10 Rock Bands Who Only Have One Original Member Left

The Last Musician Standing...

maiden image
wiki

Most rock acts these days tend to be looked at as a complete democracy. No matter how much clout some lead singers may claim to have in their time, it always comes down to teamwork if you really want to make the magic happen. Then again, sometimes it's just as good to have a revolving door of band members.

Across each of these acts, there is only one person who has remained in the trenches from day one. Oftentimes, this caters to the 'mastermind' theory of rock group, with one person looking at the big picture and basically using their other musicians as just colors in their masterpiece. However, not all rock bands work out that smoothly. Other times, many artists will be so dysfunctional that it normally just comes down to one guy left to steer the ship.

Hell, on the rarest occasion, the lone OG musician in question wasn't even the main song contributor, leaving them to rely on the hired guns they have to try and replicate the sound of the old days. That's not to say it's bad, mind you...it's just not the same as it used to be. Even though rock can be thought of as a band of brothers, you really need to just look in one direction in these acts.

10. Steely Dan

The longevity of Steely Dan has always come from their willingness to experiment. Throughout their career, songs like Do It Again, Kid Charlemagne, and even Peg have played with the boundaries of what constitutes real rock and roll. In fact, most of the music was so good that no one really bothered to keep track of the actual people playing the instruments.

From day one, most of Steely Dan's "members" were made up of session musicians under the watchful eye of Walter Becker and Donald Fagen. Though giants like Jim Keltner and Larry Carlton would come in and out of the lineup on more than one occasion, it was pretty much anyone's guess as to who would be playing on the record every time it came out. Hell, just for recording the song Aja, Fagen and Becker went through tons of different session players and actually used two different drummers before settling with the take they were happy with.

While these records still hold up as some of the cleanest productions of the '70s, Fagen is now the lone survivor for Steely Dan after Becker passed away just a few years ago. Then again, Fagen's unique vocal stylings have always been the personality of the group's music since its inception, with just the right amount of sarcasm and wit to keep you listening for more. For as much as they might be called dad music nowadays, Fagen has proven that the smoother side of rock can take you a long way.


9. Iron Maiden

The entire metal movement never really kicked into high gear until the New Wave of British Heavy Metal got underway. Whereas bands like Black Sabbath and Deep Purple may have planted the seeds for what metal would become, the sounds of acts like Saxon and Diamond Head became the blueprint for what the genre would look like going forward. In the grand pantheon of metal though, there can only be one Iron Maiden.

That being said, the Maiden we got to know back in the day is a lot different than the monster we know today. Before Bruce Dickinson came into the fold, lead singer Paul Di'Anno was the original singer, along with guitarists like Adrian Smith and Dennis Stratton coming through the ranks. Out of all the standout players, the real heart of Maiden has always been Steve Harris. From the very beginning, Steve's relentless right hand on the bass has created the foundation for Maiden's writing, from the broad scope of lyrical themes to the gallop that became synonymous with metal.

Even though the present iteration of Maiden has ballooned into a three-guitar attack, the sound of the group has always managed to remain intact with Steve out front. No matter how many compliments you might like to pay to Bruce Dickinson or even Dave Murray over the years, Steve Harris is Iron Maiden.


8. Guns N Roses

When Guns N Roses first hit the LA rock scene in the late '80s, they truly felt like a band of outlaws. Compared to the more glammified acts coming from the Sunset Strip, these players felt like the epitome of a street gang, willing to lay down their lives for the music they played. Once the family dissolved though, it became impossible to keep track of who was in and out of the group at any given point.

The first real blow came when Steven Adler was let go in the middle of the Use Your Illusion records, with Matt Sorum brought in to replace him. As the tour went on though, Izzy Stradlin's newfound sobriety led to him quitting midway through the tour. Bringing in Gilby Clarke, GNR soldiered on until the end of the Illusion tour cycle, after which Slash, Duff McKagan, and Sorum all quit after not being able to put up with Axl Rose's antics anymore.

Though they have since reunited, the entire '00s era of the group is a virtual who's who of talent, from Buckethead being part of the lineup to Bumblefoot to Robin Finck. The only real constant was Axl himself, who's warped view of reality was too much for anyone to bear for more than a few minutes. While the bad blood may be water under the bridge now, it was downright painful to see the unraveling of the World's Most Dangerous Band once everyone left Axl alone.


7. Foo Fighters

Over the years, the Foo Fighters feel more and more like some crazy rock and roll family. From the goofy onstage antics between the set to the way they are in interviews, there's definitely a group dynamic that is far more down to earth than your usual glitzy rock stars. Though everyone is able to shine on their respective instruments, there's no denying that Dave Grohl is the head hancho.

A lot of people tend to forget that before the days of My Hero and Learn to Fly, the Foo Fighters weren't even thought of as a proper band. For most of the first record, Grohl was practically a one-man band, playing all of the instruments on songs that he wrote in between being in Nirvana. Once the actual record started to pick up some steam though, Grohl set about setting up a band around him. While the start was a bit shaky, the classic lineup eventually started to congeal once Taylor Hawkins and Nate Mendel were brought out of other veteran acts like Alanis Morrissette and Sunny Day Real Estate.

Even some of the old dogs like Pat Smear have found a spot in the group in later years, after quitting in the late '90s after getting plagued by burnout. Dave might be the guy that everyone likes to focus on, but this kind of dynamic shows that he's just as comfortable when he has good players around him.


6. Deep Purple

Deep Purple's rise to fame was a lot different than most people would expect out of their favorite rock acts. As opposed to the age-old tale of starry-eyed kids forming a group, Purple came together as a group of musical professionals, with Jon Lord hooking up with Ritchie Blackmore and Ian Paice in the early days. When you have that kind of dynamic though, things can start to turn a corner real quick.

Throughout their classic run in the '70s, Purple had no fewer than 4 different lineup changes in their time. Whereas most people might be familiar with Ian Gillan as the star of the original version, he was actually the second vocalist after Rod Evans' croon didn't seem like the greatest fit. Even that didn't hold up either, with in-fighting prompting Gillan and bassist Roger Glover to be replaced by David Coverdale and Glenn Hughes respectively.

While the Gillan-Glover lineup did reunite for a short time, it didn't take long before old problems resurfaced, causing Blackmore to strike off on his own again. At the turn of the millennium, another piece of the puzzle was gone when Jon Lord announced he would be retiring from touring, bringing in Don Airey to replace him. Though the faces behind the music have changed over time, we still have Ian Paice behind the kit as Purple's beating heart.


5. Slipknot

On the surface, it only seems like Slipknot have made a few adjustments to their lineup over the years. Despite having some heavyhitters like Chris Fehn and Joey Jordison not in the fold anymore, it sometimes tends to seem like a small part of the puzzle when you have 9 people in the group. However, most people forget that there's only one person who's been there from day one.

For as much as Corey Taylor might be seen as the mouth of the group, both him and Jim Root were brought in afterwards from their group Stone Sour. In fact, most of Slipknot's original lineup was a shell of what they would become, with the initial idea being thought up by Jordison and his friends when working as a gas station clerk at night while still in Iowa. While Paul Gray was in the trenches, his death in the late '00s left a hole in the group that could never be filled.

As it stands, most of Slipknot's foundation these days comes down to Shawn 'Clown' Crahan, who's vision has led Slipknot through all of the good times and the bad. It's also pretty grounding to have him in the group now, since he seems to be the one person who completely understands the concept of what Slipknot should be. Regardless of who's behind the mask these days, the real menace of Slipknot will remain intact so long as our beloved Clown is still annihilating his mammoth drums onstage.


4. Blink-182

At the start of the '00s, it was virtually impossible to escape the sound of Blink-182. Picking up exactly where bands like Green Day had left off, this power trio from California became the embodiment of adolescence for an entire generation, with songs that were just as fun-loving as they were heartfelt. On the other hand, any chance of having a stable lineup has pretty much fallen by the wayside.

During the group's inception, the original drummer Scott Raynor was just what the group needed. However, going into the album Dude Ranch, it was clear that this kind of frantic drumming wasn't going to cut it when it came to move up to the big leagues. Finding a virtuoso in Travis Barker, Blink also managed to have two frontmen for the price of one in both Tom Delonge and Mark Hoppus. Then again, having two leaders is where ego starts to creep in.

After splitting up in the early '00s due to creative differences, the group reunited in the early 2010's, only to kick Tom out of the group again for his unreliability. Drafting in Matt Skiba from Alkaline Trio, this latest version of Blink only has Hoppus from the original lineup accounted for. Even though the face out front is a bit different, albums like California and Nine have proven that these pop punk titans still have some more gas in the tank.


3. Queens of the Stone Age

If you were looking for something heavy in the early '90s, you couldn't do much better than stoner rock. Instead of the cheap hair metal and the gargantuan stuff that acts like Metallica would have, acts like Sleep and Monster Magnet were tuning their guitars way down to get a much more gutteral sound from their music. Though Kyuss stood out as one of the main draws, Josh Homme always had other plans in the back of his mind.

When it comes to stable lineups, Queens of the Stone Age is pretty much the definition of how not to do it. From day one, there hasn't really been a single person who has remained consistent outside of Homme. Though there have been people that have stuck around for a while like Nick Oliveri and Mark Lanegan, the crux of the band has only had Homme as the common thread. On the other hand, that might be the point.

Across every one of Queens' albums, you get the impression that you're not listening to a band per se but rather a collaborative project that Homme puts together to jam with every musician he loves. Though the Queens might have a more functional lineup whenever they take to the road, it's anyone's guess as to who they're going to be when they go in to actually make a record.


2. ELO

In the early '70s, prog rock was still just being born. With King Crimson and Yes starting to lead the charge, it was time for rock to move past the traditional bluesy formula and move into the big leagues of grandiose music. On the other hand, no one exactly expected to go full orchestral just yet.

Once Electric Light Orchestra arrived on the scene, rock fans were treated to Chuck Berry by way of Beethoven, with various string arrangements taking place where a guitar solo would have originally been. As time went on though, the only real constant in the group was Jeff Lynne, who was responsible for every one of the songs. While Roy Wood played a pivotal role in the early days, Lynne's immaculate touch with production has remained intact ever since, assisting both ELO's work as well as albums by giants like Tom Petty and George Harrison.

Across every single ELO song, Lynne proves himself to be somewhat of a musical visionary, looking to use the studio as his canvas to paint lush sonic tapestries across his discography. Hell, even when reforming and taking to the road in recent years, the new lineup has been rechristened Jeff Lynne's ELO to call attention to the technical wizard at the forefront. For a band that's all about lush soundscapes, it takes a certain type of musical force to make every single element of both rock and classical sound this good.


1. Nine Inch Nails

At the start of the '90s, the term industrial rock didn't really have a set name yet. Though you did see the darker sides of electronica coming from acts like Depeche Mode at the time, we were a long way from acts like Ministry and Filter that would come later. If you want to see who really kicked everything into high gear, it was Nine Inch Nails....specifically Trent Reznor.

On the surface, the pieces are all there for NIN to be an actual proper band, and yet it always comes back to Reznor at the end of the day. Ever since starting out, Reznor has been the real captain of thid industrial metal beast, with the other people around him functioning as extensions of his warped musical vision. Though we have seen some more than competent people on NIN records like Richard Patrick and Dave Grohl in later years, there's not one note that is played that Reznor hasn't had some sort of involvement in ever since.

Then again, it's not like his creative intuition is necessarily wrong, given that albums like the Fragile and the Downward Spiral are outright classics for both the industrial rock genre and metal as a whole. Regardless of whatever musical score he might be involved in in later years, when it comes to Nine Inch Nails, all roads lead back to Trent Reznor.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97