Every Papa Roach Album Ranked From Worst To Best
The former nu metal figureheads have been kicking up a storm for nearly 30 years now.
The world was a much simpler place back in 2000. In the days before Facebook, smartphones and the inescapable presence of the internet, the simple lives we led back then already feel so long ago. Society isn't the only thing that has evolved since the introduction of the 21st century though, as music has morphed into a plethora of wide, diverse and captivating sounds over the past couple of decades, too.
Although the turn of the millennium will be remembered for many events spanning across all society, politics and culture, the nu metal explosion was surely a key moment for the latter. Bands such as Linkin Park, Korn, Slipknot, Saliva, Powerman 5000, Dry Kill Logic, Limp Bizkit, Spike 1000 and Coal Chamber defined the scene, but where are most of these names now? Nu metal dominated rock for three or four years, then vanished into oblivion along with most of the acts who defined it. Yet, a few survived.
One such group of survivors were California's Papa Roach, who emerged from the scene as an enduring talent, and one of a mere handful who are still going strong today. Alongside previously mentioned names like Slipknot and Korn, Papa Roach managed to evolve and change with the times, to avoid being swept away by them.
Here, we will look back at their journey through the years, ranking each of their records from worst to best.
12. Old Friends From Young Years
A mere handful of physical copies remain of this obscure and overlooked record, by the then no-name self-recording rap rock band, Papa Roach. Despite forming in the deceptively early year of 1993, Papa Roach didn't get round to releasing their first full length studio album until 1997, titled 'Old Friends From Young Years'.
The album was released via the band's own label, Onion Hardcore, and hardly made a splash against the surface of the American rock scene. In truth, 'Old Friends From Young Years' was a rough cut DIY release which did little to showcase the stardom Papa Roach would achieve in the decades to come. Yet, odd sparks of quality arise here and there, giving you a sense of the untapped potential which existed within the band.
Due to its self-release status and low sales, original CD copies of this album are like gold dust. The few 'Old Friends From Young Years' CD's available usually fetch prices upwards of £75 ($86), with some collectors willing to pay much more. On top of this, the majority of the songs which feature aren't available on YouTube, while the entire album is absent from Spotify.
11. Who Do You Trust?
Fastforward 22 years from Papa Roach's long forgotten debut album, we find ourselves looking at an album which isn't necessarily overlooked, but with all things considered it probably should be. 'Who Do You Trust?' was released in 2019 and followed on from 2017's 'Crooked Teeth' (which we'll be talking about shortly). The record continued the band's pop oriented era, having left their nu metal poster boy days in the dust long ago.
This continual path of constant successes evidently couldn't last forever mind, and the band's transition into pop produced rock music disenfranchised many of their fans, with this album being a key culprit. Newer fans discovering the band were seemingly given an unrealistic idea of what to expect from them, while old school fans felt they had been cut off by the band's gradual softening over the past three albums, which culminated on this critically panned record.
'Who Do You Trust?' was the band's lowest charting record in the United States since their obscure debut album, failing to break into the top 70. This theme persisted in most nations and even Belgium (a place where Papa Roach traditionally enjoys good chart success) suppressed the record to the lowly peak position of 131. Overall, 'Who Do You Trust?' is far from Papa Roach's proudest moment.
10. Crooked Teeth
One of the key elements to Papa Roach's honestly overlooked legacy is their longevity, which has been maintained by their ability to change while so many other bands from nu metal weren't able to do the same. Papa Roach are still around while the Spike 1000's and Mushroomhead's of the world aren't because they kept up, and 'Crooked Teeth' is a perfect example of them doing just that.
Released in 2017, 'Crooked Teeth' followed in the footsteps of its predecessor, 'F.E.A.R', by reaching into the currents of mainstream rock music through modernised production conventions and progressive perspectives. Although this isn't the band's most memorable or celebrated album, it received good reviews that generally averaged around a fair 7/10 mark.
The success of its singles is evident, as 'Help' alone has gathered over 24 million views on YouTube. Other singles such as the pounding arena rock anthem, 'Born For Greatness', and the more commercially viable 'American Dreams' also performed well, with the first of these earning 123 million Spotify streams to date.
Papa Roach's own label referred to them as 'dead' in 2004, yet they're still capable of pulling in such astonishing numbers on streaming services all these years later. If that doesn't scream survivalism, then what does?
9. Metamorphosis
Easily the band's least accessible album from the perspective of mainstream radio airplay due to the song narratives, 'Metamorphosis' saw the band take on a change of direction towards a darker directive. Released in 2009, 'Metamorphosis' was recorded at the famous Paramour Mansion in Hollywood, much like its predecessor, 'The Paramour Sessions', though it took on an extremely different form.
Inviting hints of glam rock into their sound for the first and only time alongside especially explicit lyrical themes, 'Metamorphosis' is (regardless of your personal opinion of it) Papa Roach's most standalone album. For once and perhaps the only time in Papa Roach's career though, the gamble struggled to pay off. The album received a generally lukewarm reception from fans and critics alike, despite a strong chart performance.
Songs such as 'Hollywood Whore' remain amidst the lofty heights of the band's most well-known tunes, but critics accuse the band of missing the glam rock point. Bands such as Twisted Sister and Motley Crue achieved success through the genre because they produced accessible, inviting and polarising singles. 'Hollywood Whore', although a good song, is none of these things. Other tunes include the equally gritty 'I Almost Told You That I Loved You', and the near polar opposite 'Lifeline'.
8. F.E.A.R
Papa Roach used their 2012 album, 'The Connection' as a stepping stone album to travel from the realms of gritty hard rock into crisp radio rock; a transition which was completed by 'F.E.A.R' in 2015. Throughout their storied career, Jacoby Shaddix and company have undergone a number of changes, with this album marking a shift into a relatively short-lived stage of atmospheric, radio friendly production mixed with softer sounding songs.
Although the album sold well upon release, it received widely differing verdicts from music critics. Cryptic Rock gave it a perfect 10, while Metacritic judged it a lowly score of 58/100, making it Papa Roach's second lowest scored album on the website. Regardless of overall criticisms for the record, there seems to be nothing but praise on display for the single, 'Gravity', which featured In This Moment's Maria Brink and is consistently considered the band's best ballad.
Interestingly, 'F.E.A.R' was the band's first album to perform better in the UK than it did the United States, becoming Papa Roach's most successful UK album chart entry since 'Lovehatetragedy' 13 years prior. At present, the songs of 'F.E.A.R' have gathered nearly a quarter of a billion Spotify streams and continue to rise every day.
7. Time For Annihilation
Strictly speaking, 'Time For Annihilation' isn't necessarily a full length studio album. Instead, it is more of a hybrid record set between the studio and live recordings. However, it is a full length album which features five new (at the time at least) studio recorded songs, so it makes the cut for this list.
'Time For Annihilation' was released in 2010 on the back end of Papa Roach's world tour, which was sparked by the 'Metamorphosis' album a year prior. Papa Roach had fallen away from their peak fame at the turn of the millenium as far as a mainstream audience was concerned, but they solidified their presence as a mainstay rock band throughout the remainder of the decade; a journey which was brought full circle by their huge tour.
This unique addition to the Papa Roach discography was opened by five brand new tunes, and owes its name to lyrics from the band's 2006 song, 'Crash' (a song which isn't included on the album). Following new songs such as 'No Matter What', 'One Track Mind' and 'Kick in the Teeth', the album transitions into live performances of the band's most well-known tunes.
6. Ego Trip
Coming into 2022, a majority of old school Papa Roach fans had become somewhat disenchanted by recent album campaigns. An invigorated focus on radio friendly rock conventions and production qualities drew the band towards pop at times, though fans who craved the grit of prior material were found wanting. This all changed though, thanks to the release of the band's twelfth (technically eleventh) studio album, 'Ego Trip', back in April.
As what must rank alongside the best comeback albums of the year, 'Ego Trip' delivered a level of enthusiasm, passion and focus that Papa Roach hadn't been able to achieve in at least a decade. Where the two (arguably three) albums which preceded it felt slightly generic and commercial, 'Ego Trip' wasn't afraid to show its teeth and bring some of that classic Papa Roach tenacity back to the surface, while also staying in tune with their modernised evolutions.
There isn't a bad song in sight on this record and it truly offers something for everyone. From the in-your-face, anthem tinted atmosphere of 'Kill the Noise', to the rap rock motivated beats of 'Liar', every song present manages to offer something completely unique. Other key songs include 'Swerve', 'No Apologies' and 'Killing Time'.
5. The Connection
As we creep into the top five, we first acknowledge what is potentially Papa Roach's most underrated album, 'The Connection'. Released in 2012, 'The Connection' represented a crucial turning point in the band's history, as they tried to look beyond a hard rock narrative they were quickly exhausting. Here, the band could either stick to their guns and settle, or push onto new challenges by experimenting with their style. Thankfully, they chose the latter.
Papa Roach used this album to delve into a cutting edge rock sound that was bolstered by bold production and infectious electronic undertones. 'The Connection' opened up new avenues within Papa Roach's style, and saw them releasing music which seemed alien compared to material they had become known for ten years prior. Yet, the brave switch paid off in emphatic fashion and fans praised the group's newfound energy.
Not only did this album introduce the band to a new generation of rock fans, but it also became their highest charting UK album since 'Getting Away With Murder' in the process. Top recommendations from this album include 'Where Did the Angels Go', 'Breathe You In' and 'Not That Beautiful'.
4. Getting Away With Murder
Music, as always, moved on from sudden trends and left most of the artists who defined the era behind. This was the case for the nu metal scene moving into 2003 and 2004, a reality which had crushing effects on many of the bands who'd been household rock names a year prior. A year later, many of them would no longer be together at all and Papa Roach had to think fast to avoid a similar fate.
Papa Roach recorded what would become the lead single for this album, presenting a rejuvenated rock sound which separated them from their native yet stagnating scene. But, they initially didn’t get the reception they hoped for. Even the band's record label, Geffen, said that Papa Roach were a 'dead band' after the collapse of the nu metal scene. However, as time went by the hostile response subsided and the band enjoyed immense success thanks to this great album.
'Getting Away With Murder' became the second of two Papa Roach albums to achieve platinum certification in the United States, making their second most success physical sales album ever. It also received silver certification in the UK, with 'Crooked Teeth' being the only record of theirs to match this feat since. Key songs include the title track, 'Scars', 'Take Me' and the dangerously underrated 'Tyranny of Normality'.
3. Lovehatetragedy
Contrary to popular belief, 'Infest' is not Papa Roach's most successful album in terms of chart performance, despite being their best selling record. Although the band's breakthrough album which featured the likes of 'Last Resort' and 'Between Angels & Insects' was a cornerstone of the nu metal scene, it was initially outdone by its overlooked predecessor, 'lovehatetragedy'.
Released in 2002, the band's third album had big boots to fill, but it performed to an exceptional standard nonetheless. Spearheaded by the lead single, 'She Loves Me Not', this record was immediately off to a promising start. 'She Loves Me Not' peaked at 14th in the UK singles chart and is still the band's second biggest UK chart single. The album itself then went to reached #4 in the UK albums chart, while it also reached the top 5 in the United States, Canada, Belgium and Switzerland.
'Lovehatetragedy' maintains the strong, influential nu metal sound that was established by 'Infest' through songs such as 'Time and Time Again', while other inclusions such as 'M-80' hinted at the band's impending transition into rock. Other key songs include 'Walking Thru Barbed Wire', 'Code of Energy' and perhaps the most overlooked song in Papa Roach's entire catalogue, 'Singular Indestructible Droid'.
2. Infest
No conversation about Papa Roach is truly complete without mentioning this exceptional album or its most famous inclusion, 'Last Resort'. Even now, 'Last Resort' remains the band's biggest single by a landslide, with the original album version of the song possessing over 800 million Spotify streams to date. The song has over four times the amount of streams as Papa Roach's second biggest Spotify single, 'Scars', which currently sits just below 200 million. But we're here to talk about the entire album, not just 'Last Resort'.
Released in 2000 through the now defunct Dreamworks Records, 'Infest' was an instant success which dwarfed even the highest of expectations that had been placed upon it. By the end of its release year, 'Infest' was amongst the top 20 biggest selling albums of the year and achieved platinum certification. Fast forward 22 years, the iconic nu metal album now has six platinum certifications worldwide, as well as three gold certifications.
'Infest' is generally held to similar heights as 'Hybrid Theory' and 'Follow the Leader', as one of the best albums to ever emerge from the nu metal genre. These high accolades were not achieved by one song though, as other inclusions such as 'Between Angels & Insects', 'Dead Cell' and 'Blood Brothers' all contribute immensely to the overall brilliance of this album too.
1. The Paramour Sessions
Despite the fact 'Infest' is far and away the biggest and most celebrated of Papa Roach's records, the immaculate quality of their 2006 album is simply untouchable. 'The Paramour Sessions' was the band's fifth studio album and the first of two to be recorded at the Paramour Mansion in Hollywood.
With this studio endeavour, Papa Roach extended their reach into the world of hard rock as the nu metal scene already started to feel like a distant memory. 'Getting Away With Murder' had opened the window of opportunity, and this record ran with that chance. Guided by singles such as 'To Be Loved' and 'Time is Running Out', this brilliant album went comparatively unnoticed when pitted against the records that have emerged since, but it was truly a defiant exclamation point in Papa Roach's career.
'The Paramour Sessions' is an unsung hero within Papa Roach's discography, bringing us some of the most underrated songs they have ever released. These include 'My Heart is a Fist', 'Forever', 'Crash' and 'Roses on my Grave'. Overall, 'Infest' and 'The Paramour Sessions' are both exceptional albums which easily surpass the 10/10 threshold, but the emotion, diversity and unmatched creativity of the latter gives it the edge, making it Papa Roach's best album.