10 Actors Who Turned Down Doctor Who

You mean Han Solo could have also been the Doctor?

Hugh Grant Doctor Who
BBC

Doctor Who has certainly come a long way, from its 1963 debut to Jodie Whittaker being the first woman ever to undertake the role of the Time Lord. The franchise has expanded out from just being a single television series, as there have also been many spin-offs, audio dramas, comics, and novels based around the original show. It is now a significant part of British pop culture and has since gained a cult following.

The programme is approaching its sixtieth anniversary, and a lot has happened to the series within that timeframe. Overall, there’s been thirteen Doctors, each of them with companionship and a variety of enemies to face.

But it does make us wonder how different the show could have been with perhaps a different actor to play the leading role. The following list recounts a surprising amount of well-known actors who turned down the chance of playing the beloved Doctor, most of which regret their decision of turning down such an opportunity.

10. Benedict Cumberbatch

Benedict Cumberbatch Sherlock
BBC

Benedict Cumberbatch is one of the most versatile actors within today’s industry, having performed in many films, television shows, theatre productions, and radio programmes, as well as lending his voice for narration. One of his more notable roles was as Sherlock in the television mystery drama of the same name.

Benedict had the chance to become the Eleventh Doctor, before Matt Smith was cast for the role. The Sherlock star didn’t think he’d be the right fit for the character, despite the Tenth Doctor David Tennant encouraging him to go for it. But the actor simply wasn’t interested in taking on such a role, and had other work that would clash with the show’s timings. Furthermore, Cumberbatch didn’t want to be the face of several pieces of merchandise.

However, the actor did admit he wouldn’t mind appearing in a one-off episode.


9. Boris Karloff

Frankenstein Boris Karloff
Universal Pictures

Boris Karloff, the legendary actor to play Frankenstein’s creation, was no stranger to being a part of monstrous stories, almost becoming the face of the horror movie genre in the 1930s.

During the late 1960s, Karloff was in mind to play the Doctor for a spin-off radio series. He declined as he was unavailable at the time. Peter Cushing stepped in to record a pilot, but the BBC passed on the series (the original recording hasn’t been found since).

However, a clip of Frankenstein (1931) appeared in the Doctor Who movie, meaning Boris did eventually feature within the franchise, even if it was brief and not as the Doctor.


8. Peter Cushing

Peter Cushing Frankenstein
Hammer Film Productions

The late Peter Cushing had a laudable career to say the least. Spanning over several decades, the actor has appeared in more than one-hundred films, as well as taking on many television, radio, and stage roles.

Peter Cushing technically has played the Time Lord before. In the 1960s, he accepted the role of appearing in two Doctor Who movies – Dr Who and the Daleks (1965) and Daleks – Invasion Earth: 2150 AD (1966). The films were remakes of stories from the television series and changed the alien Doctor to an actual human scientist.

But in terms of the main television series, Cushing declined the chance for the second Doctor. The actor allegedly had conflicting schedules but also admitted even if he didn’t have other work lined up, he probably would have still turned down the role.


7. Ron Moody

Ron Moody The Twelve Chairs
UMC Pictures

Ron Moody became a big name in the industry of acting after his role as Fagin in Oliver (1968). The musical achieved several Oscars nominations at the Academy Awards, one of which included Ron for Best Actor in a Leading Role.

Naturally, this led to greater opportunities for the actor, and a chance to play the third Doctor for the increasingly popular television sci-fi series. Moody turned down the part and the role went Jon Pertwee. He later admitted this was one of his biggest regrets in his career.

Decades later, Ron Moody was cast in the Big Fish Production audio drama ‘Other Lives’, based on the Doctor Who television show. He played The Duke of Wellington.


6. Brian Blessed

Brian Blessed
Universal Studios

Dating all the way back to the 1960s, Brian Blessed was in line to replace the very first Doctor. Although he was enthusiastic for the role, Blessed allegedly wanted to make some drastic changes to the part, which the BBC weren't willing to comply with. One of these ideas included changing the race of the Doctor, to make the protagonist Chinese. Brian also had other projects in line which may have clashed with the filming schedule of the programme.

Brian didn’t completely leave the series behind, as during the Sixth Doctor's era, he played King Yrcanos in ‘The Trial of a Time Lord’. The actor has also admitted he’d still love to play the title role, if given the chance.


5. Geoffrey Bayldon

Catweazle Geoffrey Bayldon
BBC

Alan Webb, Cyril Cusack, and Leslie French were amongst the potential actors to play the very first Doctor, back in 1963. But perhaps the biggest name of all was Geoffrey Bayldon – famed stage performer and star of the children’s series Catweazle. Bayldon declined the offer because it was a long schedule of 52 weeks and required him to play an old man.

Despite not playing the lead role, Bayldon is not shy of working on many Doctor Who-based projects. He had a guest appearance as Organon in “The Creature from the Pit”, alongside Tom Baker as the Fourth Doctor. He also played an alternative first Doctor in two audio plays based on the television series in the Doctor Who unbound series: Auld Mortality (2003) and A Storm of Angels (2005).


4. Bill Nighy

Hot Fuzz Bill Nighy
Universal Pictures

Bill Nighy has created a huge legacy for himself, as he has become immensely popular for his work in film, theatre, and television. From Pirates of the Caribbean to About Time, the actor has starred in an impressive number of critically acclaimed movies.

In early 2004, it was reported that Nighy was strongly considered to play the Ninth Doctor in the revival. He declined the chance as he felt the role of the doctor “came with too much baggage”. He refused to confirm whether this was prior to Christopher Eccleston landing the gig or not.

However, Bill did make a cameo appearance on the TV show, during the period of the Eleventh Doctor. He played Dr Henry Black in ‘Vincent and the Doctor’. Coincidentally, this episode was written by Richard Curtis, a producer who Nighy has worked with on several occasions.


3. Alan Cumming

Alan Cumming Doctor Who
BBC

Scottish actor Alan Cumming, known for various London stage appearances and the character of Eli Gold on The Good Wife, has been offered the role of the Doctor twice and has rejected the character both times.

Cumming was initially considered for the role in Doctor Who by original series writer Russell T. Davies – a man who played a big part in reviving the show in 2005. It was a great opportunity for both the series itself and Alan, who was mostly willing to undertake the part. But as the actor was living in New York at the time, he wasn’t willing to re-locate to Wales. Later on, Mark Gatiss offered him the role again but Cumming turned it down for the very same reason of not wanting to live in Wales for such a long period of time.

Alan did eventually agree to a guest appearance on the science fiction show, as King James I, in Jodie Whittaker’s series.


2. Tom Hanks, Jim Carrey And Harrison Ford

Harrison Ford Jim Carrey Tom Hanks
20th Century Fox/Universal Pictures

Why are all three of these Hollywood A-list actors lumped together in one entry, you might ask? Because they all have one thing in common – Tom Hanks, Harrison Ford, and Jim Carrey were all, at one point, offered to play the eighth Doctor in the 1996 TV Movie of Doctor Who.

Both Fox and Universal Studios wanted a big name attached to the movie as the leading role. But all three men rejected the role for different reasons. Hanks was a huge fan of the franchise and would have loved to have portrayed the Doctor, but felt as though an American playing the main character wouldn’t have done justice for the show’s legacy. Meanwhile, Carrey turned down the opportunity because he had never actually seen an episode of the main show and believed audiences would have been outraged by a non-fan playing such an iconic character. As for Harrison Ford, he simply didn’t want to work in television.


1. Hugh Grant

Hugh Grant Doctor Who
BBC

Hugh Grant has become a household name for starring as the charming, slightly awkward lead in almost every Richard Curtis movie, from Four Weddings and a Funeral to Love Actually.

When Doctor Who was re-booted in 2005, Hugh was the first choice to play the Ninth Doctor for the classic sci-fi series. He was actually no stranger to the role as he had portrayed the title character for a Red Nose Day special.

The actor turned down the role because he believed the revival wouldn’t be successful enough, and the role ultimately went to Christopher Eccleston. However, Grant later expressed his deep regret after the show was incredibly successful.


Watch Next


Quiz: How Well Do You Know Doctor Who?

Doctor Who William Hartnell First Doctor One Day I Shall Come Back
BBC

1. What Year Did The First Episode Of Doctor Who Air?

Contributor

Coffee Addict, Cartoon Obsessed, Theatre Kid