10 American Dad Episodes That Pissed People Off
American Dad! is a great show, but there were times it really missed the mark.
If Family Guy is to Seth MacFarlane what The Simpsons is to Matt Groening, then American Dad! is very much in the same category as Futurama. A brilliant second show having to struggle to break free from the shadow of what came before it.
American Dad! has never been able to enjoy quite the same popularity as Family Guy, despite being just as funny, and arguably even better at times. Like most cartoons, its quality has dropped over time, but it still has a loyal army of fans, if smaller than it deserves.
However, even among those fans there have been episodes that have crossed the line and pissed people off. In typical Seth MacFarlane fashion there are controversial topics tackled by American Dad!, as well as jokes and stories used solely for shock value that may have worked a little too well.
There are also episodes that fans can’t stand, not out of any principle or disagreement with how a message was put across, but just because they were that bad. American Dad! has had its mix of these different episodes, all with the one thing in common that they made a lot of people mad.
10. Hot Water (S8E1)
American Dad! over the years has produced some genuinely funny and intelligent stories. From down to Earth family matters, to those that could only be brought to life by a CIA man and an alien. However, this was not one of those episodes.
The opening outing of season eight saw the Smith family buy a hot tub that started to tear Stan and Francine apart. Voiced by Cee-Lo Green, who also narrated the episode, this hot tub was sentient, and tried to break them up.
Firstly, it’s a terrible concept for an episode, with the framing device of the real life Cee-Lo missing the mark. It wasn’t funny, it was just weird, and while musical episodes are rarely ever received particularly well, this was worse than most.
There was nothing necessarily offensive about the episode, particularly when compared to some of the outings that will appear higher on this list, fans hated it instead just because it was one of the worst episodes the show has ever put out. An unfunny, uninspired waste of 20 minutes.
9. American Fung (S11E17)
This episode started in a similar way to 'Hot Water', as fictional Chinese billionaire Fung Wah addressed viewers in live action. He had traded a tennis shoe business to Seth MacFarlane for control of American Dad!, and was now running things.
It was incredibly weird, and the episode only got worse. Despite the business mogul claiming the show would be exactly the same as before, it was littered with references to him, his vast fortune, and bizarre fictional product placement. This was clearly supposed to be a payoff from the episode’s opening, but it just didn’t land. At all.
In the same way as Cee-Lo Green’s hot tub, this set up to the episode just didn’t work, and left fans more confused than anything, while both stories throughout the episode were lessened significantly by these ‘jokes’.
Stan’s arc of forgetting his and Francine’s anniversary yet again was already tired and something that has been done many times before, while Roger, Steve, and Hayley’s story only existed to bring Fung Wah into the episode further. This just missed on all levels.
8. Don't Look A Smith Horse In The Mouth (S6E10)
Sometimes an episode doesn’t need to be inherently bad or particularly offensive to earn the hate of so many people watching. Often it can take just one single, solitary scene to ruin an entire episode, which is exactly what happened in season six.
With the family in monetary troubles, Stan and Roger went in on racehorse together to help pay for the former's stupidly expensive car. When he punched Roger in the arm for telling Francine he sunk all of their money into said horse, Roger wanted payback.
He pranked Stan by telling him the horse was in need of a ‘full release’, something exactly as disgusting as it sounds. He was completely joking, but Stan bought it and did the chore all the same. The next scene suggestively showed him being sprayed with an off camera water hose, something which did not go down with viewers well to say the least.
Fox reportedly received over 100,000 complaints from this episode, as well as a hefty $25,000 fine. You can safely add bestiality to the long list of ill-advised jokes made on American Dad! thanks to 'Don't Look A Smith Horse In The Mouth'.
7. Shallow Vows (S6E6)
One of the key aspects of making a show like American Dad! successful is loveable and relatable characters. For the most part, Stan Smith fits into this category in spite of his flaws, but there have been several times that he showed his true colours.
'Shallow Vows' is one such episode, where Stan is so hateful it put a bad taste in the mouth for the entire episode. When he and Francine were renewing their vows for their 20th anniversary, Stan told her that literally the only reason he married her was her physical appearance. What a dick.
As something of a form of revenge, Francine stopped doing her intense beauty regimen for two weeks so that Stan could see her as she really was, and he hated what he saw. The only way he could still be with her was to make himself blind so he couldn’t be so disgusted by her.
It was Stan however, who was disgusting in this episode. He treated his wife like crap, used her for her body, and had no remorse until it affected himself, never actually caring about Francine’s feelings. Shallow indeed.
6. Oedipal Panties (S4E11)
It’s not uncommon to see an episode of Seth MacFarlane’s cartoons flirt with the idea of incest. It’s a strange, cringe-inducing sentence to start this entry with, but it’s true. Meg and Chris have kissed before in Family Guy, while the latter has been attracted to his own mother, and in American Dad! Hayley once went out with Stan’s exact body double.
'Oedipal Panties' in season four took things much further however, as Stan was revealed to be way too close to his mom for anyone’s comfort. Francine, Roger, and everyone watching this episode was just horrified.
Every time Betty Smith would start a seeing a new man, Stan would get rid of them so he could look after her himself. This, on one occasion, stretched to taking a candle-lit bath with her and scrubbing her clean. This wasn’t funny, it was just wrong.
As Roger put it, changing planes at O’Hare is complicated, but this rendered even the alien who has done some truly disgusting things throughout his life speechless. Does someone need to have a conversation with Mr. MacFarlane and tell him no one is watching his cartoons for their incest storylines?
5. Stan's Best Friend (S8E14)
There have been jokes and stories on American Dad! that have offended more than its fair share of people, but this was an episode that upset dog lovers everywhere. For a lot of people, seeing a dog go through the things Kisses had to go through just wasn’t tasteful.
When the new family dog was badly injured, triggering Stan’s tragic memories of having to put his childhood pet down, he decided he would do anything to keep Kisses alive. This led him to Doctor Lizzy, who practiced alternative pet medicine.
She was incredibly creepy, but she promised to keep Kisses alive, which she did. However, the Frankenstein’s Monster that she turned him into was incredibly disturbing, and was absolutely not Kisses anymore.
For the most part, the injured dog was kept hidden from view, but when he was finally shown it was vomit-inducing. His skull was replaced with a softball mitt, his eyes and testicles had been swapped round, and his back legs were from a frog and chicken while he was constantly having to be electrically shocked to stay alive. Not fun viewing, this one.
4. Camp Refoogee (S3E1)
Like Family Guy, American Dad! has a history of making jokes about subjects that are bound to offend people watching. Whether the show is genuinely trying to make a point through satire, or just going for shock value, there will always be stories that cross that line of being okay.
In 'Camp Refoogee', Stan’s mistakes a refugee camp for a summer camp. After sending Steve there and realizing his mistake, he made it his mission to change it into a summer camp, either ignoring or making light of the deathly struggles the campers had to live with.
Instead of Malaria pills or water he brought them tetherballs, he gave everyone nicknames when he couldn’t be bothered to learn their real names, and he laughed off both a bloody rebel invasion and the kidnapping of Makeva as if it were nothing more than a ‘panty raid’.
The writers may have been trying to make a statement about how the world views the problems of third world countries, but in making so many tasteless jokes about it, were they actually much better? There’s a fine line between sending a message and taking the p*ss here, and American Dad! landed on the wrong side of it.
3. The 42 Year Old Virgin (S4E6)
Despite his reputation with his family and with the CIA as a cold blooded killer, Stan Smith had never actually killed anybody. He spent this entire episode trying to find the right person to be his first murder victim in a spoof of the 40 Year Old Virgin, before finally learning his lesson at the end.
There are a lot of episodes of American Dad! that end with the stubborn and pig-headed Stan learning a lesson, but viewers weren’t happy that this came by way of the paedophile that was trying to molest Steve at the water park.
The message of the episode was solid enough. Stan wasn’t a killer, and instead of trying so desperately to be someone he’s not, he should just accept who he is. However, this just didn’t sit right when framed by a paedophile having no remorse for his vile actions.
The depiction of Steve and his friends being groomed by Randy was enough for some to turn the TV off before even getting to the end of the episode, which is probably a good thing. The conclusion just made things even worse.
2. Surrogate (S4E7)
Like most leading characters in cartoons, Stan Smith has his flaws. The likes of Homer Simpson, Peter Griffin, Rick Sanchez, and BoJack Horseman all have their notable shortcomings, but in season four, one of Stan’s worst traits was on full display.
When Greg and Terry decided they wanted to use in vitro and a surrogate mother to have a baby, Stan all of a sudden had incredibly homophobic principles he would die for. He had struggled to accept that his neighbours were gay years before, but this took things to a whole new level.
He was disgusted with Francine for agreeing to carry their child, and when she born, Stan actually stole her from the hospital. He took Liberty with the intention of getting her to Nebraska, where gay couples have no legal rights, and putting her up for adoption. He even met a lesbian couple along the way, and despite agreeing that they had a wonderful family, he stole their children too.
Ultimately, Stan sees the error of his ways by the end of the episode, but the damage was already done. Greg and Terry didn’t forgive him, (why on Earth would they?), and after watching this episode it is genuinely hard to remember why Stan is so loved as the protagonist of the show.
1. Homeland Insecurity (S1E6)
When American Dad! first debuted in 2005, it was Seth MacFarlane’s satirical take on post-9/11 paranoia in America. Stan Smith worked at the CIA, and was a caricature of an extreme right Republican sitting on edge waiting for the next terrorist attack.
Though he evolved to be much more than this over the years, this was typically the limit of his character in the early days. The show always played close to the line with this concept, but ‘Homeland Insecurities’ took it way too far.
When Bob and Linda Memari moved into the Smith’s neighbourhood in just the sixth episode of the series, Stan devolved from someone on terror alert to an outright racist. He assumed that just because they were Iranian that they were terrorists, and presented a real bomb threat to his family.
He threw away the food they brought to Francine’s party, spied on them for proof despite having no real reason to actually suspect them, and imprisoned them in his own back yard. This just wasn’t funny, and was incredibly offensive, even for Stan.