10 Rock Stars That Completely Changed Their Genre
Starting Again From Scratch.
For a lot of musicians, the idea of genre labels seems fairly limiting. As much as a word like rock might suit your music very well, it can also get pretty confining when you're expected to write the same style of song from one album to the next. You tend to feel a bit restless, and these artists were more than willing to buck their own trends.
Risking career suicide in the process, these albums marked a sea change for the bands that made them, either being a completely different shift into a new sound or trying out a new experiment that they weren't even sure would work. Oftentimes, these kind of things fall on their face and get laughed at when end of the year lists come around, and yet these turned into the weird second wind that these artists needed.
As much as this was a new look for each of these bands, they still look amazing doing these different stripes of genres as well, proving that there was a lot more at work than just the gimmicks that made them popular in the first place. Then again, sometimes you need a shakeup to prove to yourself that you're more than just a flash in the pan.
10. The Nightwatchman
If you looked at a gig done by someone called the Nightwatchman, you're probably not expecting something like Cannibal Corpse or anything. When you have a band name like that, people normally expect that kind of tried and true folksy sound that becomes popular in the odd coffeehouse every now and again. That's pretty much what we have on our hands...except it's one of the greatest guitarists of the modern age.
Aside from his stints in Rage Against the Machine and Audioslave, the Nightwatchman is a folksy side project for Tom Morello, which ends up going over a lot smoother than you'd probably expect. Though the mind bending tone effects of something like Rage is virtually rendered obsolete with an acoustic guitar, the pointed lyrical subject matter hasn't changed all that much, with Morello having as much venom for injustice as he did in the early days.
Even his delivery seems to be less like a proper singer and more like an activist, as if these songs are meant to be chanted by millions of fans during a political rally of some sort. It actually makes a lot more sense than you realize. Long before we even had stuff like hard rock, artists like Woody Guthrie were using their acoustics to speak out, so why not have the new generation throw their hat into the ring?
9. The Fireman
When you achieve a fame level as big as Paul McCartney, you can't really afford to do anything by yourself anymore. Even when you so much as blow your nose, you can bet your ass that someone will be there to document the proceedings to make sure you're okay or if the transaction is available on Spotify. The name does mean a lot, so how about you start from ground zero with a completely new one?
As much as Macca could have just coaxed by on goodwill off of the strength of his solo career, the Fireman is a bold new direction for him. Though we've seen the Cute Beatle tackle everything from indie to folk to even old time jazz and ragtime, this is a decisively electronic sounding project, which leans further into the styles of house music than anything else.
You don't skimp out on the McCartney charm though, as a lot of these songs sound like what the psychedelic '60s would have sounded like if it were birthed in the era of the rave rather than Woodstock. It's not like Paul isn't proud of these projects either, even going so far as to include the odd song in one of his solo setlists. Even though Paul can comfortably sit out the rest of his career if he wants to, it's records like this that shows he still has something to say.
8. Beastie Boys
The idea of the Beastie Boys even talking about anything outside of macking on girls and partying felt a bit silly during the mid '80s. After all, since most of their songs amounted to the kind of stuff you would hear blasting out of a college dormitory, the formula already worked pretty well to begin with. Aside from the 808s though, The Beasties plugged in their instruments and gave us a trippy as hell experience on Paul's Boutique.
Outside of the outrageous amount of samples going on, their sophomore effort was a lot more mature than anyone thought was possible, having been informed by everything from old school hip hop to hardcore punk to the world of jazz. If you had even thought of playing this to the same guy who got down on something like No Sleep Till Brooklyn, chances are his head might explode.
Despite not really going over that well with their core fanbase, Paul's Boutique turned into one of the greatest slowburns of the entire '80s, going on to become one of the foundational pieces of sample based hip hop going forward. This was just the starting point though, as stuff like Check Your Head and Ill Communication showed even more growth. Not bad a couple of kids who just decided to screw around and make some hip hop on the streets of New York.
7. U2
At the start of the '90s, a band like U2 should have been dead on arrival. After making one of the most pompous rock documentaries ever pressed to cinema with Rattle and Hum, the idea of these guys settling into their groove in the era of grunge felt like it should have been one of the greatest faceplants of the modern age. And then these cheeky Irish lads come through with one of their best records in Achtung Baby.
Moving to Berlin to seek inspiration, a lot of the sounds on this record feel almost eerily precise, almost to the point where Bono and the Edge feel sterile from one track to the next. As much as this kind of thing should feel off putting, the execution is nearly flawless, as Bono plays up his more lavish sensibilities to become the walking caricature of what a rock star is supposed to be.
Aside from the gimmick, the lyrics are also fairly compelling, with Bono reflecting about how humans are not willing to connect with each other anymore, replacing the earnest emotion for just blase acceptance of love. Although someone like U2 don't have any right playing the ironic card in this day and age, Achtung Baby found a way for the world's biggest band to roll with the punches as the alternative nation rolled in.
6. Ween
Trying to pin down a Ween album down to just one genre is almost foolish on the part of the listener. Throughout every single album of original material, both Gene and Dean Ween seem to use their studio as a blank canvas, to which they spew every single thing they can onto it Jackson Pollack style. Though you can definitely expect some off the wall stuff, no one was really asking for the sweet sounds of old country music.
Despite the hilarity of the fact that there's actually 10 songs on here, 12 Golden Country Greats is one of the most genuinely enjoyable records in Ween's catalog, if only for how weird it is that it even existed. Across songs like I Don't Want to Leave You on the Farm, you can practically hear the tractor in the background of the farming montage that this track will eventually accompany.
It doesn't forget the weird enthusiast though, considering that some of these sons titles like Piss Up a Rope are still some of the zaniest song titles that would have made Frank Zappa proud. Although Ween is probably the last band that you would go to if you were looking to mellow out, this record certainly gets the job done in terms of some soothing country ballads.
5. Tegan and Sara
Ever since the era of So Jealous, Tegan and Sara were always gradually sliding into poppier territory with every record. Though the Con proved to be a return to their indie rock roots, the tides were definitely turning when we got the first few singles for what would become Heartthrob. Once we had the record in front of us, the Quinn Twins had decided to serve up some of the sweetest ear candy of their career.
Unlike other acts that just fumble the ball trying to make a pop record, both Tegan and Sara's chops at crafting vocal melodies and fleshing out arrangements prove that they know what it takes to sit down and make a meaningful melody. Aside from the general construction of the music, the edge of the rock sound that fans were used to hadn't really gone anywhere...just touched up a little bit for maximum impact.
With the help of big name producers like Greg Kurstin and Green Day producer Rob Cavallo, songs like Love They Say and Goodbye Goodbye have the same type of melodic framework you would find in today's pop scene, only amped up that much more to hit you like a punch in the face rather than just hang around in the background. Even though this could have easily gone the route of pop trash, the Quinn Twins have managed to transition into new territory without even batting an eye.
4. Ritchie Blackmore
It's almost impossible to capture an audience's attention without having some sort of gimmick to your sound. Unless you're a band like the Beatles where you can just rely on the best melodies on Earth, there needs to be something else that hooks you into a certain band's style beyond just a catchy tune. Though Deep Purple had their style down in spades with their outlandish live shows and eclectic influences, Ritchie Blackmore may have been a bit too eclectic for his own good.
Across his stints in Purple and Rainbow, Blackmore was always experimenting with different styles, going from classical runs to down and dirty blues licks within the span of a single song. Once Rainbow started to take off though, you could hear bits and pieces of medieval influences seeping in through the cracks. So when Rainbow broke up, Ritchie did the most logical thing and....put his guitar down.
In the years since the dissolution of Rainbow and a one-off Purple reunion, Blackmore has been at work working with Blackmore's Night, with influences that are taken more from the 16th century than Eric Clapton. Compared to the hard rock crowd, this is the kind of stuff that you would hear in the days of jousting and jesters than a packed arena of adoring fans. Then again, if you need something to be the soundtrack to your next D&D session, you can certainly do a lot worse than this.
3. Billy Joel
Most rock stars these days don't really come in the form of Billy Joel anymore. Then again, Joel was already a bit of an oddity when he started out anyway, being the more rustic and workhorse piano player this side of Elton John. Though Joel has always been a bit of an Everyman in rock music, there was a time when he wanted to be the ruler of all known planets.
Or that's what you would probably think if you had heard Attila for the first time. Contrary to the overly edgy band that populates the metal scene these days, Attila was the name of the first major record that the Piano Man played on, framing it as a hard rock version of prog music, complete with a cheesy as hell organ accompaniment. Then again, it's no wonder why something like this didn't last, considering what we know of Billy Joel.
Just from the press photos alone, these guys were soooo not cut out to give acts like Yes a run for their money, instead looking like the kind of guys you would find at a particularly bad open mic night on the more grimy side of New Jersey. While Billy may have found his calling in music, thank the musical gods that we didn't have to live in a world where he was competing with the likes of Genesis .
2. Bob Dylan
For the longest time, it looked like Bob Dylan was going to be the next version of the wayward folkie. Much like his heroes Woody Guthrie and Pete Seeger, Dylan made his bread and butter with just a harmonica and a guitar, spitting lyrics that were a lot more weighty than the traditional pop schlock coming down the pipeline. Once he decided to jump into the rock world though, people started to get a bit skeptical.
After a few flirtations with a rock flavored sound on Bringing it All Back Home, Dylan shocked the entire folk world when he showed up to a major festival brandishing an electric guitar, going so far as to have one of his fans call him Judas from the stage for his betrayal of the folk ethos. This wasn't a betrayal at all. If anything, it was doubling down on the rebellious attitude.
Across Highway 61 Revisited, Dylan stakes his claim as doing rock and roll better than any of his contemporaries, as he incorporated songs that were as hectic and chaotic as they were poignant, from the beauty of Like a Rolling Stone to the troubled protagonist at the center of Ballad of a Thin Man. It didn't even feel like Dylan wanted to make the journey to rock...the rock world just happened to come to him.
1. Flea
Any mention of Flea tends to bring up the sounds of some of the funkiest breakdowns on Earth. I mean, is there any picture on the Internet or otherwise than doesn't feature Flea losing his mind assaulting his four string, usually without a shirt on in the middle of the stage? As much as his schtick is synonymous with the Red Hot Chili Peppers, Flea probably has one of the most eclectic resumes out of anyone in the rock world.
Before the Chili Peppers were even set in stone, Flea was already turning in time as the temporary fill in bassist for Jane's Addiction back in the day. While that actually isn't a stretch from the Peppers, that wasn't even the beginning, with Flea even being a potential bass player for the hardcore punk act FEAR before deciding to commit to the Peppers full time.
Aside from his stints in other acts, Flea has actually built up an impressive rap sheet as a session musician, delivering the iconic bass performance on Alanis Morrissette's You Oughta Know, playing on the backing track of Young MC's Bust a Move, and even backing the Man in Black when Johnny Cash made his first American Recordings. Even up until the past few years, Flea has shown up on different projects for the Mars Volta and Thom Yorke's Atoms for Peace to name just a few of his records. No matter what kind of genre-fied box you want to put him in, it's safe to say that Flea just considers himself a fan of music first and foremost.