10 Rock Musicians That Get Way Too Much Hate
In Need of Redemption.
Rock and roll has been around a long time, and there have more than a few guitar heroes than have come out of the blue. Even though none of these guys could be considered angels by any stretch, there’s always that feeling you get when you hear some of your favorite artists go up against the man and are able to deliver some of the best music that you’ve ever heard. In that same span of time, there have also been just as many villains coming into the fold as well.
While some of these artists have been controversial in their own way, that doesn’t make them bad by any stretch. Even with all of the deserved hate that comes their way, there’s no reason to slag off everything these people have done as crap. If you just see the forest for the trees, you sometimes miss some of the greatest music that you’ve ever heard without even realizing.
Despite their nasty reputation, every one of these artists has made their respective bands that much better along the way, whether that be through the press that they get for their new record or occasionally coming through with an amazing riff that puts the final piece in a perfect song. There’s no wrong way to play rock and roll, and even if these artists tested our patience a lot of the time, they still deserve a place in the genre’s history.
10. Yoko Ono
There seemed to be a hole left in the world of music when the Beatles decided to call it a day. Since they were the ones who ushered in new forms of rock and roll and brought the genre to new heights, seeing them fall out over business casted a shroud over the rest of the music world. Fans weren't looking to move on though. They were looking for someone to blame...and Yoko Ono pretty much checked every single box.
For all of the great artistry that she had gotten into before she even became John Lennon's partner, Yoko has carried the reputation as the one who tore everything apart, coming in between the Fab Four and urging John to do more avant garde work with her. If you were to ask any Beatle about what happened towards the end though, Yoko has much less involvement in their breakup than their managers, with Allen Klein getting them to work against each other and even John Lennon wanting out of the band because he was drifting away from them creatively.
There's even video evidence of the band getting along well in the studio during the Get Back documentary, where Paul McCartney even jokes that it would be the funniest thing in the world if the band broke up because Yoko decided to sit on one of their amplifiers one day. You don't have to like her music, but Yoko was not the cause of the Beatles' breakup. These were just four creative people that had said all they could possibly say together.
9. Bono - U2
There's practically been an entire myth that revolves around U2 ever since they came out of the '80s. From their amazing performance at Live Aid to reinventing themselves into the ironic generation on Achtung Baby, everything about these guys seemed to be about something more than music, taking the confines of rock and roll and using it to enact change in the world. It's all in the presentation though, and there's far too many fans that see a lot of pretension underneath those Grandma sunglasses.
Then again, Bono being pompous for the hell of it hasn't exactly been a new thing, with footage from Rattle and Hum showing him patronizing his fans for not listening to his long winded speeches in between the songs. When you strip away all of the political ideology and soap box speeches though, Bono is actually one of the more powerful voices of the '80s, from the weird eccentric sounds he got out of his voice on a song like Drowning Man to hitting most of I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For all within his natural register without going into falsetto.
Even if some of us would prefer that he not say another word again as long as he lives, the stigma of Bono as this pretentious windbag is just looking at the forest for the trees. He may need to get over himself every now and again, but underneath those cringy moments is a good heart who's trying to make rock and roll something more than just notes on a page...like all great rockstars should.
8. Courtney Love - Hole
Every great movement in rock and roll has to have someone carrying the torch forward for the rest of us. Just as the hair metal movement was starting to get more than a little bit cartoony, Kurt Cobain became the voice that everyone wanted to rally behind, which wasn't the most comfortable position for him to be in, especially for someone who thought of himself as part of the punk community. When he was found dead in his home though, all of that frustration and anger ended up getting directed at his wife most of the time.
While Courtney Love's music with Hole has always been a bit of an acquired taste, she deserves so much more credit for making the riot grrl movement more of a household name rather than just being Kurt's wife. Although the title of her album Live Through This had some of the worst timing in the world coming a few weeks after Kurt's body was found, the album still holds up as a classic from the '90s, taking the typical tropes that you found in grunge and putting a punk spin on them on songs like Doll Parts and Violet.
Even when she was topping the charts though, there were still people making her the scapegoat, including a few ugly theories that speculated that Kurt wrote half of her material and that she intentionally drove her husband to commit suicide. Everyone has their own way of dealing with grief, but there's no reason to place the blame on Courtney. She was grieving just like the rest of us, and actually managed to pick herself up and move on.
7. Meg White - The White Stripes
Rock and roll has never been about being the most impressive musician in the world. Those scale exercises were for genres like classical music, and the main motivation behind bands starting out was to make the loudest noise possible and seeing if you could get a tune out of it by the end of your jam session. If it all comes back to attitude though, then why do we all tend to rag on Meg White for doing the bare minimum?
Because when you listen to the White Stripes' back catalog, you're not going to find anything too technical behind the kit, with Meg only having a basic setup and playing the preschool version of what rock and roll is supposed to be. While that might frustrate the prog rock enthusiasts that worship at the alter of bands like Rush, there's a good chance that the White Stripes could never have existed without the kind of simplistic drumming holding everything down.
Jack White's songs may have been great on their own, but having that pulse from Meg added a disheveled feeling to the whole thing, almost like you're hearing the song in its infant stage right before it starts to come alive. And when you saw the band live, it did most of the time, as Meg traded in the straight pulse of the track for something much more visceral, laying heavy into the cymbals and creating much more energy than what is expected out of just 2 people. Jack had always likened the Stripes' music to getting back to the roots of rock and roll, and Meg's drumming is the result of a bunch of kids trying to figure out how to rock for the first time.
6. Lars Ulrich - Metallica
There's a good chance that Metallica would have been a much more technically skilled band if they had gotten rid of Lars Ulrich back in the '80s. For all of the insanely fast runs that he put into songs like Master of Puppets, the band could tell that things were going off the rails, as evidenced by the recent videos showing Lars constantly fumbling some of the most basic drum fills imaginable. A world without Lars Ulrich in Metallica may have made for a better band, but chances are we would have never known who they were today.
Outside of just being the leader of the percussion team, Lars really is the businessman behind Metallica, helping keep them afloat when they were trying to regroup after losing Cliff Burton and molding them into something more radio friendly, including suggesting that Enter Sandman be the single off of the Black Album. And as much as people rag on him for all of the Napster bullsh*t, people forget that he did have a point, trying to look after future artists down the line who were going to struggle getting paid for their work, which only came true in the age of streaming.
Above all else, there was never a moment where Lars stopped being a fan of metal music, always looking to give back to the musical community that raised him and shedding light on some of his favorite bands that were never able to break into the mainstream. Love him or hate him, Lars is the reason why most fairweather fans of rock music can get into metal.
5. Don Henley - Eagles
Coming right out of the Summer of Love, the Eagles were the next band that we all went to for some California sunshine. Even when bands like Led Zeppelin and Aerosmith were breaking into the mainstream with songs that were much more heavy, hearing the soothing sounds of Take It Easy made it seem like everything was going to be okay in the wake of the Vietnam War. We live in a different world than 1972 though, and most of us have to end up dealing with Don Henley...the copyright dictator.
Outside of the Big Lebowski, there's a reason why you don't really hear the Eagles' music too terribly often, with Don never letting people license his music if he doesn't get paid for at least a little bit at the end of the day. In the age of streaming and fans getting back into classic rock, Don is looking more like the 'Old Man Yells at Cloud' of rock and roll, complaining that anyone who uses his music is a thief trying to cheap him out of his hard earned money. As much as we might facepalm now though, it's impossible to deny that voice whenever his songs come on the radio.
For all of the great singers that have come and gone throughout the Eagles' tenure, Don's golden throat has been running strong for years, always managing to ride the tightrope of being serious and accessible at the same time on songs like The End of the Innocence. And for someone who lived through the '80s, Don seems to be one of the few rockstars who made it on MTV and actually managed to escape with his integrity.
4. Wes Borland - Limp Bizkit
Sometimes some of the greatest musicians tend to get called trash just by association. Even if Mark Tremonti stands as one of the greatest guitarists living today, it was a much different story when he was pumping out riffs for Creed, with Scott Stapp dumping his trademark cheese on top of everything. On the other side of the rock scene though, Limp Bizkit was actually hiding something a lot more eccentric underneath that backwards baseball hat.
Getting past the obnoxious sounds of Fred Durst on songs like Break Stuff and Nookie, Wes Borland had far more talent that anyone else in the nu metal scene, turning his guitar parts inside out and almost acting like a guitar equivalent to someone like Les Claypool from Primus, looking to explore different parts of the fretboard that hadn't been looked at yet. Once you actually try to play a song like Nookie, chances are you won't have much luck coming close, with Wes flying up and down the fretboard and toying with the different effects to create something that would have never gotten on the radio were it not for some truly cringy lyrics.
There are a few songs where Wes' guitar is able to outmatch the rest of the band, with Fred taking a backseat on the theme to Mission Impossible and turning that detuned version of the theme song into something iconic. Limp Bizkit might fall to the very bottom of many rock fans' favorite bands list, but if we were talking solely on technical prowess, Wes Borland might be just a few notches below Tom Morello for what he brought to guitar in the '90s.
3. Morrissey - The Smiths
Right around the time that the indie scene started exploding over in England, the Smiths were the sad kings of melodrama. Although all of their songs dealt with pretty morose topics like on Girlfriend in a Coma, the tunefulness behind Morrissey's vocals was impossible to resist, almost like he was pleading to find some sort of happiness by the end of the song. A band is always better as a unit though, and when Morrissey opened his mouth outside of the band, people started to really reel back on things.
It's not like people don't have reason to be upset either, from Morrissey's pompous stance on snobby music taste or trying to stand up for people that really shouldn't be given the time of day. Most of the goodwill towards the Smiths tends to get redirected towards Johnny Marr these days, but there's a lot more going on with this pompous man outside of his holier than thou reputation. Going through his lyrics, Morrissey looked after his words almost like pieces of poetry by themselves, calling to mind different people like Keats when he describes something as simple as going out with your girlfriend on There is a Light That Never Goes Out.
The whole thing might seem a bit adolescent when you look at the lyrics on paper, but when paired with Johnny Marr's guitar playing, suddenly all of the dreams that are talked about in these lyrics actually feel possible, if only for a second. Rock and roll may have been his trade, but Morrissey is one of the few rockers who seems as indebted to Shakespeare as he is to Iggy Pop.
2. John Mayer
The age of the guitar hero is dead...and John Mayer is the one that killed it. Even though he seemed like a perfectly nice dude coming out in the early '00s with his pretty pop songs, the entire aura behind him was more in line with the insufferable frat gig that you would meet at a party and want to be as far away from as possible. Underneath all those layers of AXE body spray though, you're actually looking at one of the greatest guitarists living today.
Although songs like Your Body is a Wonderland may be John's calling card, his original inspiration was always in the blues, taking the basis of guys like Stevie Ray Vaughan and Jimi Hendrix and making something of his own, almost like he's trying to speak through his guitar on songs like Gravity and Slow Dancing in a Burning Room. For a man that seemed to be a media magnet at the time though, John also did the sensible thing for any musician and took time out, logging off of the rock star circus and making the songs that he wants to, like the rootsy rock that you'd find on an album like Born and Raised.
That's not to say that John has mellowed with age either, going out on the road with the surviving members of the Grateful Dead and becoming more of a blues troubadour in his older age. It might seem impossible to take a guy who writes lyrics like 'bubblegum tongue' seriously, but it takes a special breed of guitar player to play a song like Bold as Love and actually pull it off effectively.
1. Axl Rose - Guns N Roses
When Appetite for Destruction was first unleashed upon the world, it looked Axl Rose was right in the middle of the next rock and roll revolution. In between playing shows as part of the World's Most Dangerous Band, his wild reputation felt like the next logical step coming out of an era of bands that were more about their looks than the actual music. Something funny happened when making their next record though, and Axl Rose quickly went from the street rat frontman to the diva no one wanted to talk about.
Just looking at the accompanying tour for Use Your Illusion, Axl was known as one of the more insufferable people in the music industry, either cancelling shows because he had a sore throat or just not bothering to show up at all. His reputation as a diva also didn't help when the next Guns album had to wait over a decade to actually see a release. Antics aside though, any other singer would not be able to do justice to the kind of swagger Guns had, with Axl putting some real attitude back into rock and roll, channeling the cool factor from someone like Mick Jagger or Steven Tyler on songs like Welcome to the Jungle.
Even outside of Guns N Roses, Axl's turn as the lead singer of AC/DC was shockingly well done, doing justice to both the Bon Scott and Brian Johnson era while also unearthing some deep cuts that hardcore fans thought would never see the stage. Axl might not be the most reliable frontman and might not even be the most pleasant person to be around half the time, but when he's at his A game, you may be in for one of the greatest rock and roll experiences of anyone's lifetime.