10 Rock Bands That Had A Really Shaky Start

Rock and Roll growing pains for Aerosmith, Rush, Alice In Chains & more.

Aerosmith Janie's Got A Gun
Geffen

When it comes to rock and roll, no one's really expecting you to be flying off the hinges right out of the gate. Even though there have been many spectacular debut albums throughout the years, some acts need to build up some steam before really sinking their teeth into the public consciousness. Judging by these first impressions though, the fact that these acts saw success at all was nearly unthinkable.

That being said, a bad first impression can come from many different things. While the band itself might have been great in a live setting, it may have taken a while for them to actually find themselves in the studio rather than hitting the ground running. Hell, sometimes artists debuts just crib as much as they can from their influences and hope for the best. At the same time, sometimes the personnel at hand might also play into things, as most of the classic lineups of these acts weren't really solidified until later on.

In some extreme cases, it comes down to the band itself is great but the aesthetic is not, causing them to do some course correction to make up for it later. For as much as the building blocks of something great may have been in here, these musicians clearly had a lot of work to do.

10. Green Day

As the years have gone on, Green Day have turned themselves into a well-oiled machine of pop punk excellence. With a few small exceptions like the Uno Dos and Tre trilogy, the crux of these punk brats' sound has created some of the most essential rock music to come out of the past few decades. If you want to know the real start of the group though, you got to go back a little further...to the '80s.

Long before Dookie really set the world on fire, the real start of Green Day began when Billie Joe Armstrong and Mike Dirnt were still teenagers on the California punk scene. Instead of having Tre Cool behind the kit though, original drummer John Kiffmeyer was a bit of a rough fit in the group. Though albums like 39/Smooth didn't exactly suffer on the melodic front, you can just hear that these guys aren't really gelling properly, as John's tom rolls struggle to really keep up with Billie and Mike.

Once Kiffmeyer decided to leave Green Day for college though, Tre's arrival ended up having its own problems, with his snare rolls being too frantic before finally settling into the groove. It wasn't until Dookie that everything fell into place though, with Tre learning to sit in the song to perfectly offset Billie's rhythm guitar. As opposed to the typical hit the ground running band, there was a good chance we could have not gotten the pop punk explosion at all if this played out differently.


9. Aerosmith

The arrival of Aerosmith on the rock scene marked a bit of a turning point for hard rock. As opposed to having to import most of the good hard rock from over in England, these Bad Boys from Boston were the first of their kind to really bring an edge back into the traditional rock and roll format. Though the foundation of something great was there, fans took their sweet time before warming up to these boogie rockers.

Although Aerosmith's debut sported some impressive songs like Mama Kin and the ballad Dream On, most of the critics weren't having any of it, casually writing them off as just a cheap ripoff of the Rolling Stones. While it sounds crazy today, it's not hard to see where they're coming from, with Steven Tyler's lower register singing sounding nowhere near like what he would be doing later down the line.

It also didn't help that their label weren't really bending over backwards to promote this thing either. Around the same time that these guys released their debut, most of the attention was paid to another act named Bruce Springsteen, who had just signed a deal and was being heralded as the next Bob Dylan. Everything seemed to have played out in the end though, with Get Your Wings arriving and eventually giving way to classics like Toys in the Attic and Rocks. A nice start...just needed a bit more polish though.


8. Alice Cooper

On first glance, it's almost expected that something like Alice Cooper wouldn't have gone well right out of the gate. Even when these shock rockers were on top of the world in the '70s, there were still plenty of naysayers trying to denounce what they saw as too macabre for the little children to be listening to. You couldn't script something more controversial...and yet that actually happened in the early days.

As opposed to crawling out of the crypt, Cooper and co. actually got their big break when they hooked up with rocker and resident weirdo Frank Zappa, who took them under his wing. Although the first few records were certainly a trip for what they were, the product was anything but spectacular, with most of the production sounding wretched under the wrong conditions. Compared to the chaotic stage show they would put on night after night, albums like Pretties For You is what that kind of chaos would sound like if it were made into audio form.

Though Alice had been getting notoriety for his outlandish stage shows, the marriage between hooks and looks didn't really congeal until Bob Ezrin entered the picture, who helped make Love It To Death and Killer the classics they are on the strength of songs like I'm Eighteen and Under My Wheels. A touch of evil does lend itself well to rock and roll...just not total anarchy though.


7. Radiohead

Looking back on your first record after being in the game for a while tends to feel like looking at baby pictures. Though many artists can sport amazing debuts that they can return to again and again, some people would rather have their first steps swept under the rug half of the time. Enter: Radiohead.

Ever since the end of the '90s, these English rockers have been the epitome of experimental, from the electronic juggernaut Kid A to the late period masterpiece In Rainbows. On Pablo Honey though, something is just tonally off from the first minute you put it on. While it may have been serviceable enough for its time, most of these songs run as just bland alternative rock songs that were meant to ride the coattails of the grunge movement that was happening overseas. Across this album, songs like Stop Whispering and You aren't necessarily bad, but they are starting to sound much more dated with the passage of time.

This album also looks like a mess in retrospect, with Creep being the only real song that people tend to remember from this record. Even the members themselves don't really like to revisit this one all that often, with Creep being absent from most of their live shows ever since. If you're into alternative rock, this is a good helping of that, but if you want to do a deep dive into Radiohead, by no means should you start here.


6. Rush

Most of Rush's catalog is among some of the best prog rock that the genre has to offer. While other acts like Emerson, Lake and Palmer and Genesis were making waves around the same time, this Canadian power trio had the most muscle of any other prog act, with riffs that were almost metal in their construction. If they had stuck to their guns though, there was a good chance that we wouldn't have seen any prog elements at all.

For the first Rush album, the man behind the stool was original drummer John Rutsey, who fashioned himself more of a rock and roll purist. As such, most of this album doesn't fit into the prog rock genre, instead being a pastiche of the run of the mill blues rock acts of the day like Led Zeppelin and Bad Company. Though Working Man did find its way onto the charts at the time, change was in the air once Rutsey was let go due to health concerns.

With Neil Peart now providing the backbeat and working on the lyrics, things started to branch out into much more heavy topics. Right from the start of Fly By Night, the difference between the two animals are like night and day, as the chemistry of these 3 guys compliment each other perfectly. Whereas Rutsey might have been a decent enough fit, it would have been a crime if we were robbed of Peart's talent.


5. The Red Hot Chili Peppers

Most of the Red Hot Chili Peppers' career has seen a bit of a revolving door when it comes to members. Though Flea and Anthony Kiedis remain the heads of the group to this day, the records are only as good as the people they have working beside them. At the start though, things weren't looking as good for these funk rockers.

Long before John Frusciante became a part of the group, most OG Chili Peppers fans have fond memories of Hillel Slovak being the main contributor before dying of a drug overdose after the album The Uplift Mofo Party Plan. However, even Hillel wasn't really in the trenches starting out, with the group's self-titled being a bit of a mess from start to finish. While you do have some of the trademark weirdness from songs like True Men Don't Kill Coyotes, a lot of the magic (or lack thereof) comes from the fact that guitarist Jack Sherman just isn't the best fit.

That's not to say that he doesn't have a few shining moments on the record, but the way he plays off of Flea and interacts with Kiedis left a lot to be desired. Once Slovak dissolved his previous band though, he fit in like a glove going into Freaky Styley, matching the energy of the others perfectly. It just goes to show you that when it comes to the Peppers, some energy needs to click before you even play a note of music together.


4. Pink Floyd

The work of Pink Floyd has helped expand the mind of many rock fans for years now. Despite being one of the go-to bands for the more stoner set of rock fans, albums like Dark Side of the Moon and Animals have some of the greatest commentaries on consumerism that the rock world has ever seen. If Floyd had stayed the course though, there's a good chance that none of that would have actually happened.

Around the time of psychedelia in the '60s, the original lineup of Floyd originally had Syd Barrett at the helm, with songs that were zany and more than a little bit off the wall. As the years went on though, Barrett found himself more and more out of step with the band, leading to an eventual breakdown due to drug abuse. Bringing in David Gilmour shortly afterwards, Floyd's work going forward seemed to be informed by their past trauma.

That kind of trauma was eventually what sparked most of their classic output, with Wish You Were Here being a sendoff and tribute to Barrett. Using it as some sort of fuel, Floyd ended up reaching even bigger heights when Roger Waters poured his solo into creating the Wall as a reflection on what fame can do to a person. While the loss of Barrett's sanity wasn't something anyone wanted, sometimes the best art can come from this kind of tragedy.


3. Alice in Chains (or Alice N Chainz)

Once the era of grunge hit, glam metal was pretty much dead in the water. As soon as Nirvana started to make their way across MTV, the age of acts like Poison and Warrant had no real staying power anymore. Then again, we could have gotten one of grunge's biggest acts as an LA rock band instead.

Long before moving back up to Seattle, the original iteration of Alice in Chains was a much different beast than what it became. Rather than the dark themes and lyrics, the group's arrival in LA (stylized as Alice N Chainz) was much more in the vein of the dangerous side of the California rock scene. Imagine something like if Pearl Jam had tried to be Guns N Roses and you're in the right ballpark. However, it was only a matter of time before they started to drop the whole glam pursuit.

As Jerry Cantrell took over songwriting duties, most of the cowboy boots and spurs went out in the window, replaced with the grimy looking clothes that would end up defining the grunge movement. Though Alice were still getting on the same bills as acts like Megadeth, you could tell there was something else going on whenever they played something like Man in the Box. Before the rock world even knew what hit them, these initial posers were about to ignite the grunge movement from the ground up.


2. Paul McCartney

At the end of the '60s, it was no easy task for Paul McCartney to continue on as a solo artist. After all, since you were part of dissolving one of the biggest rock groups in the world, you're not just going to fall back into past glory right out of the gate. Even though many might have expected things to be shaky, this was a lot nuttier than most were expecting.

Coming out with some decent singles right out of the gate like Maybe I'm Amazed and Another Day, the solo output of McCartney was initially lukewarm to say the least. Across his proper solo debut, most of the songs feel half-baked, either being first drafts or straight up experimental tracks. Some of the songs didn't even have proper choruses, instead just filled with melody lines from Paul.

Even the beginnings of his initial band Wings were off to a rough start as well with Wild Life. Though the prospect of working with someone like Denny Laine may have been interesting at the time, most of the record was full of freeform jams rather than fleshed out songs. This was just the beginning though, as Paul would eventually come back to the top of the charts off the strength of records like Jet and Live and Let Die. If stuff like Band on the Run hadn't come along though, many were suspecting that the Cute Beatle had really lost his way.


1. Foo Fighters

When it comes to inner band tension, most artists get to iron out their differences before they even reached the big time. Since no one's really examining your every move, the first steps of any artist can be a little unorthodox when starting out. When you were a part of one of the biggest bands in the world though, people have to take notice.

Once the first Foo Fighters album came out, Dave Grohl wasn't trying to turn it into a band, using it as a means to just make some music to pass the time while trying to get over the death of Kurt Cobain. Taking to the road to support it, most people started to recognize him, causing them to request the one Nirvana song Dave sang (Marigold) every time they played. It's one thing to get pushback from the fans though...it's another when it's in the group.

Over the course of albums like The Colour and the Shape, Dave ended up juggling band members, with William Goldsmith being replaced by Taylor Hawkins and Pat Smear being replaced by Franz Stahl and later Chris Shiftlett. It was never a hinderance to the music though, with this era being considered the golden period for the Foos' brand of high energy rock and roll. While the Foos may seem like one big rock and roll family now, the initial honeymoon period was a bit awkward to say the least.


In this post: 
Aerosmith
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97