Fall Out Boy: Ranking Every Album From Worst To Best

Which is their number one with a bullet?

Fall Out boy
Wikipedia

Critics and haters of Fall Out Boy can say what they want about the band's ventures into more pop-oriented territory, but the one thing you can never criticize them for is being stuck in their old habits. Stagnation isn't a word in Fall Out Boy's vocabulary, and their evolution from pop-punk darlings to arena-filling rock stars proves that.

The most amazing part about Fall Out Boy's career trajectory is how smooth and obvious it looks in hindsight. Because even while certain genre loyalists questioned each move away from "the scene" that birthed them - moving to a major label, collaborating with Jay-Z, experimenting with funk and '80s-inspired arena rock, and diving headlong into pop music - it all feels like such a natural progression now.

And it doesn't hurt that they've always retained their tongue-in-cheek phrasings and knack for crafting lethal singles.

Patrick Stump has repeatedly mentioned his disdain for trying to meet other people's expectations and follow trends, and it's clear the rest of the band feels the same way, even if they don't always agree on which direction to steer the ship.

Some people will always prefer the more underground, Warped Tour playing version of Fall Out Boy, but the die-hard fans can sit back and appreciate their transformation into one of the most exciting mainstream bands of the new millennium.

8. Make America Psycho Again

Make America Psycho Again Fall Out Boy
Island

It takes a lot to make a truly "bad" Fall Out Boy record, but the band nearly proved themselves capable of doing just that with this remix album. Though the simple fact that they narrowly avoided adding a real stinker to their discography further proves that Fall Out Boy are damn near bulletproof at this point.

It's not that the idea of a pop/rap crossover is a terrible one, it's just that this particular collection of remixes feels too lightweight and hamstrung by a lack of direction. Unlike say, the Linkin Park/Jay-Z Collision Course EP - which has a consistent theme and a solid through-line - Make America Psycho Again sounds like it's constantly chasing a thread that it never quite grasps onto.

More than a few tracks are made worse by slowed-down, sludgy production, zapping the original songs of their crispness and spunk. The Uzi remix of 'Novocaine', in particular, took a rave-ready song and brought down the tempo until its pulse was too faint to feel. 'Uma Thurman' also gets its main riff squished into oblivion - and let's face it, The Munsters homage is what makes that original song - resulting in a pretty plain dance track.

The CD is far from beyond redemption. Perhaps the most amazing feat this album pulled off is proving how Fall Out Boy's songs can really take a punch. It's no coincidence that even while the majority of these remixes are a marked deterioration from the originals, they're still pretty solid overall. That's the hallmark of quality songwriting.

Album Standout: 'Immortals (Remix)' feat. Black Thought


7. Fall Out Boy's Evening Out With Your Girlfriend

Fall Out Boy Evening Out With Your Girlfriend
Uprising

Although Fall Out Boy would rather be asked about those infamous leaked pictures of Pete Wentz's junk than this mini-LP, it has a rightful place in the band's lore and deserves to be accounted for in a list such as this.

No other Fall Out Boy album has pined for the sentiments of '80s pop culture as hard as this debut. To say they were wearing their hearts on their sleeves would be an understatement - they were holding their boomboxes high and practically begging John Hughes to make another movie so they could provide the soundtrack.

In between previews of the post-hardcore elements they were going to include in their next release - though 'Calm Before the Storm' appears sludgier and less screamy than it does on Take This To Your Grave - Fall Out Boy spends the majority of this disc sinking into that fluttery, New Found Glory sound.

'Pretty In Punk' is the type of lightweight pop-punk they'd soon leave in the dust, while the bass lines in 'The World's Not Waiting (For Five Tired Boys In A Broken Van)' sound copy and pasted from an early Blink-182 song.

All in all, it's more than a little derivative, but still a whole lot of fun.

Album Standout: 'Moving Pictures'


6. American Beauty/American Psycho

American Beauty American Psycho Fall Out Boy
Island

If you're anything like me, the first time you heard that surf-rock Munsters sample in 'Uma Thurman', you got uncomfortable flashbacks to all those Black Eyed Peas songs that used samples of old, slightly obscure songs to make up for the fact that they had nothing original to offer.

But then, once you stopped being such a reactionary doofus and actually listened to what Fall Out Boy was bringing to the table, those fears ski-tattled. And a lot of this album had a similar effect.

To borrow some of that infamous Pete Wentz parlance, American Beauty/American Psycho is a grower, not a shower.

Weirdly enough, this has nothing to do with the songs' lack of catchiness. In fact, from top to bottom, this could very well be the most stylish, hook-heavy album the boys have ever released. They embrace chanting like never before, while instrumentally they're using anything and everything to get the job done, whether that be horns, strings, or whistling. Foot-tapping melodies are clearly not the issue.

Really, the need for some of these tracks to grow on you comes down to their quirkiness. That playfulness doesn't always hit strong right out of the gate, but it damn sure builds on each repeated listen. This could very well be the album that gets spun the most by loyal FOB fans in the long run.

Album Standout: 'Jet Pack Blues'


5. Take This To Your Grave

Fall Out Boy Take This To Your Grave
Fueled By Ramen

Nostalgia carries a lot of weight with pop-punk albums, and since this was most die-hard fans' entry point to the band, it's tough to shake the feelings you get listening to a song as passionate and blissfully naive as 'Homesick at Space Camp'. When you get into your car on a summer day and roll the windows down, the teenager inside you doesn't want to hear a deep cut from American Beauty/American Psycho.

Hell no, it wants to hear 'Dead On Arrival'. And you know what? There's definitely nothing wrong with that instinct.

Because at its heart, Take This To Your Grave is the sound of teenagers pressing as hard as they can on the gas pedal, even as they swerve around sharp corners, narrowly avoiding head-on collisions that would blow up the whole damn car. The energy is infectious, even if the second half of the album does start to feel a little same-y at times.

There's an air of romanticism around these songs that will likely never fade. Fall Out Boy fans are well aware there are better songs in their discography than 'Saturday', but do you get the same kind of pleasure from them as you do when you belt out 'Two more weeks / My foot is in the door, yeah'? Do you get goosebumps the same way you do during the opening riff of 'Grand Theft Autumn'?

Probably not.

Album Standout: 'Saturday'


4. Save Rock And Roll

Save Rock and Roll
Island

Where you stand on Fall Out Boy's evolution - or if you even want to call it that - will largely dictate your feelings on Save Rock and Roll. Is this one splash too many in the shallow end of the pop music pool? Or the first step in conquering mainstream pop radio and validating their climb out of the punk scene?

Rolling Stone suggested in their review of Save Rock and Roll that Fall Out Boy had "delusions of grandeur" with their comeback, and their "over-the-top ambitions" were something of a joke. But it turns out the joke was on Rolling Stone, as well as every critic who failed to catch the not-so-subtle winking sentiments of their bold declarations.

Besides, since when did a little grandeur ever hurt rock music?

Certainly not on Save Rock and Roll, which thumps with grandiose melodies and a sonic palette that really stretches its legs. Despite the album's title, this isn't exactly a big, chugging, guitar-based offering. No, Fall Out Boy instead takes a more layered approach to "saving rock and roll."

Believe it or not, this might also be the band's most sincere offering. They don't hide behind as many cheeky pop culture references and clever turns of phrase as they used to, and they finally sound completely free of the shackles that made them indebted to the Warped Tour crowd.

Anyone who thinks bombastic choruses and earnestness can't go hand-in-hand needs to give this album another listen.

Album Standout: 'The Phoenix'


3. From Under The Cork Tree

Fall Out Boy From Under the Cork Tree
Island

While this is probably the last Fall Out Boy album that could be firmly placed in the category of pop-punk, From Under the Cork Tree certainly doesn't shy away from its bigger rock star ambitions.

The choruses are meatier, the hooks are spicier, and the songs have more individual flavor to them than Take This To Your Grave. And for the first time, we can hear the possibility of a Fall Out Boy song being played in a stadium, rather than a basement or club.

Don't get me wrong, it's not as if they all of a sudden ditched their roots in favor of the U2 life, but 'Dance, Dance' - which has more interesting nooks and crannies than the whole of TTTYG - clearly has a different target audience in mind.

"Hello, MTV? It's Fall Out Boy. Are you guys still playing music videos? Because if so, do we have the song for you..."

Yet, you can't help but appreciate how incremental the changes in their sound are. For lack of a less obnoxious word, Cork Tree really does feel like an organic growth for Fall Out Boy. They still appeased their hardcore loyalists - 'A Little Less Sixteen Candles' sounds a little like a sequel to 'Grand Theft Autumn' - while delving into some interesting dynamics as well.

Album Standout: 'Dance, Dance'


2. Infinity On High

Fall Out Boy Infinity On High
Island

"The second you worry about other people’s expectations is the second you can expect failure...We don’t sit around second-guessing everything. If you do that, you’re bound to make sterile music, and that’s when you can expect failure." - Patrick Stump

Consider the above quote Infinity On High's mission statement. Even though the band had experienced a little bit of mainstream affection thanks to the strength of From Under the Cork Tree's dynamite singles, they'd never been put in the position of making an album while inside the mainstream spotlight.

How would they deal with it? Would they anger their diehard fans by significantly expanding their sound? Or would they retain some of their signature guitar-and-drums pop-punk sound? The answer to all of the above: Yes. Because as much as critics at the time decried this as something of a "sellout" record, Infinity On High firmly plays both sides of the fence quite well.

There are still punchy, fast-and-dirty tracks that would be natural follow-ups to TTTYG ('Fame < Infamy', 'The Carpal Tunnel of Love'), but they deftly embrace more rhapsodic, dramatic melodies elsewhere, which sounds like it should result in little more than an entertaining identity crisis.

But somehow, it all gels.

Album Standout: 'This Ain't A Scene, It's An Arms Race'


1. Folie À Deux

Fall Out Boy Folie a Deux
Island

Here it is. The moment when Fall Out Boy lays it all out on the table for anyone still curious about the band's ambitions. They are not the little pop-punk band that you can fit in your pocket. Not anymore. They want more than that and they want their fans to expect more than that from their albums.

And with that, the hangers-on willing to overlook Infinity On High as the band's "experimental phase" promptly unjoined the Fall Out Boy fan club and unhitched their wagons once and for all. It's all good, though, as it only opened up more room for fans of operatic vocal harmonies, big bursting choruses, and smirking melodrama.

Much of Folie à Deux - French for "a madness shared by two" - plays like a big-budget docudrama about the history of music. They journey through all the big eras, touching on The British Invasion, the Rockabilly revival of the '70s, and glam rock with equal aplomb. But most surprisingly, it's not jarring in the least. Everything flows as it should, their core style shining through without overreaching into any one particular genre.

And let's be honest here, all of the critical backlash and subsequent bandwagon overhaul was worth it if only for the last couple of minutes of 'What A Catch, Donnie'. Have you ever heard such a beautiful ballad come from a "joke" punk band?

Album Standout: 'What A Catch, Donnie'


Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.