of affection for your musical brethren whenever you walk up on that stage. That makes it all the more sad though when you have to part ways.

For one reason or another, these bands had to let go of some of their closest friends to make their bands thrive in the future. These weren't just some hired hands that they were replacing either. These were often major power players in their respective acts, who mostly wrote a lot of the material or had a key influence to the group's sound. This didn't mean just losing a band member...it meant losing a part of the group's collective identity.

Though the version of the group without these players looked a lot different, they managed to actually persevere and most of the time ended up becoming a stronger group by soldiering on with new blood. Compared to the usual rock stars that are only in it for the money and fame, these people were in it for the long haul and managed to find some life after death. This may have been a death blow, but these bands were due for a resurrection.

10. Vince Neil - Motley Crue

As the early '80s gave way to the bands off of the Sunset Strip, Motley Crue felt like a band ripped straight out of a cartoon. Across albums like Shout at the Devil, every single one of the members felt like their own unique character in some supremely messed up heavy metal family. Like all brothers though, things are bound to fall out every now and again.

After the tour started to wind down for Dr. Feelgood, Vince Neil was getting more and more frustrated with the band dynamic and abruptly quit during rehearsals for the next album. Almost trying to say "we don't need you anyway," the band quickly replaced Neil with John Corabi, who's voice almost seemed like the polar opposite of Vince, staying much more in the lower register with a grizzly baritone.

As much as the OG Crue fans weren't ready to accept this version of the group, the band's self titled album with Corabi ends up having some of their most inventive playing, with Tommy Lee leaning into a more muscly side of his drumming and having some more metallic riffs on songs like Hooligan's Holiday. The fallout behind this album eventually led to the Crue building bridges with Vince later down the line, but it is a crime that we never got to see what this version of the group sounded like for a second record.


9. Al Sobrante - Green Day

Sometimes having to fire a member of the band isn't always a piece of cake. Besides cutting ties with someone who helped you cut your teeth in the early days, you also have to think about everything else they bring to the band than just showing up for gigs and writing the occasional riff. Or in Green Day's case, the guy who's responsible with getting you almost half the way there.

When Mike Dirnt and Billie Joe Armstrong were first starting as the band known as Sweet Children, their name change to Green Day also ushered in the inclusion of drummer Al Sobrante, who had already been a veteran of the underground punk scene at the time. Aside from his precision behind the kit, Al also had a hand in the production of Green Day's records and worked as the band's de facto manager at the time.

Once you start to grow up though, things start to change pretty quickly, and Al announced that he would be leaving the band to go to college shortly after the release of their debut record 39/Smooth. Having to think on their feet, Billie ended up catching a gig with the local band The Lookouts, with an obnoxious young kid behind the kit named Tre Cool. When Al showed up to say hi during the recordings of Kerplunk and saw Tre behind the kit, there was definitely a change in the air. This was the sound of the pop punk legends finally finding their groove.


8. Ron Blair - Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers

Not everyone is really cut out for the rock and roll lifestyle...nor should everyone. From the relentless touring to the amount of sleazy people that are trying to get a little piece of you everywhere you go, how are you supposed to deal with that and also fit in time for your family and your personal life? Especially when you're a fairly introverted guy, things can take a downturn pretty quickly.

In the early days of the Heartbreakers, Tom Petty's band of misfits really felt like a brotherhood, with everyone looking out for one another. Once the major cash came flowing in after Damn the Torpedoes though, Ron Blair started to get more and more frustrated with the way things were working out, normally being told what to play in the studio rather than just making his own decisions on arrangements.

Combine that with the touring life that was slowly eating away at him and you can see why Blair announced his departure right before going in to record Long After Dark. Drafting in Howie Epstein from Del Shannon's band, Tom did eventually leave Ron on good terms, with Blair even turning up to see his old band in his spare time. Things do loop back around in the world of rock and roll, and Ron eventually found himself with his four string on, returning to the band after Howie's passing.


7. William Goldsmith - Foo Fighters

From day one of the Foo Fighters, everyone knew that Dave Grohl was the one who steered the ship of the band. Since the entire first record was made by Dave completely by himself, the only reason why an entire band exists is basically to give the rest of the guys opportunities to tour. When you're in the drummer's seat though, it's pretty much impossible to match up to Dave's drumming standards.

Once the Foos were set to go into the studio for the second album the Colour and the Shape, producer Gil Norton was getting more and more agitated with William Goldsmith's subpar drumming, nicknaming him and bassist Nate Mendel "the rhythmless section." To add insult to injury though, the band decided to take drastic measures to get the album done, with everyone relocating to a different studio and Dave rerecording all of Goldsmith's drum parts on the record.

By the time recording wrapped up, William was basically given an ultimatum: you can stay in the band, but Dave has to play drums on the record. With a bruised ego and trying to stand his ground, William decided it would be better if he stepped out of the fold, returning to Sunny Day Real Estate while Taylor Hawkins took over the drummer's stool. Considering the kindred spirit attitude between Hawkins and Grohl in recent years, the rhythm of the Foos ends up feeling a lot more natural.


6. Nick Oliveri - Queens of the Stone Age

It shouldn't really be that disheartening when you hear that Queens of the Stone Age have had a bit of a shakeup in the lineup. The entire project seems to just operate under the watchful eye of Joshua Homme anyway, so there's no reason to think that any one member is going to drastically change things overnight. That is, unless these are the people who have been around since the very beginning.

After completing the tour for Songs for the Deaf, it was completely understandable why Dave Grohl wouldn't be going the distance with QOTSA, going back to work on the Foo Fighters' next album. What did end up landing a heavy blow though was Nick Oliveri's departure...and it wasn't pretty either. Since Josh's time in Kyuss, he and Nick had always been friendly, until something shifted when the FBI got involved. Once hearing that the authorities paid a visit to Oliveri's house on calls for domestic abuse, Josh cut off ties with him as well, saying that there was a fracture between him and the band.

As much turmoil as it seemed at the time, Josh managed to persevere through the shakeups and put out Lullabies to Paralyze, acting as a nice companion record following the long story that you went on with Songs for the Deaf. The future of the band may have been uncertain, but it wasn't something that Josh couldn't handle.


5. Ozzy Osbourne - Black Sabbath

Of all the core members of a rock band, the lead singer is the one that seems irreplaceable. After all, this is the person who serves as the mouthpiece and main personality of the band, so how are you supposed to reinvent yourself with someone completely new? And, more importantly, how do you replace a person who has become known as the Prince of Darkness?

After making a name for themselves as one of the first great metal acts of the '70s, things were clearly going off the rails with the Ozzy Osbourne fronted version of Black Sabbath. Amid the cocaine-fueled writing sessions and several bottles of booze, Ozzy was getting less and less satisfied operating under the Black Sabbath name, all while Tony Iommi seemed to take up the frontman role when they played live. When Ozzy was sent packing though, Tony quickly realized the answer was not to get an Ozzy clone.

Completely shifting their sound around, Tony managed to find Ronnie James Dio, who was fresh out of the band Rainbow, to sing lead on the next album Heaven and Hell. Having a much cleaner sound and more complex riffs, this launched Sabbath into the next decade, where they could actually compete with the New Wave of British Heavy Metal coming up in their wake. Though their time may have seemed short, bringing in Ronnie was proof that Sabbath could be granted life after death.


4. Pete Willis - Def Leppard

As the '80s were starting to become the decade we recognize today, the hard rock world was laying at Def Leppard's feet. Around the same time that the starlets off of Sunset were making a name for themselves, Sheffield's finest had just acquired AC/DC superproducer Mutt Lange and riding high off of the success of their first blockbuster album High n Dry. The real damage would be done on the next album though, but not before they had to let go of some dead weight.

During the recording for what would become Pyromania, Lange was notorious for cracking down on the performances, which guitarist Pete Willis wasn't truly equipped for. Having been drinking throughout the tour, Willis was getting less and less reliable to come up with the right solos to some of the songs, leading to one particular session where he could barely play after drinking an entire bottle of brandy.

While sending him back home to cool out for a few weeks, the band eventually tried out different guitarists while back at the studio before finding technician Phil Collen to round out the guitar sound. All of a sudden, there was a twin guitar assault that gave you the punkish energy of Steve Clarke with the preciseness of Collen's playing. Though Willis' rhythm tracks do appear on the album, this was just the beginning of Leppard's quest to dominate the rock scene.


3. Dave Mustaine - Metallica

The rock and roll lifestyle is not always the healthiest for people to live from day to day. It's no secret that there's always a lot of drugs involved to keep you going, and more than a few of the biggest names in music have been known to indulge themselves from time to time. When you're in a band that has been nicknamed Alcholica though, how the hell do you get booted for drinking too much?

Well, that's before you actually saw what damage Dave Mustaine could do when he drank. As James Hetfield told it, the personality shift that happened once Mustaine drank was starting to affect the band's reputation. For instance, when the band was making their way to New York to sign a record deal with Megaforce Records, Dave was known for trashing the houses of some of the fans who let the band crash there.

By the time the band got to the Big Apple, they gave Dave a quick bus ticket back to California, eventually bringing in Kirk Hammett from the Bay Area band Exodus. As if to pour salt into the wound, Metallica even got some of Dave's ideas onto their records before Dave could use them later down the line, like the main riffs from Jump in the Fire and the Call of Ktulu. On the bus ride back though, Dave was already planting the seeds for what would become Megadeth. In just a few short hours, thrash metal was given a rivalry that wouldn't soon be forgotten.


2. David Lee Roth - Van Halen

The entire '80s scene that became known as hair metal could pretty much be renamed 'music derivative of Van Halen.' As much as people may have cited acts like Sweet and David Bowie for them stepping up their look, the idea of combining the hard rock riffs with a fun loving party vibe is pretty much trademarked by Eddie Van Halen and David Lee Roth. Right at the time where the band could really do some damage though, they would have to do so without their titan of a frontman.

Once the tour for 1984 wound down, Diamond Dave was no longer happy with the direction the band was going on, leaving on pretty harsh terms if you look at his next record title Eat Em And Smile. Compared to the normal rock star shakeups, this should have been a fatal blow to the band that launched glam metal, only to see them come roaring back to life with Sammy Hagar.

After making most of their classic records with Dave, here was a guy who had a much higher range, which gave Eddie a lot more room to flex his musical chops on albums like 5150 and OU812. A lot of people consider the Roth-less version of Van Halen to be the end of the classic period, but if you're swearing off Hagar, you're leaving tons of good music still on the table.


1. Syd Barrett - Pink Floyd

If you decide to cut ties with the main songwriter of your group, you're not going to be the same band you were starting out. Here was the person who ended up creating the foundation for your musical identity, so having them no longer in the band is going to twist your sound considerably going forward. And though Pink Floyd knew of the shakeup bound to happen with leaving Syd Barrett behind, it was always going to affect them for the rest of their days.

From day one, it's not like Syd wasn't pulling his weight either, being one of the main players behind the album Piper at the Gates of Dawn. When he started to party a little too hard though, the band slowly saw him losing his grip on sanity, oftentimes even struggling to hold hid guitar pick properly. Instead of having him sort out his issues, the band knew the consequences and brought in David Gilmour to fill out the Floyd sound, with Roger Waters taking the reigns for songwriting.

As the band grew bigger though, Syd always lingered in the back of their minds, with some of the group's most classic material being informed by his absence, whether it be the lunatic character in Dark Side of the Moon or the heartbreaking goodbye on Wish You Were Here. In the case of some bitter breakups in rock and roll, this is one of the biggest examples of a band member that's gone but not forgotten.


In this post: 
Foo Fighters
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97