Newcastle: 5 Things Alan Pardew Clearly Doesn't Know About Bayern Munich

Newcastle are literally nothing like them.

The Newcastle manager is basically the gift that keeps on giving: not content with claiming that stats don't really matter after being a massive card-carrying statistician when his side were losing, the former Premier League Manager Of The Year has come out with another stonking comment. This time he's likened Newcastle's current model to that used so successfully by Bayern Munich, except he's reduced the Germans down to an industrious, disciplined machine and ignored everything else about them to serve the image of himself as some sort of tactical genius:
€œOur strengths are we have incredible discipline in the team from our offensive players. The current top model in Germany are Bayern Munich. That€™s their strength, that€™s what we have got, and pace.€
A potted - and completely wrong - assessment of the current Bayern Munich tactical model there from a man who possibly hasn't actually watched them play in great detail. Luckily, when things like this are said in public, the internet and actual football knowledge help provide evidence that suggest the truth. And that is that Alan Pardew is talking utter rhubarb of the highest order. It's one thing to say that you want to emulate Bayern - that is admirable even in a team who cannot possibly hope to do so - but to say the principles are already in place while ignoring 90% of the defining characteristics of the way Munich play under Guardiola is utterly reprehensible. But again, thankfully Guardiola is always very open about the way his team play when interviewed, and even a simple look back at recent interviews puts Pardew's limp attempt to liken his team to the Germans to shame. Yes, he deserves some credit for turning things around (the jury should remain out for now though), but going to such an extreme is just silly. So to help the manager realise his errors, here are 5 things he should probably learn about Munich's style of play before he opens his mouth on them again...

5. They Press High Up The Pitch

In Pardew's own words, Newcastle don't press high any more (looking back at the last 11 games, it's hard to see where it actually did happen), instead relying on discipline and restraint from offensive players, to fit in with their individual limits:
€œWe€™ve gone back from pressing high, we€™ve gone back from possession. With this group of players those things haven€™t worked well for us."
He used that qualification to specifically liken his side to Bayern Munich (linking to the initial point about discipline) - except the Germans simply do not play like that, as their manager himself confirms:
"I like to have possession(higher up the pitch) because when the ball is far away from our box I am happy, I am calm, I am not nervous, but when the ball step by step is closer to my box i start trembling."
Ironically, Newcastle beat Liverpool precisely because they pressed high up the pitch - just not on the centre-halves. They limited the deeper lying midfielders, cut out the Reds' option to play through the middle and never gave them a minute on the ball: they just didn't fall for Liverpool's attempt to sucker them into attacking the centre-backs. So saying they don't press is not really the whole truth.

4. They Over-Run Possession

The Newcastle boss has been exaggerated in his praise of Newcastle without the ball recently, stating that the team could be more dangerous without the ball, which is pretty much the opposite of what Bayern Munich's team is built on. Like Newcastle earlier in the season, in fact, Guardiola drills it into his team the idea that the opposition cannot hurt you if they don't have the ball, but the difference is that Guardiola also openly acknowledges that possession without intent or final product is pointless. "Possession is important when you create chances, so possession for itself is nothing. We try to have the possession in front because sometimes you have loads of possession but do not create chances, just to defend and defend €“ because when you have possession, you have the ball and it is impossible the opponent can score a goal... But I like possession because I like it when my team has the ball, but always you have to try to have good possession because i repeat possession for itself is nothing." Newcastle allow their opponents the ball as a chief mechanic of their tactics - they need the opposition to attack and over-commit in order to break. Bayern are completely different in that they control possession from the kick-off, and break as well when they reduce opposition play. And to suggest that Newcastle are anything like them in that respect is to ignore the fact that Guardiola's approach demands a large amount of possession (which is why they average 61% per game, compared to Newcastle's 47%).

3. Attack, Attack, Attack

Again, it comes down to using possession correctly, but Bayern Munich create a massive number of chances every game, because it increases the chance of scoring - that's simple maths. In contrast, Pardew commits to a model of only attacking and only taking a chance when his players are sure something can come of it: suggesting a sucker punch methodology that looks to punish over-commitment by the opposition, and naturally limits the number of chances his team have per game. That's a big reason why Newcastle have scored just 13 goals so far this season, compared to Bayern's 27, and why the Magpies have created something like 70 less chances in the first 11 games of the season: by that rate, Bayern will create 608 chances (at the rate of 16 per game they're currently on), and Newcastle will create 342 chances this season (at the current average rate of 9 per game). That's why Bayern will score a lot more goals this season, and why they're so committed to expansive attacking play at all times, because you cannot score without trying to.

2. They Use Their 'Keeper's Distribution Well

One issue that Newcastle have had to overcome this season (and indeed since he became number one) is that Tim Krul's distribution is nowhere near as good as some of his other skills. Too often he kicks the ball into touch without any pressure on him, and he has sent way too many balls to the wrong players (Remy Cabella shouldn't be classed as a target for long kicks, as he was earlier in the season for some reason), and when he kicks into the right areas, it's invariably snapped up by a defender rather than an attacker. In failing to accurately pick out Newcastle team-mates, Krul is unwittingly limiting the number of ways his side can attack, taking route one out of the equation entirely. That's not to say that route one should be used all the time, but to have it as an option would be nice, and would mix things up at least. In contrast, Guardiola has spent time working on Neuer's distribution: his passing accuracy under the Spaniard has improved drastically, and he is used as a quarter-back like figure - the deepest of deep lying play-makers - and such is his ability on the ball that he spends a lot of time outside his box, presenting a passing option to team-mates under pressure. And when the ball comes back to him, it's not simply a case of whacking it long and hoping, or kicking it out of play, he actually picks out team-mates and starts attacks. When Neuer receives the ball, Bayern's full-backs push up the pitch, knowing he could pick them out, and the centre-halves spread wide, while Schweinsteiger drops deep (a la Tiote, but with more purpose to build an attack), which gives Neuer more options to pass, and to avoid the centre-backs being pressed as much. It also opens up space for Neuer to advance and pass from higher up the pitch - a valuable attacking option that Newcastle simply do not have.

1. They're Not Stronger Without The Ball

For Pardew, Newcastle can claim to be stronger or more dangerous when they don't have the ball. It's a risky strategy, as it means having to rely on the opposition to make mistakes in order to profit, and it simply will not work against teams who don't attack in numbers and don't try to press the issue - like QPR probably will. The Newcastle manager sees defensive discipline as a huge asset to his attack - using a similar approach to his style of play as the motto bestowed on the Newcastle city crest by a grateful King Charles, "Fortiter Defendit Triumphans" ("Triumphing by a brave defence") - but that can only get you so far. You cannot be a danger when you don't have the ball, because you cannot attack, you cannot shoot and you cannot win games. And this is not lost on Pep Guardiola, who concedes that his side of millionaire World Cup winners and superstars cannot play without the ball, and certainly are not "more dangerous" without it:
€œWe play in the other team€™s half as much as possible because I get worried when the ball is in my half. We€™re a horrible team without the ball so I want us to get it back as soon as possible and I€™d rather give away fouls and the ball in their half than ours.€
A horrible team without the ball. Not a more dangerous one. Those two images are dramatically different. So to say the two teams are even remotely alike is a massive untruth.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.