10 Players Who Didn't Fulfil Their Potential At Arsenal

Despite promising early signs, these players never quite cut the mustard for the Gunners.

With the 2014/15 transfer window so far seeming to be one of the more successful markets of Arsene Wenger's Arsenal career in recent years, it's easy to forget that the long-serving Frenchman has been regularly criticised over the years for buying players who turned out to be serious flops upon arrival at the club. Unfortunately for Mr. Wenger, a lot of that criticism has been well-founded and he has overseen more than his fair share of remarkably unsuccessful transfer deals during his time. Those players who, after an initial bout of optimism and joy amongst fans at their arrival, became bitter disappointments very quickly. It's the nature of the game; some players just don't become a success at certain clubs. This means that for every Thierry Henry signed by a club, there will be a Nicklas Bendtner waiting in the wings to stumble onto the scene and restore the balance. So we are here to take a look at ten players who have failed to fulfil their initial potential at Arsenal. While most of these players will have been purchased from other clubs amongst a cloud of optimism and excitement, one or two will have been academy products who burst onto the scene full of promise and talent only to ultimately disappoint. These are players who, unlike some absurd choices, did actually give cause for some promise at the club only to fall short of fulfilling it. Here are ten players who failed to fulfil their potential at Arsenal.

10. Nicklas Bendtner

Confidence can be a marvellous thing for a footballer. How many times have pundits and journalists commented on the poor form of a particular player and asserted that he looks "short of confidence" on the pitch? Confidence in one's own ability can truly play a massive role in how successful a player can be. Overconfidence can be a somewhat disastrous thing for a player, however, especially if it is unfounded and not really being backed up on the pitch. Nicklas Bendtner is a shining example of an overconfident footballer, and it really has formed a large part of his undoing. Quoted on numerous occasions about his own ability, Bendtner has always been very quick to talk himself up off the pitch. The problem is that, despite chiming in with one or two important goals for Arsenal over his nine years, he has never been enough of a threat when tasked with leading the line for the Gunners. Bendtner's confidence in himself has elevated him to the status of a cult hero in the last year, however his poor performances on the pitch have seen him fall drastically short of his self-appointed high billing.

9. Andrei Arshavin

After bursting into the Premier League in his first half season, Andrei Arshavin struggled to live up to the early promise that his initial performances, and earlier roles for his country, suggested he could fulfil. At one time Arsenal's record transfer signing, Arshavin certainly never fulfilled his potential with the Gunners. It's regularly suggested that Arshavin struggled to cope with the physicality and pace of the Premier League once defences became familiar with his playing style. Seen as being a rather leisurely player, Arshavin's apparent refusal to play his part in the defensive side of the game and unwillingness to track back up when opposition teams were in possession quickly demonstrated that he was not suited to a league where all eleven players in a team are becoming equally responsible for their team's attacking and defending. Despite a memorable four goal masterclass in Arsenal's 2009 4-4 with Liverpool at Anfield and his scoring of the winning goal when Arsenal beat Barcelona 2-1 in the Champions League in 2011, Andrei Arshavin's time at Arsenal will largely be regarded as a disappointment. Fans of the club will probably allow him a slightly more favourable view for those two performances alone, however.

8. Sebastien Squillaci

When Arsenal signed Sebastien Squillaci, there was good reason to believe he could be a very successful player for the club. Having already achieved over twenty caps for his country before joining the Gunners and after having been an established player at previous clubs Lyon and Sevilla, fans would have been forgiven for expecting better than what Squillaci turned in for the London club. Signing in the same Summer as the far more successful Laurent Koscielny, Squillaci was brought in to bolster Arsenal's ailing defence. It quickly became apparent through his early performances, however, that Sebastien Squillaci was simply not equipped to play in the Premier League. He was responsible for several high profile mistakes in his first season, and committed numerous defensive errors that would prove costly to the Gunners' season. It was suggested that the Frenchman simply did not have the defensive intelligence to play in a league as fast-paced as the Premier League. Though his promise and potential was based entirely on his assertions before joining the Gunners, Sebastien Squillaci represents another player brought in to the Arsenal set-up who just did not live up to any of the expectations Arsenal fans may have held for him.

7. Denilson

Denilson was a player whose recruitment to Arsenal puzzled a number of fans at first. As a relatively unknown player before joining the Gunners, few fans had cause to believe that he was going to provide the team with what they were lacking in midfield. Denilson was obviously a very skilled passer of the ball and suited the Arsenal playing style because of this. Early performances between 2007 and 2008 saw him impress as a fringe player and there seemed to be some optimism he could become a strong player for the club. In the following season he became more of a regular fixture in the Gunners' line-up, however he was often deployed in a more traditionally defensive holding role in their midfield. It was with this that Denilson's early promise started to disappear; despite being adept at keeping possession of the ball he was never quite good enough at winning it back in that role. His later years at Arsenal were hit by injury and he was admittedly unfortunate for the timing of those. It is unlikely, however, that he ever would have been adept enough in the holding midfield role to secure a regular place in a midfield already full to the brim with creative passers of the ball.

6. Julio Baptista

Loan signings can be a funny thing; with minimal financial output or contractual obligations involved, they can often be seen as win-win scenarios for the receiving club. Either the player performs well and earns himself a permanent transfer or he doesn't quite live up to expectations and can be sent back to his parent club before too long. The latter was certainly the case for Arsenal's Brazilian loanee; Julio Baptista. Nicknamed 'The Beast' for his powerful and physical approach to the game, it seemed that Baptista could add some much-needed force to Arsenal's team. After impressing in the League Cup for the Gunners against weaker oppositions, it quickly became apparent that Baptista was not finding any scoring form in the Premier League. It also became abundantly clear that he was not accustomed to Arsenal's style of build-up play and that his move was not going to last any longer than the initial loan period. In similar fashion to Andrei Arshavin, Julio Baptista will be fondly remembered for a four goal performance against Liverpool by Arsenal fans, but the less favourable out there will simply remember him as a low-risk loan signing that didn't yield the perfect result that so many loanees do.

5. Abou Diaby

Still at the North London club, Abou Diaby is now the Gunners' longest serving player since joining in 2006. Despite spending eight years at the club, he has managed just a measly 179 appearances in a career that has been so cruelly riddled with injury problems. Multiple injuries aside, however, Abou Diaby has still never shown much more than fleeting glances as to why he drew comparisons to Patrick Vieira in his youth career. Given his height and build, Diaby has always been expected to be a fairly powerful midfield general. In reality he has very rarely been able to dominate a midfield battle, something that Vieira was considerably better at. With neither the range of passing to help him fit the Arsenal mould, nor the physical presence to provide the brute force to Arsenal's beauty, Diaby has just never found his plce in the Arsenal setup. It is admittedly harsh to comment on a career that has been so affected by injury, and some optimistic Gunners fans may speculate on what sort of player Diaby could have become had he not been so stricken. The fact still remains that Diaby has never shown why he was likened to Arsenal legend Vieira, though, and whatever potential he may have had has certainly never been fulfilled on the pitch.

4. Thomas Eisfeld

After joining Arsenal as a promising yet raw young talent in 2012, Thomas Eisfeld stayed unfortunately confined to the club's youth setup. This is a surprising shame, given that Arsene Wenger was extremely complimentary of the German's skills when the Gunners signed him and even predicted he would have a big international future as well. Eisfeld was seen as a typical midfielder to fit Arsenal's passing style of play. Possessing an excellent first touch and with the right passing range, Eisfeld's pre season outings with Arsenal's first team have always suggested he could fit right into the senior setup. When complimented he has drawn parallels with Arsenal's own Jack Wilshere and Aaron Ramsey and is even of a similar age and build to these two established first teamers. Eisfeld's inclusion here is fairly harsh as he wasn't really given much chance to fulfil his potential with Arsenal's first team. It is worth noting him here, however, as he has now signed a permanent deal with rival London club Fulham. Here he will likely secure more first team action, and it would be to the club's advantage if he did. This is a player who, despite not fulfilling his potential at Arsenal, will find his feet at Fulham. Do not be surprised to see him back in the Premier League before too long.

3. Marouane Chamakh

Another ex Arsenal player who has made a short trip across London to another club is Marouane Chamakh, now of Crystal Palace. The Moroccan was signed to boost Arsenal's attacking options in 2010, off the back of managing to score in six consecutive Champions League games with former club Bordeaux. Big things were expected of Chamakh when he arrived at the Emirates. At first it even seemed as if he was going to live up to these expectations; the striker netted ten times in all competitions before November of his first season. After this, however, Chamakh's form dropped dramatically and he fell quickly out of the Gunners' starting line-up. Missing large chunks at the end of this season, Chamakh's fitness was cited as an issue. By the time the next season had started Chamakh had already become a fringe player at the Emirates and he made less than twenty appearances in his second season. After a fairly innocuous loan spell with West Ham, Chamakh signed a permanent move to Crystal Palace where he has now managed to re-establish a starting place for himself. Contrary to the failings of his Arsenal days, Chamakh has become somewhat of a workhorse at Palace and is actually starting to fulfil some potential with his new club. That potential was certainly not lived up to with Arsenal, however,

2. Gervinho

Signed the season after Chamakh, Gervinho was the latest in a long line of players that Arsene Wenger signed following success in the French Ligue 1. Also an already established international for the Ivory Coast, Gervinho arrived at the club on a wave of relative optimism. After a pre-season where he impressed Gunners fans - one sumptuous lob finish was particularly exciting - Gervinho struggled to cope in the Premier League. Poor discipline leading to a red card in his first game aside, Gervinho just never seemed to have the temperament to play in England. Sloppy passing and finishing was the result of poor decision making from the Ivorian. Despite making himself a regular feature in the Gunners' starting line-up for two seasons, he never really managed to offer positive impact in more than fleeting glances. Now playing his football in Italy with Roma, Gervinho has enjoyed a fair upturn in form and was even one of the few players who could take any pride from the Ivory Coast's disappointing World Cup run in Brazil. The promise he showed in pre-season for Arsenal was woefully unrepeated in two seasons.

1. Jack Wilshere

A product of Arsenal's academy who has also been unfortunate with injury since reaching the senior setup, Jack Wilshere may be a name Gunners fans are surprised to see on this list. Unfortunately this "future Arsenal captain" is still some way short of showing the Emirates faithful of just what he's capable of. To put him in the same category as failures like Bendtner or Squillaci may be a tad harsh, and he shouldn't be judged on the same plain as these. Given his enormous talent and fierce determination, however, Wilshere simply has not yet lived up to the potential that he has occasionally shown Arsenal fans that he has. Injuries have obviously not helped his development, but even after managing two fuller seasons in the last two years he is still yet to establish himself as a crucial cog in the Gunners' midfield. Despite glimpses that he was becoming a key player in 2012, Wilshere has slipped back somewhat into a supporting role. He has moved backwards whereas teammate Aaron Ramsey has exceled in the last two years. His poor discipline have regularly been criticised for his limits, but it is also true that some of his best games have come when he is most fired up. It's his temperament that is currently holding him back and which has stunted his progress thus far. If this can be honed then there is no doubt Wilshere will quickly start to show just why he has been tipped as a future captain. He may be on this list for now, but fortunately he has adequate time left to turn this around. So there you have it; ten Arsenal players who's potential and promise went unfulfilled at the club. Would you defend anyone listed here? Or perhaps you would add someone to this list? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!

Contributor
Contributor

Gareth is 28 years old and lives in Cardiff. Interests include film, TV and an unhealthy amount of Spider-Man comics and Killers songs. Expect constant references to the latter two at all times. Follow on twitter @GJCartwright.