10 Awesome TV Shows (With Just One Bad Episode)

Yep, it's the elephants in the room: those terrible episodes that prevented otherwise great shows from being near enough perfect.

Whilst pursuing the intense, painstaking research that this piece deserved (basically I sat in my pants and watched YouTube for a few hours), I came to one conclusion - there's been a lot of great television in the last 15 or 20 years, from both sides of the Atlantic. Some of these shows I haven't seen in years, and it was fun to familiarise myself with the worlds and characters of Six Feet Under, The Sopranos and Arrested Development. You can easily forget how hard the best dramas hit you when you first watched them, or how your favourite comedies made you laugh and shaped your sense of humour. You also learn to appreciate the talent of the minds behind these shows - considering most of the shows on this list have ran for multiple seasons and racked up episodes in the hundreds, the quality is remarkably high. However, even the most well-crafted and consistent show doesn't always get it right. It's almost comforting to us mere mortals that even geniuses like David Chase and Larry David are human, and have dropped a clunker or two in their time. What I've gathered here, then, are my picks for 10 great shows that have only ever had one noticeably terrible or ill-judged episode. That's not to say that all the other episodes inherent to these shows were amazing or great, of course - it's just there there's only ever been one true "dud."

10. Curb Your Enthusiasm - "The End" (5.10)

I should probably declare a bias here and state right now I am a proud worshipper at the church of Larry David. The man can do no wrong in my book €“ he basically rewrote the book on comedy with Seinfeld, then did it all again with Curb a few years later. Christ, I even sat through that Three Stooges remake to watch him play a nun (he was robbed of an Oscar for that one). But The End is, bluntly, a terrible piece of cr*p. It starts strongly enough, with the funny premise that Larry is in fact adopted and (oy vey!) not actually Jewish. He goes to meet his real, Gentile parents in Arizona and embraces his new-found Christianity. However, the episode goes rapidly downhill, with a disappointing plot U-turn that LD wasn't adopted after all and a bizarre fantasy sequence in which he briefly dies and goes to heaven, encountering his two guardian angels in the process. Of course, he comes back to life anyway and the whole season finale feels like a massive waste of time. The fifth season of Curb is widely regarded as the show's weakest, but this episode was a major misfire. Curb works best when it centres around Larry challenging familiar social conventions and watching how the smallest incident escalates until it all blows up in his face. The overlong surreal dream sequence in this episode just feels out of place and against the spirit of the show. Plus when you consider the guardian angels are played by none other than Dustin Hoffman and Sacha Baron-Cohen, it all seems like a missed opportunity. Luckily the sixth season was a return to form for the show, and The End wasn't the "jump the shark" moment it could have been.

9. Seinfeld - "The Puerto Rican Day" (9.20)

Linking nicely from Curb Your Enthusiasm then, is Seinfeld. It's possibly a controversial claim to suggest that there was only one bad episode of the 1990s classic - certainly there are fans who would point to the slow-paced first couple of seasons when the show was finding its feet, or the last two non-Larry David seasons. But personally, I can find redeeming aspects in all those episodes and wouldn't necessarily call them bad. Even the much-maligned finale I would call under-whelming rather than a total debacle. The biggest stinker in the show's run for me, is The Puerto Rican Day. Basing the action in real-time in a single setting, this episode was designed as a callback to the likes of The Chinese Restaurant and The Subway. However, where these earlier shows had sharp, natural dialogue and clever observations that made this format work, this episode has none of this and the restricted setting only accentuates the weaknesses that had crept into the show by its ninth season - the contrived plot devices, cheap jokes and the increasingly cartoonish nature of the main four characters. The show definitely became sillier in its final two seasons following David's departure, but this wasn't a bad thing and the more surreal tone inspired some genuinely hilarious episodes. Unfortunately this isn't one of them. The laser-pen plot with George features loud, ALWAYS YELLING EVERYTHING George at his worst, the infamous flag-burning scene with Kramer feels like it's trying too hard to shock, and a sequence where Jerry, George and Kramer's alter-egos all meet could have been so much more. As the show's 176th and penultimate episode, it's perhaps a sign that the sitcom had lost its lustre and Jerry was right to call it a day when he did.

8. Six Feet Under - "That's My Dog" (4.5)

Six Feet Under was undoubtedly a fantastic show, but this is an episode that deeply polarised critics and fans when it first aired. Some feel That's My Dog is a triumph in provocative television, others dismiss it as a huge misfire by the writers and the show's lowest point. I have to side with the latter camp on this one. The episode starts with the winning SFU formula - opening with a death, and cutting between each major character's sub-plot. In David's storyline, he picks up a young hitchhiker Jake who proceeds to kidnap David and subject him to horrific mental and physical torture through the rest of the episode. The show never cuts back to the previous subplots, so like our protagonist, we can't escape from the horrors on screen. This is on paper a clever idea for an episode, but I don't think it pays off in practice. As the previous three seasons had showed, David had his troubles, but he was ultimately a strong, vigilant character dedicated to his own set of values. First off, it's hard to believe that he would let anything happen to a body in his care like in this episode. Second, he has a number of opportunities to fight back or escape his captor yet doesn't take them. This is possibly the writers highlighting an ugly truth in life that sometimes the only way to survive these extreme events is to submit - but in the context of David's character, it doesn't quite ring true. There's nothing wrong with mixing up a show's structure to explore new ground, but in the case of That's My Dog, this was something of a betrayal to the character, and the fans who had grown to love him, in the name of shock value.

7. Peep Show - "Business Secrets Of The Pharaohs" (8.2)

Peep Show is one of the two greatest British sitcoms of the last 10 years. Amazingly, the story of two socially inept flatmates Mark Corrigan and Jez Osborne started back in 2003 and its ninth series is about to air later this year - in British sitcom terms such longevity is very rare. And to the credit of the show's writers and of course helped by the comedic talents of David Mitchell and Robert Webb, the quality of the show has remained remarkably consistent through the years. However, Business Secrets Of The Pharaohs, the second episode of series eight, falls flat. In it, Mark seems about to realise his dream of having his non-fiction debut that gives the episode its title finally published, whilst Jeremy endeavours to become a fully-qualified life coach. Being Peep Show, neither get their way - and we'd want nothing less. The real problem for this episode is Mark's plot - the fly-by-night publisher he encounters is so obviously a con-man and even as he becomes increasingly desperate it is a stretch to believe he'd fall for such an obvious scam. Mark is so utterly out of character that it takes us away from the comedy. The other flaw with this episode is the recycled feel of its scenes. It's perhaps inevitable that any comedy hitting its eighth series will retread old ground eventually, and its certainly apparent here. Although its hard to hate any scene featuring the line "I'm wearing a grass skirt made of dicks", Jeremy having taboo-breaking sex with his life coach is almost identical to his escapades with Nancy back in the second series. Also, Mark going clubbing with Dobby (and hating every second of it) is funny, but again it feels we've seen it all before - there's a very similar scene in the third series with Sophie. Peep Show's main duo are still worth watching, but when a comedy starts repeating itself it's usually the right time to end it - and the upcoming ninth series has been confirmed to be the last.

6. The Inbetweeners - "Home Alone" (3.5)

The Inbetweeners After Peep Show comes the other greatest modern British sitcom, The Inbetweeners. Focusing on academic Will, hopeless-in-love Simon, sex pest Jay and lovably stupid Neil, the show was that rare combination - intelligent, outrageously funny and a huge hit with audiences and critics. The third series was a little weaker than the previous two, maybe lacking their freshness, but overall it was still the funniest show on television. Apart from Home Alone. The very premise of this episode - that Will's mum is away so the boys all take up residence in his house - already puts it at a disadvantage humour-wise. The best episodes of The Inbetweeners are the ones that throw the lads into settings that are alien to them and then mine the ludicrous situations for comedy - think of the work experience, clubbing in London and caravan club episodes. By restricting the action to Will's house, it feels like a step down for the series. Also: the moments I most identified with personally were the ones that took place in and around school - the third series unfortunately was light on these, and this episode was no exception. The four main players are funny yes, but have them interact with the likes of Mr Gilbert and school bully Donovan and it's comedy gold - leaving the side characters out feels like a missed opportunity. Another common criticism of series three was that it relied more heavily on shock value and gross-out American Pie style humour than previous episodes. Unfortunately this was hugely evident in Home Alone. At the risk of sounding a bit wussy - animals getting hurt or killed is something I never ever find particularly funny, and the scene in which Jay and Neil drive over a squirrel just feels a bit cheap for such a typically well-written show. Fortunately, the minds behind the show redeemed themselves with the outstanding 2011 feature film, and The Inbetweeners 2, released later this year, promises to be a huge cultural event for a certain generation in the UK.

5. The Sopranos - "Chasing It" (6.16)

Another potentially controversial one, as it seems unanimously agreed that the episode Christopher is the lowest The Sopranos ever got. Yes, that offering, centred around the characters opposing protests against Columbus Day was overly high on moralising and at times felt more like a history lesson than a show about mobsters, but there was enough high points to make it worth watching. The Sopranos is my favourite show of all time, and I can honestly say the only episode that really jarred with me was Chasing It. The A-plot of this episode is about Tony handling his gambling addiction. You know, that gambling addiction that was always mentioned throughout the past six seasons. Except it wasn't. It literally is thrown in for the purposes of this episode. And worse, it feels completely out of character for Tony. His hatred of degenerate gamblers had already been touched on - think back to The Happy Wanderer, where Tony manipulates an old school friend's gambling addiction and effectively destroys his life in the name of profit. Even when he became involved in horse racing, he gambles not for a high but because of his fascination with the horse itself. Crowbarring such a serious character trait such as gambling addiction, in one of the final handful of episodes no less, just feels lazy for such a usually high-quality show. Aside from the main plot-line, is there much about Chasing It to like? Not a lot. A good chunk of time is given to everyone's least favourite character AJ, which doesn't help, plus the sub-plot about Hesh (a character I do like) and the death of his girlfriend is a bit hum-drum considering this is the first time we've heard of or met her and she's only thrown in to kick the bucket anyway. Again, it's lazy writing from a show that's better than that. And the less said about Nancy Sinatra's bizarre cameo the better.

4. Arrested Development - "Ready, Aim, Marry Me" (2.10)

OK, I'm cheating slightly with this one. Because Arrested Development had more than a share of bad episodes - and they were found in the horribly disappointing fourth season last year. So pretending all the Netflix business never happened, I'm focusing on the show's original run for the purposes of this article. For me, of the first three seasons, the only real dud for me is Ready, Aim, Marry Me. In truth, there's a lot of good stuff in this episode too. The Tobias sub-plot, in which he begins recording his conversations so he can hear how homoerotic and innuendo-laden they are, is just hysterical. Lucille (Bluth) and George Michael are also on funny form. In fact, there is one single character in this episode that makes it the worst of the original run - Martin Short as Bluth family friend Uncle Jack. I've never found Short particularly funny, or indeed offensive - in most stuff I've seen of him he's just sort of there. But his hammy over-acting in this episode actually ruins it for me. The problem is that the broad, loud humour of Uncle Jack completely clashes with the more low-key tone the show established and the scenes with Short fall completely flat. And as this episode's plot is centred around the character, that means there's a lot less laughs in this offering than what we're used to with Arrested Development. Fortunately, the writers seemed to realise that it didn't work, and Jack was a one-off character never seen or heard of again.

3. The West Wing - "The Long Goodbye" (4.12)

Maybe another cheat with this one, as there were a couple of stinkers in the post- Aaron Sorkin era - although overall those seasons weren't as bad as some would have you believe - but as far as the Sorkin years go, this is easily the worst episode. Like many of the episodes on this list - it's an interesting premise. Moving the action away from the White House, The Long Goodbye focuses on CJ (most reluctantly) returning to her hometown in Ohio for a school reunion and explores her home life as she cares for her father, who is gradually deteriorating with Alzheimer's disease. Alzheimer's is a difficult topic for any show to tackle, and credit to the writers who deal with it thoughtfully in this episode - there's a great scene with CJ and her father on a boat when he forgets who she is that still gives me chills. Alison Janney is a fantastic actress and this episode only highlights that fact. As good as Janney is, she can't help that CJ's plot - away from the Alzheimer's theme - is really really boring. The whole hooking up with an old high school flame plot has been done in a million other shows, and there's no interesting spin on it here. I'm a big fan of the CJ character - but largely because of seeing her interactions with the show's other major players. When you take her away from the show's usual environment, bickering with Danny, Toby, Bartlett, etc. you take away what makes her great - and it would be the same for the West Wing's other characters. Unless you're particularly an Alison Janney fanatic (a Jannatic?) then this episode is a major step down in quality from those first four excellent seasons.

2. Deep Space Nine - "Profit And Lace" (6.23)

For my money, Deep Space Nine is easily the most consistent of the various Star Trek series. The strength of the characters meant that even weaker episodes were redeemed because it was just fun to see them interact and get into conflicts with each other. But if there was one stinker in DS9's run, it was most certainly Profit And Lace. The Ferengi-based episodes divide Trek fans in general, but I quite like them. Quark was a great character and so wonderfully played by Armin Shimerman that they were very watchable, but this one was just awful. The dumb plot involves Quark proving to a leading Ferengi politician that female Ferengis can be just as effective in business as the blokes, by - how else - changing his gender and becoming a woman named Lumba. Of course, the politician falls in love with Quark/Lumba and hilarity doesn't come close to ensuing. Allegedly Shimerman hated this episode, and during filming there were tensions between him and the show's producers - the Quark actor wanted to play it straight, while the higher-ups envisioned the episode as pure comedy (because it's clearly such a funny premise). In the end, straddling the line between comedy and serious drama does Profit And Lace no favours, being neither humorous nor engaging. What we're left with is the worst show of the best Trek series.

1. The Shield - "Co-Pilot" (2.9)

Although it never had the epic, sprawling ambitions of something like The Sopranos or The Wire, there are few shows as consistently hard-hitting and entertaining as The Shield was over the course of its seven seasons. Something I've always liked about it was the writers allowing viewers to draw their own conclusions on the shows character and themes, rather than ramming political and philosophical lessons down our throats. Basically it treated us like intelligent people rather than the stinky, blithering sheep we actually are. Co-Pilot goes against this somewhat. Coming in the middle of the second season, the writers bizarrely decided to do a flashback episode that explores the events preceding the first episode, focusing on how anti-hero Vic Mackie and the rest of the Strike Team formed. This might have had potential, but for a show that was so typically so tightly written, there are a number of plot holes that anyone who's actually watched the first episode will pick up on. For example, the first episode implies the Strike Team had been together for a long while, certainly before Aceveda had arrived at Farmington - but Co-Pilot tells us they were only formed as he took over. This messes up the entire Mackie/Aceveda relationship that drives the first three seasons of the show. These type of chronological blunders are everywhere in this episode. The odd placement of this episode in the series order doesn't help either. The second season featured the excellent Money Train arc in which Vic and his boys' efforts to steal from the Armenian Mafia gets them in deeper and deeper crap. The storyline was ingeniously plotted and it draws you in like the best television does, with suspense with every episode - until this stinker comes along, and the dramatic momentum is stopped dead in its tracks. Co-Pilot just feels like an unwelcome, wholly unnecessary distraction and is one I tend to skip on re-watching the series. Disagree with any of the episodes of the list? Any other great shows that had absolute stinkers? Comment below and let me know.

Contributor
Contributor

Northern Irish man living and working in London. Heroes include Ledley King, James Ellroy and whoever invented elasticated sweatshorts. Follow me on Twitter - @MJLowry23