10 Anime That Have No Right To Be This Good
Alien teachers, cosplay romance, bunny girls - who could have seen these gems coming?
Everyone loves sharing their interests with friends, family and the world. This is, unfortunately, why being an anime fan can be a tough lot, as it can be a real uphill battle to convince people that the medium is worth their time. You'll end up like Sisyphus rolling that bolder if you're not careful, as the genre has a (mostly) unfair reputation for being juvenile, smutty and utterly bonkers.
Now, times have changed a bit, with anime becoming a far more mainstream hobby in the last decade or so. Still, even with that shift, it can be tricky to debate the perception of anime as a lesser medium. That goes double for these epic shows, as they have everything working against them.
The following anime did their best to produce something compelling, fun or emotional - or even all three in some cases. Yet, external factors made it hard to believe that they'd be any good at all. Whether it's the art style, the concept, the studio or any other factor, it's safe to say no one expected what they got when sticking these animated shows on.
It just goes to show that you shouldn't judge a book - or an anime - by its cover.
10. Assassination Classroom
It makes sense to start this list off with something as bonkers as Assassination Classroom, as it's one of the most popular properties in the medium, yet explaining it to an outsider leaves you with a face redder than a baboon. Still, if you can get behind the wild plot, you'll be rewarded with something exceptional.
Assassination Classroom tells the story of a class of kids tasked with killing their teacher. However, far from being the wild fantasies of the average high schooler, their sensei is an uber-powerful, octopus-like alien who recently blew a hole in the moon and plans on destroying the Earth in one year. Thus, they've got a real task ahead of them, and a failing grade means planetwide annihilation.
Getting to know the alien teacher (Korosensei) might seem like a tough pill to swallow, but he sucks you in without a struggle. Despite his threat to the world, he's funny, quirky and genuinely cares for the kids, making him an ideal teacher. This, naturally, fills the show with a sentimentality you would never have expected. It's just like Dead Poets Society - if Robin Williams was an octopus monster.
The show is full of quirky humour, loveable characters, tense moments and a surprising amount of heart.
9. Saga Of Tanya The Evil
Now it's time to discuss a little thing called isekai. For the uninitiated, isekai is a genre where someone is transported from the ordinary world into a fantastical one. If proving your worth as an anime was a track race, then being an isekai would give every show a penalty that causes a late start.
While there are some great ones, it's still a genre known for being a shallow power fantasy for young boys with harems, fan service, overpowered characters and lacklustre storytelling galore. Thus, this weird anime seemed like it would be dead on arrival.
Saga of Tanya the Evil depicts the events after a man dies in the real world and is reincarnated as a little girl in an alternate world at war. Despite only being a kid, she uses her retained memories to climb the ranks.
As if being isekai wasn't bad enough, the show also has to contend with every character being vile and unlikeable. Despite this, you'll get hooked on the unique world, as this isn't your ordinary World War - unless yours had magic guns and flying humans.
The use of magic in a WW2 setting is creative and leads to some pulse-pounding action sequences. Plus, Tanya herself is a blast. She certainly is a reprehensible little gal, but you'll still get invested in all the chaos she causes.
8. My Dress-Up Darling
There's a common trope not just in anime but in storytelling overall, where an awkward boy has a surprising encounter with a cool popular girl, and they set off on an unconventional romance. Usually, it's not going to be anything special, as there's not much you can do with the concept at this point. But, My Dress-Up Darling says, "hold my beer", and gives you something unique.
Gojo is a young man with the unconventional hobby of creating Hina dolls. He's a social outcast at school and feels deep shame for his passion, but a chance encounter with the popular (but geeky as hell) Marin changes that. She reveals a passion for cosplay, and his strange hobby lands him a role as her costume maker.
The series certainly has its fair share of risqué moments, but beneath that is a heart and soul that cannot be ignored. It's an incredibly passionate show that delves deep into the intricacies of cosplay, teaching you so much about the subculture that you have the tools to delve into it yourself.
Plus, the romance between Gojo and Marin is so well executed. They've got great chemistry, which fills the screen with plenty of heartfelt moments. Besides this, the show is also a coming-of-age story that explores powerful themes like social anxiety, gender roles, societal norms and more. Not bad for a goofy cosplay romance.
7. Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Magical girls are the kind of thing you need to expect in anime. They are normally pretty harmless, as you either love them or are entirely indifferent towards them. While many people (this author included) side with the latter, there is one exceptional show that should still fall under your radar as it's quite a thrilling ride. It's called *deep breath* Puella Magi Madoka Magica.
This show follows a group of young middle-schoolers who take out contracts to become Magical Girls and fight against enemies known as witches. But, the warnings of a Magical Girl named Homura soon start to make sense, as it seems there is a painful price to be paid when undertaking these roles.
You'd be mistaken in thinking this is a sugary coated and cute anime, as it's far from it. The show is shockingly dark, with the adorable visuals only serving to take you by surprise. It's packed with death, sombreness, despair and a heaping host of shocking moments that challenge the conventions of the Magical Girl subgenre.
The whole purpose of this show is to act as a mash-up of cuteness and nihilism, which is why it's so perfect for a list like this.
6. Ya Boy Kongming
It's time now to take another dive into isekai, but this time it's a reverse version, where someone from a fascinating land is reborn into the modern world.
As the ancient Chinese strategist Kongming lies on his deathbed, he finds himself reborn in modern-day Japan. There, he is entranced by the music of a local singer, Eiko, and offers his services to help her achieve her dreams and cure the world through music.
You might be able to tell here that the concept is utterly bonkers. An ancient strategist helping someone navigate the music industry sounds like the product of some pretty intense narcotics, but that's where the show thrives.
Kongming's fascinating strategies genuinely keep you on edge, and you're suckered in so easily as you want to see Eiko succeed. Her dreams are constantly hung by a thread, giving Kongming's risky plans incredibly high (and believable) stakes.
Still, the show's biggest highlight is the spectacular musical sequences. The songs are catchy, emotional and full of soul, which, when combined with the punchy and energetic direction, give Eiko's performances all the energy of a real-life Beyoncé concert.
It's a show that could have been lazy and average but excels thanks to its passion for music and live performance.
5. Beastars
Looking at pictures of Beastars without context might have you thinking it's for a certain kind of crowd who maybe like to dress up as wolves (*cough* furries *cough*), but to box it in like that would be a mistake.
Beastars takes place in a world of anthropomorphic animals, where society is divided into two categories, herbivores and carnivores. After a brutal murder at Cherryton Academy, the shy and reclusive wolf Legoshi sets off on a journey of discovery as he develops feelings for a white dwarf rabbit and searches for the killer. The story evolves from there into an epic tale of societal pressure and predatory instincts.
It's true that this description probably has you thinking, "so, it's an anime version of Zootopia?" but you're barking up the wrong tree as you shouldn't expect anything that sweet. Beastars may have a cute presentation, but it's way more dark, violent and sexual (yes, really!) than anything Disney has produced.
The show juggles so many elements. It's a compelling murder mystery with action, romance, politics and even slice-of-life school drama. With all those puzzle pieces, you'd think it would be a jumbled mess, but it handles each segment masterfully, forming the picture of a complex character study and an incredibly well-built world.
4. Uncle From Another World
Well, it looks like it's a hattrick for isekai anime. Thus far, you've seen a regular but surprisingly brilliant one and a shockingly compelling reverse version. Now it's time to look at an isekai that lovingly pokes fun at the genre with self-awareness, solid humour and some amusing satire.
Uncle From Another World does just what it says on the tin. It shows as a young boy (Takafumi) meets with his uncle, who has awoken from a 17-year-long coma. Bizarrely, his uncle claims to have been in an alternate fantasy world that whole time, and Takafumi, quite rightfully, chocks it off as insanity. That is until the uncle shows him some of the magic skills he learned there.
There's so much to love about the series, but the uncle is the sore thumb that sticks out best. He's effortlessly adorable and likeable, despite his very creepy visage. His poor looks even play into the story, as he's supposed to seem like a deadbeat loser.
A lot of the show's humour comes from the uncle misunderstanding isekai tropes. You're shown memories from his time in another world and constantly watch as he ruins his chances at a power fantasy adventure. He ignores the loving elf following him around, continually breaks things and is bullied by everyone for being an "orc face". It's a hilarious role reversal of your typical iskeai.
3. Kaguya-Sama: Love Is War
A high school romance based in a school council? Yeah, that sounds average at best. But, you sprinkle in a unique concept like romantic battle mechanics and, hey presto, you've got yourself a modern classic.
Kaguya-Sama: Love Is War seems like your typical anime romance on paper, as it shows two students dancing around their feelings for each other. But, rather than getting off the train at that stop, the show keeps riding it by turning the whole thing into a full-on war.
You see, whoever confesses their love first loses, and so to win, the ice-queen Kaguya and the prodigy student Shirogane must use tactics, seedy methods and wits to coerce the other into confessing first. This takes the mundane setting and turns Kaguya-Sama into one of the most visually/narratively extravagant anime ever produced. There are times when it gets so intense you'd think you were watching Death Note.
While these "battle" mechanics mellow out eventually, the show never lets up on the over-the-top energy, pouring so much into even tiny moments to make them feel bombastic and exciting. One example of this is the rap scene in season three, which could have easily been simple but went above and beyond to be as wild and fun as possible.
The show has NO need to go this hard, but it constantly does!
2. Rascal Does Not Dream Of Bunny Girl Senpai
Most people's first exposure to a show is through its title. For example, if you hear something like Attack on Titan, you probably (and quite accurately) imagine an action-heavy battle against giant monsters. Well, when you hear something like Rascal Does Not Dream Of Bunny Girl Senpai, it's safe to say you get a lot of *ahem* fan-service-based ideas in your head. This is a shame because this show is so, so, so much more than that.
The story follows a young man after he encounters a girl dressed as a bunny in the library and realises he's the only one who can see her. He soon learns that she's suffering from "adolescence syndrome", a fictional condition where people's insecurities manifest in strange supernatural ways. From there, he helps her and several others suffering from the same condition.
You'll likely be shocked to learn that the series is surprisingly devoid of overly sexualised characters or fan service. Instead, it's a powerful and emotional exploration of identity, adolescence and growing up.
It's got a slew of fascinating mysteries, a compelling core romance and a focus on complex issues. But you'd be forgiven for not predicting that after seeing the title/presentation. They say sex sells, but it also gives people the wrong ideas about anime.
1. Ranking Of Kings
If you want to talk about a true underdog, don't just look at this show's protagonist, but the series itself.
At first glance, Ranking of Kings looks fine, but nothing all too special. Well, beneath that underwhelming visual surface is a show so good it became a smash hit, skyrocketed to the top of every anime of the year list, and garnered a reputation for being one of the best fantasy anime of all time. So don't underestimate this little anime that could.
Ranking of Kings tells the story of the deaf/mute Prince Bojji - who is best described as painfully loveable. He's the heir to a mighty kingdom and has dreams of being the best king in the world; the only issue is that he's weak, can't speak and has no-one who understands him. He soon sets off on an adventure after encountering a rogue shadow assassin named Kage.
The first thing to notice about ROK is the minimalistic art style. It's deliberately simple, which would be a death knell for many animated shows, but it works in favour of the series as it shifts the focus from visuals to the story. Overall, the plot is a massive fantasy epic involving multiple kingdoms, plot twists, complex characters and more.
There's more than meets the eye with this powerful tale.