10 Songs That Got To Number One By Two Different Artists

Songs That Keep on Giving.

Christina Moulin Rouge
Epic

Any artist worth their salt will want to write something that they would consider timeless. As much as some people are in it for the money, it helps to put some heart into your songs and try to come up with something that will last longer than you do. Hell, sometimes the charm works so well that your song actually gets a second life.

Ever since we've had the charts, people have been trying to notch up hits with cover songs time and time again. While starting off with a cover gives you a pretty good chance of destroying your career, these are those rare instances where the songs actually manage to get played in almost equal succession by radio stations. Then again, you can't just go around and try to play the same song over again.

Adding their own flair, most of these second versions tend to be either a different take on the song or a total reinvention altogether, with artists changing it so much that it's virtually unrecognizable. It might be fun to just kick back and do some karaoke of your favorite songs, but this is what happens when you give these songs to artists who really know what they're doing.

10. I Heard It Through The Grapevine - Gladys Knight And Marvin Gaye

In the early days of Motown, performers were basically recording different versions of every song they could get their hands on. As much as one person may have written the thing, there was no limit as to how many people could try to perform on it. Although people have exhausted songs like Please Mr. Postman time and time again, I Heard It Through the Grapevine is one of those rare instances where the smooth soul is worth hearing again.

For one thing, the gender roles are flipped. On Gladys Knight and The Pips original version, you can pretty much tell that this was the standard love and heartache song that the girl group scene thrived on. A couple of years down the line though, Marvin Gaye's version took the whole thing into the stratosphere, with a a murky sound that almost sounded swampy by comparison.

There is nothing dirty about Mr. Gaye's high vocals though, which are absolute perfection from the moment they start, taking all the pain and heartache of a jilted lover and making it sound almost seductive in its own weird way. Even though these are pretty much re-hashes of the exact same sound and style, there's no real expiration date on this kind of heartache.


9. Lady Marmalade - Labelle And Christina Aguilera

Usually anyone releasing a cover song during the height of their popularity is just doing it for fun. They could just throw out another great single cut, but you sometimes just want to cut loose with a song that you know kills from the first note you play. And it's not like the camp who put the Moulin Rouge soundtrack together didn't realize the gold they had on their hands here with Lady Marmalade.

Granted, most of the songs in Moulin Rouge involve taking something old and updating it for the modern culture. Given the showiness behind the movie though, resurrecting a classic soul song from the peak of the disco era was almost too perfect, with Christina Aguilera using her tremendous range to blow the original version out of the water.

While the LaBelle original still works as an amazing dance track, Aguilera's version may be more popular now than the original...and without changing the greatest parts of the song no less. As much as it could have sounded dated, the chant section of "Hey sister, go sister" is still in there, with Aguilera putting all the soul she can muster into the track to make sure it works for the retro aesthetic. For a song that was easily pushing 30 years at this point, it's almost impossible to make something sound this good after all these years.


8. You Really Got Me - The Kinks And Van Halen

Anyone ever slogging it out in a grimy garage with a band has probably heard You Really Got Me more than they wanted to. Given its dead simple arrangement by the Kinks, this is exactly the kind of song that works just as well booming out of a grimy stereo as it does in the middle of a sold out show. Since this was called the first hard rock song though, it was only natural for it to get boosted up just a little bit more.

In one of the ballsiest moves in rock history, Van Halen actually put this out as their first single in 1978. Despite the curse of your first single being a short cut to one hit wonder status, Eddie's trademark licks made everyone stand up and pay attention, trading in the wild freakout of the '60s classic for the classic double hand tapping technique that would become the benchmark for guitar gods going forward.

Aside from the raw musical arrangement, the charisma coming off of David Lee Roth was made for this kind of song, turning this song of infatuation into a borderline obsession with his lover. She's got him so he can't sleep, and we'd probably lose many more nights of sleep if it means hearing this song one more time.


7. Twist And Shout - Isley Brothers And The Beatles

Out of all the classics of the '60s, Twist and Shout feels like it's existed since the beginning of time. Given its dead simple arrangement and basic message about dancing the night away, how the hell is this not the first pop song ever written? Well, sometimes it just takes a few rock luminaries to remind us of how good a song like this can be.

Even though the Top Notes are originally responsible for this song, The Isley Brothers were the first to really capitalize on it, bringing the song to the top of the R&B Charts in the early '60s. But there were a few other rockers making some noise across the pond in Liverpool, making Twist and Shout a part of their setlist every night. By the time the Beatles actually got ahold of it, their version became one of the trademark songs of the British Invasion.

Taking the original's manic energy, you can hear John Lennon screaming his voice out towards the end of this song, almost like his vocal cords are about to fly out of his throat by the time the tape stops rolling. Even for all of the spotty moments on record, this is still one of the few innocent rock songs that has yet to wear out its welcome after half a century.


6. The Sound Of Silence - Simon And Garfunkel And Disturbed

Whenever you're looking for cover songs, you can rarely go wrong with folk tunes. Since all you have to go on is a voice and acoustic guitar most of the time, you can bend and shift the song into any form that you want when you decide to tackle it. Even when you want to go aggro as hell, Disturbed actually managed to make it work on the Sound of Silence.

For rock enthusiasts, nothing could possibly touch the original, with the radical social commentary from Paul Simon still striking a nerve all the way in 2021. David Draiman did have a good way of approaching this as a metal vocalist though, starting slow and brooding before building to one of the most glorious climaxes in recent memory. The beginning and ending of this track alone sounds like it's taken from two different songs, going from Draiman's croon to shouting in anger at the words of the prophets being written on subway walls.

It's not like Draiman didn't have practice before this, with covers of everyone from Genesis to U2 being a part of Disturbed's repertoire for a long time. They could have easily added their nu metal touch, but this is the result of knowing the genius you're working with and putting in the extra work to make something classic.


5. Smooth Criminal - Michael Jackson And Alien Ant Farm

Michael Jackson probably wasn't even looking for a song like Smooth Criminal to be a hit on the charts. Sure, it had a great groove and was even given the full music video treatment, but there was no way that a song about a violent stalker calling out for Annie was going to become one of his biggest songs to date. As it turns out though, the public does have a pretty decent tolerance for the darker side of pop music.

Aside from Jackson building off of the success of Bad, Smooth Criminal got a whole new resurrection when it was adopted by nu metal band Alien Ant Farm in the early '00s. Keep in mind, this was the '00s, where the last person that you wanted to be compared to in the music industry was Michael Jackson. Still, AAF's version is a damn good time regardless of how aggro it is, riding the same funky groove and putting it to a detuned electric guitar.

For as far away as these styles are from each other, this is the kind of song that could please both sides of the aisle. The MJ fans will like this song for the smooth funk, and the nu metal bros can appreciate the undeniable riff that runs throughout the track. Even though getting a song on the chart for a second time is a hard sell, it can always work when you have that one great idea.


4. Hallelujah - Leonard Cohen And Jeff Buckley

When you're talking about songs that will outlive us all, Leonard Cohen practically has a boatload of tracks to choose from. Looking at Hallelujah alone, this is the kind of song about lost love that wouldn't sound that out of place in an actual place of worship. But it wasn't until Cohen's drawl was replaced with Jeff Buckley's falsetto that we were woo'd all over again.

Although the words stand as pure poetry on their own, both versions have something great going for them. Take Cohen's for example, with his raspy voice that sounds like it's coming from a man who has finally accepted the heartache that he's tried to repress all these years. Without changing any of the words though, Buckley's version is the same type of heartache at the moment it starts, with Buckley practically sounding like he's on the verge of tears in the studio as he picks away at his guitar.

Hell, even the damn Shrek soundtrack has become somewhat of a cult hit in recent years, with kids getting introduced to this beautiful song as the breakup song between Shrek and Fiona towards the end of the film. When your song is so good that even the romantic ogre treatment can't kill its power, you've got something bulletproof on your hands.


3. Respect - Otis Redding And Aretha Franklin

If the song Respect had stayed an Otis Redding original for the rest of time, chances are no one would have known what it was. As much as it was a strong force to be reckoned with in the mid '60s, you could probably hear a thousand of soul men trying their hand at a song about not getting enough respect (read as: loving) from their ladies at night. In Redding's own words though, Respect never got the reputation it deserved until "that little girl stole it from me."

By just changing a few bits and pieces and adding her amazing gospel vocals, this is the song that really introduced Aretha Franklin to the world. Compared to the typical soft spoken vocals of someone like Diana Ross around the same time, Franklin was every bit the belter that her reputation would lead you to believe, almost as if she's scolding her man while she's singing.

Even people who had no idea what soul music even was could appreciate a song like this, becoming a staple of the women's rights movement and a standard for anyone who's ever felt like they were stepped on by their significant other. When you have this passion in your voice, is it the worst thing in the world to ask to hear it on blast? Maybe a little bit...just a little bit.


2. I Will Always Love You - Dolly Parton And Whitney Houston

There are probably a good portion of you who don't even realize that I Will Always Love You started life as a cover song. Long before we got the juggernaut that we know today, Dolly Parton's original is still as beautiful as ever, being a loving tribute to the one who helped get her to country superstardom. But this was a ballad that was just aching to be blown out of the damn water on The Bodyguard.

Aside from the actual movie's inclusion of Whitney Houston, her version of this country classic still stands as one of the greatest vocal performances of all time. Just the opening notes can send shivers down your spine, leading to a mammoth chorus that makes every hair on your body stand on end. Whereas Dolly's version is great for what it is, Houston's voice is a damn tidal wave of force, rocketing this song to the top of the charts all over again.

This song alone is the reason why The Bodyguard became one of the best selling soundtracks of all time. There are probably millions of people who own this album who haven't even seen the movie. When you have a cover song like this to tie it all together though, who really cares what the movie is about?


1. Knockin On Heaven's Door - Bob Dylan And Guns N Roses

No other artist has really had their songs picked apart by different artists more than Bob Dylan. While no artist can sing a song quite like its composer, it's practically become a rite of passage for rock bands to cover a Dylan song during their peak years. The Byrds did it in the '60s...Rise Against tried their hand at it in the '00s....but Guns N Roses were one of the few able to strike pure gold on Knockin On Heaven's Door.

It's almost strange that this was the one Dylan song to make it big, with the original being the standout hit from a random Western movie soundtrack about Billy the Kid. Though the original managed to hold onto relevancy throughout the '70s, the hair metal bombast of GNR's version is still one of the most enduring rock songs of the '80s.

Compared to the raw and rugged performance that Dylan himself gave for the movie soundtrack, the unhinged vocals of Axl Rose makes the chorus line sound like a desperate cry for survival, as Slash's guitar puts everything else over the top. While Dylan has always been a bit tightlipped about other people interpreting his song, the royalty checks coming from this song's second life couldn't have hurt his impression of it.


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97