10 Scariest Albums Ever Made

Music's demented entries.

Marilyn manson
Nothing Records

Music is supposed to make you feel good. Every time you turn on your favorite tunes, you're typically looking to get pumped up and take on the world through the notes coming out of the speakers. However, there are just as many artists looking to thrill you in a different way.

Every so often, artists come out with albums that are filled to the brim with dread. Whether it be because of an intense backstory or a horrific concept, these albums have struck just as much fear into the hearts of listeners as they have excitement in others.

But how do you necessarily make a track sound evil? The answer lies less in what you play and more in how you play it. Whereas a song itself could sound fine on the surface, it becomes a completely different world once you get the right singer to add their demented spin on it. Even if the song itself sounds fine on its own, the actual performance of the instruments may be so chaotic that it ends up sounding horrifying on replay.

However, the best of times is when an artist can find the perfect unholy marriage between instruments and lyrics to make for a chilling experience. These are the albums that will send you into Hell and back up throughout their runtimes. They may be amazing, but try not to listen to them after dark.

10. Closer - Joy Division

Once the allure of punk faded away, Joy Division were one of the first bands to announce the post punk movement.

With droning bass lines and disturbing lyrics from Ian Curtis, the band's songs always had a much darker agenda going for them. On the other hand, the scariest parts of this band's discography is when that pain became shockingly real.

For as ominous and bleak as something like Unknown Pleasures is, Closer ends up sounding much more disturbed given the events that occurred directly after its release. Recorded when Curtis was going through severe struggles with mental health, the album doesn't pull any punches when depicting his frail state of mind.

However, things were dialed up a notch when Curtis was found dead by suicide shortly after the album was due for release, bringing any plans for Joy Division to a halt.

Seeing how this is the band's unintended swan song, the lyrics read as much more freaky within that context. From start to finish, every song feels like Curtis crying out for help, looking for some sort of mental closure that he never ended up getting. Joy Division certainly have their more unsettling moments, but this is the one time their music became too dark for even punks to bare.


9. Walk Among Us - The Misfits

Post punk may have been the more off-putting genre, but that didn't mean that punk couldn't get scary as well.

After the first wave of punk swept culture with the Ramones and the Clash, bands were popping up left and right trying to take the sound one step further. It's one thing to speed up the tempo, but the Misfits traded in songs about being bored for something much more sinister.

At just under a half hour, Walk Among Us is ground zero for everything that is horror punk, with songs that are packed to the brim with dread. Clad in face paint and over the top styles, these guys had more horrific imagery in their lyrics and presentation than a band like KISS could ever muster, whether it's on the space ride from Hell on "Teenagers From Mars" or the live stomper version of "Mommy Can I Go Out and Kill Tonight?."

The lyrics are already powerful on their own, but Glenn Danzig is the one who really takes these tunes over the top, living up to his moniker as the demonic punk version of Elvis Presley. This album might go by in a flash, but what it actually has to say will chill you to the bone.


8. Welcome to My Nightmare - Alice Cooper

Alice Cooper will forever be known as the original shock rocker. While acts like Arthur Brown and Screaming Jay Hawkins may have used macabre theatrics in their shows, Cooper was the first one to take the more outlandish sides of rock and roll and put it on top of the charts.

Even when his backing band abandoned him, Welcome to My Nightmare became one of the most high profile shock rock albums of the golden age of rock and roll.

Throughout the album, there's a certain emphasis on theatricality, almost as if you're listening to a macabre version of a Broadway show. There are some cheesy moments for sure, but Cooper packs this album with some genuinely off-putting material, from the eerie piano notes of "Stephen" to the monologue at the end of "Devil's Food" done by horror icon Vincent Price.

While some songs may be downtempo, Cooper finds a way to put a more demented spin on those, with "Cold Ethyl" being an ode to necrophilia and "Only Women Bleed" talking about the real life horrors of spousal abuse.

This album might be a more palatable version of Cooper than others, but that doesn't mean that the initial shock value of his music has gone anywhere.


7. Iowa - Slipknot

After emerging on the scene in the late '90s, the members of Slipknot now had a mountain to climb. With their first record, the band had made a sprawling assault of metal, as songs divulged into the creepiest parts of the genre without breaking a sweat. Given the band's twisted behavior, their sophomore effort wasn't going to be tame, but no one could have expected something like Iowa.

Looking to move past the sound of their first record, the band hooked up with producer Ross Robinson again to dial in the more aggressive side of their sound.

Approaching every single track differently, the band were determined to amplify every scary moment on the record for maximum impact, which paid off in spades. Though many parents would be outraged to hear this kind of music, Iowa found its way up the Billboard album charts, with the Maggots growing hungry for more each day.

Even with almost two decades under its belt, Iowa has been hard for any metal act to beat, with songs like "Left Behind" and "The Heretic Anthem" being the most tortured tracks the band has ever made. The making of this album definitely took its toll on the band, but given what they have to show for it, it's almost worth it.


6. Dirt - Alice in Chains

The grunge scene wasn't necessarily known for being scary. While bands like Nirvana and Pearl Jam were known to dip their toes into more serious subject matter from time to time, the impact always felt more jarring than anything outright scary. However, Alice in Chains emerged from the shadows with one of the most unsettling meditations on drug addiction.

Written while the band were battling their struggles with narcotics, the material on Dirt was a way for them to exorcize their demons from themselves. Though there might not be anything inherently scary on something like "Would?," it ends up looking a lot more serious when you take into account the state of the band at this point.

Whereas some songs like "Dam That River" could be a standard hard rock tune, something like "Angry Chair" gives off the feeling of crawling through mud in the bowels of Hell, with no hope for survival.

Even the songs that aren't about drug use like "Rooster" are absolutely haunting in their presentation, with each guitar stab sounding like it's willingly dragging you into the inferno below. Dirt ended up being the band's creative peak, but it wasn't enough to save some of them from their demons, with Layne Staley succumbing to heroin addiction in 2002.

Alice in Chains might not have aimed to be the darkest metal band in the world, but the real stories behind these songs took them from amazing to genuinely terrifying.


5. There Existed An Addiction to Blood - Clipping

It takes a certain musician to make something that will horrify an audience. In the realm of the music, you can only rely on sound to get your point across, whether it's the lyrical style you choose or the creepy instrumentals you put behind the singer. You might expect something like this to come out of the metal world, but this album came from the scariest mind of all...that guy who played Thomas Jefferson in Hamilton.

Stepping away from his stage role, Daveed Diggs has built up quite a resume as the leader of rap collective Clipping, with some great albums like Splendor and Misery under his belt. On the other hand, There Existed An Addiction to Blood is a different animal entirely, with songs that depict both real and fictional horrors from one track to the next.

Across every song, Diggs is your dark narrator, as he sets up little horrific scenarios in every song from the frantic pace of "Nothing is Safe" to the horrors of man on "Blood of the Fang."

Even the interludes on this album are absolutely bone-chilling, with one of them containing nothing more than someone's account of a ghostly presence haunting their house. After only a year, There Existed An Addiction to Blood is still one of the most unsettling releases and recent memory, and with Clipping set to release another album this Halloween season, we might be in for another unsettling listen in the next few days.


4. Black Sabbath - Black Sabbath

At the end of the '60s, horror didn't really have a voice in the world of rock. Sure, there were definitely some controversial songs coming out of the psychedelic movement like "The End" by the Doors, but most of the late '60s were still under the guise of flower power. On the other side of the Atlantic, four working class kids from Birmingham made a record that put a stake through the heart of the hippie dream.

Coming right as the '70s got underway, Black Sabbath's debut release is the first sounds of heavy metal, with Tony Iommi coming into his own as a masterful guitarist. Whereas the other members were still mining the typical bluesy sounds of the day, Iommi's riffs were the encapsulation of torture, with the title track still being one of the scariest tracks in metal history.

Aside from the music, the album also contains some of the most off-putting lyrics in hard rock, from the title track's recounting of a paranormal encounter to the demonic love story that comes through on "NIB." Sealing the deal in the middle of it is Ozzy Osbourne, whose bluesy belts sound like a madman ready to snap at every turn.

No genre is birthed in a vacuum, but if you could trace back heavy metal music to its dark origins, Black Sabbath's debut is what truly started it all.


3. Caligula - Lingua Ignota

It's tough pinning down what exactly makes a track scary. From one band to the next, artists may have to use lyrics or demented instrumentation to put a dark twist on their usual formula. Some people may have to switch up their formula from time to time, but Caligula is an album that is pitch black from the minute you start listening.

From start to finish, this album feels less like a musical piece and more like a cathartic experience for Lingua Ignota. Looking to move past the horrific experiences she had in the past, this album delves into the horrors of mental abuse, physical abuse, and everything else that comes with being in a toxic relationship. Regardless of which track you find yourself in, the music is basically a hodge podge of every intense genre you can think of, from the dark sides of classical music to noise rock to even black metal in some of Ignota's screams.

Whereas some bands tend to play up the more spooky elements of their sound, this album isn't pulling any punches and feels more like a diary from a tortured mind as they try to make their way out of the Hell they've been surrounded by. This album is definitely a trip, but if you're just starting out with heavy music, proceed with caution.


2. Antichrist Superstar - Marilyn Manson

At the midpoint of the '90s, there weren't nearly as many shock rockers to go around. After grunge stripped everything back down to its essentials and then got morbid with the death of Kurt Cobain, things were trying to go back to sunshine and lollipops whenever it could. Those bands certainly had their place, but all that darkness was just laying the groundwork for rock's first true Antichrist.

Coming from the industrial metal world, Marilyn Manson looked to be the next iteration of Alice Cooper, but his second release Antichrist Superstar blew his predecessor out of the water. As opposed to coating your standard metal tune in dread, these were demented compositions centered around a demon's journey from a worm to one of the most powerful evil beings the world had ever seen.

While there is a narrative concept to the entire record, each song stands on its own as something truly frightening, whether it be the takedown of celebrity culture on "The Beautiful People" to our protagonist laying siege on the land on the title track. Marilyn Manson may have been something different for the metal scene, but after this one record, he had found his calling as one of the most deranged figures ever to grace a stage.


1. The Downward Spiral - Nine Inch Nails

Now come on, what could more synonymous with horror than Marilyn Manson? The man had put himself through body contortions, miles of offensive material, and become a full-blown dictator in the minds of his fans. Manson may have had the high ground, but the real darkness came from the man who showed Manson the ropes.

Coming from the industrial world, Trent Reznor blossomed from an incredible producer to an artist in his own right with Nine Inch Nails. Pretty Hate Machine may have set him up nicely, but The Downward Spiral lived up to its title by throwing its listener into the underworld.

Running as a concept album, the songs follow the story of a man named Mr. Self Destruct, who is one of the most evil characters you'll ever come across. With songs spanning sexual encounters, self-harm, and the meaninglessness of life, our protagonist is actively trying to nullify the world that he's living in.

Even as the album comes to a close, our protagonist finds himself riding that spiral to the end, when listeners are greeted to nothing but the blunt force of noise. The Downward Spiral might not be the most pleasant listen from one track to the next, but in terms of capturing a disturbing message, you can't really do much better than this.


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97