5 Returning Bands That Failed (And 5 That Nailed Their Comeback)

Returning from a hiatus or break-up can be tricky.

BLACK SABBATH FALL OUT BOY
Ben Gibson/Uprising

Getting back together after a break-up can be tough. It can be awkward, especially if one side has been mouthing off about the other, or if someone's gone and found a new beau, or if they keep saying "you can't be here Steven, this is why I have a restraining order".

Bands have it just as difficult. Money, brands, ownership, the custody battle of band assets can be a torrid affair, even if a band splits amicably. Egos run amok, and it can sour relationships forever. The bridges though can be mended, whether through the foresight of time, an event of great importance (see the plane crash that eventually brought Blink-182 back together), or money, artists usually find it within themselves to put their differences aside and reconcile for a tour and/or album.

Successes can vary, coming back after a break adds a lot of pressure to whatever output the band gives. If it's not up to the standards you all laid when you were together the first time around, what's the point in you coming back at all?

Some get it right and pick up where they left off or even eclipse their previous run. Others though are not so lucky and are permanently over-shadowed by their past selves.

10. Failed: Fall Out Boy

Formed out the dissolution of several hardcore bands including Arma Angelus and Racetraitor, FOB found early success from a winning combination of catchy lyrics and excellent musicianship. Fans and critics to this day still argue which is the better album between breakthrough hit From Under the Cork Tree and its follow-up Infinity on High.

By the time Folie à Deux came around, problems within the band started to show and break the core apart, including substance abuse, relationship issues, creative differences, and a mixed reception to the album.

Following their split in 2009, FOB regrouped in 2013 and soon released Save Rock and Roll. A big departure from their pop punk sound but enjoyable nonetheless.

American Beauty/American Psycho though is an over-produced mess that sounds like Andy and Joe went on holiday for the entire recording session. It lacks any individualism and sounds like any other generic pop band. And with this year's Mania album, it's only getting worse, "Young and Menace" sounds like Alvin and the Chipmunks going through the washing machine and I think the lads' instruments are purely for decoration.

No amount of Ellen DeGeneres puns make this reunion ok.


9. Nailed: Black Sabbath

Very few bands have gone through the motions quite like heavy metal godfathers Black Sabbath. Formed in 1968, Sabbath created an immediate musical revolution with their brand of dark, blues-inspired heavy music at a time of light and colourful hippie culture.

The ravages of touring, drugs and alcohol would eventually take their toll on the band, resulting in a revolving door of talent in the band. In fact, 1978's Never Say Die album would be the last album to have the same Sabbath line-up as the previous.

Despite all this, Sabbath only ever officially broke up once, when Tony Iommi,Geezer Butler, Vinnie Appice and Ronnie James Dio teamed for Heaven & Hell in 2006. Following Dio's passing and the band's subsequent dissolution, the original Sabbath line-up reformed in 2011 and began writing what would eventually become 13.

Ward would famously quit the band (again) which threatened the album's progress. Not to be deterred, Sabbath enlisted the help of Rage Against the Machine drummer Brad Wilks to help finalise their swansong album.

The album and subsequent live shows were well received, giving the band a deservedly much better conclusion. Especially when compared to their previous effort, 1995's Forbidden.


8. Failed: System Of A Down

System of a Down reformed in 2010 and honestly, given the activity of the band since, they might as well have not bothered.

Formed in 1994, the Armenian-American group took the world by storm with their brand of artistic nu metal, counter-arguing the one dimensional complaints that was aimed at their peers. They then went on to release five records over the course of seven years with barely a dud in the lot.

Following their headline show at 2006's Ozzfest and 2005's double release of Mesmerize and Hypnotize, SOAD announced that they'd be taking a break, with members going on to work on various projects

After extensive internet rumours, System announced they'd be reforming for a series of live dates. While critics did rate their individual shows, festival appearances (including headlining 2011's Download Festival) drew criticisms of band members looking bored and disinterested.

Since then, conflicting reports have surfaced regarding a new album with Dolmayan, Odadjian and even Malakian all keen for a new album, the only conflicting factor being Tankian flip-flopping his interest, saying "the openness is there to work together" in 2015 to "screw vocals. I'm tired of it" in 2017.


7. Nailed: Bad Religion

Another product of the California punk scene, Bad Religion had the DIY aesthetic from day one, forming out of high school and playing any and every show they could get their hands on, they would release their debut self-titled EP in 1981, on their own label Epitaph.

With their politically-driven brand of hardcore earning a positive reputation, the band released their debut album How Could Hell Be Any Worse? in 1982. And then the weird happens.

The follow-up, Into the Unknown, is a keyboard-backed prog rock album that, unsurprisingly, alienated the band's core fanbase. To say it was against the grain of their reputation would be an understatement and they would disband shortly after.

Following a couple of tentative reunions, Bad Religion returned in full in 1986 with all members housing a fresh outlook and drive for the band. Now a more cohesive unit, Bad Religion would release landmark album Suffer in 1988 and the rest is history.

Bad Religion would become one of the most important bands in punk with album seventeen due in 2018 and Epitaph has hosted some of the biggest names in rock, including Green Day, Converge, Parkway Drive, Refused and Every Time I Die.


6. Failed: Black Flag

Very few bands symbolise the punk rock ethos quite like Black Flag. From their image, their raw sound, iconic artwork and stage presence, Black Flag brought in an unparalleled level of ferosity at a time dominated by the cheesiest of cheesy pop such as ABBA, Earth Wind & Fire and Boston.

The band's initial ten year run began with a series of highly regarded EPs, including Six Pack and Nervous Breakdown before enlisting the talismanic Henry Rollins and releasing their ground-breaking Damaged album in 1981. Following five more albums across the space of just two years, Black Flag imploded on itself and split in 1986.

Outside a charity supporting reunion in 2003, a full Black Flag return seemed unlikely. That was until 2013 when Greg Ginn reformed a Ron Reyes-fronted Black Flag which culminated in the release of aptly-titled What The....

The album bombed critically and commercially. The album art looks like a five year-old had a seizure whilst using MS Paint and the album itself sounds like the kid ricocheted off a guitar on the way down. The band is currently at war with itself, with Ginn suing a second Black Flag reunion, the Keith Morris-fronted Flag.


5. Nailed: Alice In Chains

It's no secret that grunge took the world by storm by the 90s.

The Seattle sound brought mainstream attention to a number of significant bands, including the grunge 'big 4' of Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Soundgarden and Alice in Chains.

AIC blended that signature sound with a more rugged, heavy metal sound, with two lead vocalists fronting the band in Jerry Cantrell and Layne Staley. This concoction proved successful, with debut record Facelift becoming the first grunge album to be certified Gold before eventually being certified double Platinum.

By 1996, the band had released three albums with a fourth becoming increasingly difficult to make, owing to Staley's drug habits. On 5th April 2002, those habits would finally take Staley as he passed away from an accidental overdose. Alice in Chains would split up shortly thereafter.

The surviving members would reform in 2005, ten years since their last live performance, enlisting William DuVall of Comes with the Fall to be the new co-lead vocalist.

The new line-up would release the eagerly anticipated Black Gives Way to Blue in 2009, a resounding success that achieved Gold certification, before beating Slayer, Mastodon, Megadeth and Heaven and Hell to the 2010 Revolver Golden Gods Album of the Year Award.


4. Failed: The King Blues

Once upon a time, The King Blues were everyone's low-key punk darlings.

Ranging from ukulele-led dreamy folk punk to angry borderline rapcore, The King Blues had a mood to suit everybody. Achieving success with back-to-back triumphs Save the World. Get the Girl and Punk & Poetry, Jonny "Itch" Fox became an unofficial voice of the voiceless, taking diss track-quality barbs at the UK's leading political faces, with the occasional sprinkle of a love song or two in between.

It's not quite clear what happened by the time of 2012's Long Live the Struggle, but the quality took a dive bigger than Brian Blessed's Hawk Men in Flash Gordon. The band recognised this, announcing their break-up three months before the album's release.

The King Blues remained absent until early 2016 when they came back with return EP Off With Their Heads which was.. awful. Seemingly released with little-to-no post-production in an attempt at a more raw sound that more resembled a cat in a bin, a full-length album soon followed up with The Gospel Truth.

While it's an improvement to Long Live..., it's in the same way as a slap in the chest is better than a slap in the nuts.


3. Nailed: Take That

And now for something completely different.

Have so much as a fleeting look at the UK music scene in the 90s and you will undoubtedly come across a cheesy, industry-backed pop scene headed by Manchester-based quintet Take That. The boyband electrified fans and critics alike with their impressive vocals, somewhat unique ability to actually songs and, of course, abs with more definition than an Oxford dictionary.

Whilst their on-screen image was that of a group of clean-cut heart throbs, behind the scenes was a bit more rock and roll, with an abundance of drugs being taken by members of the group. This resulted in the band issuing Robbie Williams a make-or-break ultimatum due to his erratic behaviour. Williams famously left, and while Take That did try to continue as a four-piece, they inevitably broke up the following year.

Ten years later, and Take That (sans Williams) returned to some scepticism as to whether they could keep up with the new era of boybands.

Oh boy could they.

Beautiful World remained in the UK Top 100 for over two and a half years and has been certified Platinum nine times. They have since release four more albums, with all but one becoming a UK No. 1.


2. Failed: At The Drive-In

How bad do you have to be to screw up two reunions? It's a question one can only pose to post-hardcore troupe At the Drive-In following their reunions in 2011 and 2015.

Formed out of El Paso, Texas in 1994 by vocalists Cedric Bixler-Zavala and Jim Ward, the pair slowly worked to the classic-looking ATDI line-up for their sophomore In/Casino/Out in 1998.

It's their third album, Relationship of Command that has cemented the band's place in history. The much heralded and hugely influential album gave ATDI short-lived but massive critical and commercial success, before deciding to break-up just over a year after its release in 2001.

In 2011, the classic line-up returned for a series of live shows including an appearance at Coachella Festival. The return was well-received up until a lack of enthusiasm displayed by guitarist Omar Rodríguez-López, and following a fallout between him and Bixler-Zavala, ATDI's short return was over. A few years later in 2015, a second reunion was in place, except with mainstay Ward opting out and replaced by Sparta guitarist Keeley Davis.

The swap proved unmissable as the resultant in•ter a•li•a lacks passion and coherency, and sounds more like yet another weird Bixler-Zavala/Rodríguez-López project.


1. Nailed: Faith No More

Consistently one of the best performing acts in rock music, Faith No More were able to transcend the trends of the 80s and 90s to stand out as an artistic juggernaut, headed by one of the greatest and most versatile frontmen of all time.

With Mr. Bungle's Mike Patton at the helm, the band received a Grammy nomination with 1989's The Real Thing and would go on to release a string of heralded albums, before calling it a day in 1998, with a desire for each member to participate in side projects cited as the reason behind the demise.

FNM laid dormant until reunion rumours began to arise in late 2008. Although initially denied, a comeback tour for throughout 2009 was confirmed. Over the next few years, FNM would perform strings of live dates, in and around various side projects, before electing to finally begin work on a new studio album.

Having the track "Motherf*cker" as the lead single should tell you everything you need to know about the album and FNM, but the resultant Sol Invictus proved worthy to the Faith No More name, being rightly heralded as one of the best albums of 2015.


Contributor
Contributor

Wish.com Jules Gill. Pretty fond of heavy music, Arsenal, video games and wrestling.