5 Bands With Disastrous Career-Killing Albums

Razorlight Over the years, many a band have released albums that could be considered flops. For many artists, it's a case of falling behind the times - look at the prog bands in the 70s when punk hit, or the hair metal genocide following the explosion of grunge. Or perhaps they tried a new direction that didn't connect with listeners like their other material, like U2 during their Zooropa and Pop era in the mid-90s. And sometimes, albums are considered flops because they're simply atrocious - St. Anger, take a bow. Usually, the big names of music can bounce back from these blunders. At worst, a bad album will set them back a couple of years, then they can carry on their designs for world domination. But what about those albums that were so badly received that there was truly no coming back? Read on.

5. The Clash - Cut The Crap

cut the crap In 1982, The Clash achieved considerable commercial success with Combat Rock, hitting double platinum in the US. In 1985, they were a band on life support. Relations between primary songwriters Joe Strummer and Mick Jones had broken down and drummer Topper Headon had quit the band due to heroin addiction, leaving Strummer and bassist Paul Simonon as the only remaining original members. At the time, the record was damned by critics across the board, in stark contrast to their earlier work. Indeed, Cut The Crap was the final nail in the coffin and The Clash Mk II dissolved soon after its release. So how bad is it? Well by Strummer's lofty standards, its pretty bad. The production is swamped with distracting mid-80s synths that make the songs sound about as punk as Culture Club. This could be forgiven if the material stands up, but with the exception of the superb This Is England, it doesn't. The creative input of Jones is sorely missed, and this album clearly shows that this incarnation of the band could never live up to past glories. The fact that this album and era has been virtually erased from Clash history, totally ignored in the 2000 documentary Westway To The World and most official compilations tells you all you need to know.

4. The Velvet Underground - Squeeze

squeeze For most bands, a couple of changes in the line-up are to be expected. Hardly surprising that inflated egos and the demands of constant touring and recording don't mix. In extreme cases, some bands have released albums that don't feature any original member. Which brings us to Squeeze. Released in 1973, this was a Velvets album in name only, being written and recorded almost entirely by Doug Yule, who had replaced John Cale on previous album Loaded. So did Squeeze point to Yule's version of the band having a future? Did it feck. Squeeze was a critical and commercial disaster on release, with Yule finally deciding to kill off his experiment after the album tour. The songs themselves aren't completely dreadful, and it is certainly more listenable than Lou Reed's infamous Metal Machine Music released four years later. But outside of a few subsequent brief reunions, Squeeze officially ended the career of one of the finest American rock bands.

3. Sly And The Family Stone - Ain't But The One Way

slystone The downfall of Sly Stone is one of the most extraordinary and tragic in pop music. Releasing album after album of fresh, ground-breaking funk from the late 60s to mid-70s that heavily influenced the likes of Stevie Wonder, Michael Jackson and Prince, there's a strong case for Sly and the Family Stone being one of the most important pop acts in history, and its largely down to the erratic genius of the band's main-man. But by the time Ain't But The One Way was released in 1981, the musicians that had featured on the Family Stone's seminal records were long gone. What we're left with is a drug-addled Sly trying to recapture past glories. Originally envisioned as a collaboration between Sly and George Clinton, the Funkadelic man left the project following a dispute with label Warner Brothers, and Sly himself went into hiding in the middle of the sessions. This left producer Stewart Levine to pick up the pieces and release something resembling a coherent album. He actually does a decent job, and for the dedicated, there is just enough in Sly's swan-song to hold your interest. L.O.V.I.N.U is a strong opener that echoes early Prince, Hobo Ken is a fun slice of classic funk and Sylvester is an eery 45-second a-cappella that sticks in the memory. But what about Sly? Well the man has made few public appearances since the release of Ain't But the One Way, and outside of a few leaked demos, no new music. In 2009, the Guardian reported that bankruptcy has left the troubled genius homeless and living in a camper-van in Los Angeles. Ultimately a victim of his own demons, this album marked the point of no return for one of funk's biggest icons.

2. Razorlight - Slipway Fires

slipwayfires Cast your mind back to the more innocent time of 2006. The UK indie music press needed a new poster boy, and inexplicably they chose Johnny Borrell of Razorlight. The band enjoyed some success with the bland indie pop ditties like America and In The Morning, which were inoffensive enough. But somewhere along the way Borrell bought into his own hype, leading us to Slipway Fires. Make no mistake about it, this album is self-indulgence taken to almost insulting extremes. On one of the more ridiculous tracks, Hostage of Love, Borrell points out his similarities with Jesus H. Christ in a totally non-ironic manner. 'I am salvation' and 'for telling my story I have been crucified' are just a couple of picks from this joke of a song. Musically, Razorlight desperately aim for Joshua Tree style bombast, but all the arena rock polish can't disguise the fact that the band's arrangements and playing are woefully pedestrian, which only makes Borrell's pretensions all the more laughable. The rest of the band bailed on their singer after this album's release, and there time as one of the most popular bands in the UK now feels like some odd dream we've all woken up from. As for Borrell? Well indie's one-time messiah released his debut solo album (modestly titled Borrell 1) in July 2013, selling 594 copies in its first week. That's not a typo. 594 copies. Pretty poor showing from the man who once declared himself the new Bob Dylan.

1. Guns N' Roses - The Spaghetti Incident?

spaghetti OK, so I'm cheating a bit this one. Guns N' Roses are still around, in the sense that Axl Rose still tours under the name with his gaggle of side musicians. But in terms of the band that the average punter recognises as GNR, i.e. the one that had a Slash and a Duff, this is the album that killed them. In a way, the decision to do an album of old rock n' roll and punk songs makes sense. The bands two Use Your Illusion albums were sprawling, bloated affairs and the ensuing world tour was pure Spinal Tap - drug and alcohol addictions, guitarists leaving, riots at concerts - you name it, it probably happened. So doing an album like The Spaghetti Incident? in 1993 was a chance for the band to return to the sleaze rock roots of their seminal debut Appetite For Destruction. And in truth, its a fun listen for what it is. It veers on the wrong side of goofy a few times (Axl's faux-English accent on New Rose and Down on the Farm is ridiculous) and the infamous inclusion of the Charles Manson ditty Look at Your Game, Girl reeks of Axl trying too hard, but lively renditions of Ain't It Fun and Hair of the Dog are welcome additions to the GNR canon. Unfortunately, the record-buying public were not quite so enthusiastic. Though selling 190,000 copies on its first week seems respectable, when you consider that the dual UYI albums sold almost 1.5 million between them in the same timeframe in 1991 then its clear this album did them no favours. The Axl-Slash-Duff lineup recorded just one more track after this album, the rather awful Sympathy For The Devil cover for 1994's Interview with the Vampire(described by Slash as 'the sound of a band breaking up') and the lead guitarist and bassist called it a day later in the decade. Though its true GNR technically live on, the band that once ruled the world in the early 90s died with this album.

Contributor
Contributor

Northern Irish man living and working in London. Heroes include Ledley King, James Ellroy and whoever invented elasticated sweatshorts. Follow me on Twitter - @MJLowry23