The Smiths: Ranking Their Albums Worst To Best

The Smiths are one of those bands who formed a remarkable legacy and a massive cult following despite only having a very short run time (1982-1987). Whether it was Morrissey's unique fashion, mannerisms (on and off stage) or unheard of before lyrical style that drew fans in, or Marr's wizardry on an electric guitar. It is undeniable to see their influence upon British pop music with current bands such as The Heartbreaks, Oasis (Noel Gallagher being a confessed fan of their music) and The Courteeners referencing them within songs, interviews or replicating their sound in the case of The Heartbreaks.
But there's not much better to copy. Five years and four almost flawless studio albums have spoiled Smiths fans, with many a debate breaking out over which of these deserves the crowning title of ultimate Smiths album. From those believing their beginning showed them at their purest in "The Smiths" to those stating that by the time "Strangeways, Here We Come" had erupted onto the scene, they had reached their ultimate potential and ended upon their highest note.
Regardless of the conclusion reached however, it is always agreed that it was a close call to choose when every album is impossibly close in quality. Whilst each album following the debut never technically changed the formula for indie rock which would unknowingly set the standard for the genre for years to follow.
They didn't have to though, with nothing else in their day or even now being able to replicate the same style or respect that they received upon every new release. But without dwelling on that, the first on the list and the "worst" Smiths album is...
4. Meat Is Murder
The Smiths second album released in 1984 is not a bad album by any means, just unfortunately one that is crushed under it's own pretension. The title was construed from Morrissey's now famous views upon those who kill animals for their own gain. As a self proclaimed vegan he felt that this album would be the perfect way to spread his message and convince the masses to stop the slaughter. This didn't work however with the title track coming over as bizarre and unsettling, but not in the intended manner. It is due to odd production choices, such as opening with the droning electronic buzz of slaughterhouse machinery accompanied by a repetitive bovine cry for the first minute of the song, which make it difficult to listen to rather than the message that is being preached. This is however one of the very few undeniably bad Smiths songs, which unfortunately is placed right at the end of the album and as of such leaves a sour overall impression of an otherwise impressive record. Songs such as "The Headmaster Ritual", "Nowhere Fast" and "Rusholme Ruffians" are highlights, showing the same emotional power and musical prowess that had been displayed throughout their debut but developing more upon the humour in Morrissey's lyrics. Such as the titular Headmaster of "The Headmaster Ritual" being cut down to size swiftly in "Sir leads the troops, jealous of youth, same old suit since 1962" It is a shame overall that such moments of brilliance are undercut by a perpetual reminder of the underwhelming title track with each listen of the album. Because whilst not a bad album overall per se, it is because of this that in the eyes of many Smiths fans it remains the weakest in their repertoire being seen as a good album overall weakened by one awful song, rather than the great one it is without it.
3. Strangeways, Here We Come
Up next is the band's swansong "Strangeways, Here We Come", recorded in 1987, the same year as the breakup of The Smiths with Marr leaving before the album's release in September. Musically it was perhaps the most ambitious record the band made, moving away on certain tracks from the standard guitar based pop that had dominated earlier efforts and allowed the band to attempt to be seen as more than just a basic pop band, much in the same vein as The Beatles' ventures in psychedelia, only on a much more toned down level. Whilst this certainly provides the listener with a more varied experience, it can't help be felt that perhaps some more time could have been used to develop this new sound. Songs such as opening track "Rush And A Push And The Land Is Ours" illustrate these feelings especially, with Marr's outstanding guitar work replaced by Morrissey on piano and a chorus of synthesised sounds which serve to make the song sound more surreal rather than memorable. That's not to say all of the more adventurous tracks were complete misfires though, in fact "Death Of A Disco Dancer" would have been a promising sign of things to come, had the band stuck together, with it's gradual evolution of the regular Smiths sound to a gothic explosion of piano and strings which wouldn't have sounded out of place on one of the better albums by The Cure. Success such as this shows the band's capability as well as ambition to change and stay relevant. But even at their best, these never quite stand up to the more classic styled Smiths songs present such as "Stop Me If You Think You've Heard This One Before" and "I Started Something I Couldn't Finish" which with three albums of practice making, prove to be some of their best yet and stand as highlights of not just the album but of their career.
2. The Smiths
In at second best is the band's debut, which still stands to this day as an example of just how good a debut album can be. It wasted no time getting the listener adjusted to The Smith's unique style with opening track "Reel Around The Fountain" wearing that grim humour, of which Morrissey has made a living off of, like a badge of honour. It's tale of teenage desperation and angst unraveling gradually without ever seeming bleak or depressing due to lyrics such as "I dreamt about you last night, and I fell out of bed twice" ensuring that it remains a lighthearted affair. This level of excellence continues throughout, with tracks such as "Miserable Lie" in which Morrissey tests the flexibility of his vocal chords by attempting to achieve pitches that no man should, "This Charming Man" which highlighted Johnny Marr's remarkable skill on guitar via one of the most instantly recognisable introductory riffs ever backed with a powerful bass line from Andy Rourke and "Hand In Glove" which served as the band's first single as well as a fan favourite still to this day, and with some of the best lyrics on an already impressive album paired with Johnny Marr, Andy Rourke and Mike Joyce all performing at exemplary levels, it's not hard to see why. Also the album showed that these darkly comical tracks were not all there was to the band, that they could show a real maturity in their writing when they wanted to. This is most noticeable in the final two songs on the record "I Don't Owe You Anything" and "Suffer Little Children" both fairly melancholic affairs. With the latter's repeated line of "Manchester, so much to answer for" feeling like a plea for help from Morrissey as he tries to convey his desperation to escape the town he felt trapped within during his youth to the listener without interrupting the main narrative of the song. It's moments like these that cause the record to stand out as one of the most impressive by the band, which is narrowly kept from the top spot.
1. The Queen Is Dead
As if it was going to be anything else. Ironically the Smith's crowning glory is their masterpiece from 1986 with it's controversy baiting title that attacked the royal family straight on. From the start you know this is The Smiths performing at their very best, with Joyce and Rourke's aggressive introduction on the opening track "The Queen Is Dead" joined by Marr's immaculate guitar playing and some of the most poignant yet comical lyrics written by Morrissey as he questions the worth of the monarchy and the values by which the British public who follow them religiously live. The album covers a diverse range of topics from the aforementioned monarchy to record producers in "Frankly Mr Shankly". A song presented as a fictional letter to the head of Rough Trade records as a mockery of him, due to Morrissey's displeasure at the deal he gave the band, backed by Andy Rourke's strongest work with The Smiths. It also shows a real progression musically for the band. In example "Bigmouth Strikes Again" remains one of their finest moments featuring an implausible performance from Marr throughout along with some of the most impressive drumming Mike Joyce ever performed during the band's short existence. Also present is the best love song about death ever recorded "There Is A Light That Never Goes Out" in the penultimate position on the album, with it's bittersweet lyrics complimented by fantastic musical performances from all involved, it's not hard to see why it's as popular as it is. And whilst that may have been one of the few to go on to achieve enormous acclaim from everyone that has ever heard it, it still isn't the most impressive on the album! Outdone by the genius present upon "The Boy With The Thorn In His Side" "I Know It's Over" and "Cemetery Gates" to name but a few. For these reasons alone "The Queen Is Dead" remains The Smiths finest album, without a single song present that you feel the desire to skip upon hearing, it remains an example of just how great a genre pop music can be when done correctly. Do you agree? Let us know in the comments below!