Chances are, at some point in your life you will have found yourself browsing music channels on TV or listening to the radio and you've happened across a song which you remember being completely and utterly awful, yet you stick with it. For some reason, the second time around something else makes you realise that the band are actually really good at what they do. In fact, as you remember complaining to your friends about just how awful it is, there remains that one thing you can't help but admire about the quality of the musicianship behind it - that tinge of guilty pleasure that can give many otherwise hated tracks a second chance. While music is an incredibly subjective thing to judge, there are songs out there that no one will ever admit to liking. From the pop stinkers to epic rock ballads that are just plain awful, the immediate judgement of an audience can cheapen what can often be an incredible amount of care that the artist has put into the track. In a lot of cases, especially in rock music, a song can be hated by the entire world. Yet take away the lyrics and what you're left with is an absolutely astounding piece of music, written with precision and care, and performed with nothing short of virtuoso skill - the whole thing discarded by a mass audience who simply detests the end product. Coming up are 20 songs that are either hated by 'everyone' or the artist's core fanbase, all of which feature amazing amounts of technical skill, but for whatever reason end up being reviled.
20. Iron Maiden - Man On The Edge
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u5UqJWRV55E Back in the mid 90s, Iron Maiden were in a period of extreme flux. Iconic guitarist Adrian Smith had left, the fog-horn himself Bruce Dickinson had fallen out with band leader Steve Harris and moved away from the band too, only to be replaced with Janick Gers and Blaze Bayley respectively. While Janick was accepted as a guitarist pretty quickly, Bayley was hated from about six seconds into this first single. The hatred is simply because Bayley is not Bruce Dickinson, and Harris was still writing songs as if Dickinson was going to be singing them. Man On The Edge is a traditional Maiden song through and through, save for the fact that the wrong singer for the job is fronting the band. Bayley lasted two albums before he was unceremoniously dumped in favour of the returning Dickinson.
19. 30 Seconds To Mars - The Kill
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8yvGCAvOAfM 30 Seconds To Mars, the musical endeavour of Oscar winning actor Jared Leto seemed to explode from nowhere with their breakthrough single, The Kill. The song itself is a fairly standard post-Emo breakup song full of tawdry clichés and ham-fisted lyrics, wrapped up in production so glossy it's almost like they ran the song through a bottle of Pledge before committing it to disc. Combined with the overwrought homage to The Shining in the music video, the song instantly got a lot of peoples' backs up (save for the fangirls who instantly adored Leto). Underneath the song however, is a complicated and intricate musical backdrop full of melodious guitar lines, jazz infused chords and even some attempts at dynamic shifts in volume and power, which is a rare thing in modern music.
18. The Offspring - Hit That
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1slFc9G7I74 The ever-lasting pop punk icons have been at their particular game for well over 20 years now. After so long churning out classics time after time, you'd expect them to have a bit of a lull in quality and with Hit That, you're looking at it. The song itself, about a guy who sleeps around recklessly, is The Offspring by numbers and is nothing particularly special. A lot of fans were put off by the track and were claiming that the band had lost their edge, however under the hood, Hit That showed that the band were maturing and evolving. The Offspring's entire back catalogue has been guitar driven pop-punk whereas this made use of piano samples and synthesisers, slowing their generally frenetic pace down and working to a more comfortable beat. It's the biggest evolution in The Offspring's sound in years and a shame that the song itself was so weak.
17. U2 - The Miracle (Of Joey Ramone)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LF0rKW1DEMo It's still fresh in the mind of anyone with an iPhone that U2 and Apple's joint venture in September had U2's newest album pushed automatically into their iTunes libraries with no regard to whether or not the user actually liked the band. It was a PR disaster and unfortunately has cast a blight on what is possibly the best U2 song since Beautiful Day. The Miracle is different and ear-catching because it sounds nothing like your average U2 song. It's raw, the arrangement isn't a standard pop one, you can actually hear The Edge playing his guitar rather than a load of effects units, and it's the first memorable song they've released since Vertigo. It's just a shame it'll always be remembered for the iTunes fiasco, rather than the decent song it actually is.
16. Sum 41 - We're All To Blame
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aUultIb2pPc Sum 41 were always the darlings of the pop-punk world, taking their metal influences and packaging them up into a radio friendly, mildly anarchic but overall inoffensive package. As the band grew older, they tried to move further from their punk roots and move towards a heavier, more mature sound. Their 3rd album, Chuck, was released and was their heaviest release leaning more on the metal they wanted to play than what their fans wanted to hear. We're All To Blame is a mournful, melancholic attempt at a grown up ballad about the state of this world we live in. The problem is, the song doesn't know what it wants to be. In its heavier moments it sounds like Slayer and Metallica, then drops to acoustic-y ballad territory which sounds more like Sum 41, but still somehow sounds wrong. The problem is, frontman Deryk Whibley is not a metal singer, so when it's heavy he doesn't fit and the lyrics for the quieter sections are simply ineffective in communicating his point. It's unsurprising that the fanbase hated it and it split them right down the middle.
15. Red Hot Chili Peppers - Aeroplane
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vV8IAOojoAA Arguably the worst song the Chilis have released to date, Aeroplane was written at a time when the band were still off their faces on everything they could get into their bloodstream, reducing creativity to a minimum. The song itself is a nonsensical hodge-podge of sex and drug references with very little point or scope, and the creepy children choir in the ending choruses is just plain weird. What Aeroplane has going for it is a band who musically are on top form, from Dave Navarro's fusion guitar playing through Chad Smith's thumping and driving rhythm, and ending with the irrepressible Flea's virtuoso funk bass playing. Aeroplane is a song that would have actually been significantly better had it just been left instrumental.
14. Linkin Park - The Catalyst
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=51iquRYKPbs Ever since the dust settled on LP's debut album Hybrid Theory, they band were making steps to change and evolve, with their next two albums deviating from that original sound, but it wasn't until their fourth that they really managed to become a different beast altogether. The first single from A Thousand Suns, The Catalyst immediately blew up and severely upset the vast majority of the band's fanbase. There's the scantest amount of guitar, very little in the way of real instruments, digitally processed vocals that together sounds more like a drum and bass song than something from a band known for being the poster boys of Nu-metal. If an act like Chase and Status or Pendulum released The Catalyst it would have been a number one hit, as it's an incredibly well put together club smasher. Just not a good Linkin Park song.
13. Guns N' Roses - November Rain
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8SbUC-UaAxE When Sweet Child O' Mine single handedly raised GnR from the level of "promising new rock act" to "stadium filling megastars", it could be very much expected that the band would try and replicate the success of their monster hit power ballad. Roll on the early 90s, years of recording and an ambitious double album in Use Your Illusion - the power ballad returned and what the world was given was November Rain. It's considered a classic by some, but others see it as Axl Rose feeding his ego with overblown production, lyrics that don't really make that much sense and more piano than a band who wrote Mr. Brownstone should ever need. However, the song redeems its languid qualities simply for that guitar solo at the end, which has Slash proving why he is, and always will be, the consummate guitar hero.
12. Biffy Clyro - Bubbles
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UxUb9Yzr1sE Biffy Clyro are one of those bands who always deserved to get huge, but when they did somehow managed to entirely alienate their core fanbase. When The Biff were picked up by Roadrunner Records for their fourth album, things were going rather well, but after when it came to their fifth album, Only Revolutions, the 'Roadrunner effect' had set in and their classic fanbase hated their new radio-friendly sound. Bubbles is a song that makes absolutely no sense, however underneath Simon Neil's weird lyrics sits a surprisingly heavy and complex piece of music. His fondness for using unconventional tunings combined with his unique style of playing over the top of the band's thundering rhythm section make this an incredibly unique track.
Next
I am a man of many interests. I am a passionate gamer, running my own YouTube channel (The Gadget Addicts) showing off the best of modern gaming in the form of Let's Play videos.
I am an ardent musician, having been a guitarist for the past 13 years. I am also a massive geek, I adore science fiction and fantasy films and TV shows and am trying to work up the courage to start writing a novel. If I can ever think of a good story to tell...
I live with my wife in the North East of England and own a belligerent little black cat.