10 Rock Songs With Horrible Backstories

Making beauty of darkness.

nirvana MTV unplugged polly backstory
MTV

Rock and roll was never meant to be the most lighthearted of genres.

Since this was the kind of music that was supposed to be the antithesis of the wholesome music of the 1940s, you can imagine the shock that most people had when seeing people like Little Richard scream into the microphone for the first time.

Still, that doesn't mean that rock and roll wasn't afraid to get pitch black in its presentation.

For as much as these songs might stick in your head time and time again, there's a lot more shady stuff going on in the background. Whether it be from how they got the lyrical inspiration or the way that the parts were recorded, a lot of pain had to happen before songs like these could have been recorded properly. And it gets even creepier when they go on to become the biggest songs that the band ever has.

Yeah, for a handful of these tracks, they aren't just a strange tangent for the group...they're the calling card of their entire career. So now you have legions of fans singing along to songs that are so messed up that reading the lyrics aloud on the street will get you some strange looks.

Then again, it takes the true artists to make something with an ugly story and turn it into something beautiful.

10. To Live Is To Die - Metallica

Of all of the phenomenal metal albums that Metallica released in the '80s, And Justice For All seems to be a bit of a black sheep. Outside of the memes being made about how you can't hear the bass, there seems to be something missing from the traditional thrash sound that the metal gods were known for. And that missing puzzle piece's name was Cliff Burton.

After going on tour to promote their previous album, Cliff was tragically killed in a bus accident on their way to the next show. Still stricken with grief by the time they went on to record the next album, most of the hazing fell on replacement Jason Newsted, which turned a bit ugly when they decided to turn his bass down in the mix. When the smoke cleared though, To Live Is To Die is still one of the most heartbreaking things you will ever hear.

Inspired by their memories of Cliff, this entire instrumental plays out like the band members trying to cope with playing music after the loss of their friend, especially with the mid section where James Hetfield recites a poem that Cliff had written shortly before his death. Even though metal is known to be a mean genre, this is the closest thing you'll get to hearing people deal with the stages of grief in real time.


9. Paranoid Android - Radiohead

Let's get one thing out of the way here...Radiohead was never known to be the most happy go lucky band in the first place. Throughout most of the Bends, half of the appeal of the songs was how you found a musical friend in Thom Yorke to be down and depressed with. When they decided to ascend to the level of rock gods on OK Computer though, that kind of sadness became pretty alarming.

Before even starting on the idea for Paranoid Android, Yorke first thought of the lyrics after witnessing a fight at a bar when he was in the States. Deciding to get some air, he went into a bar to find these people acting uncivilized, which he likened to them seeming almost inhuman. Once he hit upon the idea for the song though, it almost takes you on that kind of dark journey through a wild night in LA.

For instance, when you realize that one of the people at the bar was some screaming hanger on who demanded to be heard, the phrase "screaming Gucci little piggy" starts to make a lot more sense. This isn't just some account about how everyone in LA is a bit unhinged though. This is what happens when you put someone into the City of Angels and watch them slowly lose their mind.


8. Today - Smashing Pumpkins

By the time that the mid 90s came around, the alternative rock scene seemed to be hitting a sort of slump. Even though it was one of the biggest genres of all time at that point, it was becoming apparent that many of us weren't sure what this music was "alternative" to anymore. When you look at the lyrics to the Smashing Pumpkins material, Today isn't something that you hear every day on the radio.

Looking to create a bright and sunshine-y song, Billy Corgan originally had the idea for this song after listening to '60s bands like the Lovin Spoonful at home. If you listen to what he's actually saying though, it's probably for the best that the music in the song is actually cheery. Yeah, what ties this whole song together is suicide, with Billy talking about wanting to tear his heart out and wondering if he even has time to see tomorrow.

I repeat, this is a song that was supposed to be a singalong classic with lyrics that revolve around a man having an existential crisis. It's not like the song really has a clear conclusion either, given that the narrator keeps droning on about how today is the greatest. He might just be trying to be optimistic, but considering all that you've gone through today, was it really all that great?


7. Daddy - Korn

Most nu metal devotees would be shouting that half of this list could have been made of the JNCO jeans brand of metal music. When you look back on a lot of the stuff that made it to the top of the charts back in the day, Limp Bizkit and Staind seem to be more concerned about complaining about things that shouldn't really matter anymore. With Korn though, Daddy is painfully real and somewhat off putting if you're not ready for it.

Not even wanting it to be on the album, Jonathan Davis originally wrote this song in response to him getting molested as a child and his family not believing him. Out of all the songs on this list, this one just feels dirty from the moment you hear it, with Jonathan opening up about his problems and actually breaking down during the final take of the song.

Apparently the vibe in the room was so bad that the rest of the band eventually came into the vocal booth after Davis was finished the vocal take and gave him a group hug. And believe me, he probably needed it at that point. Because this wasn't just your standard angsty nu metal song. This was the sound of a man laying a piece of his soul onto the tape.


6. We Die Young - Alice in Chains

Most fans could have probably guessed a song by Alice in Chains would have appeared on here sooner or later. Since Layne Staley's tragic tale of drug addiction has been documented in the album Dirt, a handful of tracks from that record alone could have been contenders. If you thought that the darkness crept in on their second album, they kicked off their career in the same way on We Die Young.

Being the first song on their debut record Facelift, the sound of the record is enough to put you on edge, with Jerry Cantrell playing a riff that would have made Tony Iommi proud. When it came time to actually go through the lyrics, Cantrell was actually inspired by the real life horror stories going on with kids in the Seattle area. As he walked the streets of Seattle, he noticed that a lot of kids were carrying beepers, which were actually being used to deal drugs to underage junkies.

So We Die Young is about the very real problem of kids getting their hands on narcotics and fading away before they even knew what hit them. The video is actually pretty real too, showing the band as these kids being thrown down the river in plastic bags. For a group that always sang about their drug habits, this is one of the crunchiest anti drug songs that you will ever hear.


5. Jump - Van Halen

At the dawn of the '80s, Van Halen was the symbol of everything great about the Sunset Strip. After the bloat of the '70s came and went, the sounds of Eddie's guitar and David Lee Roth's stage charisma was the kind of irresistible energy that made Los Angeles feel like one big party. And once the keyboards kicked in for the album 1984, Roth decided to up the ante by going to the familiar topic of....suicide.

Yes, really. I mean, for all we knew, Jump could have easily just been a song about jumping, with a synth sound that seemed destined for workout playlists. When actually getting the lyrics together, Roth was working through different ideas when he saw a news story on television about a man at the top of the building threatening to kill himself, which is where Roth got the phrase "might as well jump."

So...is this song basically just a man promoting the idea of someone committing suicide or did Roth just try to put in some placeholder lyrics and forget to change them? You decide. Either way, this made for one of Van Halen's biggest hits, giving Eddie the ability to reach out for different sounds with the synths. And now we only have to wonder whether the guy Roth heard about was actually okay. The melody sounds like he should be fine, but it's pretty easy to assume the worst.


4. Mother - Pink Floyd

Imagine you're just a random music fan in the late '70s. You're in the record shop and you find a copy of Pink Floyd's the Wall sitting in the record shelves. This is the one that had the smooth groove of Another Brick in the Wall, right? Surely, the rest of the album should be awesome too. Afraid not, buddy. You're stuck with a song about Roger Waters' complicated relationship with his mother.

Though most of the Wall is a concept album based around a character named Pink, Waters has made it clear that pieces of the character were loosely inspired by his own life, with Mother being a prime example. After Pink's father is killed in the war, his mother starts to become transfixed with keeping him safe in whatever way she can, which can get more than a little bit uncomfortable at times.

While it starts off pretty tame with David Gilmour talking about a mother keeping her child safe and warm, things start to take a turn when you have this woman picking out girlfriends for her son and ensuring that all of his nightmares will come true. The key line is when you hear her say "mommy's gonna help you build a wall," basically helping Pink close himself off from reality at a young age. You might have the best intentions of your child in mind, honey, but this is the definition of being a helicopter parent.


3. Polly - Nirvana

There's no real reason to pay too much attention to half of Nirvana's lyrics.

Aside from not being able to hear what Kurt Cobain was actually saying during takes, one of the biggest bands of the '90s was more about the feeling that the music gave you rather than the words in between.

When Kurt actually stepped up to say something though, you start to remember just how dark the grunge scene could really be.

Instead of just making your simple song about being disillusioned, Polly is a real story about a torture scene that Kurt had read about in the local newspaper.

According to what he had read, a woman was kidnapped outside of a concert in the Seattle area and was tortured by a sexual predator, only managing to get away when she started to flirt with him and having him let his guard down.

Being equally disgusted and inspired, Kurt makes an odd choice in the lyrics and actually takes on the role of the torturer, sounding almost desensitized to the kind of heinous actions that he's doing. With no real drums and made up of just guitars and voice, this song gets about 10x more creepy once you know what it's about.

This is a man that is numb to all the pain that he's causing and just sees it as a habit at this point.


2. Detroit Rock City - KISS

Nothing that KISS ever did could ever be called subtle. Since these are guys that wear horrifying makeup every time they took to the stage, everything that they sang about regarding the rock and roll lifestyle had to be larger than life. Even if it meant detailing the death of one of their fans.

So before we get into this...a little bit of backstory. When KISS hooked up with producer Bob Ezrin to create Destroyer, Ezrin suggested expanding their songwriting style to something other than sex, drugs, and rock and roll. Instead of just writing the typical anthemic song he was known for, Paul Stanley penned Detroit Rock City as the real life account of a fan who died in the process of getting to a rock concert. Opening with the sound of keys and the slamming of a car door, the entire song plays out like a movie in your head, as this man speeds down the highway to see his favorite band play.

Being drunk off his ass and swerving in and out of lanes, the entire song climaxes with our protagonist slamming into a truck head on and being thrown from the car. If you were just listening to the song on its own though, you would have thought this was a celebration of the care free lifestyle that comes with rock and roll. Once you hear the tires skidding, you really sober up and see what a life in rock and roll can really do to you.


1. Nebraska - Bruce Springsteen

Bruce Springsteen had been run ragged for the back half of the '70s before eventually making Nebraska. After Darkness on the Edge of Town showed us the burnt out Springsteen that came after Born to Run blew up, this was the kind of intimate Springsteen that only seemed reserved for him when he was fleshing out songs on his own. When you get to the title track, there's a level of darkness that not even the E Street Band could have helped with.

Instead of the usual slice of life songs that we were used to from the Boss, this is the real life story of Charles Starkweather, who became famous for going on a killing spree in the late '50s, eventually leading to the deaths of 11 people. This is the kind of thing that you'd normally see on crime dramas late at night, but Springsteen makes the strange choice of actually sympathizing with the cold blooded murderer.

Framing the song in his shoes, there's a personal touch to these lyrics, as if you're just watching the story of a boy with his life ahead of him make that one fatal decision that sentenced him to death in the electric chair. The only reasoning that the Boss gives for Starkweather's actions was the meanness that exists in the world. 40 years on, I don't think even Springsteen realized how right he was.


In this post: 
nirvana
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97