Star Trek: 10 WORST Holodeck Episodes
These are the times we've been delighted to hear the words 'Computer, End Program'
The Holodeck is a wonderful thing, really. It can create entire worlds, bring characters to life, and allow crewmembers to go on wild adventures. It also leaves ample room for some morally dubious borrowing of peoples' likenesses, but what's a bit of identity theft between friends?
Sadly, like anything, there's such a thing as too much of a good thing. How many more times can we get the word thing into a sentence? But, the thing is - the Holodeck can be just as detrimental to a story as a benefit. There can be over reliance on the magic box to make everything come out alright in the end, which makes it difficult for the writers to add any stakes to the stories.
For anything to really threaten anyone on the Holodeck, those safety protocols needed to be shut off. Then, one needs to explain why they've shut down this time - and so on, and so forth. Holodeck episodes can be just as groan-inducing as smile-inducing.
Then of course there are the episodes that aren't set on the Holodeck itself, but rather uses the Holodeck as a plot device. Schisms is an excellent example of this, as is Relics. Like anything, it doesn't always land. Let's dive right in.
10. Star Trek: Insurrection
Yes, this is a movie. This entry is here because it stands out in how Starfleet operates. If we compare it to another story that sees a mass transport of people, The Next Generation's Homeward, that case saw a people taken into the Holodeck to save their lives. This was done under duress, as Nikolai Rozhenko managed to transport people without the Enterprise detecting it.
In Insurrection, Starfleet is utilising cloaking technology - the first big issue here - and engaging in a forced resettlement. The resettlement story feels like a retread of Journey's End, while the cloaking technology feels like the writers simply forgot about the Treaty of Algeron.
Then there is the Holodeck within the Holoship itself. It's unlike previous Holodecks the audience has seen, which isn't a crime. What is a crime is the inconsistent rules. Does it work properly, or not? Are those Son'a guards holograms, or not?
It's not that we're against the idea of Holoships, and quite frankly they could be fun, but the biggest issue with this story is that it simply raises too many questions - all for, seemingly, the chance to do a 'cool'.
9. Spirit Folk - Voyager
I'm going to draw on all of the goodwill that I've ever built up in Ireland as I make this shocking statement. While yes, Spirit Folk most certainly does belong on this list, it's really not quite as bad as people might think!
While that statement alone might get me flagged at customs the next time I try to travel anywhere, this episode has definite strong points. The musical score by Jay Chattaway is absolutely gorgeous, and everyone involved commits whole-heartedly to the bit. While the Irish accents are about as good as Tom Cruise in Far And Away, there isn't a sense of meanness to proceedings.
It's never going to rank as one of the best episodes - there is a little too much twee and fiddle-dee-dee going on - but there is a sort of innocence to it that certainly helps. Richard Riehle may be as Irish as the British Crown, but he's charming and loveable all the same.
Now there's still a question in there. Would Maggie O'Halloran have kissed Harry back?
8. Author, Author - Voyager
This may raise a few eyebrows. Generally, EMH-centric episodes tend to be quite good. Author, Author, on its own merit, isn't a bad episode. There's an engaging story, the regulars get to act in new ways, and there's even a trial to evoke The Measure Of A Man to boot.
Therein lies the issue. There's no hiding the fact that Author, Author is an attempt to redo Data's trial to asses his sentience, and this version of the story fails to live up to the original. Added to this, there is no clear ruling by the episode's close. That's to say nothing of the reveal that the EMH Mark 1 program is now used as slave labour in the Federation.
The episode starts as a fun romp through the holodeck, before becoming something a little darker, and even nastier, by the end. This was unfortunately one of a string of episodes in Voyager's final season that felt like padding for time, only with this one, it casually stated that holograms still aren't considered sentient beings, despite dozens of examples to the contrary.
7. Emergence - The Next Generation
As The Next Generation was rounding out its final season, one would assume that they would try to go out on a high. When it comes to both Preemptive Strike and All Good Things, there is no question that they succeeded. Sadly, the same cannot be said of Emergence.
As the third to last episode, was it truly necessary to see a story that suggested the Enterprise itself was becoming sentient? Or, that aside, spending the entire forty minutes moving from one train carriage to another on the holographic Orient Express?
While the train is certainly the derailment of the episode, the opening scene wherein Data plays Prospero from Shakespeare's The Tempest shows off Spiner's range, and comedy skill, at the same time. The biggest crime of the episode that follows is that it's a bit of a slog. While the train sets are quite pleasant, very little else about the episode is. There is an appearance by the Paramount Studios lot as well, one that would become only too familiar to viewers as the franchise went on.
Emergence isn't a terrible episode by any means. It's where it falls in the episode order for The Next Generation's victory lap that truly lets it down.
6. A Matter Of Perspective - The Next Generation
While this episode granted audiences the gift of the Riker Facepalm meme, there is an undeniable fact that, despite the best attempts of all involved, it simply doesn't come together as it should. The holodeck here is used as a tool to tell several versions of the same story.
This is a trope that has been used in media before, and is often a successful way of addressing differing stories. Yet this episode, despite its multitude of plot twists, just sits in that middle section of 'fine'. The true issue, perhaps, it that the mystery isn't at all interesting enough to sustain the case.
The audience knows Riker didn't kill anyone. The audience knows that nothing is going to come of this. So, dragging out the reveal at the end makes this episode feel like a bottle show, crafted to save money, and perhaps rather cynically one could assume it was a cost cutting exercise for Yesterday's Enterprise, which would be the next episode in production order.
But, to end on a positive, we did get that Riker Facepalm, so that makes up for things - a little.
5. Fair Haven - Voyager
Fair Haven is a bit of an oddity. While Spirit Folk has an air of well-intentioned nonsense to it, which I say as an Irishman, Fair Haven is a bit murkier. There's not one thing wrong with wanting to create a nice Irish village for the crew to relax in, nor is it wrong to want to reuse that great village set, one that the audience first saw in The Killing Game.
Fair Haven stumbles because of the tired Irish stereotypes that it employs. Added to this, however, is the odd decision to make Janeway - one of the strongest champions of rights in the franchise - someone who deems being a lowly innkeeper beneath her.
Sure, 'delete the wife' became an iconic joke, and served as inspiration for some fairly fun cosplay at conventions, but Janeway completely rewriting Michael's character to better suit her just seemed out of character. We must also bear in mind that Star Trek: Voyager, out of all of the series, was the one that spent time championing holographic rights, via the character of the EMH.
The story concludes with the program having to be rewritten, which makes the entire outing feel a bit pointless.
4. Once Upon A Time - Voyager
This is one of those episodes that has a truly heartwarming message at its core, though in the execution, it stumbles toward the finish line. Who, exactly, is this episode about? On the surface, surely it concerns Naomi Wildman, and learning to deal with the possibility her mother isn't coming home.
Perhaps it could be about the dangers of serving in Starfleet, with a family to worry about - much like The Next Generation's The Bonding. And then, the episode switches to Neelix, and ends up as something of a rehash or reminder of the first season's Jetrel.
Again, that doesn't make this entry a bad episode so to speak, simply a very muddled one. There are too many ideas going on for it to make a satisfactory whole. Even the inclusion of the nightmare-inducing Ogre of Fire isn't enough to save it, although it does make for a very informative lesson.
Scarlett Pommers is a welcome addition to the crew as Naomi Wildman, and it was nice to see Ensign Samantha Wildman back again, but overall this story was a bit too light for what it set out to achieve, relying a little too heavily on the holodeck in the end, without the back up it needed.
3. The Fight - Voyager
Perhaps its a little generous to describe The Fight as a holodeck episode, though to be fair, I'm not entirely sure if any category would want it in their camp. The qualifier for including it here is that the set in which the majority of the action takes place - that boxing ring - makes its first appearance as a holodeck recreation. That good enough for everyone?
Chakotay episodes tended to swing for the fences as Voyager went on through its seven-year run. Coming in the fifth season, this episode is really a good example of nothing really happening to affect anything overall. While the appearance of Ray Walston's Boothby is always welcome, the entire subplot of Chakotay's grandfather losing his mind, and his grandson's fear of that happening to him, never goes anywhere.
It would also mark the first, and only, reference to Chakotay's boxing days in the series. If perhaps anything had come of this episode, then it might be excusable - but instead, we're siding with Kid Chaos in this one. Knock the Maquis Mauler out, and be quick about it!
2. Booby Trap - The Next Generation
Booby Trap is an episode that was handled poorly during production and release, and the years that have passed have not been kind to it. It really is a shame because there are certainly strong parts to the story, but then we get the whole Geordi on the holodeck thing.
To be fair, LeVar Burton hated this storyline, and the subsequent episode Galaxy's Child. The issue lies in how the writers handled his relationship with Leah Brahms. In this episode, she was created to be an interface with whom he could work, enjoying a one to one with a 'person', instead of the off-screen voice of the main computer.
However, Leah is presented as something close to a slave, with amorous intent, and is shown stroking the back of Geordi's neck. This is the scientist who we are told designed the main engines on the Galaxy-class ship. Gosh, isn't it great she can have a career AND please a man?
It was not handled or presented well, which makes this an uncomfortable watch. In the follow up, when the real Dr. Brahms discovers this program, Geordi is shown getting angry at her for feeling that way, as opposed to facing the inappropriate actions themselves.
All things considered, neither episode are Star Trek's best.
1. These Are The Voyages - Enterprise
Presumably, this will surprise absolutely no one. These Are The Voyages aired as the final episode in Star Trek: Enterprise's run, and was designed as a love letter to that entire era of Trek, from 1987 until 2005. However, rather than serving as a crowd-pleasing send-off, it instead offered a rather ignoble end for this cast of characters.
There are truly any number of reasons to choose from. We could go with Trip's death. We could address Riker's odd interactions with T'Pol. There's the thought of sandwiching this story into The Pegasus, one of The Next Generation's strongest episodes from its final season.
Instead, we'll simply use this example: Captain Jonathan Archer hugs T'Pol, and ascends the steps to deliver one of the most iconic speeches in Federation history - and then, before he gets a chance to open his mouth, Riker ends the program, and Star Trek: Enterprise just ends - even with that closing passage showing Picard's, Kirk's and Archer's Enterprises one after the other.
It was a jarring ending to a series that deserved better, and though perhaps as a standalone event it could have been an interesting what if, instead it serves as a damp squib of an ending to the final Trek series of that era.