1 Reason Why Evil Morty Isn't Rick's Original Morty (And 5 Why He Is)
Who is the one true Morty?
Rick and Morty. Batman and Robin. Han Solo and Chewbacca.
How nicely does the grandpa/grandson team sit in the league of all-time protagonists and sidekicks? Well, Rick can't really be said to be a hero, of course, so there is that.
Rick and Morty as a series can't be said to have had a strong narrative running through it, though there is one evolving story in the show that has drawn the attention of all who watch the show. That is, of course, the Evil Morty saga.
Evil Morty was introduced in the first season as a sidekick to Evil Rick, though it's later revealed that Evil Rick is a robot being controlled by Evil Morty who escapes with the other Mortys that he captured and sent to live on the Citadel of Ricks. Evil Morty is shown to be everything a normal Morty isn't, namely highly intelligent, cunning, unscrupulous, sadistic, and cold.
His appearance in the show has caused debate among fans as to where he has come from, and, while there are a few good theories out there, one has captured the fans' attention more than the rest.
This is the one that says Evil Morty is Rick's original Morty and that Rick C137 isn't who he says he is. This theory would certainly fit in well with the show, because there are some things that don't add up with Rick's backstory, as well as some of the comments made in the show that seem to support such an idea.
So, let's look at the reasons why this is true and one why it could all be smoke and mirrors.
6. Why He Isn't - It Might Be Too Convenient
The issue with all of this is that until it is a proven theory, it remains hearsay and conjecture.
Rick and Morty is one of the only shows, other than something like Futurama, that can simply dispel with something that is seemingly important by using its setting to throw it out as quickly as it can be thought of.
This has been the case on a few occasions, for example when Rick just shifted him and Morty to a new dimension because they wrecked the old one beyond repair. It's a very easy and obvious answer that they take because they can, though there are aforementioned caveats to it.
Rick can just pull a solution out of thin air and use the show's multi-verse premise to explain it away in a second. So, is the Evil Morty theory just too convenient? It has had many things that point in that direction, but this could all just be one big red herring.
Evil Morty being the original Morty of our Rick might not be a good theory for this show just because it's too obvious a road to go down. Especially with a series that uses the obvious to its own end, often ending up in a mixture of the obvious and the totally off the wall.
5. Why He Is - Rick's Memories
This is perhaps the biggest indicator that something isn't right with Rick C137's backstory.
When Rick is tied to the table and he and Evil Rick (Evil Morty) are talking about themselves, we see some of the memories that Rick has in his head - one of which shows us Rick picking up Baby Morty.
This is a huge moment because Rick's whole backstory is that he has been gone for 20 years and only a year before the events of the show has he come back to live with the Smith family. So, how would he have ever met Baby Morty? This is something that directly contradicts everything we know about C137 in the show since it's proof that he has been lying about something to do with Morty.
While Rick's travels in time could explain away him meeting a Baby Morty somewhere, it wouldn't explain the other moment that reveals Rick's true feelings towards his Morty. That is that he is shown to be crying whilst looking at the memory.
Cut to another episode of the show - The Rickshank Redemption - where, whilst in a Mexican stand-off with one Rick of the Council of Ricks, Council Rick tells C137 that he is a renegade Rick, that he is emotional toward his grandchildren.
Cut back to the table and it makes sense. Rick had raised a Morty to not have any of the nervousness that Jerry has in him, to be a great, clever being, only for that Morty to eventually rebel and cause problems. However, upon seeing those memories, Rick C137 cries at the memory of his original Morty.
This all has the feeling of an endgame somewhere, where we'll find out once and for all who the Evil Morty really is.
4. Rick's Warning To Morty
Once again, in the episode Close Rick-counters of the Rick Kind we're fed more information than would ostensibly be useless if the Evil Morty being Rick's original Morty theory weren't true.
When the day has been saved and both Rick and Morty C137 are headed back to their own dimension, Morty is angry with Rick for not caring about Morty. Though in his own way he rebuffs this accusation by saying that he is the Rick-est Rick, and that if that is true then Morty would be the Morty-ist Morty.
Seeing that Morty seems to like this, Rick warns Morty against the dangers of a cocky Morty, saying it can lead to some very bad things happening. When Morty questions this, Rick simply replies that he'll tell him when he's older.
This can be taken a number of ways. One of which may indicate that Evil Morty is slightly older than the other Morty's in the universe, though that isn't an accepted theory. Another thing that can be taken from it, is that something went wrong in Rick C137's past that gave him the awareness of that specific danger.
The fact that we cut to Evil Morty's reveal directly after this sequence gives credence to that being true.
3. Evil Morty's Specific Discussion With Rick
When we're first introduced to Evil Morty in the episode Close Rick-counters of the Rick Kind, we're led to believe that he is following his Rick. Of course, this is subsequently shown to be untrue, as that Rick is a robot which is being controlled by the eyepatch Morty (later Evil Morty).
After our Rick and Morty are captured by Evil Rick and Evil Morty, they are separated and Rick is tied down on a table with a device hooked up to him that will read his memories. We find out a great many things in this scene (some of which will feature later), however when viewed with the knowledge that this was actually Evil Morty having a discussion with Rick, the game changes - specifically the line Evil Rick says about Ricks not caring about Mortys.
This line gives an indication as to why Rick C137 is the target of Evil Morty in the episode. Perhaps Evil Morty has been betrayed by Rick at some point in the past and is using the robot Evil Rick to get some answers out of him.
It becomes clear that Evil Morty's plan was to kill Rick after taking his memories out. Though, more intriguingly Evil Morty has no real feeling toward Morty C137 when he meets him, other than to just put him in a cell with the other captured Morty's. This indicates that his beef is with just Rick C137, as opposed to Morty C137 too.
2. Rick's Knowledge Of Dimension Hopping
In Rick Potion #9, when Rick helps Morty by giving him a serum so that anybody he gives it to outside of his family will fall in love with him, he kicks off a chain of events that leads to Rick being unable to fix the mess he has created.
So, he finds a new reality where he fixed everything but died with Morty in an unrelated explosion, and the duo go there and assume the places of that universe's Rick and Morty. When he does, this Rick tells Morty that they can only do this a couple more times.
This raises the question of Rick's knowledge that he can do this in the first place. The show's premise is that Rick just showed up after 20 years away and moved in with Beth and the family. So, what if Rick C137 isn't Rick C137? What if this Rick just dimension-hopped to get away from another mess that he caused? And why hasn't he brought his Morty with him, in that case?
Well, if that Morty was the Evil Morty, who had gone beyond Rick's control and begun being a problem for Rick - a problem so big that Rick was forced to flee - that would fit in very nicely in the Evil Morty is Rick's original Morty theory. He knows that they can dimension hop because he has already done it.
1. The Opening Credits
Rick and Morty's opening credits show a vast plethora of adventures the two have undertaken over the year that Rick C137 has been back in the Smiths' lives. Or does it?
What if those weren't adventures that Rick and our Morty have undertaken, and instead they are a precursor to the entire series? In the Evil Morty saga when running for President of the Citadel, Evil Morty himself has been asked where his original Rick is and what dimension they're from. He responds by claiming not to remember because they moved about so much.
Now, with a cunning genius like Evil Morty, this clearly is a diversion as to the real answer. So, what if the opening titles were in fact the original adventures of Rick and the original Morty. We see almost nothing of C137 Morty's adventures in those credits, which makes you wonder why the animators would go to so much trouble of animating whole adventure sequences without ever expanding upon them.
What if this was just a part of Evil Morty's eventual reveal as Rick's original Morty? If so, this would be a phenomenally well-thought-out arc if it was to come true.
To see all those adventures rendered before our eyes as one of the biggest signs that the show wasn't all we thought it was and was in-fact hiding something huge in plain sight? That would be complete and utter genius from the minds behind Rick and Morty.