12 Worst Sellout Albums In Hard Rock
KISS goes grunge??
Selling out doesn't have to be a bad thing on principle. While the more radio-friendly sounds a band has to offer might not have their best material, it's a great way for young hard rockers to get used to this heavier style of music. However, when some bands go too far, it's a burn you won't soon forget.
Over the years, many bands have come out with records that are a shell of the band we know, with songs that sound as hollow and insipid as the worst of pop music.
Instead of reaching into their souls to bring their audience quality material, these songs are the equivalent of just cashing a check and coaxing off the goodwill of your already existing fanbase. Whether that be to just redo the formula over again or hop on the trendy sounds of the day, these artists have a lot to answer for given the sound of these records.
That's not to say that all of these records tarnished these bands' reputation. For as much cringe is on display here, many of these artists have been able to turn it around and bounce back with some of the best tracks of their career. But with these records as the predecessor, they certainly had a long road back to normalcy.
12. Come Out And Play - Twisted Sister
By the time Twisted Sister reached the mid 80's, they had covered more ground than most bands could hope for. After hardening up the glam rock look of the 70's, the band became darlings of early MTV with the album Stay Hungry, with angry protest songs like "We're Not Gonna Take It." So where do you go after you run out of things to be angry about?
With their main songwriting fire centered around being angry, vocalist Dee Snider found it difficult to write about rebelling against the man once he had paid his dues and become a rock star. Trying to be make the magic strike twice, Come Out and Play is the sound of a band desperately trying to bring their initial fury back in full form. What really sealed the deal as being a drop off was the pop-centric singles, where the band pulls in guest stars like Billy Joel and Alice Cooper to try and legitimize their arrival as rock heroes.
Sister's music always had a tuneful bent to it, but who was necessarily asking for the glam rock transplants to cover the Shangrilas on record? Though nothing can tarnish the band's classic hits, this was first sign that things were about to go very wrong.
11. Demolition - Judas Priest
Judas Priest hardly owes the music world anything after laying the groundwork of heavy metal. With screamer Rob Halford at the helm, the band crafted dark tales of rock and roll glory that have stuck in the minds of metalheads everywhere. However, what happens when you take the Metal God out of the equation?
Right after completing the tour for the band's return to form album Painkiller, Halford decided to leave to focus on other projects. While the band initially had a worthy replacement with Tim "Ripper" Owens, their second effort Demolition was one of the most ill-advised moves to come from the band's A&R department. Instead of being the bright sounding metal of years past, this feels like a deliberate attempt for the band to nab a spot on the nu metal hype train before it leaves the station, with Owens staying in his lower range rather than letting out the insane screams he's known for.
Though the band's congregation felt burned by this record, they were overjoyed just a few years later when Halford finally returned to the throne on Angel of Retribution. With this disastrous album in the rearview, we can safely say that Demolition was the worst offering that Judas Priest had attempted. ALMOST...
10. Path Of Totality - Korn
Out of all the nu metal schlock that came out of the 90's and 2000's, there were tons of great material to be found in that scene. For as much as the rock community likes to rag on the rap-metal hybrid nowadays, bands like Korn were actually pushing the genre forward with their weird detunings and Jonathan Davis' slightly demented vocal delivery.
On the other hand, these guys who defined the genre back in the 90's seemed really behind the times 2 decades down the road. Though later albums like Untitled and See You On the Other Side had some pretty heavy material, Path of Totality is the one release that left most Korn fans a little underwhelmed. Compared to the band's abrasive sound in years past, this lazy attempt at an electronic hybrid took every single dubstep cliche of the times and crammed them into a huge sonic mess.
There's nothing wrong with working like DJs like Skrillex on principle, but the pairing was clunky from the start, with this album being nothing but those misguided collaborations. Korn was able to overcome this album on later releases, but Path of Totality seems like a little blemish on their catalog when compared to the other excellent albums they've made.
9. Turbo - Judas Priest (AGAIN)
When talking about the sell out years of Judas Priest, people are quick to point to the period of Priest without Rob Halford. Though each member plays an essential role in the band, it's pretty easy to just label the Halford-less Priest as sell outs because of the soundalike Tim "Ripper" Owens. Priest without their Metal God is already at a handicap, but even Priest at full capacity could drop the ball.
As the band entered into the 80's, they had made a massive stamp on the genre with British Steel and Screaming for Vengeance. Right when it seemed like they were going to rise to the top of the metal scene, the band started to get a horrible idea for commercial potential. Coming right after the crunchy Defenders of the Faith, Turbo is the sound of heavy metal's greatest band trying to go Top 40, with songs that sound like they could have been written by Bon Jovi.
There are some heavy songs to go around, but it almost feels like heresy hearing this come from Judas Priest rather than a typical hair metal band. This wasn't exactly going to ruin Priest overnight, but when other bands use this album as an example of screwing up, you know we have a problem.
8. Hot Space - Queen
If there was any hard rock act that did their sell out sound right, it was Queen. After casually pushing the boundaries of rock music in the late 70's, the band entered the 80's with a pop sheen that gave them fantastic gems like "Another One Bites the Dust." They may have gotten the first sell out record right, but the follow up was a bit too far into pop territory.
Compared to almost any other record in the band's catalog, Hot Space is regarded as a musical pedestrian rather than a fully fledged album. Though the record does contain one of the band's greatest singles with the David Bowie collaboration "Under Pressure," the rest of the record sounds like the band trying to capture the same magic they had with "Another Bites the Dust..." and slipping under the bar each time.
There are some heartfelt songs like the John Lennon tribute "Life is Real," but this was one of the first instances when the Queen sound could be described as hollow. Looking back on the sessions nowadays, even drummer Roger Taylor expressed distaste for the record and outright dismissed some of the songs. It may have had a great single on it, but the staying power of that one song was not enough to save the record.
7. Risk - Megadeth
During the mid 90's, thrash metal was going through a bit of a transitionary period. Though the genre had dominated most of the 80's underground scene with breakneck tempos and jaw-dropping solos, Metallica showed that the genre could reach a much brighter audience with their self-titled Black Album. Fellow thrashers were certainly paying attention, but none more so than Dave Mustaine.
Knowing the potential of a hooky single, Mustaine steered Megadeth towards poppier territory on Cryptic Writings, which did a decent job on the charts thanks to the single "Trust." It may have been a good start, but those pop inclinations became a bit too much once the band recorded Risk. Instead of gently incorporating some softer touches into their sound, this sounds like Megadeth turning into an alternative rock act without any real warning.
There are some genuinely interesting artistic choices like the use of an electric violin, but as a whole, the record feels like odds and ends that should have been left on the cutting room floor rather than being put onto a major album release. While they would course correct just a few years later with The Worlds Needs a Hero, this example of pop pandering seems like sacrilege coming out of one of the Big 4 of thrash.
6. One More Light - Linkin Park
Throughout their career, Linkin Park always felt like an evolving artistic idea. Whether it was with their nu metal beginnings or their electronic experimentations in the 2010's, the band had a consistency for pushing their sound into places it had never been before. It's a noble effort for any band to undertake, but One More Light steered the band into waters they had no business being in.
As opposed to the band's previous effort The Hunting Party, this record has the band's pop tendencies turned up to 11, as if they are actively trying to snag radio time rather than write legitimate hooks. Granted, many Linkin Park songs had been able to cross over on the charts through the years, but these cuts were the first time the band sounded a bit soulless, with most of the songs being downtempo and slow burning.
While the album does open up about the band's transition into fatherhood, the actual music behind it seems too bland and uninteresting to hold your attention. It stings all the more considering Chester Bennington's suicide just a few months after this album release. The band may still be nursing a fresh wound at this point, but there's still hope that they will be able to come together and use music as the healing force.
5. Diabolus In Musica - Slayer
From day one, Slayer has never been a band that compromised their sound. Whether it was in the 80's or on their last legs last year, the band always stuck to their guns and did whatever the hell they wanted to do regardless of any commercial viability. That kind of attitude has resonated with fans over the years, but Diabolus in Musica is the one moment where everything went awry.
Coming in the late 90's, this record shows the band embracing lower tunings and rhythmic structures that were ripped straight out of the nu metal scene. Instead of the battering ram songs, we were treated to cheap imitations of the nu metal kids from one of the greatest metal bands of all time.
On the surface, this album is not all bad, but it's definitely a low point considering the artist at work here. This is Slayer, the guys who tore into Metallica for becoming a rock band in the early part of the 90's. However, just a few years down the road, these guys found themselves following trends just like their heavy metal brethren. The band have always stood by their music until the end, but even Kerry King has admitted that Diabolus is his least favorite Slayer record.
4. Slang? - Def Leppard
In the era of sprayed hair and spandex, Def Leppard were always one notch above their hair metal brethren. Though they still had the same type of look, the band's ability to write genuine hooks and quality songs set them apart from the cheap wannabes on the Sunset Strip. But like all other hair bands, everything changed once Nirvana came to town.
Eager to get out of their polished sound, the band went into the record Slang? determined to not redo the same kind of record they had done on Hysteria and Pyromania. At the same time, that idea of not copying themselves seemed to just get traded in for copying the sound of something like Pearl Jam, with growly vocal harmonies and a much more organic approach. Those ideas don't sound bad at the outset, but when put up against the sheen of all other Def Leppard albums, this was a sign of bad things to come.
It's not like Def Leppard didn't have a place in the 90's either, with their album Adrenalize from 1990 holding up surprisingly well. Leppard were eventually able to get back on solid ground for 1998's Euphoria, but Slang? is the one sonic experiment that cost a fortune and was ignored by everyone.
3. Generation Swine - Motley Crue
Whenever you turn on a Motley Crue record, it feels like stepping into a great big party. Regardless of what kind of edge the band has to their sound, each of their records has that relentless energy that makes you want to go and tear up everything in sight. After the band finally reunited in the late 90's, fans expecting to be wowed all over again got a bit of a different story with Generation Swine.
With Vince Neil back in the band after a stint with John Corabi, it seemed that the time was right to go back to their roots, but this record ups the ante on experiments. Quickly embracing the sounds of industrial and electronic music, these songs make for for some of the most uncomfortable experiences on a Crue record. There was always a bit of menace in the Crue's songs, but these songs were the first ones that made you feel dirty after listening to them.
Instead of being a bold new direction for the group going forward, this is basically everyone's favorite hair metal band trying to pull off a miracle and turn into Nine Inch Nails. It has a handful of good tracks, but Generation Swine is something best left in the shadows of hard rock music.
2. Carnival Of Souls - KISS
Whenever you threw on a KISS record, you typically knew what you were getting. As opposed to the more experimental kinds of rock bands, these guys were always out to create a hard rock empire rather than cater to the art rock sort. That's completely fine as long as the music kicks ass, but sometimes you get the record that should have been left out to dry.
While many people would probably expect Dynasty to be on here, the album actually holds up as a solid rock release in the band's catalog aside from the disco single "I Was Made For Lovin You."
No, if you wanted to see KISS desperately trying to hop on trends, Carnival of Souls was certainly it. After making a pretty slamming hard rock record on Revenge, this collection of tracks seem to just be piggybacking off the grunge sound, with songs that feel like lesser versions of Alice in Chains tunes.
There was always a possibility for a KISS record to fall into sellout territory, but this stung all the more considering the good material that came just a few years before. With the band releasing it in obscurity as they went out on their makeup reunion tour, this became the KISS record that was almost meant to be forgotten.
1. Just Push Play - Aerosmith
At the end of the 80's, it seemed like Aerosmith was back in peak form. After fumbling through the late 70's and early 80's in a drug-fueled haze, things seemed to be on the rise once the band got Joe Perry back in the band and melded their sound with the hair metal of the day. As the decades went on though, that polish beneath the heaviness started to overtake one of America's greatest rock acts.
Though Get A Grip was a step towards more commercial material, songs like "Cryin" and "Livin On the Edge" have still held up as great Aerosmith cuts. However, once the band got into the studio in the era of boy bands and pop, they decided to cower to the commercial sound hook, line, and sinker.
Just Push Play does start off strong with tracks like "Beyond Beautiful" and "Jaded," but the record runs out of gas really quick, with many of the songs feeling like bad rewrites of the 2000's pop sound.
This may have served as a fine pop album, but the idea of it coming from the Bad Boys of Boston is all the more devastating. After years of rock and roll debauchery, that rootsy rock band we knew and loved had been replaced with a pop-rock shine.