5 Bands Who Improved After Replacing Their Singer (And 5 Who Didn't)

Which of these classic groups benefitted from a change at the front of the stage?

FILE - This Aug. 3, 2012 file photo shows Ozzy Osbourne of Black Sabbath performing at the Lollapalooza festival in Chicago's Grant Park. Black Sabbath's latest album
Steve Mitchell/AP

It's a source of inter-band drama as old as music itself; the lead singer is the person the public most associates with the musical band. When someone mentions The Doors, Ray Manzarek's name isn't likely to come to mind before Jim Morrison's.

While established acts have often carried on with new bassists or drummers, switching out the face of the band is often the kiss of death. Fans will often give a band a pass if they replace their vocalist due to death or health issues. When it's only a matter of money, personality clashes or ego, fans expect to be rewarded for their loyalty. Bringing in a singer who can't fill their predecessor's leather pants only sets the fans up for disappointment and sets the band up for poor ticket sales.

On the other hand, some bands reach their greatest success after making a change in vocalists. The new blood brings new zeal and energy to some acts. In choosing replacements, some bands made good calls, thriving in their new era. Others... to quote the knight from Indiana Jones... chose poorly.

10. Became Worse - The Cars

The Cars were a Boston-based band that emerged from the New Wave scene of the late 1970s. When MTV and synth-pop took off in the early 1980s, The Cars became more of a household name. The Cars' classic line-up remained from the band's formation in 1976 until 1988. During that twelve-year span, the band produced four top 10 hits and won MTV's "Video of the Year" in 1984 for their hit single You Might Think.

The real creative force of The Cars was driven (pun intended) by the long-time collaboration of bassist Benjamin Orr and guitarist Ric Ocasek. The two men shared lead vocal duties-something many fans didn't realize based on how similar both voices sounded. Orr and Ocasek were also the primary songwriters. Despite the creative partnership, much of the public saw Ric Ocasek and the Cars as being one in the same.

A growing divide between Ocasek and the others led to the band dissolving in 1988. The surviving members of the band reunited as The New Cars, with classic rocker Todd Rundgren on vocals and guitar. Rundren is no slouch, but with the Cars he was also no Ric Ocasek. The New Cars performed until 2009 (without Orr, who died in 2000). The Cars enjoyed one last album with Ocasek before he too died in 2019.


9. Improved - AC/DC

Bon Scott was great. Let's get that out of the way. AC/DC were wildly successful with Scott. In this case, Bon died from alcoholism, so the band had some sympathy going forward in regards to replacing him. That sympathy was no longer needed after the first listen to Back in Black.

AC/DC formed in Sydney, Australia in 1973. By the next year, they had already gained a strong following. Over the next five years, the band produced six studio albums (which collectively reached platinum status 19 times).

In 1980, the band was working on their seventh album, Back In Black, when tragedy struck. Scott was found unresponsive and died of acute alcohol poisoning. This left some tremendous shoes to be filled.

Bon Scott had spoken highly of singer Brian Johnson after seeing him perform with his band Geordie. The band contacted Johnson, who auditioned twice, to officially make him the new singer for AC/DC.

Back in Black was released in July 1980. It became AC/DC's biggest selling album, and touted some of their most iconic songs (You Shook Me All Night Long, Shoot To Thrill, Back In Black).

With all respect to Bon, it has been with Brian Johnson that AC/DC has rocked at their highest voltage.


8. Became Worse - Black Sabbath

Black Sabbath's classic lineup lasted only ten years, but their influence on heavy metal is still heard in today's bands. Formed in 1968, Black Sabbath consisted of drummer Bill Ward, bassist Geezer Butler, guitarist Tony Iommi, and front man Ozzy Osbourne. Leaning into darker occult themes and down-tuning their instruments, Sabbath shocked the world with their evil, but very listenable, brand of hard rock.

Iconic songs like Iron Man, Paranoid and War Pigs still receive regular radio play and have been licensed scads of times. One decade and eight albums into their run, Iommi fired Ozzy due to the frequency and intensity of the singer's substance abuse.

It was actually Ozzy's future wife Sharon who recommended Rainbow frontman Ronnie James Dio for the job. Dio had legit hard rock credibility and, to his credit, gave a great version of Ronnie James Dio while in Black Sabbath.

Sabbath never reached the same heights that they did with the original lineup. Even drummer Bill Ward had stated "It was intolerable for me to get on the stage without Ozzy". The Dio era may not have been intolerable...but it wasn't Ozzy.


7. Improved - Pink Floyd

When David Gilmour replaced Syd Barrett as the vocalist for Pink Floyd, they didn't just change a singer. It was as if they'd become a whole new band. One of those bands was significantly better than the other. That was the band with David Gilmour.

Formed in London in 1965, Pink Floyd were pioneers of psychedelic rock. Helmed by vocalist/songwriter Syd Barrett, Pink Floyd produced two hit singles and one album, The Piper at the Gates of Dawn. By 1967, Barrett was displaying increasingly erratic behaviour. This led to missed gigs and/or train wreck gigs where Barrett would refuse to show or stand on stage, staring at the audience.

Guitarist/vocalist David Gilmour was brought into the mix. As Barrett's condition deteriorated, Gilmour was doing more and more of the heavy lifting musically. In March 1968, Barrett was fired from Pink Floyd and Gilmour was now the guitarist and second vocalist for the band.

It was after this that Pink Floyd produced essentially all of their iconic work. 1973's The Dark Side of the Moon is one of the best-selling albums of all time, having gone platinum 15 times over. The band's final reunion show in 2005 showed that those four musicians together were the real magic of Pink Floyd.


6. Became Worse - Journey

Journey, as most people know them, was led by dynamic vocalist Steve Perry. While Perry wasn't the original singer, it was during his tenure that the band became the international juggernaut that still saturates classic rock radio.

Starting with the intent of being a backup band, Journey quickly changed directions and began working on their own material. It wasn't until the band's fourth album, Infinity, that Steve Perry was hired and the classic Journey line-up was born.

Perry remained with Journey for 13 years (not including an eight-year hiatus). From 1998-2007, Journey entered a lull, cycling through a couple of different vocalists. In 2007 they hired Arnel Pineda; a guy who got the job because he sounded just like Steve Perry.

Guitarist Neil Schon saw a YouTube video of Pineda singing the Journey hit Faithfully. He then called Pineda, had him come in for a two-day audition, and shortly after, Pineda was announced as the new singer for Journey.

It's like the time actor Danny Trejo was turned down for a role that was written for a "Danny Trejo type". Talented as he is, Arnel Pineda still feels like the singer in a great Journey cover band.


5. Improved - Dropkick Murphys

Dropkick Murphys were formed in Quincy, Massachussetts in 1996. They brought the Celtic Punk sub-genre to the forefront, blending aggressive street punk and traditional Irish music. In 1997, the band was signed to Hellcat Records and produced Do or Die, their first full-length record.

Up through the making of Do or Die, Dorchester native Mike McColgan served as lead vocalist. His raw vocal style helped make Do or Die a breakthrough for the band. As the other members of the group were getting more serious about the band professionally, McColgan's interest began to wane. A mutual, amicable split ensued and DKM were in need of a new frontman.

McColgan was quickly replaced by The Bruisers' vocalist Al Barr. Will Barr, DKM quickly evolved into their signature sound. They also reached new heights post-McColgan when their song I'm Shipping Up to Boston was used in the soundtrack for the film The Departed. The song has been their biggest single to date.

Unlike Pink Floyd, who essentially became a new band, or Journey, who replicated their old singer, Dropkick Murphys hit the sweet spot. Barr didn't change the direction of the band stylistically. He helped them to become the best version of themselves. As of 2022, they are still going strong.


4. Became Worse - Van Halen

David Lee Roth said it best. His Van Halen songs were all about sex and Sammy Hagar's were all about love.

Van Halen began in 1972 in Pasadena, California. By 1974, brothers Eddie and Alex Van Halen had recruited vocalist David Lee Roth and bassist Michael Anthony. This became the classic Van Halen lineup. The band released their smash debut, Van Halen, in 1978. Between then and 1984, Van Halen revolutionized guitar rock over a span of six studio albums. Each of those albums has been certified either platimum or diamond based on sales.

After recording the sixth record, 1984, Roth decided to quit and form a new band. Each band member has given different reasons for the split, but all reasons appear to be based around creative control.

Eddie Van Halen met former Montrose singer Sammy Hagar in 1985. Hagar was established as a solo performer at the time. Eddie brought in Hagar to sing and play rhythm guitar. The first album of the "Van Hagar" era, 5150, was their first to reach number one. The band released three more albums with Hagar, and each had very strong moments.

Nothing about the Van Hagar era was bad. If they had started with Sammy Hagar, they likely would have still thrived. After a decade of Diamond Dave though, Sammy just felt a little "B-Team".


3. Improved - Faith No More

An early version of Bay area rockers Faith No More was formed in 1979. By 1983, the band settled into their new name and first steady line-up. They recorded a self-titled cassette with singer Chuck Mosely. Faith No More, now attached to Mordam Records, recorded and released their first official album. Faith No More released one more record, Introduce Yourself, in 1987. Mosely's behaviour was becoming increasingly erratic and violent. After touring for the album, Mosely was fired by the band.

Mr. Bungle vocalist Mike Patton officially replaced Mosely in January 1989. Within two weeks of joining the band, Patton had written the lyrics for every song that would appear on their biggest release yet, The Real Thing. The album's second single, Epic, became synonymous with the band from that point. The video for Epic boosted the group into a new level. The Real Thing went on to become their first of two albums to be certified platinum with Patton at the wheel.

Mike Patton's inclusion in Faith No More didn't completely change the direction of the band (ala Pink Floyd). Rather, it felt as though he was the missing piece that just needed to be found.


2. Became Worse - Deep Purple

Heavy metal pioneers Deep Purple have had a LOT of line-up changes in their 55-year career. The band began in London in 1968. Drummer Chris Curtis wanted to recruit a supergroup of established musicians. Organist Jon Lord was brought onboard first. Guitarist Ritchie Blackmore joined soon after. After landing on the name Deep Purple, this early version of the band replaced Curtis with Ian Paice and hired vocalist Rod Evans.

Deep Purple released two albums with Evans, 1968's Shades of Deep Purple and The Book of Taliesyn. The following year, Lord and Blackmore met with Ian Paice to discuss a new direction. Wanting a heavier sound, bassist Nick Simper was replaced with Roger Glover and Evans was replaced with Ian Gillan. The classic (or Mark II) lineup was born.

With the exception of Hush and Kentucky Woman, Deep Purple's most iconic tracks came from the Mark II lineup. Albums Machine Head, Made in Japan and Who Do We Think We Are? cemented Deep Purple's legacy as one of the "Unholy Trinity" of British hard rock (along with Led Zeppelin and Black Sabbath).

Gillan quit in 1973 after an exhausting schedule and inter-band conflict. After Gillan's departure, Deep Purple’s vocalists have included David Coverdale and Joe Lynn Turner. Gillan has since rejoined Deep Purple, releasing their latest record in 2021.


1. Improved - Black Flag

1980s anti-authoritarian hardcore legends Black Flag is another group who has had a revolving lineup over the years. Like Deep Purple, Black Flag was a few years into things before settling into their classic lineup.

Started by guitarist Greg Ginn (the group's only consistent member) in 1976, Black Flag began with vocalist Keith Morris. Citing creative differences and his own escalated drug use, Morris quit the band in 1979. Vocalists Ron Reyes and Dez Cadena briefly served as lead singer until Cadena switched to guitar and the band recruited Henry Rollins in 1981.

It was during this time that the band achieved their greatest success and notoriety. Rollins has also served the longest tenure of any Black Flag singer. In 1981, the band released their first full-length album, Damaged. Damaged became he record that truly put Black Flag on the map. In 1984, Black Flag released three more records and performed 178 shows. They continued to tour for much of 1985.

Lineup changes, touring and infighting followed Black Flag's most prolific years. Two months after their last show in June of 1986, Greg Ginn left the band, essentially dissolving Black Flag in the process.

Black Flag has reformed and played reunion shows since then (without Rollins), but has never recaptured the zeitgeist of the Rollins years.


Contributor
Contributor

George is a life-long fan of genre, wrestling and guitars. He is an actor, writer, CrossFit trainer and former WWE storyline writer. He currently works as talent development for PWX wrestling and resides in the birthplace of the zombie movie, Pittsburgh, PA.