10 Players Who Probably Regret Joining Everton

The reality of the Toffeemen isn't always all that sweet.

For quite some time, Everton€™s reputation has been one of a selling club. While the bigger clubs around them were able to spend vast fortunes on recruitment, Everton were forced to sell before they could buy. That often led to them selling off their prized assets for large fees and spending the money to fill out a squad that was desperately lacking in quality in certain areas. No deal highlights this more than Wayne Rooney€™s transfer to Manchester United, while the club also did well out of deals for the likes of Mikel Arteta and Jack Rodwell. During the David Moyes era at the club, he was often forced into spending very little money but trying to build a squad that was capable of competing towards the higher ends of the Premier League. It was arguably a job that the Scot did well, with a number of his deals proving to be absolute bargains. Just look at the prices paid for the likes of Tim Howard, Tim Cahill, Mikel Arteta, Steven Pienaar and even Leighton Baines and the value that the club got for their money. It was often labelled at Moyes that he was better at small deals that big ones. That is certainly something which is evident in his transfers, with those that were more expensive often failing to be as successful as Evertonians would have liked. With that in mind, let us take a look at some of the players who probably regret joining Everton, with many who feature on the list some of Everton€™s biggest transfers.

10. Richard Wright

Arguably it had all gone a bit wrong before Richard Wright joined Everton from Arsenal but it certainly unravelled at Goodison Park. Before moving to Highbury, Wright had been a club hero at Ipswich Town following his penalty kick save that saw the club promoted to the Premier League in the 1999/00 season. He left in 2001 after amassing 355 league and cup appearances from the Tractor Boys. He was soon shipped off to Goodison after a series of terrible performances saw him fail to replace David Seaman in the Arsenal goal though. His first campaign in Royal Blue was an okay one as the club finished 7th in the table in their first season under David Moyes. After that, everything seemed to go wrong at Goodison Park for Wright as a series of bizarre injuries hampered his career and left him as understudy to veteran Nigel Martyn. The first of these injures was the result of falling out of his loft at home when trying to pack a suitcase, while later in his career he managed to fall over a sign warning players not to warm up in the goalmouth before an FA cup game against Chelsea, severely twisting his ankle. He would only feature 60 times in four seasons and now finds himself in the wilderness of Manchester City.

9. Alessandro Pistone

Injuries no doubt left Alessandro Pistone wishing he had never joined the Blues, and it is interesting to think about what might have been had he avoided them. Before joining the Toffees he spent three years at Newcastle United, featuring heavily under Sir Bobby Robson after having been frozen out of the set up by Ruud Gullit. Signing in July 2000 for £3.5 million, the Italian appeared in the first game of the season before succession of injuries limited him to just 8 appearances in his first season at the club with the following season being mostly missed through injury as well. Although he eventually managed to overcome his injuries and feature in most of Everton€™s successful Champions League qualification in 2004/05, a cruciate knee ligament injury quickly ended his Everton career after just three more appearances. He failed to make an appearance after that injury, having made just 103 appearances in seven years on Merseyside.

8. Per Kroldrup

Easily one of the worst signings in the history of Everton and arguably the worst of the David Moyes era, Per Kroldrup is still probably ruing joining Everton back in 2005. There was a lot of expectation around the Danish defender when he joined from Udinese for £5m. Already an international with the Denmark side, he looked to be a bargain as the Blues aimed to strengthen following their Champions League qualification. Unfortunately things started badly at Goodison Park as he suffered a groin injury before playing a single game, leaving him requiring surgery and missing an extended period as a result. He would eventually make his debut against Aston Villa on Boxing Day of 2005, putting in a forgettable performance in a 4-0 defeat that proved to be his only appearance for the club. So bad was his time at Goodison Park, his Everton career is widely referred to as one of the worst transfers in the history of the club and English football itself, with the defender himself later admitting that he struggled to adapt to the pace and intensity of the English game. It is arguable that had he stayed in Italy, things would have gone much better for him as his short stint in England certainly ruined not only his reputation but certainly any chances of another shot at the bigger stage.

7. Niclas Alexandersson

More of a right winger than a left winger for Everton, a position which is occupied by someone more prominent than the Swede, Niclas Alexandersson was certainly left ruing his move to Everton. The winger initially began his time in England at Sheffield Wednesday, where he quickly became a fan favourite. In his first three seasons in Sheffield he went on to win the Player of the Season award in the same season that saw the club relegated from the Premier League after nine successive seasons of top division football. As dubious an award as that may be, it helps to show well he played and the important role he had in that side. Such were those performances; a £2.5m deal to Everton followed the season after. He initially featured regularly in his first two seasons on Merseyside, before losing his place after a succession of injuries and the arrival of David Moyes. Struggling with fitness and form, and unable to break into the Everton side he left to return to Sweden and likely still wonders about the Sheffield Wednesday icon he could have became had the move to Everton never came around.

6. Andy Van De Meyde

Probably the most illustrious of names on this list, Andy Van de Meyde is the best example of how some footballers go on to waste their prodigious talent. A former star for Ajax and Inter Milan, many Evertonians thought the signing of the Dutchman was a good one considering the club had only paid £2m for his services. At the time, most even considered that it could be one of the smartest signings that Moyes had managed, especially as he had managed to beat the likes of Tottenham Hotspur and Monaco to the winger€™s signature. Ultimately though, Moyes will have wished he hadn€™t, as off-field antics proved the undoing of the Dutchman, who preferred partying to playing football, all of which meant he ending up spending more off the pitch than on it. As it was, Van de Meyde only managed 20 appearances for the club with drug and drink issues causing his fitness to be missing for large parts of his time on Merseyside. Considering he could have went to Monaco, a place where in his own words he €œcould have made a lot of money€ because of tax laws, it€™s arguable that not going to Everton may have meant he would play well past his retirement age of 31.

5. Diniyar Bilyaletdinov

Once upon a time, Diniyar Bilyaletdinov was the hottest young property in Russia but that all evaporated following his move to Goodison Park. Before joining the Blues he featured heavily for Lokomotiv Moscow, with his first season at the club seeing them winning the Russian Premier League and him being named the Young Player of the Year, with him later being made club captain. That prompted a £8.9m move to Everton in 2009, under the recommendation of then Chelsea manager Gus Hiddink, making him the clubs€™ third most expensive signing in their history. However, despite scoring nine goals in 77 appearances, he failed to make an impact during his time at the club despite some wonder goals to suggest things could be otherwise. He eventually left for a return to Russian in 2012, criticising their tactics and lack of creativity. Since then his career has continued to go downhill as he lost his place in the national side and now finds himself playing for Torpedo Moscow on loan, all of which is drastic career slide for a player who was once the hottest property in Russia.

4. Ibrahima Bakayoko

The 21-year-old who was more than likely lying about his age, and the first of several strikers on this list who probably wish they€™d avoided Goodison Park. Before his move to Everton, Ibrahima Bakayoko has been impressing in France with Montpellier, where his short three-year stint had led to him scoring 25 goals in 76 appearances. That prompted a whole host of clubs to take a look at him, including Arsenal, as at 21 years of age he represented a decent investment for the future. His form prompted manager Walter Smith to pay £4.5m for his services in October 1998, and at the time many Evertonians regarded it as a decent piece of business. How wrong they were, as the forward went on to make just 23 appearances and score just seven goals, with fans affectionately referring to him as €˜Baka-joke-o€™. Everton soon got rid the following year, managing to get back £4m in a deal to Marseille, where he would score 34 goals in 115 appearances over a four year stay, probably leading him to wonder where his career might have gone had he stayed there and not moved to England. He now turns out for Stade Bordelais after spells in Spain, Italy and Greece.

3. Daniel Amokachi

Weirdly, Daniem Amokachi is considered a bit of a Premier League legend, despite not actually being that successful at Goodison Park. Nicknamed €œThe Bull€, Amokachi made his name during the 1194 USA World Cup, where the 21 year old looked highly impressive for Nigeria. His club career had also been mildly successful, with 35 goals in 81 league appearances proving good form for Club Brugge in Belgium. Those goals and that World Cup prompted Everton manager Mike Walker to pay £3m for his services, and make him one of his key signings in the process. Unfortunately for the Nigerian, he was brought into a team that was entirely lacking in confidence and seemed unable to do anything right. He would go on to score just 10 league goals in 43 appearances for the Blues, with two of those coming in the infamous game against Tottenham where he wasn€™t actually supposed to be on the pitch. He was later sold to Besiktas for £1.75m but his career never kicked off and he retired in 2005 after scoring just 19 goals in 77 appearances for the Turkish giants.

2. James Beattie

Much was expected of James Beattie when he joined for £6m in 2005, making him Everton€™s most expensive ever signing, but he ultimately failed to impress at Goodison Park. Beattie had previously spent the majority of his career at Southampton, managing to score 68 league goals in 202 appearances during a seven-year stay at the club. During the 2002-03 season he even managed to score 23 league goals, leaving him third on the Premier League goal scoring charts that year and the highest Englishman on the list. That kind of goal scoring prompted a £6m move to Everton in 2005, but the striker simply failed to settle on Merseyside and his most famous incident in the Royal Blue was probably his sending off for head-butting William Gallas. He would score just 13 league goals in 76 appearances for the club before moving on to Sheffield United, later blaming David Moyes for his demise at the club. Unfortunately for the striker, he was simply not the right fit for the puzzle and his career suffered as a result.

1. Andy Johnson

Another English striker who suffered at Goodison Park after relative success in the Premier League was Andy Johnson. Back in 2004, the bald-headed forward was a bit of a wonder in the Premier League for Crystal Palace, managing to score 21 goals in 37 appearances for the Eagles despite their subsequent relegation. That led to him being one of the most talked about players that campaign, and later joined the Blues for a then club record fee of £8.5m and reportedly became their highest earning player on £40,000 and linking up with his good friend James Beattie in Everton€™s new forward line. Although he scored on his debut against Watford, he failed to replicate his Crystal Palace form at Goodison Park, with his time at the club being plagued by accusations of diving, with Jose Mourinho labelling him untrustworthy after a game in December 2006. Those accusations were coupled with inconsistent form and the failure to form a partnership with James Beattie, leaving Everton to sell him to Fulham in 2008 and Johnson to join the long list of failed Everton forwards. Which other players probably regret joining Everton? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

Everton fanatic. Comic book reader and Spider-Man idoliser. Film watcher and TV binger. A smorgasbord of interests.