Rihanna: Ranking Her Albums From Worst To Best
Robyn Rihanna Fenty is one of the biggest names in the world right now and has become, quite rightly, a massive global star. Of course the world knows her under a sole name - 'Rihanna'. For the past seven years, Rihanna has emerged from being a vaguely catchy purveyor of pop music to one of the most influential, monitored and beloved women on the planet. Always a step ahead of the musical curve, she made house pop catchy before it hit its stride and sent us all clamoring for our spacey midtempo ballads before we even knew she wanted them. Quite what makes Rihanna such a culturally phenomenon is a mystery - perhaps it's that thin line she treads between being explicit and being enjoyable. Equally cheeky, sassy and saucy, mothers might be shocked and outraged at some of her on-stage antics, but they'll still dance to her songs in a club and sing along with everyone else. She's the antidote to the picture perfect pop, or rather takes it and makes it her own - if Katy Perry is the preppy cheerleader and Gaga is the weird nerd, Rihanna is most certainly the bad girl, the unashamed, unabashed rebel of the pop world. She takes the best parts of pop and adapts it to herself and her team, and transforms era-to-era to suit her own purposes. Having released seven albums in as many years, Rihanna's sound and image has dramatically changed per era, from a sun-kissed island princess to a sexy R&B pin-up to the dark avenging angel to the irreverent, 'no-damns-given' star of any show she attends. Rihanna has more than secured her place in musical history and so have her albums, but with regards as to which is the top of the pile, plenty of people have their own differing opinions as to which secures the top spot. Here's my own listing...
7. 'Music Of The Sun' (2006)
Rihanna's first album, 'Music of the Sun' is definitely her weakest to date, lacking a general direction or cohesiveness that even her most disjointed albums possess. While not necessarily a 'bad album', nothing much about 'Music of the Sun' stands out as being original, inventive or anything other than cheap and disposable. The album feels very much like a two-dimensional introduction and so the songs about partying and romance feel a touch uninspired and make for a debut album that fails to make a solid or lasting impression upon the listener. Songs such as the lifeless cover of Dawn Penn's 'You Don't Know Me (No No No) and the numerous reggae and dancehall-flavoured duets on the album do nothing much to save the album, and while 'If It's Lovin' That You Want' is pleasant enough, it too falls prey to the amount of filler on the album and fails to truly stand out against the array of generic dance tunes on offer, particularly in the case of 'Here I Go' and 'There's A Thug In My Life' which fade from the memory quicker than their actual song duration. 'The sole saving grace of the album is debut single 'Pon de Replay' which remains a catchy dancehall-pop number that is simple and effective in its repetitiveness and sunny demeanour and which allowed Rihanna to emerge as a new threat to the mid-2000s wave of popstars going through creative changes - Britney was a year away from her famed breakout, Christina was on top of her game but not making a huge aural impression, and Beyonce was only just breaking out of her 'Destiny's Child' bubble. 'Pon de Replay' positioned Rihanna as a distinctly un-American popstar who used her Bajan heritage and Caribbean roots to set herself apart from her pop contemporaries and so made her a fun breath of fresh air in the stale pop world. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oEauWw9ZGrA Unfortunately not even this one ray of light could redeem 'Music of the Sun', which looking back now seems rather like a postcard picture of the Bahamas, all invitingly shiny and sunny at first glance but nothing much beneath the surface.
6. 'A Girl Like Me' (2007)
The first album that really positioned Rihanna as a future global superstar in the making with a score of moderate and catchy hits that took Rihanna from the realm of being a one-hit-wonder into being a proper popstar. The album emerged with two major hits on its hands that proved to be big across the globe in the form of two very different and yet strangely equal smash hits that made people finally sit up and pay attention to Ms Fenty. The first is electropop thumper 'SOS' which became a template for party tunes for the next few years with its infectious sledgehammer beats and the sexy, sensual transformation of Rihanna from a party girl into a seductive siren, as evidenced by the memorable video. 'SOS' is perhaps the first of Rihanna's singles that aimed at the dancefloor but eschewed her reggae and dancehall roots in favour of a strong R&B/dance sound which complimented her strong vocals well. The second smash single was a complete U-turn from the sensual 'SOS' - 'Unfaithful' was and still is a remarkable single in many respects as it deals with a popular musical topic (infidelity) but portrays it from the idea of a woman cheating and makes her both sympathetic and likeable. In music, infidelity is usually reserved for bad boys and the women who love them, the women either heartbroken over their wandering men or defiantly breaking up with them; in 'Unfaithful', the musical point-of-view changes and stops portraying the female singer as the victim and instead as the perpetrator. Rihanna becomes both protagonist and the 'bad girl', cheating on her boyfriend with a more exciting lover, making it an interesting song to say the least and a surprisingly feminist one at that as it both promotes female agency and humanises the adulterous woman archetype in the media. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rp4UwPZfRis However, a lot of the album is filler with generic reggae and dancehall that has not aged well and which falls flat in the face of its two biggest singles. The album showed promise and in its two lead cuts, unwittingly showed the two sides of Rihanna that would become her template - aggressive, confident and in control of her sexuality and agency, and then the vulnerable, heartbroken, achingly human side. Unfortunately, despite a fair bit of solid production, the album falls flat in terms of Rihanna's overall discography. It's decent enough, but not really one for the ages, which is a shame given that it gave her two of her strongest, most memorable singles to date.
5. 'Loud' (2010)
RiRi's most 'pop' album to date, the sunny sounds and effervescently irreverent sound was a breath of fresh air after the tumultuous and dark 'Rated R' era. Kicking back onto the music scene as a fully-fledged superstar with lead single 'Only Girl In The World', RIhanna symbolised the beginning of a new more positive era with a bright smile, flame red hair and a sweeter, happier demeanour now that her demons had been laid to rest and her public persona secured. The album is a reflection of the same themes, albeit with little to no cohesion - the sinister dancehall tune 'Man Down' sits alongside overwrought ballad 'California King Bed' and ultra-smutty sex anthem 'S&M' with no sonic or lyrical arcs that dominate the album or even define it really. There are still signs of her vulnerability here - 'Skin' is a strange, subdued ballad that becomes so much more, while 'Complicated', an electropop tune becomes a heartfelt ode to her past troubles that seems to signify Rihanna continuing to deal with her issues to the present day, rather than making a clean cut and fresh start. Whether or not this is a deliberate attempt or not remains unknown - after the dark 'Rated R' era, Rihanna seemed to be putting all her efforts into going the other way and becoming a breezy, brazenly joyous character. There are more classic 'party anthems' and fun songs than normal, and the sonic spectrum she explores is so disparate and wide, she seems to painting with every colour she has available on her musical palate, rather than the shades of blood red and grey she had previously equipped herself with. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZR0v0i63PQ4 However, this remains Rihanna's biggest 'singles' album, full of chart-topping hits that dominated radio for most of 2010 and 2011. Sultry duet 'What's My Name' with Canadian rapper/crooner Drake and Avril-Lavigne-sampling party anthem 'Cheers (Drink To That)' are both solid, fun songs that remain catchy to this day, while album closer 'Love The Way You Lie, Part II' transforms her mega-smash team-up with Eminem from a ferocious rap-pop anthem into a vulnerable and beautiful track that she makes her own and symbolises her own personal heartaches. Well worth the price of admission, if not her finest work.
4. 'Good Girl Gone Bad' (2008)
Rihanna had become one of the most hotly-tipped young stars without a solid 'hit' album that had given her the significant boost she needed to make it as a full-on popstar. Fortunately third album 'Good Girl Gone Bad' more than provided this with plenty of singles including lead single 'Umbrella' that launched her into the pop stratosphere with its R&B sound and pop hook. Rihanna jettisoned her previous dancehall and reggae leanings, instead opting for mor of an R&B-pop sound with singles such as the MJ-sampling 'Don't Stop the Music', aggressive 'Shut Up & Drive' and Justin Timberlake-guesting 'Rehab' becoming successful songs in the eyes of the music-buying public. Even so, the album tracks began to catch up to the strength of the singles - Timbaland's impressive production on songs like 'Sell Me Candy' and 'Lemme Get That' elevate the songs while the R&B production by contemporaries such as Ne-Yo, StarGate and Justin Timberlake made this a much more cohesive listen and a more enjoyable LP as a result. Point in fact, the success of 'Good Girl Gone Bad' lead to a re-release with several new tracks, leading to hits such as 'Take A Bow' and 'Disturbia' enjoying the same level of success as their predecessors. The 'Reloaded' edition of 'Good Girl Gone Bad' saw the beginning of a more mature side to Rihanna - 'Take A Bow' is very much the sequel to 'Unfaithful' with Rihanna this time taking on the role of the wounded woman and becoming a brilliantly ballsy, independent woman who tosses the possessions of her cheating lover out the door with a smirk. Best of all might be 'Disturbia', an inventive and excellent pop song that saw Rihanna dip her toes into the dark image that she would later full-on adopt, with a song that incorporated mental illness metaphor and romance into a danceable song that was the spiritual precursor to Lady Gaga's 'Bad Romance' a couple of years later. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E1mU6h4Xdxc 'Good Girl Gone Bad' was not a hugely exciting album, when it all comes down to it, singles aside - it was certainly solid, but there were no real standouts or experiments that made anyone consider her a true artist, for example. However, it was a crucial and vital stepping stone in Rihanna's musical career and was the first album to offer a solid foundation for her to begin her career with the eyes of the world watching and considering her as someone that the world of pop should be keeping a very close eye on the immediate future...
3. 'Talk That Talk' (2011)
Following off the back of the erratic and joyous 'Loud', Rihanna turned a little more electronic to her next single, the dance-house-pop 'We Found Love' which had considerable production for Scottish producer Calvin Harris. The song went on to become Rihanna's biggest single, being performed at the closing ceremony of the 2012 Paralympic Games, and was voted on several websites as the best song of 2011. The song is, certainly, a joyous blast of EDM with Rihanna providing strong and emotional vocals that made it the must-play-tune for the fourth quarter of 2011. 'We Found Love' kickstarted the 'Talk That Talk' campaign which saw Rihanna shift to a largely electronic and dance sound as well as channeling some of the boisterous, irreverent attitude that has marked Rihanna's public persona. Songs like the anthemic dance tune 'Where Have You Been', the ballsy 'Roc Me Out' and the sassy, sexy interlude 'Birthday Cake' were all marked with a strong electronic sound production and an equally strong shift in Rihanna's persona. Gone was the sweet and cheeky girl of the 'Loud' campaign and in its place was a moody, aggressively confident woman who engaged openly in recreational drugs abuse and was as bad a typical 'role model' as any middle-class mother could have worried about. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tg00YEETFzg This same sonic aggression and arrogance makes 'Talk That Talk' such a thrill ride at times - the back-to-back delight of 'Where Have You Been' and 'We Found Love' is a miniature story in itself of young love and longing set against a blistering electronic backdrop. Rihanna has never been a morally responsible popstar but 'Talk That Talk' finds her at her most carefree and disparaging - the title track is a swaggering ode with mentor Jay-Z behind her, while bonus tracks like 'Red Lipstick' and 'Do Ya Thing' are snarky and full of strong electronic production; the former's dubstep-heavy beats are of considerable note. That's not to say the whole album is full of fierce tunes - 'You da One' is a meandering reggae ballad that fails to live up to its full potential, although album closer 'Farewell' fares much better with its rock-tinged production and 'Fool In Love' is ultimately sweet beneath the surface. Fortunately, it's still a largely strong album that usually lives up to its confident premise and kept Rihanna poised as the world's biggest star.
2. 'Unapologetic' (2012)
The latest album to emerge from Rihanna, making it her seventh album in as many years, 'Unapologetic' proved that from era to era, Rihanna was more than capable of making big sonic shifts and keeping the listeners and fans more than hooked on her every word, making her one of the few musicians and popstars whose entire sound can adapt so diversely and yet retain a loyal fanbase. 'Unapologetic' is led by a more midtempo R&B-pop sound overall, although the diversions away from this sound are more than notable - catwalk trap anthem 'Phresh Out The Runway' is a strut-worthy treat while David Guetta channels his brand of house-pop production into 'Right Now' and the two-songs-in-one epic that is 'Love Is Tragedy/Mother Mary', a personal pair of songs that change from depressing to quietly uplifting on a corkscrew turn, exploring religious and spiritual themes alongside ones of insecurity, pain and recovery after the loss of a major relationship. Rihanna experimented much more with her sound and with the themes she was willing to explore - 'Pour It Up' is typical 'drunk-in-the-club' fare but 'Numb' hides feelings of isolation and feeling numb on the inside, hidden within a drug allegory. Album standout, 'Half of Me', becomes an anthemic ballad that Rihanna has never conquered before, combining emotional and introspective lyrics that reflect on her life and yet feel applicable to a lot of people too as it references the trouble with celebrity culture. In this, she addresses the two sides of her public persona - the unrepentant woman, and the girl behind her - to astonishingly honest and powerful effect. The strongest tracks, however, are the ones that utilise this R&B-pop sound to full effect - 'What Now' is a blistering and emotional R&B-dubstep tune, 'Lost In Paradise' is a chilled out reggae-esque standout and lead single 'Diamonds' uses pulsing pop beats and a warm, chilled vibe to create a stadium-sized anthem. Even the album's now-iconic cover is tellling - on it she is both edgy and laid bare, naked and tattooed, the story of her album and her life literally written all over her. She has become stripped away and the truth lies on her and inside the music. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lWA2pjMjpBs 'Unapologetic' is certainly one of Rihanna's most personal albums and one that deals with her introspection over her relationship to fame and her controversial ex-beau Chris Brown who features on the spirited 'Nobody's Business'. It's an album whose emotional context that is matched by being sonically innovative and diverse - there are enough mainstream hits on the album to keep Rihanna's momentum going, but plenty of diversions and intriguing aural gymnastics to make sure it's a solid, enjoyable listen.
1. 'Rated R' (2009)
Rihanna's relationship with R&B singer Chris Brown provided more than its fair share of industry fodder when Brown was arrested for viciously assaulting the singer following the 2009 Grammys and so the idea of this dream-team R&B couple was forever tainted despite future reunions and collaborations. Rihanna took time out and returned months later with 'Russian Roulette', a fiercely dark, bitter rock ballad that was as captivating as it was arresting. This was the start of the 'Rated R' era and the most cohesive, sonically impressive and thematically challenging and mature album Rihanna's ever produced. 'Rated R', quite obviously, came out of a dark place in Rihanna's personal life and so seems to be both a reflection or her thoughts, ideas and internal reactions following the incident, and a catharsis of how she was able to assess, recognise and cope with said incident. Rihanna transforms from the sexy singer of 'Disturbia' and 'Umbrella' into a gun-toting, vengeance-seeking valkyrie with songs such as the positively sinister 'Wait Your Turn' and aggressive 'Hard' establishing Rihanna as the most fearsome of opponents, her vocals oozing an angry menace and fury that is not only palpable, but uncomfortably so. Despite the rage fuelling through her veins, the album also contains themes of restoration 'Rockstar 101' is a cocky and brash self-empowerment anthem that is the dark flipside to positive and similarly-themed tunes as Rihanna tells both the listener and herself that she is able to overcome her current situation. This same empowerment becomes physical in 'G4L' where she leads a troop of similarly downtrodden and battled women who begin to seek their revenge against the people who wronged them. Even the brighter cuts like the only danceable single, 'Rude Boy', is a snarling call-out to the males, challenging their conceptions of gender roles and masculinity in which Rihanna becomes both siren and emasculating scythe. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZQ2nCGawrSY Paradoxically, this album is simultaneously Rihanna's most aggressive and equally most vulnerable as she trades turns of being the enraged heroine with much more emotional and heartbroken songs that display the woman beneath the leather and spikes that made up the 'Rated R' image. For every 'Hard', there is a 'Fire Bomb', a dramatic R&B-rock ballad that is full of sad regret and anger in equal measure, and the songs such as 'Stupid in Love' and 'Cold Case Love' are full of loathing and sadness. Album closer 'The Last Song' is a suicide-themed ode which is the culmination of the emotional arc Rihanna goes onto during the album, allowing herself armor and vulnerability in order to work through a horrific and traumatic event. But, 'Rated R' offers some hope the album is much more than the dramatically bleak showcase of a woman going through a horror with the eyes of the world on her, it is a cathartic expression which allows Rihanna to channel her negative experiences and overcome them, however slowly it might take. Boasting a slick production and lyrics as profound and heartfelt as we've ever heard from her, 'Rated R' is certainly Rihanna's best album and one that deserves your time and attention, no matter how dark going down the rabbit hole may be. So, do you agree with my ranking of Rihanna's albums? Think one of them should have shuffled higher than any of the others? Let me know in the comments below...