10 Worst Album Covers In Rock

Rock's Greatest Eyesores.

Iron Maiden Dance of Death
EMI

A lot of extracurriculars tend to go into an album's development. Aside from the massive amounts of overdubbing, songwriting, and time spent in the studio, a lot of it does also end up coming down to what catches the listener's eye before listening to it. Then again, there's definitely a right and a wrong way to catch a person's eye.

Throughout the years, there have been some truly reprehensible album covers to come out of the rock genre. No matter what kind of idea they may have had to start with, somehow these awful pictures managed to make the cut. While it's excusable for most of the more underground artists to just work with what they have, these are actual big name artists who could easily paid a better artist to make something worthwhile for them. As it stands though, this was the product that we were left with...all the disgusting pictures that you could ask for.

Granted, an album itself can withstand any bad album cover. For as much as people might like to take shots at the cover, it usually holds up so long as the music kicks ass. However, regardless of quality or even the band in question, these acts should definitely know better than letting these pieces of trash go to print.

10. Rocka Rolla - Judas Priest

As metal started to get its feet, Judas Priest were the ones who really set everything in motion. Whereas other acts of the time like Black Sabbath pushed the boundaries for what heavy music could be, Priest unpacked everything and gave the music the fangs and screams that it really deserved. You'd say that now...but not if you took one look at their debut record.

On the surface, most of Rocka Rolla is already way off from the metal we would get used to, instead being a bit of bluesy hard rock with Rob Halford not dialed in just yet. Though the music is already pretty contentious for what it is, the cover itself is the main antithesis of what metal should be. Up until this point, metal album covers always had a sense of dread on Sabbath albums, and yet this feels like the most generic piece of merch that Priest ever put out, complete with a bottle cap that Coca Cola might want to have a chat about.

Then again, Priest would recover from this very nicely going forward, with both a lot more dour album covers on Sad Wings of Destiny as well as trading in their threads for the leather and spikes that we all know and love today. For as much as Priest can be a religion to some people, this isn't going to inspire some metallic devotion from anyone anytime soon.


9. Killing is My Business - Megadeth

On paper, making an album cover fit in with the music shouldn't be the hardest thing in the world. At the very minimum, most artists just have to sit with the music and make some sort of graphic that would be able to suit the material within the grooves. When you're just starting out though, a lot of stuff can be lost in translation.

Coming out of the Bay Area, Killing is My Business by Megadeth is a juggernaut of a thrash record, with Dave Mustaine proving that Metallica made a big mistake by kicking him to the curb a few years prior. This also includes the first appearance of the trademark mascot Vic Rattlehead...sort of. Instead of the robot like droid that we would familiarize ourselves with on Rust in Peace, this cover was thrown together after the initial budget presumably ran out for the album art.

Sticking to the original theme of a menacing skull, most of the mechanics of this thing look like they were thrown together for some middle school art project, complete with what looks like ketchup for blood and paper mache holding the rest of this mascot together. Even though it's not out of the question to have some trademark mascot, this iteration of Vic clearly had to go back to the drawing board more than a few times.


8. Reality - David Bowie

Of all the giants of the golden age of rock and roll, David Bowie may have been the most artistic of them all. Rather than just squeak by with a style of music that he knew worked, the Thin White Duke took pride in throwing caution to the wind, going down the musical rabbit hole on almost each subsequent album. Though his relevancy started to wane after the '90s, Reality announced that the Starman was back...with the exception of the cover.

Make no mistake, Reality is probably one of the greatest late-era Bowie albums there is, as he gets back in touch with some of the more glam-centric production tricks he helped pioneer back in the '70s. As far as the album cover goes though, this is probably the most ill-advised Bowie has ever looked, with a drawing that feels like it's trying to be some sort of cartoon character.

Though there's nothing wrong with the actual construction of the design per se, there was absolutely no one asking for Ziggy Stardust himself to actually have his own anime looking character. In retrospect, it's probably a good thing that people didn't bring up the cover. I mean, could you imagine having this guy take on a life of his own, with a show on Cartoon Network? Aside from the amazing music, this is not the kind of reality that anyone really wants to be a part of.


7. Just Push Play - Aerosmith

It's safe to say that after the '00s turned a corner, Aerosmith had really stopped trying. Once they had their first big hit with I Don't Want To Miss A Thing, the album Just Push Play is the sellout album to end all sellout albums, with each track being more poppy than the last. That's not a problem so long as it's good...but that album cover sure didn't start us off on the right foot.

Since Aerosmith had already been giants of the scene up to this point, most people would have bought this regardless of what kind of graphic they wanted to put on the cover. However, this robot figurine of Marilyn Monroe is one the truly cursed images of the early '00s. From the reason why she's a humanoid to why this album had any connotations to Marilyn Monroe, all this cover does is leave you with a lot more questions than outright answers.

At the same time, that might be the point. When it comes to the more manufactured side of Aerosmith's sound, most fans can't help but look on everything with profound amazement, as if to wonder how the hell things got so out of hand. In that case, it did it's job pretty well...just not the job that Aerosmith would have wanted it to.


6. Born Again - Black Sabbath

Black Sabbath's time in the early '80s was spent treading water most of the time. Though the inclusion of Ronnie James Dio worked really well across records like Mob Rules and Heaven and Hell, his departure signaled the start of a pretty rough ride for the founders of heavy metal. While the arrival of Deep Purple's Ian Gillan seemed promising, the same could not be said for Born Again.

Aside from the artwork, most of this album is just a decent hard rock record with terrible production, and yet the cover is about as bad as the record itself sounds. For as wrong as this cover seems on the surface, it's not like it doesn't make sense, with this baby demon of sorts being reborn to wreak havoc on the world once again. That is, if it didn't look like it was painted by an amateur.

Coming from the same band who had one of the most menacing debut album covers of all time, this feels way below their paygrade, as if they just coerced someone from the record label to throw something together in a few minutes. Compared to some of the other menacing titles coming from the likes of Iron Maiden at the time, this feels like the first draft of an album cover that could be good only to be put out unfinished instead.


5. Father of All... - Green Day

Any average rock act can really yuck it up by having a horrendous album cover. No matter what the music is like inside, sometimes the artwork itself might be a little weird for most to take in all at once. However, there's a difference between making a bad cover and actually cheapening your own legacy.

With the little bit of hindsight that we have surrounding Green Day's Father of All..., the whole record just feels like it was released kicking and screaming in an attempt to get the pop punk brats out of their record contract. At the same time, what the hell have you done to the amazing cover art from American Idiot? Make no mistake, this is just a raw reimagining of what they originally used for American Idiot. Whereas the original version had a barebones structure that cut right to the point, this is inexcusable, with a unicorn drawn by Billie Joe Armstrong himself throwing up to censor the word "Motherf*ckers" on the sleeve.

While the core foundations of punk are about how nothing is really set in stone, you really didn't have to go ahead and do this to one of your most critically acclaimed records. As it stands, this isn't just a bad album cover. This is the face of a great album cover that has been defiled for no good reason.


4. Metal Magic - Pantera

Most people familiar with heavy music don't really need any introduction when it comes to Pantera. From the snarl of Cowboys From Hell to the pure bludgeoning of Vulgar Display of Power, these Texas metalheads were the few flying the flag for all things heavy in the '90s, with the album covers being no exception. On the other hand, time never forgets your more sophomoric beginnings.

Instead of the hard-edged punch to the gut you got in the '90s, Pantera's first inception as a glam band was one of the most unintentionally hilarious things to look back on, starting with Metal Magic. In what can only be described as doofy, this character of sorts looks like they were trying to make some scary sort of metal mascot like Iron Maiden. However, one look at this will elicit more chuckles out of metalheads than something like Eddie would have.

From the way he's holding this sword (I think) to the "sinister" smile that he's supposed to have, most of this looks like some of the cheesiest metal there is out there. For as bad as this is, it might just go all the way around back into being endearing. Make no mistake, this is one of the least scary metal album covers out there, but you'd be hardpressed to find anyone who says that they outright hate this album cover.


3. Fire Down Under - Riot

Out of all the major metal acts arriving on the scene in the late '70s, Riot has remained one of the undiscovered gems lost in the shuffle. All told, albums from the early era of this band are underground classics for any metalhead looking to dig a little deeper into the genre. In fact, probably the only thing holding them back is the reprehensible album artwork that they had on almost every single record.

Honestly, you could probably throw a dart at nearly half of Riot's catalog to find a bad album, given that most of them feature this strange creature. However, the biggest travesty has to come from their best album Fire Down Under, which shows this furball at the very center of the frame. With one look at this album art, most people would probably never suspect that this would come from a metal band, instead thinking its some doofy bubblegum pop act.

Then you get to the actual songs like Swords and Tequila and you realize that this is almost the polar opposite of what you were promised on the cover. Though there's no scientific proof of it, trying to justify this music with this kind of cover is enough to make you experience massive brain fatigue. At the end of the day, Riot's still a great band...with an absolutely wretched marketing campaign.


2. Live It Up - Crosby Stills and Nash

It's not exactly that hard to really screw up a Crosby, Stills, and Nash cover. Since day one, these old folkies have pretty much made a set system to their album art, which is more often than not something rustic, outdoorsy and reminiscent of the old days hiding out in nature. Why anyone would want to take them off of the Earth though is beyond the traditional comprehension.

Make no mistake, album covers coming from space are pretty cool, given that Journey has made a career out of the same kind of album art. However, using this for what amounts to a pretty drab rock record doesn't really have the same impression on the listener. The showstealer though has to be the hot dogs, which add another ultra level of weird to the scenario, as if the graphic designers were taking almost any suggestion that popped into their head.

Then again, this kind of thing could have worked if it were a different artist at the helm. I mean, this kind of thing works terribly next to folk rock, but when put next to, say, a Frank Zappa album, it would work wonders. As it stands though, it's just kind of there, and there's a good chance that Crosby, Stills, and Nash have already since forgot about it. While drugs may have ran rampant during the band's '70s run, you'd have to be on some potent stuff to give this the green light.


1. Dance of Death - Iron Maiden

As far as hard rock goes, Iron Maiden may have made one of the greatest marketing plans of any other metal act. Instead of mugging for the camera with their good looks like glam rockers would have done, the invention of what would become Eddie has been burned into the minds of metalheads for years now. Though Eddie the Head can still hold his own, you just have to wonder what he got himself into on Dance of Death.

It doesn't take you long to look at the album cover before you realize that something is very wrong. While Eddie looks alright, the figurines he's forced to stand next to make it look like one of the most off-putting masquerade balls you've ever been to in your life. Also, it's clear that our artist here is having his first real go-around with CGI characters, given that most of them are either bald, naked, and pulled every which way in the ruckus.

The icing on the cake of this being the worst is that it could have been great, with the original drawing being just Eddie on the cover with most of the other figures removed entirely. It's not like Maiden themselves weren't aware of this either, as Bruce Dickinson took jabs at it and even the artist asking to have his name redacted from the inner sleeve. It just goes to show you that while some album covers are wretched, it stings more when you realize what could have been.


In this post: 
Iron Maiden
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97