8 Newcastle Players Who Almost Signed For Man Utd

The Red Devils haven't had it all their own way.

Shearer Man Utd Despite Craig Bellamy's assertions that Newcastle are nowhere near the size and profile of Manchester United, the two clubs have some serious history when it comes to close rivalry and some bad blood. The clubs have butted heads on the pitch several times, playing their part in some of the most entertaining Premier League matches, and though the days the Magpies compete with the big bucks of Van Gaal's side are gone (as we're told almost every window), for a while the pair were close business rivals. The revelation that Alan Shearer turned down Man Utd more than once is nothing new, but he is far from the only Newcastle player who almost ended up playing for the Red Devils at one point in their career...

8. Paul Gascoigne

Having made his name at Newcastle as a prodigious, if a little wayward talent, Gazza sought a bigger move in 1988 and was duly rewarded with a move to London and Spurs. But that wasn't how it was supposed to go down. At the start of the summer, by his own admission, Gazza had assured Sir Alex Ferguson that he was going to sign for him:
"I told Sir Alex I was signing for United and that he should go away and enjoy his summer holiday. I drove to Old Trafford to put pen to paper, but I kept on driving in my car and eventually joined Tottenham."
Apparently, Chris Waddle was the man Sir Alex should be most annoyed at: he had already moved to Spurs and told Gazza how happy he was and that he should follow him South. Terry Venables then rang Gascoigne personally, which impressed him, and told him he would get him into the England squad within three months - a promise he delivered with a month to spare.
"I enjoyed my time at Spurs, but I do look back and wonder what my life might have been like if I€™d signed for United. I reckon Sir Alex Ferguson would have taken me by the balls €“ just like Vinnie."

7. Hatem Ben Arfa

According to The Daily Mail, when Newcastle's attempt to sign Hatem Ben Arfa on loan from Marseille hit a stumbling block - surprise surprise it was all down to Newcastle's supposedly derisory offer that had infuriated the French side - a big Premier League side (either Man Utd or Liverpool) attempted to swoop in and scupper the deal. Perhaps it was just Marseille planting a story to get Newcastle to firm up their interest a little more, but it's intriguing all the same. Imagine what the Frenchman could have done at Man Utd under the tutelage of Sir Alex Ferguson, who would no doubt have massaged his ego and let him know he was the asset that Newcastle never quite did.

6. Craig Bellamy

Bellamy might never have been as talented as he was in his own head, but for a while there he was one of the hottest properties in the Premier League, having had his career rescued by Newcastle after relegation with Coventry City (a point lost on him ever since). And it's not much of a surprise that he attracted some big interest at his peak in 2002, or that he sent people to see what he could get:
€œThere was a link with Sir Alex as far back as 2002, when my representatives went to see him at United€™s training ground, with a view to a move going ahead."
In typical Bellamy fashion, the player simply used Sir Alex's interest in him to get a better contract at Newcastle:
€œBut Newcastle had just qualified for the Champions League, I loved playing for Sir Bobby Robson and had just been offered a new contract there. To be honest, I used an inquiry from United to hold out for a better deal.€
Later, when he was at Man City, Sir Alex tried to sign him again before he joined Cardiff on loan in 2010, but City point-blank refused to allow him to move.

5. Daryl Janmaat

The latest member of Newcastle's foreign heroes club - following some all-action displays in his first 10 games, and particular that challenge on Mario Balotelli - was apparently a big target for both Man Utd and Spurs earlier in the summer. After impressing at the World Cup, Man Utd had approached Feyenoord about the possibility of signing the right-back - who could have fit into Van Gaal's wing-back model - but reports of his impending move to the ousted Champions were off the mark. Some reports even suggested that Janmaat had agreed a deal to sign for international boss Louis Van Gaal early in the summer, but it seems Newcastle did more than was expected to convince him to choose Tyneside.

4. Haris Vuckic

Back in 2010, just a year after he signed for Newcastle, Slovenian former wonder kid Haris Vuckic was apparently the subject of interest from Manchester United, according to the Daily Mail. At that stage, he had only started three games for the Magpies, but he was still a hugely rated talent, and Sir Alex Ferguson was apparently sniffing round. But this wasn't the first time Man Utd had been interested, and before Vuckic signed for Newcastle - at a time when he also had a trial for AC Milan - he almost signed for Man Utd in 2009 from NK Domzale. Ultimately, Sir Alex's loss was Newcastle's gain, and while he hasn't quite blossomed into the talent he should have, there is still time for him to pull off a Mehdi Abeid style resurgence.

3. John Barnes

Long before Barnes joined Newcastle in the twilight of his career - a move that isn't as fondly remembered as it should be considering he was top scorer in his first season, and played a major part in the Barcelona victory - he almost signed for Man Utd, rather than Liverpool. Dave Bassett had just been appointed at Watford, and knew he couldn't keep ahold of his star player, so offered Sir Alex Ferguson the opportunity to sign him. Unthinkably, Ferguson turned the chance down, believing that he had a better option in the shape of Jesper Olsen, as he revealed in his autobiography. As errors in judgement go, that has to be one of Sir Alex's biggest ones.

2. Alan Shearer

Though Alan Shearer has said that he has never had any regrets about choosing Newcastle (and turning Manchester United down a number of times in his career) you have to suspect that he occasionally wonders at what could have been. Freddy Shepherd revealed recently how close Shearer came to signing for Man Utd, saying both he and Man Utd chief Martin Edwards had a gentleman's agreement that they wouldn't go over his valuation of £10m. Euro '96 changed Shepherd's mind, however, and though Edwards told him of his intention to sign Shearer, Shepherd had already found out and beat him to the punch:
€œWe met Shearer at David Platt€™s mother-in-law€™s house in Crewe. Martin rang me and said, €˜We€™re going to go over the 10€™. I said, €˜Oh aye€™ but I already knew that it had leaked out that Shearer had met (Alex) Ferguson. €œWe went in to see Shearer and Kevin had to leave to head off to the Far East for the pre-season tour. Me and Douglas (Hall) were left to do the deal and we did the deal with Alan.€
Shepherd also revealed that Jack Walker had told him it would have cost Man Utd £25m to sign Shearer, who had made his mind up to come home, despite meeting Man Utd's boss.

1. Peter Beardsley

Though some will say that Alan Shearer's snub of Manchester United was the most significant in the two club's history, another was far more significant for both teams. Having already played for the Red Devils once under Ron Atkinson without making a league appearance, Peter Beardsley almost returned to the club in 1992 as Sir Alex Ferguson wanted to sign him to replace Dion Dublin. Ferguson was a massive admirer of the Geordie playmaker having tried to sign him from the Magpies in 1987, and had asked Martin Edwards to go and sign him in November 1992, but as he prepared to make the bid, Leeds chairman Bill Fotherby rang to see if Denis Irwin was available, and the subject of Eric Cantona came up. The rest was history, but had the phone call come later, Man Utd might have signed Beardsley, denying their fans the sight of Cantona in a red shirt, and stopping the formation of Keegan's Entertainers in one fell swoop. Which of these players are you most happy didn't sign for Newcastle United? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.