Next Newcastle Manager: 10 Favourites To Replace Alan Pardew

Which man would be brave enough to take the poisoned chalice at Newcastle?

140 Premier League games and out. Alan Pardew's time as Newcastle United boss looks untenable after the thin ice he was on utterly cracked for him at completely the wrong time yesterday at St. Mary's - his hapless Newcastle United going down far too easily to Southampton in a miserable 4-0 drubbing. It was an afternoon where he audibly and visually lost any small faith he still had with the fans, the players and ultimately, from what the footage screamed by their respective physical reactions, in himself and owner Mike Ashley. Although there has been fevered speculation before that Pardew's tenure as Newcastle boss was up, this time it really does feel like it's for real and a parting of ways has to happen for the good of the club. It may go down as mutual consent or it may be an old fashioned sacking situation but it is clear to everyone that a change is needed and a new era should be embarked upon. But where would Newcastle United owner Mike Ashley turn to next? He clearly saw Alan Pardew as the long term answer to deliver the Champions League football the owner craves (although only on his own financially prudent terms) and his fifth place finish in his first full season as boss showed promise that he could achieve it. However, a dismal sequel season which saw Newcastle only survive the drop by the skin of their teeth in the following campaign almost saw Pardew axed (he seemingly survived the crisis talks in May 2013) and although a 10th place finish last season achieved the owner's minimum requirement of the campaign, the miserable second half of the season since the beginning of 2014 that has carried on over the summer and into this season despite a huge £40 million outlay on new players, has led to Ashley being forced to look elsewhere. So who does Ashley want as the new Newcastle boss? Which man would be brave enough to take the poisoned chalice at Newcastle? These are the top ten bookies favourite for the job at the time of writing (via Oddschecker) in a reverse order...

10. Malky MacKay (25-1)

Status: Unemployed (and shamed) North of the border product Malky MacKay would have been Crystal Palace manager right now had the text message scandal stemming from his time as Cardiff City boss not purposefully leaked to the media at the 11th hour of his appointment. We wouldn't like to repeat the terrible scandal here but needless to say it severely damaged Mackay's reputation and it would be extremely difficult for him to walk into a top job (or any significant English based job) for the considerable future. For that reason alone McKay must simply be seen as a complete rank outsider and his 25-1 (10th favourite) status looks particularly generous to him. Although there's in reality no chance of it happening... SHOULD the impossible happen and he was offered the Magpies job he would deliver much what he did at Cardiff, a combative side that could play above their strengths in big matches and frequently relied on the atmosphere the home fans could create to push his players to victory, something the St. James' Park atmosphere has badly been lacking on a consistent basis since the days of Sir. Bobby Robson. But it's all pie in the sky as he's not going to get the job as he needs much more time away on footballing probation to relinquish his sins.

9. Glen Hoddle (25-1)

Status: QPR first team coach / TV pundit The longer Glen Hoddle stays out of the managerial spotlight and instead delivers his tactical pearls of wisdom as a television pundit, notably for Sky Sports, the more his credentials as a coach himself are more favourably looked upon. He hasn't had a job as manager since his time at Wolves ended in 2006 but has been constantly linked with the Tottenham job every time that comes up (which is frequent) and also the England manager's role, a position he had success with in the 90s before being forced to leave after making some ill-advised comments of his own. Hoddle's teams always promoted an attacking style of football and were all about winning games, much like his own world class style of play. He has tactical nous that is superior to Pardew and is a great man manager, knowing the strengths of every player and is a true student of the game who has kept up with football since his time away from management. In 2008 Hoddle opened the "Glen Hoddle Academy" in an attempt to give young players who were released by England clubs another chance to earn a professional contract. This is said to be a key reason why he has turned down any managerial jobs that have come his way since (of which he claims he's had at least 28 serious offers) as he didn't want to leave until the Academy could run itself although he has returned to coaching in recent weeks, linking up with Harry Redknapp at QPR as his first team coach. This is very much seen as a signal that he could be ready to return to management. Mike Ashley did take Joe Kinnear out of a way bigger wilderness to become Newcastle United manager during the last crisis period... though any appointment of Hoddle looks unlikely.

8. Gianfranco Zola (25-1)

Status: Unemployed Definitely an outsider, Gianfranco Zola's name has quietly been mooted for the Newcastle job should Pardew be given the heave-ho. Almost a forgotten man since he resigned as Watford boss in December, Zola has been in relative obscurity in 2014 and hasn't really looked close to take any other job. At Watford, at least initially, Zola impressed many with his passion and the style of football his team were playing. They finished 3rd in the table and only missed out on Premier League football when Crystal Palace defeated them in extra-time at Wembley in the play-off final. His second season however started much less promising and by the time he resigned Watford were 13th in the league and had lost five home games in a row. Prior to his spell at Watford, Zola was West Ham manager, succeeding Alan Pardew's successor Alan Curbishley for the role at Upton Park, his first job as manager. He led the Hammers to a lofty 9th place finish in his first season in charge but then the second season left them crawling away from relegation, barely surviving with a 17th place finish. Bad signings on strikers and pressures of top flight management on the inexperienced Italian led to the end of his spell there when new owners came in, although several years later it will be interesting to see if he has grown the backbone to try the Premier League again.

7. Tim Sherwood (20-1)

Status: Unemployed Despite impressing many with how he turned Tottenham around after Andre Villa-Boas' damaging time as Spurs boss, Daniel Levy decided that rookie manager Tim Sherwood was too inexperienced to deliver Champions League football at White Hart Lane. Seen as a particularly harsh decision by many, Sherwood may just have impressed Mike Ashley when his Tottenham side utterly outplayed and thrashed Newcastle before Mike Ashley's eyes in a 4-0 drubbing at St. James' Park in February. Few teams were so impressive at St. James' than Sherwood's Tottenham. Of course bringing in Sherwood would also likely mean Newcastle legend Les Ferdinand would make the journey back to St. James' Park as his number two, something which supporters might welcome as a sweetener to Sherwood's inexperience. Still much of an unknown quantity, Sherwood certainly deserves an interview should Mike Ashley get rid of Alan Pardew. Though how Sherwood would be able to work under Ashley's restraint is unknown, particularly after his experience with Levy. He turned down the West Brom vacancy when the club didn't match his expectations and a similar thing may have happened at Crystal Palace where at one point he looked favourite to gain that job. The young manager might be too full of beans for Ashley to take the plunge with him but one thing is for sure... he proved with the likes of Adebayor he could get the best out of players others had given up on, and given his prior role in the Tottenham academy, was a big proponent of bringing through the youth to the first team... two virtues that Newcastle fans would love to get out of the likes of Papiss Cisse and the likes of Rolando Aarons and Sammy Ameobi.

6. Christoph Galtier (20-1)

Status: Saint-Etienne boss Linked with replacing Alan Pardew at the end of last season for a few Media frenzied days, St. Etienne boss Christoph Galtier finds himself sitting pretty as the sixth favourite for the job currently. The 47-year-old has enjoyed a steady and fruitful five seasons in France, winning the French League Cup last term and incredibly guiding his side to fourth in Ligue 1 this year, delivering Champions League football. He managed this all on a shoe-string budget and a rebuilding job after the sale of star striker and one time Newcastle target Pierre Aubameyang, something Pardew himself struggled to do when star players like Demba Ba and Yohan Cabaye left. He is known for his free-flowing, attacking football and for always banking on a well-organised defence. That would be music to Newcastle's ears if he could bring that to St. James' Park. Just like the players chief scout Graham Carr manages to find on the continent, Galtier could be an astute hiring over more expensive English coaches. Looking like Jose Mourinho, he could be a hidden gem from a country Newcastle have found so many of their players from. United's last foreign coach was Rudd Gullit's disastrous spell in the late 90s... but maybe it is time to try and give another type of French flavoured sexy football a go.

5. Neil Lennon (16-1)

Status: Unemployed Having recently being spotted by WhatCulture.com's senior editor Simon Gallagher at St. James' Park in recent weeks (no mischief here, we believe he was doing punditry work), Neil Lennon has found himself subject of being linked with the Newcastle United job should Pardew be axed. Having delivered three consecutive Scottish league titles with Celtic and many memorable Champions League nights for supporters against the likes of Barcelona and AC Milan, Lennon left his post in Scotland after four years at the end of last season. He has been linked with a move into English football since and the Newcastle job might be of big interest to him. Only 43-years-old, Lennon might be seen as the kind of manager who Ashley could hire to secure Newcastle's long term future in the Premier League and who might be able to take the club to the next level of the Champions League. Completely unproven as a Premier League manager and with a doubt over just how difficult the Celtic job is to win the Scottish league without Rangers being around, Lennon's potential appointment would likely bring a mixed and confused reaction among supporters. Just as we found out when we brought Jean-Alain Boumsong for big money from Rangers all those years ago, becareful what you wish for when it comes to attracting talents who have impressed in Scotland.

4. Steve McClaren (8/1)

Status: Derby County boss Former England manager Steve McClaren regularly finds himself linked with any job in the North East and probably for good reason - he was the last manager to bring silverware to a North East side, delivering Middlesbrough's first ever trophy in 2004 with a League Cup final win over Bolton Wanderers. Yorkshire man McClaren earned the England job after his successful time on Teesside, although his shameful spell as national coach ended when England didn't even qualify for Euro 2004. McClaren's reputation was so low after his dismal England spell that he had to move overseas to carry on his career, ending up in the Dutch league with FC Twente where he enjoyed a surprisingly successful spell, delivering the Eredivisie over rivals Ajax, Feyenoord and PSV Eindhoven. A certain Cheick Tiote was his lynchpin in midfield and he could be seen as the manager to get the best out of him once again, however his more recent spells back in English football and his failure to replicate his Twente success at Wolfsburg and a second spell at Twente might hamper his chances. His European football knowledge will be of interest to owner Mike Ashley whose chief scout Graham Carr is responsible for finding cheaper bargains on the continent than English players. He would be an unglamorous signing in the eyes of Newcastle fans having struggled to regain his reputation in England to gain a Premier League job, but the same can be said of Alan Pardew when he was hired and he lasted way longer than anyone expected.

3. Tony Pulis (4/1)

Status: Unemployed Tony Pulis surprisingly left Crystal Palace just days before the Premier League campaign kicked off under mysterious and mostly unexplained circumstances. He had been Premier League manager last year after guiding Palace from relegation favourites to the lofty heights of Premier League midtable, finishing just one place behind Newcastle in the end, four points behind the Magpies with a much weaker team. He managed to get the best out of unglamorous players and is particularly well known for his side's having discipline and structure. In contrast to Newcastle's crippling defence with experienced players Mike Williamson and Fabricio Coloccini looking amateurish yesterday, Pulis' sides are always solid at the back, believing that you win the game from the back rather than the front. Pulis' Palace last season only conceded one goal from a set play when he was in charge, organisation at the back that has been sorely missed ever since Pardew landed the Newcastle job. Pulis certainly ticks most of the boxes for Ashley, however his unceremonious exit from Crystal Palace just before the campaign, rumoured to be over a break down in relationship between manager and owner, will be a big red flag in his contention for the job. He is a stubborn manager who although would deliver steady campaigns season after season for Ashley, he would only do it his way and wouldn't fit in well under too much interference from a chairman.

2. Steve Bruce (3/1)

Status: Hull City boss Geordie born manager who was formerly in charge of rivals Sunderland quickly emerged as the early favourite for the St. James' Park hot seat just hours after Newcastle's miserable 4-0 defeat at Southampton yesterday. He quickly denied reports linking him with a move to Tyneside and called them unfair with Alan Pardew still in charge of the club. Earlier reports on Saturday claimed that a Geordie dream team of Bruce and Alan Shearer as his assistant would be of interest for Mike Ashley. Given both men's past association with Ashley (Shearer was brought in to rescue the club from relegation after Joe Kinnear's disastrous spell but ultimately sunk the Magpies) and Newcastle fans (Bruce is hardly the man top of any fans list given his miserable time at Sunderland), bringing Bruce back home may not be so easy. Let's also not forget that Bruce has much more power at Hull than he would at Newcastle, particularly over player acquisitions, with Bruce bringing in Hatem Ben Arfa on loan on transfer deadline day from Newcastle, where he wasn't wanted. It's unlikely there was a recall clause to bring Ben Arfa back to Newcastle from Hull and after acquiring other talents such as Mohammed Diame and Gaston Ramirez on deadline day, he might figure he is better off where he is, with a forward-thinking chairman who is willing to back his club to the ends of the Earth to bring success to Hull.

1. David Moyes (2/1)

Status: Unemployed Sacked after delivering Manchester United's worst season of the modern era, Scotsman David Moyes is currently the slight bookies favourite to replace Alan Pardew in the Newcastle United hot seat. Having been out of the game over the summer, Moyes was linked with every Premier League job that came available over pre-season, including the Tottenham Hotspur vacancy that ultimately went to Manuel Pochettino. Despite his failure at Old Trafford, the positives of Moyes for owner Mike Ashley are obvious. He consistently for years managed to punch above his weight with very little resources at Everton. He not only managed to get the best of ordinary players but he could find gems on a limited budget that could be turned over for higher profits when sold. He created many different teams at Everton and also managed the impossible by making them break the top four and delivered Champions League football at Goodison (albeit short lived as they failed in the qualifier). He's available and likely hungry for the opportunity. A manager that only 15 months ago was good enough for the biggest club in the country (and Premier League champions at the time), is likely to be top of Ashley's list. Who do you think should be Newcastle United's new manager?Do any of the above names sound like reasonable choices to replace Alan Pardew?

Editor-in-chief
Editor-in-chief

Matt Holmes is the co-founder of What Culture, formerly known as Obsessed With Film. He has been blogging about pop culture and entertainment since 2006 and has written over 10,000 articles.