10 Terrible Rock Bands With One Incredible Album

Pieces of Genius.

Nickleback Band
Atlantic

Not everyone who makes it to the top of the charts is necessarily going to be the next version of the Beatles. Sometimes it comes down to being in the right place at the right time, and some artists have reached the pinnacle of success and have become the laughing stock of the entire rock scene. That doesn't mean that they were always bad though.

Every musician has to have at least one good song in their arsenal, and these acts proved to have more than a bit of potential for a few albums. Instead of just being a fluke, these were the albums that gave us hope that these bands were more than just a bunch of kids who somehow managed to latch onto a gimmick. As time went on though, these definitely didn't pay off, with one album after the next either getting too boring to take seriously or too embarrassing to listen to for more than a few minutes.

In fact, the existence of these albums just manages to sting that much more when you see what these acts have done through the years. Since we know what you're capable of, why are you deciding to just continue on making the kind of mediocre music time and time again? Then again, they got it right once, and we'll happily take what we can get.

10. Yourself Or Someone Like You - Matchbox 20

It would be a stretch to call Matchbox 20 one of the worst bands in history. By the time they actually got around to reaching the top of the charts, their kind of adult alternative post-grunge was getting far too sanitized for anyone to really take seriously anymore. Once you see how bad the later bands like Lifehouse could get, you will have so much more respect for Yourself or Someone Like You.

That's because this album doesn't really seem to be going for your traditional post-grunge hangups. Instead of copying the kind of tried and true formulas of someone like Stone Temple Pilots, there's a lot more pop smarts behind a lot of these songs, especially when paired with the nice rasp of Rob Thomas. As much as they may have been played into the ground, songs like Push are going to be remembered just for how catchy they are.

This would prove to be a bit of first album syndrome though, with the next album showing Matchbox 20 really starting to run out of ideas and Rob Thomas later reaching the top of the charts either on his own or with Santana. Though this ended up being the high point of their career by a longshot, you'll still have the chorus to 3 AM stuck in your head until the day you die.


9. My Own Prison - Creed

There's a part of your writer that doesn't even want to call Creed a bad band. For all of the hang-ups that come with Scott Stapp's butt rock delivery, Mark Tremonti is a fantastic guitar player and Brian Marshall and Scott Phillips are certainly no slouches behind their instruments either. And on their first step up to the plate, it looked like we were about to see another rock titan start to walk the Earth.

Although we eventually got to see the more embarrassing side of this band on albums like Weathered, My Own Prison is a lot moodier than what would come later. The greatest strength of this album is it's the least... well... Stapp-sounding out of them all. As opposed to the emotional "powerhouse" vocals that would come later, Stapp either takes a backseat on some songs or has a much more growly register, which tends to suit him a lot better.

Also, if you were to put this into the realm of Christian rock, this is some of the top tier stuff that that genre may have ever produced, especially when going for the moodier cuts like What's This Life For or the title track. With this kind of songwriting in tow, no one could have imagined that the quality control was about to hit a massive brick wall on the next record.


8. Look What the Cat Dragged In - Poison

In the grand history of hair metal, Poison arrived at a bit of a strange time. Though the look of Bret Michaels circa 1989 has become synonymous with the sillier sides of the genre, their arrival in the mid '80s was the point where the poodle haired bands on Sunset weren't treated like a punchline just yet. Before people like Winger and Warrant became mainstream stars a few years later, Look What the Cat Dragged In was a lot more fun than people realized.

First of all, let's get one thing out of the way right off the bat: this is by no means a great metal album. Even with the growl of the title track, this is some of the tamest metal that would have legends like Black Sabbath laughing at it. As far as hard rock and power pop is concerned though, it's not too shabby at all, with Bret Michaels having a commanding presence and CC Deville's guitar having a lot more grit than you'd come to expect.

Sure, it's not necessarily on the level as Motley Crue or even Twisted Sister from around the same time, but it's not trying to be. Poison was always about the party atmosphere, and this is the kind of mindless energy that made the '80s so good to look back on. Above all else, it's fun, and who says that metalheads can't have some fun every now and again?


7. Fush Yo Mang - Smash Mouth

It's nearly impossible to look at a band like Smash Mouth and not at least laugh a little bit. Any good will that these guys had at being a credible rock band ended up getting buried in layers upon layers of Shrek memes a long time ago. Before the lovable ogre though, there was some definite chops to be found on Fush Yu Mang.

Ignoring the ill-advised album title, the tunes on here are a great time capsule of what we were up to in the late '90s. With nothing really to worry about and the sorry sounds of post grunge starting to go way out of style, this is the kind of sunshine-y rock that soundtracked a lot of our childhoods. That didn't mean that we had lost the irony either, with songs like Walking on the Sun having a bit more of a dark touch if you look at the lyrics.

Compared to the rest of the rock scene, there's also something a bit retro about Smash Mouth's presentation. Along with the beach party theme on some of these songs, the crunch of the guitars and the echo on everything makes it sound closer to something by The Doors than your usual joke band. Some bands might aim to become a punchline, but someone like Richard Cheese wishes he could make a groove this sticky.


6. Crazy Horses - The Osmonds

And this is the point in the list where most of the hardcore rock fans start to tune me out. How on the Earth is a group like The Osmonds considered to have anything worthwhile in them? Even though this is the kind of music that seems designed for the teenybopper crowd, a funny thing happens when you start to actually grow up.

Once the sounds of something like One Bad Apple started to wane, the more mature version of The Osmonds on Crazy Horses is a welcome change of pace. From the sounds of the first few songs, you would never guess that you were listening to a piece of '70s cheese, with the sounds of a prog rock-style organ and a guitar riff that's actually got a bit of teeth to it. Since this was also around the time where Donnie's voice was changing, letting the other brothers sing gives this album a lot more grit.

When they do go for the high notes though, it's not the kind of squeaky clean things that your mom loved to jam to back in the day. For a second, you'd swear that someone turned the dial and put on something like Deep Purple. And since this record has fans in people like Paul Gilbert and Joe Elliott from Def Leppard, it definitely deserves a little bit of hype in the rock conversation.


5. Night Visions - Imagine Dragons

Wasn't it a much better time before the alternative rock scene was anything else but Imagine Dragons? I mean, if you really think about it, Imagine Dragons have basically stripped all of their rock skin off in the past few years and traded it in for some of the most milquetoast pop beats into their sound. Which is a shame considering the first record actually showed some real promise.

Granted, that's not to say that Night Visions is a masterpiece from top to bottom. From the production alone, you can tell that this thing was made in the early 2010s, down to the processed beats on some songs. From a songwriting perspective though, there are a lot of gems on here, with Dan Reynolds actually showing some promise as a vocalist before shoving his voice into a synthesizer on songs like Believer later.

And without breaking anybody's hearts, the best songs on here tend to be the singles, especially the build that comes with a song like It's Time or Radioactive. For the past few years, Imagine Dragons have always been trying to push themselves to sound just a little bit bigger than they were before. If they'd have gone back to their very first try though, they already had the capacity to be something gigantic.


4. Cracked Rearview - Hootie and the Blowfish

Not every band that fills this list is the absolute worst of the worst. Because if there's one thing that music fans have argued about for years, it's the difference between being outright bad and just too boring to listen to. Though Hootie and the Blowfish's last few albums feel more like background music these days, they certainly hit the ground running on that first album.

And it would seem like a lot of people would agree, with Cracked Rearview being one of the best selling albums of the '90s, which is a decade that also includes the Bodyguard soundtrack and Nirvana's Nevermind. So why did this little bar band relate with so many people? Well, it turns out that their style fit perfectly in any kind of genre that you could think of. Outside of their bar band roots, their mix of Americana and rock managed to rope in every stripe of rock fan.

That's before you even get around to the fact that Darius Rucker can sing his ass off, especially when going for broke on the more emotional cuts on here like Let Her Cry. If life were a sitcom, this is what would happen if a band like Mouserat from Parks and Rec actually managed to hit it big. It's cheesy on pretty much all fronts, but this is the kind of music that many a dad will be able to rock out to later down the line.


3. Drops Of Jupiter - Train

Seeing Train's career trajectory has been one of the more interesting cases in the pop rock scene. Although they did manage to pull off a career comeback with Save Me San Francisco late in their career, it's about time that we realize some of the more cringy aspects that come with Pat Monahan's songwriting techniques. If you want the more bearable version of this, we gotta take it back to the real early days.

Fresh off of their independently released debut, Drops of Jupiter was the moment that made Train superstars in the eyes of the public. With the title track alone, fans got a perfect piece of soft rock that actually managed to have a bit of muscle behind it with the string arrangements. And that wasn't the only strength of this album either, going for a more rootsy approach and making decent songs like She's On Fire in between the hits.

Are the lyrics still the wrong kind of zany? Yes, but the way that Monahan puts everything together makes you forget about the more questionable lines. The main bridge off of the title track is absolutely atrocious, and yet the melody is so sticky that you probably won't even care when it comes by. Any band's first steps might be embarrassing, but this is the real potential before Pat descended into the abyss of writing about Hefty bags and ripping off Heart and Soul.


2. Songs About Jane - Maroon 5

Most of us have pretty much washed our hands with Maroon 5 a long time ago. Ever since the aptly named Overexposed, Adam Levine has pretty much done everything within his power to put his band at the top of the charts, which most of the time involves reaching the absolute bottom of the barrel for songwriting. It's gotten so bad now that if you take a listen to Songs About Jane, it feels like a completely different band.

Though technically the latest iteration of Maroon 5 has most of the key members in the background, this record is the definition of how to do pop rock correctly. As much as Levine might want us to forget this version of the band, their mix of different funk grooves and some of the stickiest melodies of the '00s made for some intriguing stuff, especially when starting things off with a heavy riff on Harder to Breathe.

This is a pop rock record though, and the focus is still on the POP part of that label, with songs like She Will Be Loved and Sunday Morning being the strongest songs on the record. If Adam Levine insists on making the latest version of Maroon 5 one of the most forgettable bands in the world, they at least have this little gem. It may be a guilty pleasure for rock fans, but there's no shame in putting some pop rock in your musical diet.


1. The State - Nickelback

If you've been reading this far, you've probably noticed that a lot of these records involve some of the first albums that a lot of these respective artists made. And you could probably assume that most of the reasons why these acts turned out bad was just because of labels wanting the bottom line and getting them to go in a more pop direction. Though the shift towards radio friendly stuff was Chad Kroeger's decision, it was a really missed opportunity considering what The State started with.

Yes, you heard that correctly. As much as Nickelback has come to be known as the punchline of the rock music scene, The State is one of the few albums that actually managed to show some real development from this band. Just listening through songs like Breathe, you can tell that these guys have some legitimate rock chops and have the potential to be something a lot bigger than just your average rock band.

And then Silver Side Up arrived and basically showed us that Nickelback were going to become legendary, just for all the wrong reasons. Then again, the fact that The State sounds so good is the real tragedy here. If Chad had decided to write something that was a little more genuine on the next album, we may have been spared the knock offs like Theory of a Deadman.


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97