8 Uses Of Auto-Tune That Are Actually OK

Sometimes you WANT to sound like a robot.

Kanye West accepts the video vanguard award at the MTV Video Music Awards at the Microsoft Theater on Sunday, Aug. 30, 2015, in Los Angeles. (Photo by Matt Sayles/Invision/AP)
Matt Sayles/AP

Ever since Cher transformed her voice into a synthetic warble for her 1998 single "Believe", auto-tune has transformed the way pop vocals are recorded. Within a year of the hit, inventor Andy Hildebrand had sold the technology to every major studio in the world.

Pretty soon the technology wasn't just a stylistic choice - producers began to conceal imperfections in singers' voices. Artists like T-Pain used it blatantly and openly (to the extent that the singer tried to sue the makers of Auto-tune), whilst others (like Britney Spears) used it for more deceptive ends. Soon enough, it became synonymous with artistic laziness, gaining criticism from all corners of the music industry. These detractors ranged from Death Cab For Cutie to Jay Z (although the latter seems to have changed his, um, tune).

As the technology progressed, so too did its insidiousness; auto-tune can now easily be used to enhance live vocals, as evidenced by Gamu Nhengu's notorious 2010 X-Factor audition, as her voice was audibly yanked on key.

Despite this, some artists have carried on in the spirit of Cher, using it as an artistic tool, not a shortcut. Here are eight of its most inspired uses, where auto-tune augments the singer's vocals in interesting ways.

8. Bon Iver - Woods

A song regarded by Kanye West as a masterpiece, "The Woods" closed Bon Iver's 2009 EP "Blood Bank" and stands as an odd track in the singer's discography. Entirely acapella and chant-like in its circular repetition, it marked one of the clearest leaps forwards in the artist's career, straddling the gap between the shy folk singer and electronic auteur.

This strange slice of lonely rambling is made spectral and isolated by the vocal’s thick autotune, counterpointed with a reverb-soaked harmony line. The song is not only rustic (Vernon sings from "down in the woods") but ancient; the lyrics "I'm building a still to slow down the time" suggest that the singer is working on a more leisurely timescale. The auto-tune, then, offers an intriguing contrast between the ultra-modern production and the pastoral antiquity of the lyrics.


7. James Blake - I Mind

Blake's voice, at once fragile and powerful, has become one of the most recognisable in contemporary British music. This isn't just the case within the electronic world; he has contributed vocals to songs for artists like Beyonce and Kanye West. But this hasn't stopped the artist using all manner of editing techniques to chop and screw his vocals into something alien and unrecognisable.

Whilst sometimes these experiments detract from the ghostly beauty of his voice, often they result in something extraordinary. His track "I Mind", from his debut self-titled album, applies liberal amounts of effects on his voice, particularly in the dancehall section at the end of the song. Fragments of melody are looped and auto-tuned into a wordless prayer; this is Blake at his trippy best.


6. Frank Ocean - Provider

He may have an incredible voice (a tender baritone, occasionally soaring into an angelic falsetto) but Ocean has grown increasingly interested in warping, distorting and enhancing his voice digitally. His 2016 album Blond(e) clothed his voice in countless effects, giving the album a schizophrenic, polyglossic quality.

When he returned with a crop of surprise songs in late 2017, this vocal experimentalism continued to explore new territory. His use of auto-tune was especially noticeable on 2017 track “Provider”. Name-checking Stanley Kubrick, the song has a futuristic, but heartfelt, bent, like a robot with a soul. The auto-tune's wobbly texture also gives the song a psychedelic flavour, as if sung through a smokey, druggy haze.


5. Cat Power - 3,6,9

Cat Power is not the first name that pops into your head when you think about auto-tune. The enigmatic American singer's first few albums graced shelves back in the 90s, when the vocal effect was just a glint in T-Pain's eye. These records featured melancholy, sparse arrangements with Power's vulnerably imperfect voice prominent in the mix.

But the singer’s 2012 return album Sun changed her style considerably, borrowing heavily from R&B production techniques. Bright keyboards, drum machines and buoyant bass lines replaced the stark minor piano chords of her earlier work. The vocals on the album featured occasional bursts of auto-tune, particularly in the harmonies: the effect is a sunny, warm bed of vocal texture on which she her voice flutters melodically.


4. Chance The Rapper - No Problem

There's a reason Chance the Rapper is more likely to just call himself "Chance" these days: he spends almost as much time singing as he does rapping. Whether it's covering the Arthur theme tune or sing-rapping on "Sunday Candy", he makes good use of his distinct thin voice.

But on Chance's ebullient 2016 track "No Problem", he used a thick, in-your-face dose of auto-tune as a loving homage to the vocal traits of Atlanta's rap scene. The song itself blends gospel positivity with hip-hop aggro. The result is something quite special, and the autotune gives his reedy voice a drunken, slurred edge. Even Lil Wayne's druggy contribution is swept up in the jovial atmosphere of camaraderie.


3. Kanye West - Say You Will

West’s album 808’s and Heartbreak left a lot of fans disappointed with its morose self-pity, poppy R&B production and heavy autotune on every track. True, the technique was often used to disguise the faults in West’s less-than-perfect voice, but occasionally it provided just the right vocal texture to accentuate the album’s wounded loneliness.

This is best seen on opening track “Say You Will”, a seriously underrated track in Ye's discography. Aided by a beautifully sombre minor-key melody and portentous chords, the track details Kanye's nocturnal longing, punctuated by flashes of something darker: lyrics like "when I touch your neck, I see your soul" lurk ambiguously between tenderness and aggression. A stunning remix was released in 2016, featuring violinist Caroline Shaw.


2. Vampire Weekend - Step

Vampire Weekend's first two albums arrived with a sound so perfectly distinct (the band wryly termed it "Upper West Side Soweto") that it became hard for them to outgrow the box that people had painted them into. Ezra Koenig's upbeat voice instantly became associated with the preppy, energetic image that the maturing band were attempting to move past.

So, for the album "Modern Vampires of the City", they teamed up with producer Ariel Rechtstaid and used his bag of vocal enhancement tools to give Ezra's vocals new textures. These are especially noticeable album standout track "Step". A subtle use of auto-tune and a technique called “formant-shifting” give Ezra Koenig’s vocals a meek, breathy quality which is especially noticeable in the song's refrain.


1. Sufjan Stevens - Impossible Soul

Like Bon Iver, indie-folkster Sufjan Stevens had outgrown his acoustic guitar by the early 2010s. This resulted in the extravagant, abrasive electronic sprawl of "Age of Adz", one of the last decade's weirder albums. An uneven and sometimes impenetrable experimental offering, the album's more outre moments were redeemed by the brilliant closer "Impossible Soul".

This 25-minute, four-suite masterpiece features a middle section smothered in a liberal dollop of autotune. Rather than concealing imperfect vocals, the effect serves to emphasise the singer’s chaotic, slippery state of mind. Stevens slides between emotions as dramatically as his voice shifts between notes. The section finds the anguished singer at his lowest ebb before he climbs towards redemption in the following sections. Find a dark room and listen to the track in full - you'll emerge a different person.


In this post: 
Kanye West
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Another wayward English graduate who makes money by arranging words into the correct order. Is really at it good!