10 Rock Bands Without Any Original Members Left

Are they even the same bands anymore?

Judas Priest Sister British Steel
Columbia/Sony Music Entertainment

The Ship of Theseus is a philosophical challenge that posits the following question - if something has had all of its original parts replaced, is it still the same thing? Or is it something else entirely?

This theory also applies to Trigger's broom from that episode of Only Fools and Horses and, as it turns out, rock bands.

Whilst they may have carried the same name for their entire existence, there are plenty of famous groups that have chopped and changed so many times that there are no founding members left. And yet, they still continue to carry the same lineage as the band that started it all. Is this fair? Is it morally right? Does anybody really care? Probably not.

Still, it makes for an interesting read (hopefully), but it's also a murky subject with plenty of rules and regulations to go over.

An "original member", for the purposes of this list, is one who was present during the first full iteration of the band. They don't necessarily have to have played on all of the band's records, they just had to have been there right at the start.

10. Opeth

Opeth are a progressive metal band from Sweden, which seems to produce slightly alternative metal at an alarming rate. If they could somehow harness it as a fuel source, then all of their energy concerns would be gone forever.

The group were formed in 1990 by vocalist David Isberg, who pulled together a gang of fellow musicians that he knew from his time on the scene. When things weren't working out, Isberg recruited the guitarist Mikael Åkerfeldt to serve as the band's new bassist.

There was just one problem - Isberg hadn't told the original bassist that he was being replaced. Whoops.

This resulted in a massive falling out between Isberg and the other members, all of whom walked out on Opeth, leaving just he and Åkerfeldt behind. Whilst Åkerfeldt has stuck around since that day, Isberg bailed after just two years, handing the vocal reigns over to his buddy in the process.

And just how did Opeth fair following Isberg's departure? Well, they've released 13 studio albums, many of which routinely appear in the Billboard charts over in America.

So, yeah, they managed just fine.


9. In Flames

It turns out that shedding original members is a common habit amongst Swedish metal outfits, as that's precisely what happened to In Flames, a group also formed in 1990.

This lot are often credited with helping pioneer the Swedish death metal sound, as well as the melodic metal subgenre overall, and were born when guitarist Jesper Strömblad was looking for a new project to throw himself into. He was joined by guitarist Anders Iwers and bassist and singer Johan Larsson to form the first version of In Flames.

There should probably be some lame pun here about how this lineup "failed to catch fire" or "burnt themselves out", but that would be cheap.

The first to go was Iwers, who was replaced fairly quickly with Glenn Ljungström. Larsson made it onto the first two albums before being replaced by Iwers' brother Peter, with Strömblad sticking around for 20 years before finally walking away in 2010.

In Flames have released five studio albums since their founder's departure, proving that their flame is still as hot as ever... dammit, one of those puns found a way in after all.


8. Quiet Riot

The first group of non-Swedes on this list, Quiet Riot were formed in Los Angeles, California in 1973 by bass player Kelly Garni and Randy Rhoads, the man who would go on to play guitar for Ozzy Osbourne on his Blizzard of Ozz and Diary of a Madman albums.

This hard rock unit made waves by bringing the songs of UK glam metal act Slade to the US, including Cum on Feel the Noize and Mama Weer All Crazee Now. Notice how they didn't attempt to correct any of Slade's spelling errors.

Despite hitting the number one spot with their 1983 album Metal Health, Quiet Riot couldn't keep things stable for long enough to capitalise on any of this momentum.

Garni got the boot for threatening to shoot singer Kevin DuBrow, Rhoads went his own way not long after to focus on his work with Osbourne and, with DuBrow's death in 2007, that was it for the original lineup.

Not to worry, as they haven't let this get them down whatsoever! Quiet Riot are still going today, even if they're a little less riotous now in their old age.


7. Napalm Death

With a name like Napalm Death, it will not surprise anyone to learn that this group from the English West Midlands do not make bubblegum pop.

Instead, the band, who were formed in 1981, helped innovate the genre of grindcore, through their use of blast beats, wailing vocals, and fast-paced playing. Though they've never been a mainstream success, they have amassed a massive cult following over the years and continue to tour, even supporting Slayer for their final ever set of shows in 2018.

All this, despite the fact that the last original member of Napalm Death left in 1986.

Nic Bullen and Miles Ratledge, the pair who had founded the band as teenagers, were both gone before their first studio album was even released, and the last original band member to play on that record, drummer Mick Harris, said his goodbyes in 1991.

The longest-serving current member of Napalm Death is bassist Shane Embury, who's been around since 1987, but even he was still the third new bass player after the original one.

Basically, Napalm Death's membership history is just as wild and confusing as the band's musical output, but nobody seems to mind.


6. GWAR

In reality, GWAR's lineup could have stayed the same since its inception in 1985, just with the original members changing up masks and stage names without telling anyone.

However, in the spirit of trust, it's best to assume that they are telling the truth and have rotated their roster several times in the many decades since their formation.

GWAR's whole gimmick is that each member is part of a tribe of alien warriors who just so happen to enjoy making heavy metal music on the side. This has led to some cracking names being present on the call sheet over the years; take the original line-up of the band, for example.

Johnny Slutman; Mr. Magico; Oderous Urungus; Balsac; Jaws of Death; and, finally, Hans Sphincter. Everyone else can go home now, because GWAR absolutely knocked it out of the park with this one.

Over the years, these wonderful weirdos all went their separate ways, leaving only Urungus (real name Dave Brockie) left standing. Sadly, in 2014, Brockie passed away, leaving GWAR with zero original members, but countless memories of some of the most absurd moments in all of music history.


5. Yes

Formed in London towards the tail-end of the swinging '60s, Yes earned a decent following through their technically-advanced playing style, fantastical lyrics, and long, varying song structure.

Then, in the 1980s, they realised they liked money, and totally sold out.

The history of Yes is a confusing one, containing 20 officially recognised members and even more who were just there for sessions and tours. The generally agreed-upon original lineup consists of Jon Anderson, Chris Squire, Peter Banks, Tony Kaye, and Bill Bruford.

Banks didn't last long at all, splitting in 1970. Bruford first left in 1972, only to briefly re-join between 1990 and 1992. As for Kaye, he enjoyed several stints with Yes, but hasn't played with them full time since 1995.

Anderson and Squire were by far the most consistent members, appearing regularly on albums in both phases of the band's life. Anderson chose not to return after the band went on hiatus between 2004 and 2008, so, when Squire died in 2015, that was the end of that.

Anderson, Bruford, and Kaye are all still around, so maybe the band will offer to have them back, and they'll say... well, you can probably figure out what.


4. Pantera

Before morphing into the hard-hitting, groove metal gods they were in their prime, Pantera were a very run-of-the-mill hair metal act, which goes to show that even rock music deities made bad choices from time to time.

At the heart of both iterations of the band were the Abbot brothers, "Dimebag" Darrell and Vinnie Paul. With Darrell on guitar and Vinnie on drums, they were the driving force behind Pantera during its embarrassing early life and were the ones who helped pull it out of the mud and create the tour de force fans recognise today.

The original Pantera singer, Donny Hart, didn't even make it to the first album. He was followed by a procession of disappointments, before the band finally struck gold by hiring Phil Anselmo in 1986. Original bassist Tommy Bradford also vanished prior to their first release, with current bass man Rex Brown taking his spot.

Sadly, with both Abbots no longer on this mortal plain, any chance of a truly original Pantera reunion are gone with them.


3. Thin Lizzy

Whether they were heading back into town, breaking out of jail, or filling a jar with a certain alcoholic spirit, Irish band Thin Lizzy always knew how to have a good time.

Though keyboard player Erix Wrixon was present for their first single, The Farmer, he'd gone by the time the band's first album was released. That left drummer Brian Downey, guitarist Eric Bell, and bassist/charismatic frontman Phil Lynott left on the bill.

Bell parted ways with the Lizz in 1973, never to return, and was eventually superseded by the classic guitar pairing of Scott Gorham and Brian Robertson.

Downey made it all the way to the end of the band's first tenure in 1983 and has returned for sporadic reunions ever since, but, as of 2013, he has not been an official member.

That leaves Lynott, whose mounting drug issues were the cause of that break in '83. Alas, these dalliances caught up with the star three years later, as he died in 1986.

Even without their main attraction, Thin Lizzy have found a way to carry on, even if they're not quite the same as you remember them.


2. Lynyrd Skynyrd

This list has dealt with its fair share of tragedy already, but the story of Lynyrd Skynyrd is by far the saddest one yet.

The Southern rock idols took on their most famous moniker in 1969, after a series of failed names. This incarnation of Skynyrd consisted of Larry Junstrom and Bob Burns, who weren't around long enough to be of much interest, and three men who would be on all of the band's original albums - guitarists Gary Rossington and Allen Collins, and singer Ronnie Van Zant.

Van Zant famously lost his life in a 1977 plane crash that also killed five other people. Whilst Skynyrd were able to reform in 1987, Collins had been in a serious car accident the year before, which paralysed him from the waist down. He served as the band's musical director until his death in 1990.

That just leaves Rossington, who survived that fateful plane crash and re-joined the band upon their '87 reunion. He played with them for the next 35 years, until he also passed away in 2023, aged 71.

Okay, that's the heavy stuff out of the way now.


1. Judas Priest

The iconic Judas Priest setup - the one that produced British Steel and Screaming for Vengeance - consisted of Rob Halford on vocals, K. K. Downing and Glenn Tipton on guitars, Ian Hill on bass, and Dave Holland on drums.

None of them were originally in the band.

Halford joined in 1973, several years after the band's formation in September 1969, with Tipton following suit in 1974 and then Holland in 1979.

Downing and Hill were both present nearer the start, but they had joined in 1970. Or rather, original singer Al Atkins had joined them, as they were originally part of a band called Freight. Atkins had tried and failed to start Judas Priest the previous year, but, when that fell through, he took himself and his cool name over to Freight, convinced them to accept it, and the rest is history.

Atkins only lasted until 1973 and none of his former bandmates ever joined up with the "new" Judas Priest. Hill has the distinction of being the longest-serving Priest member, as he's still in the band today, but that Atkins-era bass player prevents him from being classed as a true original.

Curse you, Bruno Stapenhill!


Contributor
Contributor

Jacob Simmons has a great many passions, including rock music, giving acclaimed films three-and-a-half stars, watching random clips from The Simpsons on YouTube at 3am, and writing about himself in the third person.