10 Rock Bands Who Blatantly Copied Other Artists

Professionals Borrow...But Geniuses Steal.

Bob Dylan / The Beatles
Parlophone / Capitol / Columbia

It's never easy trying to find something truly original in the music realm. Regardless of how much of a unique artistic mind you may think you possess, chances are there are millions of hopefuls out there just like you who have tried and failed at making their fortune. When you run short on ideas though, stealing is usually the next best thing.

Instead of taking real time into crafting these songs, these artists decided to coax on the goodwill of their own musical heroes. Compared to some of the more intellectual sides of rock and roll, a lot of these songs are just the products of what these guys were hearing in their record collections. Is that such a bad thing though? Aside from blatantly plagiarizing, these songs actually hold up in an unusual way. By attributing their influences directly, most of these fall into the realm of homage, looking to pay tribute to their musical heroes rather than just wearing their music as a mask.

Other times we may see the opposite happening though, where artists try on a new style specifically to mock one of their contemporaries. Regardless of how they actually came to be, these songs actually managed to become timeless in their own way by pulling so much from the past.

10. Welcome Home (Sanitarium) - Metallica

Metallica deserve to be cut a little bit of slack compared to their metal brethren. Despite having some real clunkers in their discography like St. Anger and Lulu, that doesn't take away from the massive influence they had in birthing the genre of thrash as we know it today. Then again, maybe even some of their classic moments weren't all their own.

When combing through the back catalogs of Metallica's softer side, Welcome Home is the prototype for the thrash ballad, featuring darker lyrics and a more subdued musical structure. Though this type of rolling arpeggio figure was a staple of James Hetfield's guitar playing at the time, even he admits that the main riff behind this song was not all his own. Though he has remained tight-lipped about his inspiration, the old NWOBHM band Bleak House seem to be the true originators, with their song Rainbow Warrior having an opening guitar figure near identical to Hetfield's version.

Although there's probably a whole slew of lawsuits that could be made out of something like this, Bleak House seem to have mellowed out, citing the rip off as a plus to give them more exposure. Even when cribbing from their old influences, making something like this is a great way to keep the spirit of metal alive for those who never reached their fullest potential.


9. Glycerine - Bush

There was a renewed sense of creativity in the rock scene when the alternative movement started happening. Whereas the hair metal movement felt like a slew of acts copying off of the same 5 bands, no one really sounded the same from Green Day to Nirvana to Pearl Jam to the alternative side of U2. In Bush's case, their new approach to songwriting was "just do what Kurt Cobain did."

Aside from the more grizzly features of Gavin Rossdale, most of Bush's first album is a clear homage to the Seattle sound happening across the pond. Though there are some songs on here worth some serious consideration like Machinehead and Comedown, Glycerine is one of the most blatant attempts at cribbing the vocal style of Cobain, as Rossdale reaches to get just the right amount of grit to sell the rest of the song.

Compared to some of the more open hearted material present in the old grunge bands, this is probably the closest the alternative nation ever got to a power ballad, feeling like it's as much indebted to the marketing plan of someone like Motley Crue or Def Leppard than it is to Mudhoney. Bush may have managed to squeak by on past glory, but the Cobain estate might have something to say about some overdue royalty checks.


8. Purple Rain - Prince

When talking about the true chameleons of rock and roll, no one really brings up Prince nearly enough. Much like the likes of David Bowie, The Purple One's unique flair for melody led him to creating some of the most elegant tapestries of sound ever produced, playing with soul, funk, rock and roll, and R&B as if they were all interwoven with one another. So when Prince eventually decided to swing for the fences, his ticket to success came from....heartland rock?

Aside from the more hectic moments of channeling Jimi Hendrix on songs like Let's Go Crazy, the title track to the Purple Rain film and album came about during soundchecks when Prince was on the same circuit as Bob Seger. Watching Seger take the stage, the original chords of this song came about when Prince was discussing with keyboardist Dr. Fink about why Seger was so famous.

Looking to expand his musical horizons, this song drenches itself in that trademark Prince melodrama, which erupts into one of the most orgasmic guitar solos he would ever commit to tape during his lifetime. It's no secret that the heartland community was listening right back, with Bruce Springsteen singing this song in tribute the night that Prince died. Just another example that even when delving into new musical territory, it's still just good music for Prince at the end of the day.


7. 4th Time Around - Bob Dylan

As the '60s revolution got underway, Bob Dylan could have made off like a bandit on the amount of royalties he could have had from people ripping him off. From the folk rock craze happening around the same time to the massive amount of Dylan soundalikes like Barry McGuire, Dylan had become the unofficial voice of his generation without even knowing it. He did have a playful side though, and that came out when he took a shot and one of the greatest pop groups of all time.

During the Beatles' ascent, John Lennon was taking massive influence from Dylan on each album, even making some blatant homages like on You've Got to Hide Your Love Away. Though the folk rock hit a peak with Rubber Soul, Dylan went the extra mile to parody Lennon on 4th Time Around, with a guitar line that was near identical to what was used in Norwegian Wood. When asked about the similarities, Dylan was always coy and said that Norwegian Wood sounded like his song but he recorded it later.

This was all in good fun though, prompting a competition of sorts between Lennon and Dylan which would continue until the end of Lennon's life in 1980. See, not all of the dustups have to necessarily end in a brawl, now do they?


6. Mechanix - Megadeth

You could imagine that nearly anyone who was in Dave Mustaine's position would be annoyed at the hand he'd been dealt. While he has carved out a name for himself as one of the titans of the thrash metal genre with Megadeth, the fact that he got snuffed out of being the lead guitarist of Metallica has made him keep that little bit of resentment in each song he plays. Though it might be water under the bridge, things weren't so chipper when it came time to make the Mechanix.

In one of the more unique forms of plagiarism there is, Mechanix is the result of Mustaine rewriting Metallica's The Four Horsemen the way that he wanted, going so far as to make the tempo even faster than it is on Kill Em All. After all, most of the music for this song was Mustaine's to begin with, so it's not so much a means of royalties anymore.

Even when performing the song live these days, Mustaine makes light of the comparisons before they play Mechanix, saying that you can listen to it either his way or "their way" before exploding into the first few riffs. If they say geniuses steal though, it's another thing entirely to say that you stole from yourself.


5. Hold On - Green Day

Nothing about Green Day really screams classic rock from the word go. Aside from having one of the most timeless pieces of music of the '90s in Dookie, the signature brand of pop punk that these teens from the Bay Area were known to make clearly were more indebted to the Ramones than to Led Zeppelin. By the time we got to Warning though, it seemed that these misfits had started to actually grow up.

Going in a more folked tinged direction, the entire album takes more than a few cues from the classic style of rock and roll, with Billie Joe Armstrong citing the Kinks as a direct influence. If there was one direct inspiration on Hold On though, it would have to be the Beatles, with a basic strumming chord progression that's ripped straight out of the A Hard Day's Night era. In fact, maybe a bit too much, considering that the harmonica intro is almost lifted from John Lennon's I Should Have Known Better.

It would seem that Armstrong actually noticed this too though, initially going back into the studio to re-record it because it sounded way too similar. Then again, if you were to steal from the old guard of rock and roll, it pays to steal from one of the best to ever grace the stage.


4. Name And Address - Paul McCartney

In the grand scheme of rock and roll, there probably aren't that many people arguing about Paul McCartney's pedigree as a musician. Compared to many of the other classic songwriters of the '60s, McCartney can practically fill up a greatest hits album with songs that have defined childhoods for years now. That doesn't mean he's above paying tribute to his influences though.

During his pop rock period with Wings, London Town is one of McCartney's more yacht rock centric releases, down to the fact that some of it was recorded aboard an actual yacht. Though songs like I'm Carrying and the title track are a lot more cutesy than pure rock and roll, the song Name and Address shows McCartney going back to the early days of rock royalty. From the excessive reverb on his voice to the lower register he has, the entire song is about as close as McCartney comes to an Elvis parody, even having a rockabilly rhythm underneath it all.

Compared to some of the more flagrant plagiarisms though, this doesn't feel mean spirited in the slightest, with Paul, Denny Laine, and Linda McCartney having some fun tipping their hat to the first true champion of rock and roll. We're a far ways off from the real King here, but this is more than qualified to have a throne of its own.


3. Whiter Shade of Pale - Procol Harum

Towards the mid '60s, the rock world was starting to get a whole lot more adventurous than the fun music started by Chuck Berry and Little Richard. Starting with the Beatles' experimentation on albums like Revolver, bands were popping up left and right with their own forms of psychedelia, where Procol Harum rose to prominence with White Shade of Pale. Whereas others found their inspiration in acid though, these guys found their rock and roll dreams during classical music practice.

When discussing the creation of the classic organ line, Gary Brooker had talked about practicing his classical pieces before screwing up Bach's classic Air on a G String. Instead of just relearning what it sounded like, Brooker decided to just carry on improvising before coming up with the classic opening of what is now a White Shade of Pale. As such, the whole song feels like it has some sort of regal scope about it, almost like it's floating above the clouds whenever it starts.

They didn't even bother to hide it too much either, considering the opening chords are still verbatim from the Bach piece. So next time you think that classical music is too pure and clean for rock and roll, just remember one of the foundational moments of '60s rock would be incomplete without some help from ol' J.S.B


2. Step Out - Oasis

Cases of plagiarism on the part of the Gallagher Brothers have been following them around since they first started back in the mid '90s. Ever since the first time Liam Gallagher uttered a word in his trademark Mancunian drawl, people have lined up to say that Oasis are blatant ripoffs of the Beatles. Whereas some spots do sound Beatlesque, the real plagiarism came from the other side of the musical spectrum.

Released as a B-side to Don't Look Back In Anger, Step Out remains one of the biggest low lights of Oasis' career, not even being released on the B-sides collection the Masterplan. Then again, there might be a reason why this got lost in the shuffle, considering Noel Gallaghers' fairly obvious love of Stevie Wonder on the chorus. While the rest of the song is clearly Noel's, every rhythmic accent of the chorus is lifted from Wonder's own Uptight, down to the fact that Noel just changed the words.

Even though Noel had to pay a lawsuit on behalf of Wonder's estate, he still insists that he never maliciously intends to steal songs, instead likening it to when people use songs as a blueprint when first getting the ball rolling. For as much as Noel does have a point here, the similarities are too scary close to really ignore.


1. The Bitter End - Sum 41

The early '00s were not really a high point for Metallica. After being one of the premier rock acts for the better part of 2 decades in the world of hard rock, the St. Anger era was just about to get underway, bringing any goodwill towards these thrash titans to a glaring halt. If you wanted to get a taste of that thrashy goodness again though, we actually found the next best thing in the world of pop punk.

Being die hard metalheads, Sum 41 had started to experiment with some heavier styles on Chuck, culminating in a direct homage to Metallica on The Bitter End. Compared to other songs that try to mask their influences, these Canadian punks aren't above wearing Metallica on their sleeves as they play, leaving in references to old Metallica songs and taking the rhythmic structure of the chorus from Metallica's own Battery.

Considering Metallica were looking almost down for the count around this time, this was the kind of thrash heaviness that many fans were aching to hear from St. Anger, only to be disappointed when it was finally released. Even though we're a far ways off from classic territory on something like this, Sum 41 at least gave us a healthy reminder of the glory days of speed metal on here.


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97