10 Rock Bands That Only Have One Bad Album
Just Shy of Perfection.
For as much as some rock fans might not like to admit it, no band is really perfect. No matter how much conviction you might have going to bat for your favorite acts, there aren't too many artists who you could say had a perfect discography from top to bottom. Then again, these guys did come damn near close to it.
Out of all the records in these respective artists' discographies, there is always that one track or record that does not like to be mentioned among the fanbase. For one reason or another, these have been ostracized to the dark corners of the rock industry, never to be heard from again unless it's to openly mock them. That being said, do these albums really deserve that scorn? Well...yeah...a lot of them. With the exclusion of one-offs and collaboration projects, these had all the potential to be great only to come crashing down with the passage of time. Oh, they may have charted well and have even done financially well in their time, but the passing years have been all the more cruel to these records.
It ends up being doubly hurtful when you realize the amazing gems that are at every other corner of these artists' work. While hard work may pay off, it might also piss you off as well.
10. John Lennon
Bad Album: Some Time In New York City
The aura that surrounds the legacy of John Lennon could be considered the stuff of music legend today. Despite some of the more ill-advised moments in his career throughout the years, the calls for peace and social justice Lennon talked about both in and out of the Beatles made him a near musical prophet in the eyes of the public. However, even the prophets aren't without sin.
Starting off his solo career with his more experimental moments with Yoko Ono, Lennon's streak of Plastic Ono Band and Imagine came to a drastic halt with Some Time in New York City. Instead of the emotional gut punches we were given previously, there's something about this record that feels really off from a tonal perspective. Though there are a few great moments like New York City, the switch between John and Yoko's songs from one track to the next really started to wear on some fans.
Given that Lennon was also known to be a fairly political guy, this was where the protesting got a little harder to stomach, with almost every track calling out some injustice in the world. After this one went pretty much belly up by both fans and critics, Lennon was still able to soldier on with great albums like Mind Games and Double Fantasy before being gunned down outside his apartment in 1980. Not a crash and burn album necessarily...but definitely losing the momentum with this one.
9. Queen
Bad Album: Hot Space
There's probably a certain subset of rock fans who think that Queen can do absolutely no wrong in their field. It's not like that argument doesn't hold water either, with each member of the group being a technical virtuoso at their craft, from Freddie Mercury's undeniable stage presence to Brian May's creative guitar symphonies. On the other hand, who was asking them to become a dance band?
Granted, it's not like we couldn't really feel this one coming, as Queen had already started to get into dance-oriented material on Another One Bites the Dust a few years earlier. While the David Bowie duet Under Pressure got us excited for what Hot Space had to offer, time has been so very cruel to this record over the years. As opposed to the amazing bass lines of Another One Bites the Dust, songs like Staying Power just feel like a blatant retread into dance territory as they try to make lightning strike twice in the same spot.
That's not to say it's all bad though, with Life is Real being a loving tribute to John Lennon and Under Pressure turning into one of the greatest singalong tracks of all time. For all of the adulation that Queen have gotten from every stripe of music fan, you guys know you can do better than this.
8. My Chemical Romance
Bad Album: I Brought You My Bullets
No one can really blame bands for not having the pieces together right from the start. Hell, most musicians finding their feet can only hope to throw something worthwhile together as they start to find their sound. Given what we heard on I Brought You My Bullets, many wouldn't be surprised if we never heard from My Chemical Romance ever again.
Compared to the rock juggernauts that would come afterwards on albums like the Black Parade, this is about as sophomoric as these rock icons had ever gotten. Though there is a distinct lack of polish in the guitars, that punk rock style of production does this record absolutely no favors, with Gerard Way's vocals being almost completely buried next to the wall of guitars. It also seems like the trademark push and pull from Ray Toro and Frank Iero isn't fully in place yet, as they basically try not to step on each other's toes for most of the album.
While this album does tell a story like all of the following MCR albums, you can't really focus on it outside of a few amazing tracks like Headfirst for Halos and Vampires Will Never Hurt You. Gerard Way has gone on record as not being fond of the 'emo' genre label, but this is the one release in their catalog that does seem to fit that description...and not in a good way.
7. Muse
Bad Album: Showbiz
As time has gone on, Muse have proven themselves to be one of the few great power trios working today. With each passing record, Matthew Bellamy has always tried to steer the band in a slightly more ambitious direction, from the soaring space rock of Origin of Symmetry to the symphonic-electronic songs on The Resistance. You'd be saying all that stuff now though...times were a little different back in the late '90s.
With their first step up to the plate with Showbiz, it was clear that Bellamy and co. still had a lot of work to do. Are the trademarks of Muse still there? Sure, with Bellamy's soulful falsetto in place and having a handful of decent licks on tracks like Muscle Museum and Sunburn. On the other hand, this is probably the most incoherent Muse album ever made, flipping from country rock on Falling Down to grunge sounding licks on Sober and even a proto power ballad on Unintended.
For as much as something like Simulation Theory may have been divisive for fans, at least it had the ability to hold onto its themes for the rest of the album. It also doesn't help that you really start to hear the Radiohead influence a little too much after a while, with Cave sounding like something off of the Bends if it was just the slightest bit darker. Given that Muse have changed their sound so much over the years, the feeble attempts at rock on here almost feel cute by comparison.
6. The Clash
Bad Album: Cut the Crap
Every single Clash album had always carried some level of importance behind it. Whether it was the clarion call of punk rock on London Calling or even the wild experimentation of something like Combat Rock, you couldn't deny the conviction behind them, with Joe Strummer and Mick Jones selling punks on the idea of music having an impact on the rest of the world. Once you take Jones out of the equation though, things started to go downhill really fast.
After the touring for Combat Rock, Jones ended up getting kicked out of the group by Strummer for what he deemed as selling out by punk standards. Drafting in an almost entirely new lineup for the Clash, Strummer and Paul Simonon went in to make Cut the Crap, which turned into one of the biggest travesties in punk history. Compared to the more aggressive stuff coming from the likes of the Ramones, this feels like the neutered version of what punk should be, from the shoutalong chorus of We Are the Clash to the stupid subject matter of Fingerpoppin.
Though there is one shining light in This is England, it feels less like a good Clash song and more like a shroud to put across Strummer in the group's final days. While the Clash had the music world by the throat for most of their career, this is evidence of how far the Only Band That Mattered could sink.
5. Van Halen
Bad Album: Van Halen III
After years of hindsight, it's about time that the sparring sessions of David Lee Roth-Van Halen and Sammy Hagar-Van Halen be put to rest. For as many people like to rag on Hagar for turning these hair metal giants into a pop act, there's really nothing that could stop the raw talent on display, with 5150 holding up just as well as 1984 as years go by. However, most people don't like to acknowledge that Van Halen actually did have a third singer.
Once coming together to contribute songs to a greatest hits package, Hagar abruptly quit the band, leaving Eddie to find a replacement in Extreme vocalist Gary Cherone. While not exactly a bad choice at the outset, Van Halen III is one of the most high-profile screw ups in rock history, as Cherone just tries (and fails) to sound like Sammy throughout most of the tracks.
Compared to the more punchy titles that you would find with either Roth or Hagar, these songs also don't seem to have any sort of structure, with most of them feeling like random riffs thrown together without any concern for the listener's...well...enjoyment. Though VH would recover from hard times on the sort-of reunion album A Different Kind of Truth, this was not the note that anyone would have wanted to go out on.
4. Red Hot Chili Peppers
Bad Album: Self-titled
Countless musicians have been able to benefit from the slow build. Though some knock it out of the park on their first step up to the plate, there are many artists who polish away at their sound until they hit on some of their best work. However, that also means you have to dig through monsoons of sh*t before you actually get there.
Throughout the '90s, the Red Hot Chili Peppers became one of the hottest bands in the world, fitting somewhere in between the funk rock stylings of the '70s while also being just alternative enough to break into the mainstream. On the other hand, listening to the group's self-titled is almost like night and day by comparison. A lot of this has to do with being at the wrong place at the wrong time though. Being an extension of their guitarists, the only two original members on this record are Anthony Kiedis and Flea, who, while bringing their A-game, can't really hold together the entire Peppers foundation.
While Cliff Martinez does a serviceable job behind the kit and Jack Sherman does deliver some tasty licks, the real magic wouldn't fall into place until you had people like Hillel Slovak and John Frusciante working in the Chilis' world. Even though this record does contain some production from Gang of Four's Andy Gill, this kind of thing is on the wrong side of entertainment.
3. Metallica
Bad Album: St. Anger
No other metal band really has been picked apart throughout the years quite like Metallica have. Despite having some more eclectic moments in their discography, even their more celebrated albums like the Black Album tend to get hate from the metal community for not being metal enough. For those who were looking for Metallica to return to heaviness though, St. Anger proves you should be careful what you wish for.
Made while the band was in absolute turmoil, this record is probably the harshest listen that any metal fan had to endure at the time. Looking to move past the departure of bassist Jason Newsted and work out their demons in therapy, a lot of these tracks feel less like songs and more like grieving sessions put to music. Though that kind of thing should work well in a metal context, the production is hot garbage from one song to the next, with Lars Ulrich's snare being too far forward in the mix and James Hetfield giving a much more subdued contribution after coming out of rehab.
With each passing listen, it just feels like you're listening to Metallica wear down their sound one minute at a time, as they desperately try to make music together in the middle of their own hell. Say what you want to about the more contentious records like Load and ReLoad...at least they had the decency to not crush your eardrums every time you listened to them.
2. Led Zeppelin
Bad Album: In Through the Out Door
The first four album run of Led Zeppelin is enough to put them in the conversation of rock legends. Once the blues rock boom of '60s England began to spread out, records like Houses of the Holy and Led Zeppelin II became the blueprint of what rock was going to look like for many years to come. Though there was a bit of an adjustment period going into the album Presence, In Through the Out Door is where you start to see the cracks forming.
Going into recording, most of Zeppelin were in really bad shape, with Robert Plant still reeling over the death of his young son to a stomach ailment. As it stands, this is probably the most misguided mainstream release that Zeppelin ever put to tape, with songs like Hot Dog feeling like they're wasting time just so they can get to the next song. Since it's a Zeppelin record though, it's not all bad, with Fool in the Rain having some of John Bonham's most inventive drumming and All My Love being a stunning tribute to Plant's son and an opportunity for John Paul Jones to break out a new synthesizer.
This did end up being somewhat of an omen though, as Bonham would die of alcohol poisoning before Zeppelin could even take to the road to promote it. For as much as Zeppelin are celebrated as rock and roll giants, they really deserved a better final hoorah than this.
1. Guns N Roses
Bad Album: Chinese Democracy
The fallout of Guns N Roses in the mid '90s felt like the stuff of rock and roll folklore. After the massive tour cycle for Use Your Illusion cost the group two band members and Axl Rose's sanity, most of their covers album the Spaghetti Incident? was a feeble attempt to sooth things over before the next record started. Once Slash and Duff McKagan left, fans waited and waited until we finally got Chinese Democracy in 2008.
As it stands, this album was pretty much slated to fail right out of the gate, given that the anticipation period ran almost 14 years. On the surface though, there's nothing too wrong with the actual construction of the songs. Being primarily written by Rose, most of this record is just a revolving door of musicians doing their best to cater to Axl's ego, which makes for some musical trainwrecks on songs like Sorry and Scraped. Even though some tracks like Shackler's Revenge and This I Love still sound like GNR tracks, the overproduction makes them feel bloated before they are even finished.
Then again, this may have had a silver lining by actually bringing Slash and Duff back into the fold again just a few years ago. Though the core members of GNR are now accounted for, maybe it's best to leave the legacy where it is than risk going down the rabbit hole even further.